Blue Star for this comment, well done:
quote:
let's just say I could see a guy from the choke point connecting the north to the rest of westeros having a 'coexist' bumper sticker on his horse
My immediate thought was to dismiss the HR theory on the Old Gods point as well but then I read it. It really makes a lot of sense and is less of a reach than many things in the books, especially the point that the Septon seems to have an affection for the Starks (who aren't of the Seven) and clearly does not care for the Lannisters (who are).
Moreso, what do we know about HR? Our primary knowledge of him is the story of the Tourney of Harrenhall. What happened there? HR left the Neck ALONE and went on an adventure. He came across the Tourney and did not announce himself as a Lord. He also was clearly involved in the Knight of the Laughing Tree (though this was likely Lyanna). It really isn't a reach at all to assume that he would disguise himself as a Septon, he could also likely use his wisdom and knowledge (which is apparent) to win over the common folk easily.
Also, the followers of the Old Gods have a different idea of being devout. You don't really hear them talk about blasphemy or have a negative attitude about other religions. Ned was very comfortable with allowing Cat to remain faithful to the Seven and to raise his children in both faiths.
I have always thought the crannogmen have some COTF blood in them but I don't know that that helps or hurts the theory.
HR as the High Septon would be awesome. It doesn't make sense for him to raise and army of crannogmen since they are little folks who don't have much money and use non traditional weapons, they would be crushed in a normal battle.
