Lindsay Clancy Trial

157,799 Views | 1680 Replies | Last: 9 hrs ago by BadMoonRisin
Spergin
User Profile
Private Message
Ignore User Stop Ignoring
How long do you want to ignore this user?
24 hours One week Permanently Cancel
7:01a, 8/14/26


If you haven't been following X or Tik Tok, then you're not seeing the insane response from tons of women. They are blaming everyone except the woman. It's not just feminists, I have seen tons of supposed conservative women doing the same thing. The amount of women not doing this has been like 5% of women.



Mental illness is not an excuse to murder. Many men are mentally ill and they get life in prison or execution. That is what this woman deserves.

Also, it's clear more than ever that we need to repeal the 19th and that women should not be allowed to be judged.


Reply Quote
25
reineraggie09
User Profile
Private Message
Ignore User Stop Ignoring
How long do you want to ignore this user?
24 hours One week Permanently Cancel
In reply to Queso1 • 7:05a, 8/14/26
AG
Went to my doctor for my annual physical. Mentioned I've had a ringing in my ear for a few weeks. Her first response, go see an ENT. Her second response, we can try SSRIs. For ear ringing……..
Reply Quote
13
The Collective
User Profile Ignore User Stop Ignoring
How long do you want to ignore this user?
24 hours One week Permanently Cancel
7:16a, 8/14/26
AG
Feminists being ok with murder isn't exactly a novel concept.
Reply Quote
23
Spergin
User Profile
Private Message
Ignore User Stop Ignoring
How long do you want to ignore this user?
24 hours One week Permanently Cancel
In reply to The Collective • 7:38a, 8/14/26
The Collective said:
Feminists being ok with murder isn't exactly a novel concept.


Read what I said again, it's all women not just feminists. Tons of conservative women are doing it too.

Women can never be criminals, they are always victims.
Reply Quote
4
ErnestEndeavor
User Profile
Private Message
Ignore User Stop Ignoring
How long do you want to ignore this user?
24 hours One week Permanently Cancel
In reply to Spergin • 8:00a, 8/14/26
One way to view that as a positive is a bunch of women are actually talking about the negative effects of these psych medicines that doctors are over-prescribing.

For example, when someone is prescribed Prozac it can take years to effectively wean them off of it without significant side effects.

IMO this is one of those rare cases where there's a reasonable belief that she was legally insane at the time of the murders.
Reply Quote
3
1 edit
Queso1
User Profile Ignore User Stop Ignoring
How long do you want to ignore this user?
24 hours One week Permanently Cancel
In reply to reineraggie09 • 8:01a, 8/14/26
AG
reineraggie09 said:
Went to my doctor for my annual physical. Mentioned I've had a ringing in my ear for a few weeks. Her first response, go see an ENT. Her second response, we can try SSRIs. For ear ringing……..


Don't worry, they'll have a pill for the side effects too. Crazy stuff.
Reply Quote
8
ErnestEndeavor
User Profile
Private Message
Ignore User Stop Ignoring
How long do you want to ignore this user?
24 hours One week Permanently Cancel
In reply to Vessel • 8:08a, 8/14/26
It does matter if she was insane or not at the time. For hundreds of years going back to English common law we have not held people legally responsible for crimes they commit when they cannot appreciate what they are doing as being right or wrong. The legal standard that she has to meet here is very high and I don't know whether or not she will get there, but she has one of the best cases for insanity I've seen in a long time of watching trials.

IMO she needs to be in a psych facility for an extended period of time but considering this was postpartum psychosis exacerbated by medication, they would probably let her out within a few years if not sooner. If I'm not mistaken, in Massachusetts I think a judge has to actually sign off on her release which would likely not be granted on the first try.
Reply Quote
1
Hardcore Greg
User Profile
Private Message
Ignore User Stop Ignoring
How long do you want to ignore this user?
24 hours One week Permanently Cancel
8:09a, 8/14/26
Sorry, this may sound inhumane, but anyone who does something like this should be given a bible and access to a minister for two weeks and then this treatment on the final day. They need to know that they are dying soon and that they have one final chance to at least get right with The Lord.



