AT-AT is not the same as the AT-ACT. They probably were more heavily armored
Rogue One: A Star Wars Story (spoilers and discussion)
236,513 Views |
1640 Replies |
Last: 4 yr ago by Fat Bib Fortuna
Had my 2nd viewing today, took the family. The last 2 days, it was either sold out or near capacity in every showing at our local theater (3 screens I think).
I enjoyed it even more this time around. No one in my family knew about the 2 CGI characters and didn't know it until I told them afterwards. I thought Tarkin looked much better in 2D than 3D, wasn't nearly as distracting. I'm in the minority still, but I thought Leia looked real.
My wife and 2 kids all absolutely loved it, as did I.
I enjoyed it even more this time around. No one in my family knew about the 2 CGI characters and didn't know it until I told them afterwards. I thought Tarkin looked much better in 2D than 3D, wasn't nearly as distracting. I'm in the minority still, but I thought Leia looked real.
My wife and 2 kids all absolutely loved it, as did I.
coupland boy said:
If an X-wing can blast an imperial walker why did they sacrifice so many pilots in those T-47 airspeeders in the battle of Hoth?
It's not considered canon anymore, but one of Stackpole's books describe the snow speeder's as having very weak blasters meant for clearing away ice and snow. They were much weaker than military blasters on the X-Wing's.
I always liked that description.
coupland boy said:
If an X-wing can blast an imperial walker why did they sacrifice so many pilots in those T-47 airspeeders in the battle of Hoth?
Because they were trying evacuate Hoth, not win the battle. They probably did not want to sacrifice their X-wings.
Talk about something worse than the prequelsredline248 said:
No, but I saw Jumper
CJS4715 said:coupland boy said:
If an X-wing can blast an imperial walker why did they sacrifice so many pilots in those T-47 airspeeders in the battle of Hoth?
Because they were trying evacuate Hoth, not win the battle. They probably did not want to sacrifice their X-wings.
Okay. Thanks for this and the other explanations.
wangus12 said:Talk about something worse than the prequelsredline248 said:
No, but I saw Jumper
Come on, I enjoyed Jumper
coupland boy said:
If an X-wing can blast an imperial walker why did they sacrifice so many pilots in those T-47 airspeeders in the battle of Hoth?
If I remember right, one of the nameless commanders mentions early on the X-wings are having trouble adapting to the cold. That's why they don't use them to fight the walkers on Hoth.
wangus12 said:Talk about something worse than the prequelsredline248 said:
No, but I saw Jumper
I recognize that this is a bad movie, and that Hayden Christensen is indeed terrible in it... but I still really like it
Quote:
Okay. Thanks for this and the other explanations.
Just guessing... I really don't know.
Aggie_Journalist said:coupland boy said:
If an X-wing can blast an imperial walker why did they sacrifice so many pilots in those T-47 airspeeders in the battle of Hoth?
If I remember right, one of the nameless commanders mentions early on the X-wings are having trouble adapting to the cold. That's why they don't use them to fight the walkers on Hoth.
Insert irony since they operate in the vacuum of space. Guess outer space is warmer than Hoth.
They were having trouble with the speeders and the cold, not the x-wings. The statement is made when Han wants to go out in the evening to look for Luke.
I think they were using x-wings to escort transports... though, I'm not sure if it is stated or implied. Like I said, the goal once they were found by the Empire was to get away. No reason to waste their fleet.
I think they were using x-wings to escort transports... though, I'm not sure if it is stated or implied. Like I said, the goal once they were found by the Empire was to get away. No reason to waste their fleet.
Aggie_Journalist said:coupland boy said:
If an X-wing can blast an imperial walker why did they sacrifice so many pilots in those T-47 airspeeders in the battle of Hoth?
If I remember right, one of the nameless commanders mentions early on the X-wings are having trouble adapting to the cold. That's why they don't use them to fight the walkers on Hoth.
It's the airspeeders they had trouble adapting to the cold, which is why they were using Tauntauns.
Ask if it were another young actor playing HC's character if it would have been a better movie?ChipFTAC01 said:wangus12 said:Talk about something worse than the prequelsredline248 said:
No, but I saw Jumper
Come on, I enjoyed Jumper
He was bad in it, but again (like SW) I don't think another actor could have done better with Jumper either.
Should have just been a movie with HCs character teaming up with that other jumper guy taking on SL Jackson and his goons without the terrible pointless love story that sucked up most of it.....
Hell they still could have left the story arc of his mom being a part of the cult pursuing them which is why she had to abandon him
Makes me think, has he done anything since Jumper or has SW destroyed another actors career?
He retired from acting, I believe.
AliasMan02 said:
He retired from acting, I believe.
I also, "retired" from acting
Does the family of Peter Cushing receive royalties from his likeness being used in the new film? I would imagine they would.
