Completely disagree. Paul is supposed to be slight and not physically imposing. Several times in the book characters remark that Paul is small for 15.Quote:
To an extent Paul should be a larger actor, Chalamet is a small guy, and Paul is supposed to be a natural leader of men.
*** DUNE: PART TWO ***
154,267 Views |
1415 Replies |
Last: 6 mo ago by oragator
Yes, i made this same comment and when I reread Dune right before the movie came out I realized i was wrong.powerbelly said:Completely disagree. Paul is supposed to be slight and not physically imposing. Several times in the book characters remark that Paul is small for 15.Quote:
To an extent Paul should be a larger actor, Chalamet is a small guy, and Paul is supposed to be a natural leader of men.
powerbelly said:Completely disagree. Paul is supposed to be slight and not physically imposing. Several times in the book characters remark that Paul is small for 15.Quote:
To an extent Paul should be a larger actor, Chalamet is a small guy, and Paul is supposed to be a natural leader of men.
This.
He was a leader because of his breading and training, not his size.
In the immortal words of Gurney Halleck, "you bake when the sourdough rises, no matter the mood."
Never doubt the power of panko.
He had to play a teenager and teens do not put themselves out there, naturally. I do agree that the movie did not illustrate his intellect or Bene Gesserit training, which was disappointing.
We will see how good of an actor Tim is in Part II. There, he will have to lead millions, be a husband, and defeat the Harkonens in the same movie. His character will be completely different.
We will see how good of an actor Tim is in Part II. There, he will have to lead millions, be a husband, and defeat the Harkonens in the same movie. His character will be completely different.
Just finished Chapterhouse... what a great series
powerbelly said:Completely disagree. Paul is supposed to be slight and not physically imposing. Several times in the book characters remark that Paul is small for 15.Quote:
To an extent Paul should be a larger actor, Chalamet is a small guy, and Paul is supposed to be a natural leader of men.
So Tom Cruise could still play Paul.
https://i.postimg.cc/rpHKr9JQ/IMG-0770.jpg
Duncan Idaho said:
Never doubt the power of panko.
On Caladan, we ruled through Grain and Seed power. On Arrakis, we need to cultivate Dessert power.
Your would think his Fremen name, Muad'Dib, aka the Desert Mouse. would be a solid hint. It's why they showed the mouse in the movie.powerbelly said:Completely disagree. Paul is supposed to be slight and not physically imposing. Several times in the book characters remark that Paul is small for 15.Quote:
To an extent Paul should be a larger actor, Chalamet is a small guy, and Paul is supposed to be a natural leader of men.
Little known fact: Earlier versions of the manuscript had it as Paul Soyboy atreides.
Duncan Idaho said:
Little known fact: Earlier versions of the manuscript had it as Paul Soyboy atreides.
Quote:
I can't even describe it, there's something about the way she holds the needle in the new one vs the needle just being on the tip of her finger in the Lynch film.
I do like the look of the needle in the new movie better. But it really annoys me how much her hand is wavering in that scene. She's a Bene gesserit with perfect muscle control. That needle should have been rock solid.
TCTTS said:Warner Bros. and Legendary’s ‘Dune Part Two’ is ramping up its pre-production efforts as sources tell Deadline Florence Pugh is in negotiations to join the cast. While not confirmed, sources say she will play Princess Irulan Corrino https://t.co/LCRtBiKBHz
— Deadline Hollywood (@DEADLINE) March 8, 2022EXCLUSIVE: Austin Butler is in negotiations to play Feyd-Rautha in Warner Bros. and Legendary’s ‘Dune Part Two’ https://t.co/g0jwKSTOv0
— Deadline Hollywood (@DEADLINE) March 10, 2022
Brilliant casting, this dude has a seriously punchable face.
