SeattleAgJr said:There are two years between this and IX, so a lot of analysis will be coming from all sides.bangobango said:
The true damage of Johnson's decision will not be seen until the release of the third film. I have a feeling at that time the fallout will be fully realized and it will be larger than many expected.
On top of that, however Solo is received will play into this as well.
I agree with you on Dirty Harry, but nothing like that happened in this movie.cbr said:
I totally disagree. If Dirty Harry had shot a nun in the first ten minutes and gone off to be a drunk hobo for the rest of his life it might have been 'unpredictable and intelligent' but it would have been a ****ty movie like this one. None of the characters are acting in anyone's self interest. They are just doing stupid, irrational **** - and **** that is out of character as well as full of assinine current social assumptions. .
Cromagnum said:
My in-laws thought this was hands down the best star wars movie and were blown away that I thought it was in the bottom 3 of all 9 movies (counting Rogue One). They were more blown away that I had Rogue One in the top 3-4.
Cromagnum said:
No there aren't. IX comes out spring of 19.
Not everybody can. But plenty of characters did. Much more so than previous SW movies.redline248 said:
Poe and Finn had no depth.
I assume Rose told him.texasaggie04 said:
I must have missed something. How did the first order know the rebels were escaping on their ships from the cruiser? I thought they said they were told by the code breaker, but how would he know? As far as they knew from radio transmissions, Poe was taking the ship to light speed.
What did I miss?
aTmAg said:
I just realized that the write/director was from the Breaking Bad franchise. Now it makes more sense. That, along with the Wire are the two best television shows of all time and there is not a single karate scene in either of them. Characters are deep and all have their good points and flaws. I hope they keep these writers and allow them to take over the franchise for a long time.
aTmAg said:
Yep. Ren is exactly the same guy we saw at the end of TFA. No change at all.
My daughter (16 years old) and son (18 years old) thought it was great and want to watch it again. Meanwhile they think super hero movies are boring, cheesey, and lame (except TDK). Perhaps our families are interested in different things.02skiag said:aTmAg said:
I just realized that the write/director was from the Breaking Bad franchise. Now it makes more sense. That, along with the Wire are the two best television shows of all time and there is not a single karate scene in either of them. Characters are deep and all have their good points and flaws. I hope they keep these writers and allow them to take over the franchise for a long time.
The movie felt like a way too long TV episode so that makes sense if that's what he's Used to. It did it work as a movie and felt very disjointed. 4/5 of my family were bored. The 5th is a 10 yr old boy.
aTmAg said:I assume Rose told him.texasaggie04 said:
I must have missed something. How did the first order know the rebels were escaping on their ships from the cruiser? I thought they said they were told by the code breaker, but how would he know? As far as they knew from radio transmissions, Poe was taking the ship to light speed.
What did I miss?
He showed himself to be intelligent and much more than a guy who merely idolized Darth Vader. He became a much more sympathetic character than he was in TFA. The reason he turned on Luke makes actual sense unlike Anakin through 3 entire movies.digital_ag said:aTmAg said:
Yep. Ren is exactly the same guy we saw at the end of TFA. No change at all.
What about him developed or changed?
She would know about cloaking device on the transports, but probably not know the overall plan about using the big ship as bait and all of that. Del Toro probably would have put 2 and 2 together. It's not that much of a stretch.DannyDuberstein said:aTmAg said:I assume Rose told him.texasaggie04 said:
I must have missed something. How did the first order know the rebels were escaping on their ships from the cruiser? I thought they said they were told by the code breaker, but how would he know? As far as they knew from radio transmissions, Poe was taking the ship to light speed.
What did I miss?
How did Rose know? She had to know before they took off on the codebreaker plan, if she knew, then running off on some half-banked mutiny plan doesnt make much sense
aTmAg said:
I just realized that the write/director was from the Breaking Bad franchise. Now it makes more sense. That, along with the Wire are the two best television shows of all time and there is not a single karate scene in either of them. Characters are deep and all have their good points and flaws. I hope they keep these writers and allow them to take over the franchise for a long time.
Poe and Finn didn't know about the cloaking devices and Rose is not smart... both in that she blabbed and didn't put it together on her own. Not everybody is a super genius.DannyDuberstein said:
Enough of a stretch that it never occurred to Poe, Rose, or Finn. Just emphasizes bow nonsensical the Canto Bight story was.
I assume you think Marvel movies are the greatest thing ever? There are plenty of those coming out to get your fill.FL_Ag1998 said:aTmAg said:
I just realized that the write/director was from the Breaking Bad franchise. Now it makes more sense. That, along with the Wire are the two best television shows of all time and there is not a single karate scene in either of them. Characters are deep and all have their good points and flaws. I hope they keep these writers and allow them to take over the franchise for a long time.