Sex Panther said:AliasMan02 said:
He retired from acting, I believe.
I also, "retired" from acting
Apache said:
Does the family of Peter Cushing receive royalties from his likeness being used in the new film? I would imagine they would.
It's a complicated question.
http://www.vulture.com/2016/12/rogue-one-peter-cushing-digital-likeness.html
So did the little kid who played Anikan in TPM soon afterwards....Sex Panther said:AliasMan02 said:
He retired from acting, I believe.
I also, "retired" from acting
Course the only other movie I can think of with him in it is Jingle All The Way
I will say he was decent in Life as a House, but I'm not sure how much acting he was doing.Yoda said:PatAg said:Dude can't act, he would **** that scene up somehow.AliasMan02 said:
Hot sports opinion: I think it would have been interesting if they put Hayden in the Bacta and the suit. Proving they can do things better than Lucas is a worthy goal for Disney, and using HC successfully would have been a good step if they could manage it.
He was not good in the prequels, but not sure it was all his fault. Ever seen Shattered Glass?
I'm sure he is rich as hell from the Star Wars movies + JumperSex Panther said:AliasMan02 said:
He retired from acting, I believe.
I also, "retired" from acting
I've not seen anyone else post about it, but the first shot of the Star destroyer in front of the Death Star was so terribly laughable. It looked like a couple of kids were filming their toys. It was shocking.
The rest of the movie made me forget about it. So much fun. I had heard about the Tarkin CGI and was pleasantly surprised by how good it was.
I would have loved a three hour movie to get more of the doomed characters more exposition. Can't wait to see it again.
The rest of the movie made me forget about it. So much fun. I had heard about the Tarkin CGI and was pleasantly surprised by how good it was.
I would have loved a three hour movie to get more of the doomed characters more exposition. Can't wait to see it again.
I'm not sure how you'd expect that to look like. If Lucasfilm opted to instead build a full sized death star and star destroyer and place them in the same orientation to a similar sized sun, it would look identical to that. The graphics algorithms required to render that have been have been hashed out for several decades (unlike translucent human skin which is much more recent). If you think that looked fake, then it's probably your expectations that are wrong, not the rendering.1 said:
I've not seen anyone else post about it, but the first shot of the Star destroyer in front of the Death Star was so terribly laughable. It looked like a couple of kids were filming their toys. It was shocking.
I'm assuming the proposed political subtext came from the scene where she was imploring the rebellion to get in the fight. They used the "hope" message about 6 times in 30 seconds which could have easily been interpreted as Obama's hope and change message, if you are a cynical person. If I put my politics board hat on it looks pretty blatant as a pro-Obama / anti-Trump message.
However, Occam's Razor says it was simply a nod to ANH.
However, Occam's Razor says it was simply a nod to ANH.
I'll have to go back and watch it and see if it's the same shot but I noticed the same thing. It looked like they were filming a cheapo hobby shop model of a star destroyer.
I don't have a highly critical eye when it comes to movie magic (I was confused by Tarkin and Leia but didn't notice any obvious CGI) but the head on shop looked like it was made out of monochromatic plastic.
I don't have a highly critical eye when it comes to movie magic (I was confused by Tarkin and Leia but didn't notice any obvious CGI) but the head on shop looked like it was made out of monochromatic plastic.
I get accused on this board of seeing everything through political glasses (and I'll agree). That's part of the reason I hate avatar and crap like that. But I didn't see any slant in Rogue One. Except the obvious comparison of the empire to Nazi Germany, but that's by design. I think all the Hope stuff was in reference to ANH. Nothing more.YouBet said:
I'm assuming the proposed political subtext came from the scene where she was imploring the rebellion to get in the fight. They used the "hope" message about 6 times in 30 seconds which could have easily been interpreted as Obama's hope and change message, if you are a cynical person. If I put my politics board hat on it looks pretty blatant as a pro-Obama / anti-Trump message.
However, Occam's Razor says it was simply a nod to ANH.
When the trailer for Rogue One released I thought the star destroyer in front of the death star looked like really cheap plastic. I figured it was going to be polished up in editing. Nope. I think it just looked too white. All the other shots of star destroyers looked fine.
Clear to me that they were trying to replicate the OT look.
Well, just got a text alert that debbie reynolds was taken to the hospital.
The destroyers are all digital.
Unless he was added after the fact, he's not in the trailer version of that shot...
He's probably using his Sith Lord powers to remain invisible in trailers.
Featured Stories
See All
24:46
13h ago
22k
'The Other Kid': A&M dismantles Mizzou in Weigman's return, 41-10
by Olin Buchanan
22:57
15h ago
15k
Post Game Review: No. 25 Texas A&M 41, No. 9 Missouri 10
by Kay Naegeli
138:15
22h ago
6.2k