Insanity or postpartum psychosis should never be an excuse for murdering anyone, especialy your own children. Instead, the taxpayers will fund the entire remaining balance of her life. Not fair to society.
Reply Quote
15
4 edits
Hardcore Greg
User Profile
Private Message
Ignore User Stop Ignoring
How long do you want to ignore this user?
24 hours One week Permanently Cancel
In reply to ErnestEndeavor • 8:14a, 8/14/26
ErnestEndeavor said:
It does matter if she was insane or not at the time. For hundreds of years going back to English common law we have not held people legally responsible for crimes they commit when they cannot appreciate what they are doing as being right or wrong. The legal standard that she has to meet here is very high and I don't know whether or not she will get there, but she has one of the best cases for insanity I've seen in a long time of watching trials.

IMO she needs to be in a psych facility for an extended period of time but considering this was postpartum psychosis exacerbated by medication, they would probably let her out within a few years if not sooner. If I'm not mistaken, in Massachusetts I think a judge has to actually sign off on her release which would likely not be granted on the first try.

Clinically insane killers must still die. But she needs to be given a few weeks before execution to get right with God so she has a chance of being reuinited with her babies THAT SHE BRUTALLY MURDERED.

Their last memories are horrific beyond anything we can possibly imagine. I have never had a nightmare half as terrifying as my mother brutally killing me and my siblings. She needs to pay and has proven she can NEVER be trusted to function in society again. A certain level of trust has been broken.

Some of yall need to stop watching The View and the Don Lemon podcast. It's warping your brains.
Reply Quote
18
1 edit
Hardcore Greg
User Profile
Private Message
Ignore User Stop Ignoring
How long do you want to ignore this user?
24 hours One week Permanently Cancel
In reply to Spergin • 8:22a, 8/14/26
Yep, I saw sympathetic posts on instagram from a few conservative ladies I know and thought "wtf am I missing"? I genuinely assumed maybe there was some new evidence that could have dropped, indicating that she was not the killer (I have not been following this case closely at all).

If this was a father, even if his meds did make him insane, EVERYONE would want him buried 50 ft under the ground.
Reply Quote
5
FIDO*98*
User Profile
Private Message
Ignore User Stop Ignoring
How long do you want to ignore this user?
24 hours One week Permanently Cancel
In reply to Spergin • 8:26a, 8/14/26
AG
Spergin said:
The Collective said:
Feminists being ok with murder isn't exactly a novel concept.


Read what I said again, it's all women not just feminists. Tons of conservative women are doing it too.

Women can never be criminals, they are always victims.


A good friend who's very conservative and reposted a Instagram video basically blaming the husband and the legal system that was set up by men to benefit men. She was in a very toxic relationship and her husband stole from her so she is projecting her experience in this case
Reply Quote
6
Hardcore Greg
User Profile
Private Message
Ignore User Stop Ignoring
How long do you want to ignore this user?
24 hours One week Permanently Cancel
In reply to FIDO*98* • 8:48a, 8/14/26
FIDO*98* said:
Spergin said:
The Collective said:
Feminists being ok with murder isn't exactly a novel concept.


Read what I said again, it's all women not just feminists. Tons of conservative women are doing it too.

Women can never be criminals, they are always victims.


A good friend who's very conservative and reposted a Instagram video basically blaming the husband and the legal system that was set up by men to benefit men. She was in a very toxic relationship and her husband stole from her so she is projecting her experience in this case

Very few conservative women are not highly vulnerable to being emotionally hijacked into adopting ret@rded, nonsensical positions, if you really target them.
Reply Quote
7
ErnestEndeavor
User Profile
Private Message
Ignore User Stop Ignoring
How long do you want to ignore this user?
24 hours One week Permanently Cancel
In reply to Hardcore Greg • 8:51a, 8/14/26
Psychosis is a real thing and wasn't invented by daytime TV talk shows. This is a woman with no history of violence, no criminal history, excellent work history, by all accounts loved and cared for her kids. A typical, normal mother of three.

Either she's the most subtly manipulative and evil woman on the face of the planet who concocted a scheme to pretend to have psychiatric issues in an effort to eventually get away with murdering her three children (including jumping out of a high window and ending up partially paralyzed) or she had a psychiatric/psychotic break and did something completely out of character that she would have never done if she were in her right mind.

