*** STAR WARS: ANDOR *** (Disney+)

212,276 Views | 1987 Replies | Last: 4 mo ago by ABATTBQ11
OnlyForNow
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
So, one thing I thought of after reading this post above, why didn't Cassian kill every guard he came across during the prison escape?

That blaster gun, didn't only fire stun bolts/rays right? If so, he is a prison rioter, I mean that's most likely an Imperial death sentence. Was it because it wasn't good for the writing/show, or what? Once they have massive control, kill all the guards, no one will be reporting anything for a while and the "chase" should be severely slowed down to a degree.

Aggie_Journalist
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Red Five said:

Aggie_Journalist said:

My only quibble is it felt a tad contrived that almost everyone was on Ferrix at the same time. It doesn't really make sense for the empire to go all out on the funeral assuming Andor will show up; it doesn't really make sense for Andor, knowing he's a very wanted fugitive, to go to the funeral; and it didn't makes sense for Luthen and the two rebel ladies to all be there either for a job one or two of them could handle. It was all just a tad "we need these people to be here for a finale, so it's going to happen," when really a small imperial force keeping an eye out, 1 or 2 luthen agents and No Andor would make more sense if folks were all making the smart moves. But this is a very small quibble because the climax putting all those folks in one place gave us was quite fun.
Oh, and Andor seemed to get in and out of the garrisoned hotel wayyy too easily. Even with the riot drawing troopers outside, I'd have still expected more command and control inside that he'd have to deal with.

I also really liked how organically the riot happened. It's not clear how much of an uprising was planned at all. The people were feeling tense and defiant, sure, and one kid wanted to avenge his dead father (?) with a pipe bomb, but if the imperial agent hadn't flipped out and knocked over the droid, there might not have been a riot at all. Really liked the way they showed chance and opportunity play out here. And the way they showed it was chaotic, but this didn't end in an "empire driven off the planet!" Moment, or anything silly like that.
The Empire didn't go all out for the funeral. It was 1 ISB agent and her assistant along with the local garrison that was already on planet to take over security/governance from the Corpos following the first riot. The garrison was deployed due to the high tensions and risk of another riot.

I'm not sure Andor knows he is a wanted fugitive to that level. He was wanted for the murder of 2 men, but even the failed raid by the corporate security forces was mostly covered over by the first riot. He came back after Aldhani and was able to slip in and out without trouble, so it's reasonable to think he could do it again. Until arriving on Ferrix I don't think there is any reason to think he would know that the ISB considers him a high priority target since that is only due to his connection to Axis, which he doesn't even know is Luthen.

Cinta was always there because her job was to wait there until Andor came back and then kill him. Vel makes sense because she is actively being brushed off by everyone when she thought she was important, so she is trying to get people to pay attention to her even if it compromises other people's cover/mission.

Luthen is the one who shouldn't have been there, but even his assistant tells him that and he says he needs to see to it personally. Maybe the business with Kreegyr and Saw unnerved him and he felt like going there to recruit Cassian instead of killing him would ease his conscience. It's certainly acknowledged by the show that he shouldn't have been there.


Good points
Thanks and gig'em
jeffk
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Finally caught up and I just wanted to say how much I've enjoyed this series. Just continues to hit all the right notes for me and largely avoided common pitfalls that usually drag down SW properties.
ABATTBQ11
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Red Five said:

Aggie_Journalist said:

My only quibble is it felt a tad contrived that almost everyone was on Ferrix at the same time. It doesn't really make sense for the empire to go all out on the funeral assuming Andor will show up; it doesn't really make sense for Andor, knowing he's a very wanted fugitive, to go to the funeral; and it didn't makes sense for Luthen and the two rebel ladies to all be there either for a job one or two of them could handle. It was all just a tad "we need these people to be here for a finale, so it's going to happen," when really a small imperial force keeping an eye out, 1 or 2 luthen agents and No Andor would make more sense if folks were all making the smart moves. But this is a very small quibble because the climax putting all those folks in one place gave us was quite fun.
Oh, and Andor seemed to get in and out of the garrisoned hotel wayyy too easily. Even with the riot drawing troopers outside, I'd have still expected more command and control inside that he'd have to deal with.

