Last night's episode was, hands down, the worst episode of Lost I have ever seen. It was as if they stuck some film student with only a small, limited amount of cast members and let him make the most Losty-ish episode he could. It felt like the pretentious, fan-fiction attempt of someone who was trying to audition their "cool" idea of what a Lost episode is... and then failing miserably like those ******bags who direct dramatic Star Wars shorts and post them on iFilm.
The spiritual talking island thing officially reached "OK, you've crossed the line" territory. The Locke being mute was annoying and pointless. And it's not that it was shot horribly - it's that it was shot in this "look at what I can do" kind of way that just MADE IT horrible. And man, Locke's flashback story? Not only did it have a 5% relevance to the whole gotta-find-Eko fiasco, but there was hardly any arc or conclusion to it whatsoever. If anything, he should have shot Tom Cruise's kid in War of the Worlds simply because there was no way in hell he should have been alive at the end of that movie.
The only saving grace of this pile of crap (I think that's what the dump truck in the cave symbolized) was the last two minutes. The whole Desmond time-travel-deja-vu thing just elevated the WTF! factor to a new extreme. That, and the preview for next week are the only things keeping me optimistic for the next episode (and the fact that every episode up until last night's is part of the best series in years).
_____________________________________________
On a more plot-relevant note, just before we started watching tonight, my roommate was talking about this thing called The Philadelphia Experiment (
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philadelphia_Experiment) and relating it to the island. If you ever watch The Discovery Channel, The History Channel, or The Military Channel with any kind of consistency, then you've probably seen at least one of the dozens of documentaries on the subject.
Essentially, the claim is that in 1943 the US Navy was testing Einstein's Unified Field Theory as a military application. The theory states that gravity and magnetism (electromagnetic radiation, specifically) are connected, just like mass and energy are connected (E=mc2)...
"Through a special application of the theory, it was thought to be possible, with specialized equipment and enough energy, to bend light around an object, rendering it essentially invisible. The navy considered this application to be of obvious value in wartime (as the United States was engaged in the Second World War at the time) and approved and sponsored the experiment. A navy destroyer escort, the USS Eldridge, was fitted with the required generator equipment at the naval yards in Philadelphia."
Whether you believe this happened or not (much like I can't believe I'm actually typing all this crap), the gist of it is that...
- There's a story involving the US Navy using electromagnetic radiation to make an object invisible.
- There was a fail safe in the hatch ultimately using electromagnetic radiation to make the island "invisible"... one could assume. Which would explain why no one can (or will ever) find the island (at least using traditional methods NOT used by Desmond's girlfriend).
Keep in mind, my roommate and I semi-discussed this relation BEFORE last night's episode aired, or knowing Desmond's episode-ending situation.
Now, here's where The Philadelphia Experiment REALLY gets "out there" (yet connects even more to Lost). Allegedly, in the more fantastical accounts of the story, at the moment of the experiment, witnesses reported a "greenish fog" surrounded the ship, the ship then completely disappeared - and two of the sailors on board actually claimed that during this period the ship and crew somehow time-traveled and "materialized" in 1983 as a result. Once back in 1943, crew members felt disoriented and severe nausea.
Kind of sounds like a certain cast member's situation, right? The electromagnetic radiation of the experiment - the electromagnetic radiation of the hatch. The green fog of the ship - the white "fog" at the turning of the fail safe key on the island. Sailors traveling in time - Desmond traveling in time. Sailors feeling crazy and disoriented - Desmond running around like a loon and not remembering much of anything.
Again, whether The Philadelphia Experiment really happened (especially to that degree) is irrelevant - that's not the point being argued. We're just relating two STORIES, one as inspiration/an explanation for the other. Are the writers of Lost borrowing elements from The Philadelphia Experiment? Is "the island" using technology to manipulate gravity and electromagnetic forces to bend light, somehow rendering it "invisible"? Is this how Desmond seemingly traveled in time and saw the future? And is it mere coincidence that Tom Hanks starred in a movie with the title "Philadelphia" AND one in which he was LOST ON AN ISLAND as a "Cast Away"? We shall see...
And I shall be total fahg for analyzing it THIS much...
[This message has been edited by TCTTS (edited 10/19/2006 7:11a).]