As a society I think there are deep questions as to what to do with someone who has a psychiatric break like this. Personally I think she needs to be in a long-term facility.
Reply Quote
4
1 edit
ErnestEndeavor
User Profile
Private Message
Ignore User Stop Ignoring
How long do you want to ignore this user?
24 hours One week Permanently Cancel
8:56a, 8/14/26
And I think one of the reasons all these women are coming out in support of her is because she was actively trying to get help for her postpartum depression. She tried to check herself into an inpatient facility and even called her psychiatry office to get advice on what to do when she was having intrusive thoughts. In their mind, she didn't get the help she needed.

Given how many meds she was prescribed in a very short time I don't know that I disagree with that assertion. I just think this is a terrible situation any way you look at it.
Reply Quote
7
Hardcore Greg
User Profile
Private Message
Ignore User Stop Ignoring
How long do you want to ignore this user?
24 hours One week Permanently Cancel
In reply to ErnestEndeavor • 8:59a, 8/14/26
ErnestEndeavor said:
Psychosis is a real thing and wasn't invented by daytime TV talk shows. This is a woman with no history of violence, no criminal history, excellent work history, by all accounts loved and cared for her kids. A typical, normal mother of three.

I know. I am sorry, it is unfortunate, but just not an excuse to me. If you go crazy enough to kill your own chidlren, you have broken all trust and can never be trusted again. Honestly, there is really no point in living anymore anyways after doing something like that.

Honestly, imagine waking up from a psychotic episode in which you butchered or drowned your own children. Anyone who wants to keep living is diabolical to begin with. A person with any conscience whatsoever says their prayers then kills themselves.

Are you female? Just curious.
Reply Quote
8
2 edits
B-1 83
User Profile
Private Message
Ignore User Stop Ignoring
How long do you want to ignore this user?
24 hours One week Permanently Cancel
9:06a, 8/14/26
AG
Why not send her to a mental facility for a time, figure out wtf is wrong with her (is she still on psychoactive drugs?), then ship her to the big house? Someone that would brutally kill her kids probably doesn't need to be dumped into the general prison population without making sure she isn't a danger to herself or others.
Being in TexAgs jail changes a man……..no, not really
Reply Quote
TrumpsBarber
User Profile Ignore User Stop Ignoring
How long do you want to ignore this user?
24 hours One week Permanently Cancel
9:12a, 8/14/26
During the trial, the prosecution established this woman had enough wits about her to send her husband on various errands the day she chose to murder her children. If she carefully planned the murder, then it would not matter to me whether she is insane. My sympathy is for the dead children and the grieving relatives who did not kill them.
Reply Quote
19
Hardcore Greg
User Profile
Private Message
Ignore User Stop Ignoring
How long do you want to ignore this user?
24 hours One week Permanently Cancel
In reply to TrumpsBarber • 9:20a, 8/14/26
TrumpsBarber said:
During the trial, the prosecution established this woman had enough wits about her to send her husband on various errands the day she chose to murder her children. If she carefully planned the murder, then it would not matter to me whether she is insane. My sympathy is for the dead children and the grieving relatives who did not kill them.

Also...Why does she even want to live at this point? Speaks volumes about her.

What kind of POS wakes up from a crazy spell where they strangle their poor children to death and fights like hell to keep on living life?
Reply Quote
7
MsDoubleD81
User Profile
Private Message
Ignore User Stop Ignoring
How long do you want to ignore this user?
24 hours One week Permanently Cancel
9:37a, 8/14/26
AG
Ok, since I've been watching the trial, I've changed my mind and thinks she is guilty. After seeing the kids. However, all of the YouTubers I've watched still seem to be on her side, even Lawyer You Know. Forget Melanie Little. Everyone seems to hate the prosecutors and love the defense attorney and thinks the defense is winning. Surprisingly, except for Jen Coffindaffer.

But I think that since it in Massachusetts, it's going to be difficult to prove her guilty with the low bar they have.
Reply Quote
schwack schwack
User Profile
Private Message
Ignore User Stop Ignoring
How long do you want to ignore this user?
24 hours One week Permanently Cancel
9:41a, 8/14/26
AG
I've watched a lot of it & it's a sad case for sure. Was there ever a plea bargain offered? Seems like she should have taken it if so. If I was on the jury, my main problem would be that. Was she hoping for sympathy & perhaps a short stay in a mental facility?