I also really liked how organically the riot happened. It's not clear how much of an uprising was planned at all. The people were feeling tense and defiant, sure, and one kid wanted to avenge his dead father (?) with a pipe bomb, but if the imperial agent hadn't flipped out and knocked over the droid, there might not have been a riot at all. Really liked the way they showed chance and opportunity play out here. And the way they showed it was chaotic, but this didn't end in an "empire driven off the planet!" Moment, or anything silly like that.
The Empire didn't go all out for the funeral. It was 1 ISB agent and her assistant along with the local garrison that was already on planet to take over security/governance from the Corpos following the first riot. The garrison was deployed due to the high tensions and risk of another riot.

I'm not sure Andor knows he is a wanted fugitive to that level. He was wanted for the murder of 2 men, but even the failed raid by the corporate security forces was mostly covered over by the first riot. He came back after Aldhani and was able to slip in and out without trouble, so it's reasonable to think he could do it again. Until arriving on Ferrix I don't think there is any reason to think he would know that the ISB considers him a high priority target since that is only due to his connection to Axis, which he doesn't even know is Luthen.

Cinta was always there because her job was to wait there until Andor came back and then kill him. Vel makes sense because she is actively being brushed off by everyone when she thought she was important, so she is trying to get people to pay attention to her even if it compromises other people's cover/mission.

Luthen is the one who shouldn't have been there, but even his assistant tells him that and he says he needs to see to it personally. Maybe the business with Kreegyr and Saw unnerved him and he felt like going there to recruit Cassian instead of killing him would ease his conscience. It's certainly acknowledged by the show that he shouldn't have been there.


All of this. Plus, I don't think Cinta could find/kill Cassian on her own with the funeral going on and the substantial imperial presence. Too many people to follow and too much ground to cover. Vel would have been needed as an extra set of hands, and the same for Luthen to an extent. I think Luthen was also close enough to it that he wanted to be hands on. It makes sense for all three to be there.

Honestly, it makes absolute sense for everyone to be there. Cassian isn't going to miss it, and everyone looking for him knows it.
jokershady
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
This was an interesting little tidbit and seems to be accurate....check this breakdown and if you want just skip to the 16 minute mark....cause it really does look like Maarva doesn't actually say "Fight" the empire in the video....

lurker76
How long do you want to ignore this user?
We finally saw the final episode yesterday and it kicked ass. This entire series is fantastic. Here's to hoping, as has been stated already, that Disney catches on and puts the same effort into future SW shows. Enough of the Bobba Fett/ Obi-Wan disappointments.
BBRex
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I also finished this last night, and I thought the whole series was amazing. It reinforces my thoughts that the folks running Star Wars (back to RotJ) worry too much about making stories about the main characters kid friendly and kid accessible. Once they get past established characters and canon, there's a lot more room to explore and be creative.
StinkyPinky
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Awesome. Now I'm going to re-watch it all again with my wife (her first time through). I typically 1000% hate re-watching shows/movies, but this is the very rare exception. So much detail, complexity, canon, easter eggs, etc. that I suspect I'll like even more a show I already love. And I can also expect I'll be budgeting another couple of hours after the Season 2 Final to re-watch Rogue One again, which I suspect I will equally love more as well.
MandoArms
How long do you want to ignore this user?
So question do you think the doctor we saw on Narkina 5 has to confirm all 100 people on level 2 were dead before the disposed the bodies? Was that why he knew so much and was convinced they were all doomed?
IG: mando_arms
CondensedFogAggie
How long do you want to ignore this user?
MandoArms said:

So question do you think the doctor we saw on Narkina 5 has to confirm all 100 people on level 2 were dead before the disposed the bodies? Was that why he knew so much and was convinced they were all doomed?

