When you have a large outcome spread, like in this case, options have good risk profiles relatively speaking. With HDY, holding stock and buying calls may have close downside loss(assuming dry hole), but the upside on calls is exponentially higher.
As for everyone bashing MGMT, you clearly know little about drilling and less about the previous HDY mgmt.
If Ray and Co are guilty of anything it is posting a best case drilling timeline originally. However, this aggressive time line was the only way to drill (2) wells with the cash available....its simple math. It wasnt unrealistic, just very ambitious.
Also, the $250k day rate Ray got was a major discount, about half of what that drillship could go for. To my surprise it even arrived on time.
As someone who provides subsea drilling equipment to rigs in the GOM and gets rig updates daily I can honestly say 2 things:
1) The delays experienced are not that uncommon, in some cases I have seen much worse delays on much higher day rates.
2) Drilling delays have everything to do with engineering and geological factors and very little to do with mgmt once the contractual arrangements have been made.
The major difference is that the customers I deal with have enough cash to weather delays and are diversified at other well sites.
Ray is a geologist trying to prove the value of the asset. Blackrock wanted HDY to keep the full 77% and prove the value of the asset rather than making a cheaper deal...so did shareholders.
This aggressive strategy of "going at it alone" has been widely publicized and known for a long time. Everyone is just now being critical because they are both ignorant about subsea operations and do not know how to control their emotions.