Also, I see why people like Reddington but I'm pretty turned off by his body language at the defense table - overly dramatic & distracting: the head in hands, the closed eyes, the finger drumming on the table, the hand holding & shoulder rubbing with his client & really, the fact that the judge doesn't crack down on him/her with the sobbing & stopping the procedure over & over. I get she's upset, but she had to know that autopsy reports & other hard to face issues would come in - they do at every murder trial. That stuff would bother me if on the jury.

Reply Quote
2
Ervin Burrell
User Profile Ignore User Stop Ignoring
How long do you want to ignore this user?
24 hours One week Permanently Cancel
In reply to Hardcore Greg • 9:45a, 8/14/26
AG
Hardcore Greg said:
TrumpsBarber said:
During the trial, the prosecution established this woman had enough wits about her to send her husband on various errands the day she chose to murder her children. If she carefully planned the murder, then it would not matter to me whether she is insane. My sympathy is for the dead children and the grieving relatives who did not kill them.

Also...Why does she even want to live at this point? Speaks volumes about her.

What kind of POS wakes up from a crazy spell where they strangle their poor children to death and fights like hell to keep on living life?


You realize she tried to kill herself already and failed, right? How do you know she is "fighting like hell" to keep living? I would bet you she wishes she were dead.
Reply Quote
Hardcore Greg
User Profile
Private Message
Ignore User Stop Ignoring
How long do you want to ignore this user?
24 hours One week Permanently Cancel
In reply to Ervin Burrell • 9:47a, 8/14/26
Ervin Burrell said:
Hardcore Greg said:
TrumpsBarber said:
During the trial, the prosecution established this woman had enough wits about her to send her husband on various errands the day she chose to murder her children. If she carefully planned the murder, then it would not matter to me whether she is insane. My sympathy is for the dead children and the grieving relatives who did not kill them.

Also...Why does she even want to live at this point? Speaks volumes about her.

What kind of POS wakes up from a crazy spell where they strangle their poor children to death and fights like hell to keep on living life?


You realize she tried to kill herself already and failed, right? How do you know she is "fighting like hell" to keep living? I would bet you she wishes she were dead.

I did not realize this. Good on her. Tells me she at least has a soul and a functioning conscience. Unlike the evil women in your political peer group who were gleefully applauding the passing of bill the other day signing full-term abortions into law.

if I were her, I would be telling my lawyer to fight for the death penalty though. I would be saying so myself in court...please execute me.
Reply Quote
4
2 edits
Ervin Burrell
User Profile Ignore User Stop Ignoring
How long do you want to ignore this user?
24 hours One week Permanently Cancel
In reply to Hardcore Greg • 9:59a, 8/14/26
AG
Hardcore Greg said:
Ervin Burrell said:
Hardcore Greg said:
TrumpsBarber said:
During the trial, the prosecution established this woman had enough wits about her to send her husband on various errands the day she chose to murder her children. If she carefully planned the murder, then it would not matter to me whether she is insane. My sympathy is for the dead children and the grieving relatives who did not kill them.

Also...Why does she even want to live at this point? Speaks volumes about her.

What kind of POS wakes up from a crazy spell where they strangle their poor children to death and fights like hell to keep on living life?


You realize she tried to kill herself already and failed, right? How do you know she is "fighting like hell" to keep living? I would bet you she wishes she were dead.

I did not realize this. Good on her. Tells me she at least has a soul and a functioning conscience. Unlike the evil women in your political peer group who were gleefully applauding the passing of bill the other day signing full-term abortions into law.

if I were her, I would be telling my lawyer to fight for the death penalty though. I would be saying so myself in court...please execute me.


If I were gullible enough to believe the fairy tale that all I'd need to do was read the bible for two weeks and repent then I'd get to go to heaven, I'd want to die too.
Reply Quote
MsDoubleD81
User Profile
Private Message
Ignore User Stop Ignoring
How long do you want to ignore this user?
24 hours One week Permanently Cancel
In reply to schwack schwack • 10:09a, 8/14/26
AG
That was my point. Was there not a plea bargain?