1) Prisoners on the bridge learn a man was sent to their floor instead of being feed
2) Those 100 prisoners, or enough of them, start rioting on the bridge
3) They get zapped
4) Doctor is called in and hears what happened from a dying prisoner or two.
5) Then confirms all 100 dead.
6) Maintenance tech is called in to fix things after the bodies are disposed, which is why he didn't know exactly what happened.
ABATTBQ11
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
BBRex said:

I also finished this last night, and I thought the whole series was amazing. It reinforces my thoughts that the folks running Star Wars (back to RotJ) worry too much about making stories about the main characters kid friendly and kid accessible. Once they get past established characters and canon, there's a lot more room to explore and be creative.


The issue I have with this is that the franchise's commercial success has been based around being kid accessible. Without those kid accessible stories, you don't get everything else.

Look at Clone Wars. It touched on some really deep subjects, but only to the point that an animated show made for kids could. However, it paved the way for The Mandalorian, the financial success of which paved the way for Andor. I think if Andor has been first in that progression, it would not have worked.
GreasenUSA
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
ABATTBQ11 said:

BBRex said:

I also finished this last night, and I thought the whole series was amazing. It reinforces my thoughts that the folks running Star Wars (back to RotJ) worry too much about making stories about the main characters kid friendly and kid accessible. Once they get past established characters and canon, there's a lot more room to explore and be creative.


The issue I have with this is that the franchise's commercial success has been based around being kid accessible. Without those kid accessible stories, you don't get everything else.

Look at Clone Wars. It touched on some really deep subjects, but only to the point that an animated show made for kids could. However, it paved the way for The Mandalorian, the financial success of which paved the way for Andor. I think if Andor has been first in that progression, it would not have worked.
It's kind of funny when originally watching through The Clone Wars a few years back, my buddy and I joked about how so much of the material is actually way too much for kids.
redline248
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I had to watch a lot of stuff again before letting my son watch...but of course he picked a day when grandma was watching him to just burn thru a couple seasons
AliasMan02
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I've been thinking about it and don't see how the Ghost crew doesn't show up in Season 2. There are things they're involved in that touch what Andor is doing too much to be excluded.

Gilroy could just say No, of course, and that would be that.
redline248
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I wonder how difficult it is to pull off a decent looking live action Zeb
The Porkchop Express
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I can see them just emplying hera and chopper.
Life is better with a beagle
ChipFTAC01
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
In a world where I fully accept Chewbacca (and all of the wookies I think) I can't imagine that a good Zeb is that hard. But maybe the purple makes it harder.
ChipFTAC01
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Wookies and ewoks benefit from not speaking English. I wonder if it would be harder to accept Chewie if he talked like Barf.
The Collective
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I want a more in-depth understanding on how they tortured Bix. Maybe a Black Mirror meets Star Wars styled short could better inform me?
powerbelly
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
ChipFTAC01 said:

In a world where I fully accept Chewbacca (and all of the wookies I think) I can't imagine that a good Zeb is that hard. But maybe the purple makes it harder.
The length of Wookies hair helps hide a lot of "sins". The Lasat don't have the long hair so I would think it would be motion capture and not a practical costume.
AliasMan02
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
The Porkchop Express said:

I can see them just emplying hera and chopper.

Yep. She shows up for the planning of the rescue and most happens off screen.

Not sure I'd be able to resist a shot of Freddie as Kanan, though.
redline248
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
There has to be some sort of way Disney can get Freddie as Kanan vs Sarah Michelle as the 7th sister or whatever...right?
The Collective
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
redline248 said:

There has to be some sort of way Disney can get Freddie as Kanan vs Sarah Michelle as the 7th sister or whatever...right?


Sounds like the perfect parental couple for a Disney+ teen comedy.
The Porkchop Express
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
They can go the Poochie the Dog route and say Zeb died on the way back to his own planet.

Life is better with a beagle
The Porkchop Express
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Denise Gough (Dedra Meero ) has an interview with Empire today. A couple of really cool things to take from it.

1) She only got cast on Andor because the Game of Thrones spin-off with Naomi Watts didn't get picked up, as she had been cast in that. She is confirmed for Season 2, happily!

2) Her first DAY shooting was the season finale in the couryard with Aunt Petunia's hologram, as has made the story around the Internet:

The rest of this post is straight from Empire.

