quote:Rogue One is set between 3 and 4. Not sure how they could tie in Tatooine though. (Seeing as how Obi Wan is exiled there)quote:Hopefully they do one with him in the Anthology films. I'm pretty sure that he has said he would be interested in coming back for a story between 3 and 4. Personally I think there is some potential for a one off story, probably involving the Hutts.quote:
Obi-Wan is the most pivotal Jedi in the saga, IMO.
Agreed. I'm still holding out hope for one of the anthology films to be about him with Ewan McGregor coming back
*** STAR WARS: THE FORCE AWAKENS Spoiler Discussion/Reactions ***
419,370 Views |
2952 Replies |
Last: 6 yr ago by Philip J Fry
quote:I'm not sure what you point is here. Rebels is set between 3 and 4 (actually just a few years prior to 4). I don't see a reason why there can't be more stories that cover that time period.
Rogue One is set between 3 and 4. Not sure how they could tie in Tatooine though. (Seeing as how Obi Wan is exiled there)
quote:quote:
quote:Yea I thought so too. Different voice actor?
Did 3po's voice seem a little off?
Same
This may be kind of controversial, but I don't know why they had C3PO in this movie. His lines were all kind of Hokey, and nothing would have changed at all if you removed him. I think they just included him to include him.
quote:Wookie before nookie man, Wookie before nookie.
Something a friend mentioned related to Han's death that bothered me as well.
When the Falcon got back after he'd been killed, Chewie walked right past Leia. You would think that they would share a moment there.
quote:quote:quote:
quote:Yea I thought so too. Different voice actor?
Did 3po's voice seem a little off?
Same
This may be kind of controversial, but I don't know why they had C3PO in this movie. His lines were all kind of Hokey, and nothing would have changed at all if you removed him. I think they just included him to include him.
C3P0 has ALWAYS been Hokey. Thats the point. Also not including him would have been wrong as he's been in EVERY movie.
Did TCTTS ever post his review of the film?
quote:quote:quote:quote:
quote:Yea I thought so too. Different voice actor?
Did 3po's voice seem a little off?
Same
This may be kind of controversial, but I don't know why they had C3PO in this movie. His lines were all kind of Hokey, and nothing would have changed at all if you removed him. I think they just included him to include him.
C3P0 has ALWAYS been Hokey. Thats the point. Also not including him would have been wrong as he's been in EVERY movie.
Yeah, but I think with BB-8, you had all the comic relief you needed. It just felt like they had to include him, so they just had him point out the obvious any time he spoke in this movie. He just didn't do anything as a character for me to be glad he was in the movie.
quote:when did he ever?quote:quote:quote:quote:
quote:Yea I thought so too. Different voice actor?
Did 3po's voice seem a little off?
Same
This may be kind of controversial, but I don't know why they had C3PO in this movie. His lines were all kind of Hokey, and nothing would have changed at all if you removed him. I think they just included him to include him.
C3P0 has ALWAYS been Hokey. Thats the point. Also not including him would have been wrong as he's been in EVERY movie.
Yeah, but I think with BB-8, you had all the comic relief you needed. It just felt like they had to include him, so they just had him point out the obvious any time he spoke in this movie. He just didn't do anything as a character for me to be glad he was in the movie.
all he ever did was point out the obvious or the dire circumstances...make bad puns...otherwise he only served to translate and play off of R2D2. and with R2 dormant in this one he just needed a brief (annoying) cameo.
I think he did on the other thread but then staff delete them, the thread got locked, drama ensued. He said he would move his thoughts here but also said he was about to get on a flight, if I recall, so hasn't posted.
quote:quote:I'm not sure what you point is here. Rebels is set between 3 and 4 (actually just a few years prior to 4). I don't see a reason why there can't be more stories that cover that time period.
Rogue One is set between 3 and 4. Not sure how they could tie in Tatooine though. (Seeing as how Obi Wan is exiled there)
Did you not read the posts mine was in response to? I was talking about Ewon McGregor being cast in an anthology movie that takes place between 3 and 4. (The time in which Obi Wan is exiled on Tatooine) That was my point.
quote:quote:I'm not sure what you point is here. Rebels is set between 3 and 4 (actually just a few years prior to 4). I don't see a reason why there can't be more stories that cover that time period.
Rogue One is set between 3 and 4. Not sure how they could tie in Tatooine though. (Seeing as how Obi Wan is exiled there)
19 years between 3 and 4. Plenty of time for a Kenobi solo movie
I was just under the impression that Obi Wan was playing the role of a hermit on Tatooine the whole time is all
AWESOME MOVIE
In A New Hope he translated for Luke and R2. And in ROJ he saved them from the Ewoks, as ridiculous as it was.
