*** THE MANDALORIAN - Season 1 ***
359,871 Views |
2480 Replies |
Last: 1 yr ago by jeffk
MuckRaker96 said:
The irony is that these last 2 episodes are what we all assumed the show would be before it came out, but the first 3 made us expect huge payoffs every time out.
I don't expect huge payoffs, but the first three episodes seemed to create "where did this baby come from and what happens to it now" as the most important question in the show and the last two episodes have made the baby seem more like an inconvenience to the show than it's central point.
Until I see how the season plays out, I can't think of the last 2 episodes as not moving the plot forward. By taking out the big-time assassin, Mando might have woken up a much nastier enemy. By helping those people out in the village, he might have earned a favor that he can cash in somewhere down the line.
Things that seem random sometimes end up being part of the longer arc that we can't see until the end.
Things that seem random sometimes end up being part of the longer arc that we can't see until the end.
Plus, from the Mando's point of view isn't baby Yoda just an inconvenience? I mean, he's decided the right thing to do is protect the baby somehow, but (unlike us) he's got no clue why the baby might be a big deal.
It's not like the x-files where every week they saw crazy alien stuff but still ended up skeptical in time for the next episode. He's seen the force used once and didn't know what it was.
It's not like the x-files where every week they saw crazy alien stuff but still ended up skeptical in time for the next episode. He's seen the force used once and didn't know what it was.
I get there are complaints about the filler, but doesn't he kind of have to go in hiding and constantly be on the run from people now? It is the logical next step in the story. He isn't about to go john wick every bounty hunter and the empire remnants across the whole galaxy.
bobinator said:MuckRaker96 said:
The irony is that these last 2 episodes are what we all assumed the show would be before it came out, but the first 3 made us expect huge payoffs every time out.
I don't expect huge payoffs, but the first three episodes seemed to create "where did this baby come from and what happens to it now" as the most important question in the show and the last two episodes have made the baby seem more like an inconvenience to the show than it's central point.
The ramp up here is pretty deliberate in building to a few things even in the standalone episodes.
- They haven't introduced the Big Bad yet
- They have teased but not gone into Mando's Clone Wars origin
- Hasn't removed his helmet
- Haven't given the Purge backstory
- Obviously the secret of Baby Yoda
Mando has made a number of allies and one really big enemy still in the shadows and is now on the run, about to be confronted with some combination of an ex-Imperial warlord and the Guild. I doubt we answer all of the above mysteries, but if the series follows suite, things will pull together using the unanswered questions and some of his recent adventures as the foundation.
Last episode was a lot of fanservice for sure, but checking in on known locations like Tatooine to see how it's faring is an important part of the worldbuilding. We KNOW what Tatooine was like during the Empire, so seeing the same locations after the fall (and Jabba's death) makes it clear how things have changed. This has for better or worse been part of the bedrock of the lore across all of the media, especially Tatooine. All three prequel episodes, RotJ, novels, comics, and classics like KotR visited Tatooine.
It's the only old location we've seen so I think it's fine. If every week was another trip to Endor and Mustafar and Hoth, it would be a bigger dig.
I think it's less that it's "filler" and more that it's "filler without a goal." Reposting what I said yesterday...
In other words, if, say, toward the end of episode three, a character had told Mondo of a place where he knew Baby Yoda would be safe, where his abilities could be cultivated, etc, and THEN we had these past two episodes, I wouldn't be nearly as annoyed. If Mando was trying to get to a bigger destination across the galaxy, but on the way there, circumstances forced him on the farming planet, and then to Tatooine, I'd be totally on board (for the most part, as I still had more minor issues with each episode). But right now, instead, it just feels so aimless.
Quote:
Baby Yoda has been reduced to nothing more than a literal reminder that there's a larger story at play, but a larger story that keeps having to be stuffed in the closet or sidelined for no apparent reason. For two episodes now there hasn't been any real goal or plan. Mando is just kind of wondering from planet to planet with a baby. By the end of episode three - when he decided to save the baby - there should have been some kind of goal or ultimate destination established. If he gets the baby to [X], the baby will be safe. And the next few episodes should have made it a huge challenge for him and the baby to get to [X]. Then the planet hopping wouldn't seem so aimless, and the "monster of the week" wouldn't feel so forced.
In other words, if, say, toward the end of episode three, a character had told Mondo of a place where he knew Baby Yoda would be safe, where his abilities could be cultivated, etc, and THEN we had these past two episodes, I wouldn't be nearly as annoyed. If Mando was trying to get to a bigger destination across the galaxy, but on the way there, circumstances forced him on the farming planet, and then to Tatooine, I'd be totally on board (for the most part, as I still had more minor issues with each episode). But right now, instead, it just feels so aimless.