Quote:

"My first day was Ferrix… I was given my two Death Troopers one of whom had to be trained to run like a Death Trooper and not like a musical theatre star and I couldn't help myself, I just started doing the [hums the Imperial March]. Then, everyone started doing it. Fiona's voice was over all of us. Except, at the end, she didn't say, 'Fight the Empire!' She said, '**** the Empire!' Which we were all really excited about. But we weren't allowed to keep it, obviously."
One of the biggest hurdles for her was that infamous Star Wars dialogue. While Andor's dialogue is likely a bit more grounded than what George Lucas asked of his actors and actresses, playing in the Star Wars world was a challenge for Gough. She said:

Quote:

"I had to say, 'I need a multisector data blend going back two years.' And I couldn't do it. I couldn't get my mouth around the words. Ben Caron and I sat in the corner of the set, and I was like, 'You don't understand, Ben, all anyone has told me for the past five years is that I'm really excellent at acting. And now I'm really not. This is terrible.' I realised I needed muscles that I only usually use on stage. Tony says Anton Lesser [Imperial boss Partagaz] makes exposition sound like sonnets. Once I got it into my body, that language became really fun."
After getting into the Star Wars mindset, it became easier. The villain came to life, and something Gough's mother would tell her became a common thing again:

Quote:

"My mother used to say to me, 'You need to smile, because you can look quite sour if you don't.' I have a naturally downturned mouth."

We didn't see much smiling at all from Meero over the course of Andor, although she definitely took satisfaction in torturing Bix Gough said she also took pleasure in performing that scene:

Quote:

"By the time I got to the interrogation, I was just like, 'Let me at it! I love this so much!'"
Denise Gough will return for Andor season 2, although her role is still a mystery. Ironically, shortly after getting the scripts for season 2, Gough said that she ran into Ian McDiarmid in an unrelated setting. While not an indication that the Emperor will make an appearance in season 2, Gough touched on her wishes for Meero. She said:

Quote:

"What I'm really hoping for is Dedra out of uniform. I would look at Genevieve's [O'Reilly, Mon Mothma] costumes like, 'Oh my god.' Michael [Wilkinson, costume designer] deserves a real shout-out. I did one of my fittings and I put on an outfit and said, 'This is so Mon Mothma… I can't wear this, can I?' He was like, 'No.'"
On the more serious side of things, Gough made a declaration about what she will bring to the table next season. With a more appropriate F-bomb for good measure, she had this to say:

Quote:

"I am going to Dedra the **** out of the second season."

Life is better with a beagle
redline248
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Nice. She was really great in her role (as were the rest of the cast)
TCTTS
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I think I would have literally jumped out of my seat had they actually kept her f-bomb. Man, that would have been cool...

ABATTBQ11
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Frack the empire would have been great. Could see click bait bloggers everywhere trying to tie BSG into SW.
Malachi Constant
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Since we know "dank ferrik" is a curse word in the SW universe, they could have had her say "Ferrik the Empire"
TCTTS
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Considering the planet they're on is called "Ferrix," people probably would have just been confused more than anything.
redline248
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Too close Ferix. Personally, I'm glad they didn't. SW has always done a good job of using slightly different words for things we would understand.

Slicer instead of hacker
Caff instead of coffee
Refresher instead of restroom
etc.

I would have been pulled waaay out of the moment with the F word.
Dro07
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
redline248 said:

I wonder how difficult it is to pull off a decent looking live action Zeb
funny you say that is that i always thought that guy infatuated with Andor, cant remember his name, was a live action of Agent Kallus for some reason.
jkag89
How long do you want to ignore this user?
TCTTS said:

I think I would have literally jumped out of my seat had they actually kept her f-bomb. Man, that would have been cool...


Maybe it was simply Bee softening Maarva's language a bit to protect what he believed her image should be even in death. ******* being something he heard her utter countless times, but an Eff bomb was a no go in the little droid's mind.
The Dirty Sock
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I want to be made into a brick when I die. Then used to beat people in a riot.
TCTTS
How long do you want to ignore this user?
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.