People are saying "why did they have to show all the stuff about autopsy. She knows what she did". Well, if she knows what she did......
Reply Quote
1
Hardcore Greg
User Profile
Private Message
Ignore User Stop Ignoring
How long do you want to ignore this user?
24 hours One week Permanently Cancel
In reply to Ervin Burrell • 10:43a, 8/14/26
Ervin Burrell said:
Hardcore Greg said:
Ervin Burrell said:
Hardcore Greg said:
TrumpsBarber said:
During the trial, the prosecution established this woman had enough wits about her to send her husband on various errands the day she chose to murder her children. If she carefully planned the murder, then it would not matter to me whether she is insane. My sympathy is for the dead children and the grieving relatives who did not kill them.

Also...Why does she even want to live at this point? Speaks volumes about her.

What kind of POS wakes up from a crazy spell where they strangle their poor children to death and fights like hell to keep on living life?


You realize she tried to kill herself already and failed, right? How do you know she is "fighting like hell" to keep living? I would bet you she wishes she were dead.

I did not realize this. Good on her. Tells me she at least has a soul and a functioning conscience. Unlike the evil women in your political peer group who were gleefully applauding the passing of bill the other day signing full-term abortions into law.

if I were her, I would be telling my lawyer to fight for the death penalty though. I would be saying so myself in court...please execute me.


If I were gullible enough to believe the fairy tale that all I'd need to do was read the bible for two weeks and repent then I'd get to go to heaven, I'd want to die too.

But if you believed the lights just went out peacefully and there was no pain, you would want to still keep living after waking up from a fever dream in which you strangled your poor children to death? Weird take. I will never understand atheists. Atheists support so many freakish, degenerate and ghoulish things and are completely confused by the basic centuries old concept of gender. So hyper-intelligent in their own minds, all because they believe the entire existence of the universe came into being from absolutely nothing, because "magic n shiiii". Meanwhile, you all seem to want more muslims here. I just can't with atheists (there are a few conservative ones who are normal and have their head on straight, as there are exceptions to just about everything in life).
Reply Quote
7
3 edits
Ervin Burrell
User Profile Ignore User Stop Ignoring
How long do you want to ignore this user?
24 hours One week Permanently Cancel
In reply to Hardcore Greg • 10:52a, 8/14/26
AG
Hardcore Greg said:
Ervin Burrell said:
Hardcore Greg said:
Ervin Burrell said:
Hardcore Greg said:
TrumpsBarber said:
During the trial, the prosecution established this woman had enough wits about her to send her husband on various errands the day she chose to murder her children. If she carefully planned the murder, then it would not matter to me whether she is insane. My sympathy is for the dead children and the grieving relatives who did not kill them.

Also...Why does she even want to live at this point? Speaks volumes about her.

What kind of POS wakes up from a crazy spell where they strangle their poor children to death and fights like hell to keep on living life?


You realize she tried to kill herself already and failed, right? How do you know she is "fighting like hell" to keep living? I would bet you she wishes she were dead.

I did not realize this. Good on her. Tells me she at least has a soul and a functioning conscience. Unlike the evil women in your political peer group who were gleefully applauding the passing of bill the other day signing full-term abortions into law.

if I were her, I would be telling my lawyer to fight for the death penalty though. I would be saying so myself in court...please execute me.


If I were gullible enough to believe the fairy tale that all I'd need to do was read the bible for two weeks and repent then I'd get to go to heaven, I'd want to die too.

But if you believed the lights just went out peacefully and there was no pain, you would want to still keep living after waking up from a fever dream in which you strangled your poor children to death? Weird take. I will never understand atheists. Atheists support so many freakish, degenerate and ghoulish things and are completely confused by the basic centuries old concept of gender. So hyper-intelligent in their own minds, all because they believe the entire existence of the universe came into being from absolutely nothing, because "magic n shiiii". Meanwhile, you all seem to want more muslims here. I just can't with atheists (there are a few conservative ones who are normal and have their head on straight, as there are exceptions to just about everything in life).


How do you reconcile the "fact" that she can just say "sorry Jesus, my bad"…and she gets to go to the same heaven as everyone else. Seems f'ing stupid, no?

