Nm
quote:A "premature ePublication" if you will?quote:In my experience, people are seldom pleased with a quick release.
You are making assumptions that he is interested in pleasing his fans with a quick release
quote:quote:A "premature ePublication" if you will?quote:In my experience, people are seldom pleased with a quick release.
You are making assumptions that he is interested in pleasing his fans with a quick release
quote:
I just can't imagine Jon being stabbed in episode 10. Sure they could keep it quiet (maybe) that Harrington would be shooting after all, but there is no way they risk alienating the much more fickle TV show fans with a cliffhanger that kills off the show's most broadly appealing character. They WOULD lose viewers over Jon Snow being dead. There would be lots of non-readers that would be pissed enough, like the types who quit over the red wedding.
quote:They don't have the benefit of LSH like we do.
I really don't think Jon getting stabbed will really be that big of a cliff hanger. I mean, does anyone on here think he's done and we will never hear from again? I think all the readers of the books assume he's going to be back. The only question is how. I think the TV viewers will feel the same way.
quote:quote:They don't have the benefit of LSH like we do.
I really don't think Jon getting stabbed will really be that big of a cliff hanger. I mean, does anyone on here think he's done and we will never hear from again? I think all the readers of the books assume he's going to be back. The only question is how. I think the TV viewers will feel the same way.
quote:
Did Melisandre leave the wall in the books?
quote:And they don't have the benefit of the prophecies or the tower of joy flashback. Nor do they have the warg chapters.quote:They don't have the benefit of LSH like we do.
I really don't think Jon getting stabbed will really be that big of a cliff hanger. I mean, does anyone on here think he's done and we will never hear from again? I think all the readers of the books assume he's going to be back. The only question is how. I think the TV viewers will feel the same way.
quote:
I really don't think Jon getting stabbed will really be that big of a cliff hanger. I mean, does anyone on here think he's done and we will never hear from again? I think all the readers of the books assume he's going to be back. The only question is how. I think the TV viewers will feel the same way.
quote:You are mistaken. Lord Beric clearly "came back." In Season Three, we saw Thoros bring him back after Beric was killed by Sandor Clegane. We also saw him discussing the fact that Thoros had resurrected him multiple times.quote:Up until this point in the show we have no reasoning to think that a main character will come back after being dead. Because it hasn't happened yet. Unless you count the white walkers. To quote Dookie, "there's no special kind of dead, they're just dead". That's how most of the TV audience views the show thus far.
quote:I think you missed the part where he said "no main character".quote:You are mistaken. Lord Beric clearly "came back." In Season Three, we saw Thoros bring him back after Beric was killed by Sandor Clegane. We also saw him discussing the fact that Thoros had resurrected him multiple times.quote:Up until this point in the show we have no reasoning to think that a main character will come back after being dead. Because it hasn't happened yet. Unless you count the white walkers. To quote Dookie, "there's no special kind of dead, they're just dead". That's how most of the TV audience views the show thus far.
quote:yes, but....you wouldn't likely reveal that on a main character the first time, thats cheap. they set the groundwork for it by doing it with Beric. And also you have to wonder if that wasn't important and we were not going to see Beric again (we haven't) then why show it. They have to be economical with what they show. they tend to cut all unnecessary stuff. they could have just let Clegane kill Beric and be done - the end result was the same. Clegane went free and Arya left the Bw/oB after Beric sold Gendry to Melisandre.quote:I think you missed the part where he said "no main character".quote:You are mistaken. Lord Beric clearly "came back." In Season Three, we saw Thoros bring him back after Beric was killed by Sandor Clegane. We also saw him discussing the fact that Thoros had resurrected him multiple times.quote:Up until this point in the show we have no reasoning to think that a main character will come back after being dead. Because it hasn't happened yet. Unless you count the white walkers. To quote Dookie, "there's no special kind of dead, they're just dead". That's how most of the TV audience views the show thus far.
quote:
Wrong icon! Hahah