When Paul Atreides meets the Paul Atreides of Earth-2: pic.twitter.com/Lk3iOvTrKA
— Zack Stentz (@MuseZack) March 29, 2022
SPOILERS MANbonfarr said:TCTTS said:Warner Bros. and Legendary’s ‘Dune Part Two’ is ramping up its pre-production efforts as sources tell Deadline Florence Pugh is in negotiations to join the cast. While not confirmed, sources say she will play Princess Irulan Corrino https://t.co/LCRtBiKBHz
— Deadline Hollywood (@DEADLINE) March 8, 2022EXCLUSIVE: Austin Butler is in negotiations to play Feyd-Rautha in Warner Bros. and Legendary’s ‘Dune Part Two’ https://t.co/g0jwKSTOv0
— Deadline Hollywood (@DEADLINE) March 10, 2022
Brilliant casting, this dude has a seriously punchable face.
Dune: Part Two principle photography is currently scheduled for July 18 at ORIGO Studios, Budapest. #Dune pic.twitter.com/X1FwJICvbj
— Secrets of Dune | Ralí (@SecretsOfDune) April 21, 2022
Quote:
Your would think his Fremen name, Muad'Dib, aka the Desert Mouse. would be a solid hint. It's why they showed the mouse in the movie.
Yeah but he's also Usul, aka the Strength at the Base of the Pillar.
Suppose the contradiction of names represents the Duality of Man. Or something like that.
Apache said:Quote:
Your would think his Fremen name, Muad'Dib, aka the Desert Mouse. would be a solid hint. It's why they showed the mouse in the movie.
Yeah but he's also Usul, aka the Strength at the Base of the Pillar.
Suppose the contradiction of names represents the Duality of Man. Or something like that.
The book also says he's literally small about a dozen times.
Renck is legit. This also tells me they're gearing up to hopefully have this ready around the time the sequel movie hits…
— Johan Renck (@johanrenck) April 27, 2022
Duncan Idaho
Joined:
Apr 3, 2012
Posts:
29,081
How long do you want to ignore this user?
The sisterhood??!!?!?!!!!!!;!!!
This show had better not be woke.
This show had better not be woke.
Awesome! Would love to see this show touch on the Butlerian Jihad and the formation of the Metats/Spicing Guild as well. Not sure if those timelines all line up though.
My post was a joke btw.
congrats on finishing it out. very rewarding despite the obvious plans for another volume by FH.SpreadsheetAg said:
Just finished Chapterhouse... what a great series
Don't even think of picking up the garbage by his son and Kevin J. Anderson.
Edited to add: I've grown to appreciate the later novels even more upon my last reread last year. Dune 4 (we will call it that to not encroach upon the "no spoilers because novel readers REEEEEEEEEEE" crowd) is a great bookend to Dunes 2 and 3. Dunes 5 and 6 are superb stand-alones that feel satisfying as far future sci-fi pieces with some continuity to the others.
At least 130 deleted scenes???!!!!?!!!
130 deleted shots. Not scenes. That said, between this video and all the others that channel has covered, there are easily AT LEAST 10 significant deleted scenes, if not 12-15 or so. Either way, I've never seen so much quality content left on the cutting room floor. To the point where there HAS to be an extended cut at some point. This stuff is too good otherwise.
WHOA
BREAKING: Christopher Walken has been cast in #Dune2 as Padishah Emperor Shaddam IV of House Corrino, the father of Florence Pugh's Princess Irulan and the ruler of the known universe. https://t.co/S7RuhWp5Q4 pic.twitter.com/Uliy1pMA2t
— Screen Rant (@screenrant) May 12, 2022
Whoa.
I think I like this casting.
Walk without rhythm and we won't attract the worm
I'd be just fine with Christopher Walken being emperor of the galaxy
Will the Sardaukar have a fever?
https://i.postimg.cc/rpHKr9JQ/IMG-0770.jpg
Walken is a great actor, but he has been on Saturday Night Live & parodied so much the past 20 years it may be tough to separate the character from the actor.
He was great on Severance
btk55
BREAKING: The Dallas #Cowboys and head coach Mike McCarthy have decided to part ways.
in Billy Liucci's TexAgs Premium
110