My theater for Rogue One seemed to be in utter shock. The moment K2 died, it was pretty damn obvious where it was going. From that point forward, it was more of a "they really aren't going to do this, are they"? By the time it got to the scene where Vader said, "Prepare a boarding party" and then it cuts back to Jyn and Cassian I think many thought that we were done. I could hear sniffling. Of course, this is where mentally I regretted knowing that Vader had a badass scene, because I knew that had not happened yet. Then, it cut back to Vader's transport with Tie escorts, and one guy let out a loud "Hell Yes", and the place laughed. It was the emotional break the entire room needed that had not been provided in that third act, unusual for Star Wars but probably the right decision in this case.