quote:
Initial reaction:
Pro: I think overall the best acted of any Star Wars film. Really liked the chemistry between Finn and Rey.
Con: Apparently not satisfied with retconning one of the greatest screen villains of all time into a wooden emo loser in the prequels, they start the sequels with a villain who is a wooden emo loser from the word go. Why?
The only thing that made the whole insufferable chapter of the prequels at least a coherent story was recasting the whole Epic as the fall and redemption of Anakin Skywalker...except now it seems he turned back to evil after he died and possessed his grandkid. I'm sure there will be some convoluted, dualistic interpretation of this, but really, I would think Han and Leia's kid could turn out evil without the direct personal involvement of Darth Vader.
Initially enjoyed the lighter tone after the heavy handed, taking itself way too seriously feel of the prequels (and ROTJ, honestly), but think Abrams took it too far. Putting in lines for the explicit purpose of drawing laughs is not Star Wars.
Overall: Meh. I'm neither for or against the retelling of New Hope as a new movie, but this one won't hold up well in comparison when the whiz-bang NEW feel wears off.
I'm very confused by your review... Kylo is not at all like anakin. Kylo is who anakin should have been all this time. Kylo feels he is dark, bring tempted by the light, and has convinced himself Vader was the same way.
You understand Darth Vader isn't possessing anyone and is still good in the end right? Kylo has taken the stories of his grandfather's evil, and trying to rebel and be like him. I thought it was good motivation. You're off your rocker on somehow thinking this mean Darth Vader turned evil again...
I won't list them out right now, but PLENTY of lines in the OT were purely for humor. Star Wars is supposed to have humor.
The rehashing of story lines was my biggest gripe by far. I think that was a bad overall premise to attack this movie with, but the execution on the premise was superb. Hopefully it sets them up well for the next two episodes and some more originality.