And your strawman about Muslims was impressive but I'll bite. Islam, like every other religion in the world, is a complete joke so no, I don't "want more of them here."
Reply Quote
1
Vessel
User Profile
Private Message
Ignore User Stop Ignoring
How long do you want to ignore this user?
24 hours One week Permanently Cancel
10:58a, 8/14/26
A couple things that the insanity plea people can't reconcile. And keep in mind this is philosophical, not letter of the law. Obviously there are stupid laws we disagree with.

The first is this was clearly planned out. She sent her husband out of the house, knowing she'd have close to 30 minutes to kill the kids. Then she called them down the basement one by one and murdered them in an extremely terrifying and depraved way.

Then, she tried to kill herself, probably to free herself of the guilt of killing her kids. If she was just a crazy person who wanted to be freed of the voices in her head, why not just try to kill herself without killing the kids?

Finally, if you argue the depravity and illogic of it is proof that she was insane, then that leaves open the interpretation that any murderer has an insanity case.

If there were ever an obvious case of "remove this person from society forever in any way possible," this case is it.
Reply Quote
6
Hardcore Greg
User Profile
Private Message
Ignore User Stop Ignoring
How long do you want to ignore this user?
24 hours One week Permanently Cancel
In reply to Ervin Burrell • 11:04a, 8/14/26
Ervin Burrell said:
Hardcore Greg said:
Ervin Burrell said:
Hardcore Greg said:
Ervin Burrell said:
Hardcore Greg said:
TrumpsBarber said:
During the trial, the prosecution established this woman had enough wits about her to send her husband on various errands the day she chose to murder her children. If she carefully planned the murder, then it would not matter to me whether she is insane. My sympathy is for the dead children and the grieving relatives who did not kill them.

Also...Why does she even want to live at this point? Speaks volumes about her.

What kind of POS wakes up from a crazy spell where they strangle their poor children to death and fights like hell to keep on living life?


You realize she tried to kill herself already and failed, right? How do you know she is "fighting like hell" to keep living? I would bet you she wishes she were dead.

I did not realize this. Good on her. Tells me she at least has a soul and a functioning conscience. Unlike the evil women in your political peer group who were gleefully applauding the passing of bill the other day signing full-term abortions into law.

if I were her, I would be telling my lawyer to fight for the death penalty though. I would be saying so myself in court...please execute me.


If I were gullible enough to believe the fairy tale that all I'd need to do was read the bible for two weeks and repent then I'd get to go to heaven, I'd want to die too.

But if you believed the lights just went out peacefully and there was no pain, you would want to still keep living after waking up from a fever dream in which you strangled your poor children to death? Weird take. I will never understand atheists. Atheists support so many freakish, degenerate and ghoulish things and are completely confused by the basic centuries old concept of gender. So hyper-intelligent in their own minds, all because they believe the entire existence of the universe came into being from absolutely nothing, because "magic n shiiii". Meanwhile, you all seem to want more muslims here. I just can't with atheists (there are a few conservative ones who are normal and have their head on straight, as there are exceptions to just about everything in life).


How do you reconcile the "fact" that she can just say "sorry Jesus, my bad"…and she gets to go to the same heaven as everyone else. Seems f'ing stupid, no?

And your strawman about Muslims was impressive but I'll bite. Islam, like every other religion in the world, is a complete joke so no, I don't "want more of them here."

LOL, a complete over-simplification of scripture, obviously by design because you are so riddled with hatred and probably self-loathing that you don't have an honest bone in your body. You are completely free to read Jesus's parable of the workers in the vineyard and think it's "f'ing stupid". But no one believes salvation is just "Jesus, my bad". Not Catholics or Protestants.

This type of matter is extra special because it's hard to argue she was in control of her mind...she was obviously in a purely psychotic state.
Reply Quote
3
1 edit
AgLiving06
User Profile Ignore User Stop Ignoring
How long do you want to ignore this user?
24 hours One week Permanently Cancel
In reply to MsDoubleD81 • 11:06a, 8/14/26
MsDoubleD81 said:
That was my point. Was there not a plea bargain?

People are saying "why did they have to show all the stuff about autopsy. She knows what she did". Well, if she knows what she did......


A quick google search tells me she was not offered one.

