TheCougarHunter said:dave94 said:TheCougarHunter said:
Mac is clearly a liability as HC
Red was a better game manager and that's saying a lot.
Lol, WHUT
Prove me wrong then
Prove to me that Mac is a good coach and not a liability
jteagle said:
Starting WR Cooper- Out
Starting LT Smith- Out
Starting DE Gregory- Out
Starting DE Lawrence- Out
Starting WR Lamb- Left game with concussion
Not to mention that all of these players are field leaders.
Ag Natural said:
Is it possible to "prove" anyone is a good coach outside of Bilichik?
Seriously, every team in the league has stinkers.
ChemAg15 said:
Isn't zeke the better pass rush blocker? Pollard does seem to be the better back in space.
DannyDuberstein said:ChemAg15 said:
Isn't zeke the better pass rush blocker? Pollard does seem to be the better back in space.
Yes, Zeke is better in protection while I think Pollard is better at almost everything else. What really bugged me yesterday was that even though the OL was getting its ass kicked, they kept sending Zeke out on useless checkdowns. If he was going to be out there, keep him in protection to provide help and chip guys. Otherwise, put Pollard in. It felt very Atlanta 2018-ish
jr15aggie said:jteagle said:
Starting WR Cooper- Out
Starting LT Smith- Out
Starting DE Gregory- Out
Starting DE Lawrence- Out
Starting WR Lamb- Left game with concussion
Not to mention that all of these players are field leaders.
Those are 5 of our 9 elite players (with Dak, Martin, Parsons, Diggs also on that list).
That's pretty much impossible for any team to overcome in a hostile environment. Dallas has won without quality starters all year... but to be without that many studs all at once is a bit much.
Gonna be a helluva fight on T-day if Lamb is still out.
ChemAg15 said:Ag Natural said:
Is it possible to "prove" anyone is a good coach outside of Bilichik?
Seriously, every team in the league has stinkers.
They all stink until they lift the trophy
SOURCE: The Giants have fired offensive coordinator Jason Garrett. He was let go in the past hour.. The move was first reported by @PLeonardNYDN
— Bruce Feldman (@BruceFeldmanCFB) November 23, 2021
Grapesoda2525 said:
The NFL is not a league that rewards teams who play with no aggression, no innovation, and a "not to lose" mentality. All 3 of those things are what Jason Garrett is known for. I'm surprised he lasted as long as he did with another nfl organization. It just shows you how stupid Jerry was to keep him as long as he did.
I would've canned his conservative ass after one season, but then again I never would have hired him in the first place.Ag Natural said:Grapesoda2525 said:
The NFL is not a league that rewards teams who play with no aggression, no innovation, and a "not to lose" mentality. All 3 of those things are what Jason Garrett is known for. I'm surprised he lasted as long as he did with another nfl organization. It just shows you how stupid Jerry was to keep him as long as he did.
Well he made it 1.5 seasons. Thats not exactly an eternity
https://www.theringer.com/nfl/2021/11/23/22799744/jason-garrett-giants-scapegoat?utm_campaign=theringer&utm_content=chorus&utm_medium=social&utm_source=twitterQuote:
The real story is not that the Giants fired Garrett. The calamity that Mara needs to address is why Garrett was ever hired. Garrett spent nine years as the head coach of the Dallas Cowboys. Their defining quality under him was less than the sum of their parts. His Cowboys offenses had an embarrassment of riches: the league's best offensive line, talented skill players, and a seamless quarterback transition from Tony Romo to Dak Prescott. These are the rosters most coaches dream of, yet Garrett's players complained for years that their offense was too predictable. The Cowboys' special teams play was awful for years, a sign of a lack of attention to detail. Garrett's clock management was awful, which is genuinely inexplicable for a coach who gave up play-calling after 2013. (If a coach isn't calling plays, why aren't they excellent at managing the clock?) In hiring Garrett, the Giants got the absolute worst of the Cowboys over the last decade: all the sloppiness and poor attention to detail without any of the talent.
Again, this was not hard to predict. Was there one - literally, one - Cowboys fan who was upset that the Giants hired Jason Garrett? (The vibe was more lol, good luck with that.) I am a Giants fan, and I can tell you that every Giants fan I know was distraught by Garrett's hire. It went exactly as anyone who watched Dallas in the 2010s predicted it would go when you hand Garrett the worst roster in the NFC East instead of the best one. The Giants are supposed to know their division rivals better than they know other teams. Did they not watch the last decade of Cowboys football? How could the Giants evaluate Dallas's coaching decisions over the last decade and decide that Garrett would improve their team, or that Garrett was a good mentor for Joe Judge or a good coordinator for Daniel Jones? Instead, the inane lack of attention to detail, clock management, and general unpreparednessthe sloppinessthat defined Dallas has plagued the Giants.
jtstanley4621 said:
Garrett squandered Romo's career and is the largest reason he isn't a hall of famer. I hope to one day die on a hill defending this point