I'm just saying, with BB-8 being the comic relief guy, his lines just seemed kind of unnecessary. I understand why he was in the movie, but I feel like they could have taken him out and it wouldn't have made a difference.
I'm just saying, with BB-8 being the comic relief guy, his lines just seemed kind of unnecessary. I understand why he was in the movie, but I feel like they could have taken him out and it wouldn't have made a difference.
quote:
AWESOME MOVIE
Yes it was!!
Loved it. Couldn't be more pleased with the new characters. Acting was fantastic.
quote:quote:quote:
quote:Yea I thought so too. Different voice actor?
Did 3po's voice seem a little off?
Same
This may be kind of controversial, but I don't know why they had C3PO in this movie. His lines were all kind of Hokey, and nothing would have changed at all if you removed him. I think they just included him to include him.
And that craziness just keeps going. That's your answer.
Merchandising, Merchandising, Merchandising
There are way more people who would complain about C-3PO not being in the movie at all than are complaining about the screen time he did get. I think they did a good job with him.
BB-8 is perfect though, because he combines the comic relief of 3PO, the utility of R2-D2, and the mobility of a human character. The couldn't have designed him (her?) any better.
BB-8 is perfect though, because he combines the comic relief of 3PO, the utility of R2-D2, and the mobility of a human character. The couldn't have designed him (her?) any better.
Is a bb8 / WALL-E crossover film in the future?
I had the weirdest sense that I saw this movie in 1977 ...
quote:It's coming tomorrow. Probably later in the day. Have been doing Christmas early with one side of the family and I haven't had a free minute since I got home. Will be in the car for five straight hours tomorrow, and will knock it out then.
Did TCTTS ever post his review of the film?
Moichandizing
One of my biggest complaints comes at the end of the movie: there's no way Chewie just walks past Leia upon returning after Han dies. No way. That was a mistake.
A few other quibbles with it, but definitely exceeded my expectations.
A few other quibbles with it, but definitely exceeded my expectations.
quote:except he would have to be with leia..it would make no sense for him to not be
In A New Hope he translated for Luke and R2. And in ROJ he saved them from the Ewoks, as ridiculous as it was.
I'm just saying, with BB-8 being the comic relief guy, his lines just seemed kind of unnecessary. I understand why he was in the movie, but I feel like they could have taken him out and it wouldn't have made a difference.
Just saw the movie, and thought it was awesome.
So Andy Serkis is playing golem in this movie too?
So Andy Serkis is playing golem in this movie too?
Saw it today. Abrams pulled if off! Awesome film. Loved how the old and new were blended together. The new characters are all great. Rey (Daisy) will become a mega-star from this. This film, unlike the prequels, felt like a legit Star Wars movie and brought back the feeling I had as a kid when the crawl was going and how it jumped into it, and never stopped.
quote:
Anyone get a Kaylee vibe when she was fixing the falcon and said I'm pointing right at it"
Totally thought that and Joss thinking - you're welcome.
It wasn't a perfect movie. But it was a perfect Star Wars movie.
I loved it.
I loved it.
Not worth a new thread, but how about we all go on the record as to Rey's lightsaber color.
I'm going with yellow. The new expanded canon materials have made special effort (imo) to establish yellow as a viable option for Jedi.
Like most others, I expect her to use a double blade
I'm going with yellow. The new expanded canon materials have made special effort (imo) to establish yellow as a viable option for Jedi.
Like most others, I expect her to use a double blade
quote:According to IMDB, James Arnold Taylor (voice of Obi-Wan Kenobi in Star Wars: The Clone Wars) confirmed on his Twitter that he recorded Obi-Wan saying "Rey" in her Force vision, but they later replaced it with the voice of Ewan McGregor.
Just got back from a 2nd viewing and here are my thoughts:
It was Luke talking to her in the scene where she touches the light saber and I"m not of the opinion that he guided her through the first movie. After he says her name, you here these are your first steps.
D
I want to see her get a pike instead of a double-blade. I'm going to guess yellow or purple. Buck the trend.
quote:
Not worth a new thread, but how about we all go on the record as to Rey's lightsaber color.
Pink. For midichlorian cancer awareness.
Daisy Ridley loving that green tho 
Featured Stories
See All
A&M at risk of undercut when undertaking trip to underrated Auburn
by Olin Buchanan
48:02
1d ago
4.1k
5:59
22h ago
2.2k
16:53
1d ago
3.1k