I'm not even sure they can offer "life in a mental institute" but that's what I would have offered.
Reply Quote
Street Fighter
User Profile
Private Message
Ignore User Stop Ignoring
How long do you want to ignore this user?
24 hours One week Permanently Cancel
In reply to Hardcore Greg • 11:13a, 8/14/26
AG
Hardcore Greg said:
But no one believes salvation is just "Jesus, my bad". Not Catholics or Protestants.



You sure about that?
Reply Quote
1
Hardcore Greg
User Profile
Private Message
Ignore User Stop Ignoring
How long do you want to ignore this user?
24 hours One week Permanently Cancel
In reply to Vessel • 11:14a, 8/14/26
Vessel said:
A couple things that the insanity plea people can't reconcile. And keep in mind this is philosophical, not letter of the law. Obviously there are stupid laws we disagree with.

The first is this was clearly planned out. She sent her husband out of the house, knowing she'd have close to 30 minutes to kill the kids. Then she called them down the basement one by one and murdered them in an extremely terrifying and depraved way.

Then, she tried to kill herself, probably to free herself of the guilt of killing her kids. If she was just a crazy person who wanted to be freed of the voices in her head, why not just try to kill herself without killing the kids?

Finally, if you argue the depravity and illogic of it is proof that she was insane, then that leaves open the interpretation that any murderer has an insanity case.

If there were ever an obvious case of "remove this person from society forever in any way possible," this case is it.

Brah, trying to put yourself into the mind of a complete schizophrenic or someone in a psychotic episode is a fools errand. Throw all logic and reason out the window. We also need to realize these states don't just last 2-3 minutes. It can be days, or more...so it's not surprising at all that she operated as if it were a calculated mission that she could not fail no matter what.

My wife's cousin had a psychotis or manic meltdown in grad school at Stanford just a few years ago. You would not believe the things she was saying on social media for all the world to see. Sometimes it made sense but was extremely dark or lewd, and sometimes it may as well have been gibberish. This was about ad prim and proper, intelligent and well mannered of a girl you could imagine. Quiet high-achieving Asian academic in med school with toger parents. Life of pressure to excel may have helped crack her.
Reply Quote
Hardcore Greg
User Profile
Private Message
Ignore User Stop Ignoring
How long do you want to ignore this user?
24 hours One week Permanently Cancel
In reply to Street Fighter • 11:14a, 8/14/26
Street Fighter said:
Hardcore Greg said:
But no one believes salvation is just "Jesus, my bad". Not Catholics or Protestants.



You sure about that?

Not enough people to be statistically significant. I have never heard it taught that way. At all. Have you? Sources?
Reply Quote
2
Street Fighter
User Profile
Private Message
Ignore User Stop Ignoring
How long do you want to ignore this user?
24 hours One week Permanently Cancel
In reply to Hardcore Greg • 11:16a, 8/14/26
AG
Plenty of "influencers" pushing that line of thinking on social media. it's a dangerous belief that is growing in Christian circles.
Reply Quote
Vessel
User Profile
Private Message
Ignore User Stop Ignoring
How long do you want to ignore this user?
24 hours One week Permanently Cancel
In reply to Hardcore Greg • 11:17a, 8/14/26
That's basically my point. We know for certain she planned and carried out the murder of her children. That's enough to say she can't walk among peaceful people for the remainder of her life.

The lawyers and defenders of the insanity plea want to psychoanalyze these people, which is basically pseudoscience. We have to judge actions and decide if those actions are compatible with polite society.
Reply Quote
6
Hardcore Greg
User Profile
Private Message
Ignore User Stop Ignoring
How long do you want to ignore this user?
24 hours One week Permanently Cancel
In reply to Street Fighter • 11:25a, 8/14/26
Street Fighter said:
Plenty of "influencers" pushing that line of thinking on social media. it's a dangerous belief that is growing in Christian circles.

That's crazy...I follow diff Christian influencers who actually go by the Bible. I do believe salvation is open for all...even the likes of Jeffrey Dahmer. In fact, I know a man who ministered to him for an extended period of time and he was convinced that he became a true believer and fully repented.

I just get a kick out of atheists acting shocked over the Christian concept that anyone can be forgiven. It's the whole premise and essence of NT scripture and liberal atheist male feminists who don't know what a woman is act shocked every single time.

This is "good news" to everyone without a blackened heart.
Reply Quote
7
1 edit
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.