MuckRaker96 said:
The irony is that these last 2 episodes are what we all assumed the show would be before it came out, but the first 3 made us expect huge payoffs every time out.
Precisely.
Is there really any confusion that thus team was confident enough in their abilities to know that this would get picked up for multiple seasons and that they would be able to spend this season focused on world building and universe expansion while having enough fan service to keep everyone happy.
Basically I dont think they created a season of 8 episodes but a story with X chapters which will be released 8 at a time.
Basically I dont think they created a season of 8 episodes but a story with X chapters which will be released 8 at a time.
amercer said:
Plus, from the Mando's point of view isn't baby Yoda just an inconvenience? I mean, he's decided the right thing to do is protect the baby somehow, but (unlike us) he's got no clue why the baby might be a big deal.
It's not like the x-files where every week they saw crazy alien stuff but still ended up skeptical in time for the next episode. He's seen the force used once and didn't know what it was.
The baby using the force to save his life was an indication to him that it is something special. Beyond what they were going to put the thing through, the fact he's saving something special is part of it too.
We'll see what happens but I already wonder if these episodes wouldn't feel so aimless if we could watch the whole season at once.
From Mando's perspective the baby is definitely an inconvenience, but I meant more like from a show creator standpoint. The baby was so inconvenient in this episode that they chose to LEAVE IT WITH A TOTAL STRANGER.
TCTTS said:
I think it's less that it's "filler" and more that it's "filler without a goal." Reposting what I said yesterday...Quote:
Baby Yoda has been reduced to nothing more than a literal reminder that there's a larger story at play, but a larger story that keeps having to be stuffed in the closet or sidelined for no apparent reason. For two episodes now there hasn't been any real goal or plan. Mando is just kind of wondering from planet to planet with a baby. By the end of episode three - when he decided to save the baby - there should have been some kind of goal or ultimate destination established. If he gets the baby to [X], the baby will be safe. And the next few episodes should have made it a huge challenge for him and the baby to get to [X]. Then the planet hopping wouldn't seem so aimless, and the "monster of the week" wouldn't feel so forced.
In other words, if, say, toward the end of episode three, a character had told Mondo of a place where he knew Baby Yoda would be safe, where his abilities could be cultivated, etc, and THEN we had these past two episodes, I wouldn't be nearly as annoyed. If Mando was trying to get to a bigger destination across the galaxy, but on the way there, circumstances forced him on the farming planet, and then to Tatooine, I'd be totally on board (for the most part, as I still had more minor issues with each episode). But right now, instead, it just feels so aimless.
I get what you're saying but disagree.
1. If Mando knew where to take Baby Yoda where he'd be safe, it would eliminate a lot of the complete mystery that he is. Right now the only people with answers about him are the ones trying to exploit and/or kill him. In the lore, where could such a place even be 5 years after Jedi that doesn't involve Luke? I don't think that's a can of worms any of us would want opened.
2. Mando isn't simply wandering. He's being doggedly pursued. One of the big things established by the last two episodes is that he and/or the Child aren't safe anywhere. The enemies will catch up to him next episode or the one after and the main arc will come back into focus.
3. Baby Yoda has not been sidelined. He's become Mando's kryptonite. The last two episodes have seen Mando's elite skills and general badassery sidelined because of the Child's vulnerability and Mando's dedication to him in spite of his code and best interest. I expect this point will become the culminating moment of the first season.
bobinator said:
We'll see what happens but I already wonder if these episodes wouldn't feel so aimless if we could watch the whole season at once.
Some Stranger Things episodes come to mind. Like the season 2 episode when El goes to find her "sister." Definitely viewed differently when it's binged.
Fair enough. I don't 100% agree, but you raise some good points.
I recently binged the whole show before season 3, and that episode still feels wildly out of place. It doesn't help that it leaves all of our other main characters in the middle of a cliffhanger.
I think the missing piece in the puzzle here is that Mando doesn't want what happened to him happening to The Child.
We all think being a Mando is bad-ass, but is it? He had a family on a planet before the Clone Wars came there, his parents got murdered, and he got saved, but saved into a people who seem to not laugh or be happy or do much of anything other than walk around in suits of armor and helmets telling each other "This is the Way." Even just being a normal bounty hunter is probably a lot happier lifestyle because then when you make a big score you take a nice vacation or buy a fancy house or get yourself some hot multi-species action or whatever. When Mando gets rich, he gives it all up to either get upgrades on his gear or help other people. The flashbacks are definitely a clue that he would have much rather stayed happy with his parents in his town than becoming a Mando.
When he sees Baby Yoda getting carted off, it's not necessarily about it being the Empire taking him, it's the fact that it's a kid not being given a choice, which is exactly what happened to Mando. So with that filter on, the last two episodes make perfect sense. In Episode 4, he's looking for a place to lay low and plot his next move. That doesn't work out so he tries to live the kid there, but he can't so he has to move on.
In Episode 5, he's seen what BY can do and leaves him asleep in a locked part of the ship. You think the Mando elders are leaving their kids with babysitters and pacifiers? He's parenting the way he was probably parented. Doesn't know any better.
Taking BY back is probably the first irrational thing he's done since he became an adult. The last two episode are reflective of that - he knows how to hunt and he knows how to take orders for the good of his people. Doing something selfish and trying to help someone else out isn't in his nature, so he's stumbling along.
We all think being a Mando is bad-ass, but is it? He had a family on a planet before the Clone Wars came there, his parents got murdered, and he got saved, but saved into a people who seem to not laugh or be happy or do much of anything other than walk around in suits of armor and helmets telling each other "This is the Way." Even just being a normal bounty hunter is probably a lot happier lifestyle because then when you make a big score you take a nice vacation or buy a fancy house or get yourself some hot multi-species action or whatever. When Mando gets rich, he gives it all up to either get upgrades on his gear or help other people. The flashbacks are definitely a clue that he would have much rather stayed happy with his parents in his town than becoming a Mando.
When he sees Baby Yoda getting carted off, it's not necessarily about it being the Empire taking him, it's the fact that it's a kid not being given a choice, which is exactly what happened to Mando. So with that filter on, the last two episodes make perfect sense. In Episode 4, he's looking for a place to lay low and plot his next move. That doesn't work out so he tries to live the kid there, but he can't so he has to move on.
In Episode 5, he's seen what BY can do and leaves him asleep in a locked part of the ship. You think the Mando elders are leaving their kids with babysitters and pacifiers? He's parenting the way he was probably parented. Doesn't know any better.
Taking BY back is probably the first irrational thing he's done since he became an adult. The last two episode are reflective of that - he knows how to hunt and he knows how to take orders for the good of his people. Doing something selfish and trying to help someone else out isn't in his nature, so he's stumbling along.
Wet well said.
Excellent analysis.
I agree with all that. And the story makes sense from a wide angle.
I still just think it's hard to care about these other characters when we only meet them for one episode. Like this episode I know why everything happened, I just found myself not really caring about it.
I still just think it's hard to care about these other characters when we only meet them for one episode. Like this episode I know why everything happened, I just found myself not really caring about it.
anyone else get Hayden Christensen vibes from the bounty hunter in episode 5? How he talked/acting ability so on
Part Anakin Skywalker and part Shia Labouf's character from the newest Indiana Jones movie.
Best teamp up idea since ANakin and Nic Cage in the White Ghostbobinator said:
Part Anakin Skywalker and part Shia Labouf's character from the newest Indiana Jones movie.
3,2,1,4,5
And 5 was good!
And 5 was good!
The vibe I kept getting was the kid in Unforgiven....
The plot with the helpless village reminded me too much of The Dark Tower: Wolves of the Calla. Of course, their babies weren't being stolen and returned as simpletons, but everything else is eerily similar.
No Andy the Robot (Other Functions)rynning said:
The plot with the helpless village reminded me too much of The Dark Tower: Wolves of the Calla. Of course, their babies weren't being stolen and returned as simpletons, but everything else is eerily similar.
rynning said:
The plot with the helpless village reminded me too much of The Dark Tower: Wolves of the Calla. Of course, their babies weren't being stolen and returned as simpletons, but everything else is eerily similar.
They come back roont
Ah, I couldn't remember the word.Blatant Disregard said:rynning said:
The plot with the helpless village reminded me too much of The Dark Tower: Wolves of the Calla. Of course, their babies weren't being stolen and returned as simpletons, but everything else is eerily similar.
They come back roont
I should take this opportunity to mention I have a tattoo of roland holding as gun and a rose from my shoulder to just under my sleeve that took 7 and one half hours to apply
Was it just me, or did y'all not hear spurs jingling when whoever walked up at the end?
Those were sleigh bells. Christmas special is next week.
I just started watching this last night I'm through episode three and I really enjoy this. The baby Yoda just cracks me up. I love the way he reached out for the little ball.
Although I will say I wish I could see the guys face that's kind of driving me crazy.
Although I will say I wish I could see the guys face that's kind of driving me crazy.
Currently a happy listless vessel and deplorable. #FDEMS TRUMP 2024.
Fight Fight Fight.
Fight Fight Fight.
Oh, the sweet, sweet irony/fail pre-edit...
Featured Stories
See All
19:50
22h ago
4.9k
Donors can now earn priority points by giving to Texas Aggies United
by Texas Aggies United
5 Thoughts: No. 23 Texas A&M 78, No. 21 Ohio State 64
by Luke Evangelist
A&M's approach remains the same with NMSU coming to Aggieland
by Olin Buchanan
116:42
2h ago
668
27:22
12h ago
3.9k