Thank God the movie didn't spell EVERYTHING out for me. It assumes I'm smart enough to think on my own. That's a sign of good writing.FL_Ag1998 said:aTmAg said:She would know about cloaking device on the transports, but probably not know the overall plan about using the big ship as bait and all of that. Del Toro probably would have put 2 and 2 together. It's not that much of a stretch.DannyDuberstein said:aTmAg said:I assume Rose told him.texasaggie04 said:
I must have missed something. How did the first order know the rebels were escaping on their ships from the cruiser? I thought they said they were told by the code breaker, but how would he know? As far as they knew from radio transmissions, Poe was taking the ship to light speed.
What did I miss?
How did Rose know? She had to know before they took off on the codebreaker plan, if she knew, then running off on some half-banked mutiny plan doesnt make much sense
Yep, you as a fan are stretching to put 2 + 2 together, based on what you're guessing the characters knew and what they might have done... but sure, the writers did a fantastic job.
aTmAg said:I assume you think Marvel movies are the greatest thing ever? There are plenty of those coming out to get your fill.FL_Ag1998 said:aTmAg said:
I just realized that the write/director was from the Breaking Bad franchise. Now it makes more sense. That, along with the Wire are the two best television shows of all time and there is not a single karate scene in either of them. Characters are deep and all have their good points and flaws. I hope they keep these writers and allow them to take over the franchise for a long time.
aTmAg said:Thank God the movie didn't spell EVERYTHING out for me. It assumes I'm smart enough to think on my own. That's a sign of good writing.FL_Ag1998 said:aTmAg said:She would know about cloaking device on the transports, but probably not know the overall plan about using the big ship as bait and all of that. Del Toro probably would have put 2 and 2 together. It's not that much of a stretch.DannyDuberstein said:aTmAg said:I assume Rose told him.texasaggie04 said:
I must have missed something. How did the first order know the rebels were escaping on their ships from the cruiser? I thought they said they were told by the code breaker, but how would he know? As far as they knew from radio transmissions, Poe was taking the ship to light speed.
What did I miss?
How did Rose know? She had to know before they took off on the codebreaker plan, if she knew, then running off on some half-banked mutiny plan doesnt make much sense
Yep, you as a fan are stretching to put 2 + 2 together, based on what you're guessing the characters knew and what they might have done... but sure, the writers did a fantastic job.
Perfect. That is all that we need to know.FL_Ag1998 said:aTmAg said:I assume you think Marvel movies are the greatest thing ever? There are plenty of those coming out to get your fill.FL_Ag1998 said:aTmAg said:
I just realized that the write/director was from the Breaking Bad franchise. Now it makes more sense. That, along with the Wire are the two best television shows of all time and there is not a single karate scene in either of them. Characters are deep and all have their good points and flaws. I hope they keep these writers and allow them to take over the franchise for a long time.
Greatest thing ever? Haha, no. But most are way better than TLJ. And nice cheap jab there bud. Sorry you're so riled up. Hey, if you like it, good for you.
FL_Ag1998 said:aTmAg said:She would know about cloaking device on the transports, but probably not know the overall plan about using the big ship as bait and all of that. Del Toro probably would have put 2 and 2 together. It's not that much of a stretch.DannyDuberstein said:aTmAg said:I assume Rose told him.texasaggie04 said:
I must have missed something. How did the first order know the rebels were escaping on their ships from the cruiser? I thought they said they were told by the code breaker, but how would he know? As far as they knew from radio transmissions, Poe was taking the ship to light speed.
What did I miss?
How did Rose know? She had to know before they took off on the codebreaker plan, if she knew, then running off on some half-banked mutiny plan doesnt make much sense
Yep, you as a fan are stretching to put 2 + 2 together, based on what you're guessing the characters knew and what they might have done... but sure, the writers did a fantastic job.
aTmAg said:Perfect. That is all that we need to know.FL_Ag1998 said:aTmAg said:I assume you think Marvel movies are the greatest thing ever? There are plenty of those coming out to get your fill.FL_Ag1998 said:aTmAg said:
I just realized that the write/director was from the Breaking Bad franchise. Now it makes more sense. That, along with the Wire are the two best television shows of all time and there is not a single karate scene in either of them. Characters are deep and all have their good points and flaws. I hope they keep these writers and allow them to take over the franchise for a long time.
Greatest thing ever? Haha, no. But most are way better than TLJ. And nice cheap jab there bud. Sorry you're so riled up. Hey, if you like it, good for you.
aTmAg said:He showed himself to be intelligent and much more than a guy who merely idolized Darth Vader. He became a much more sympathetic character than he was in TFA. The reason he turned on Luke makes actual sense unlike Anakin through 3 entire movies.digital_ag said:aTmAg said:
Yep. Ren is exactly the same guy we saw at the end of TFA. No change at all.
What about him developed or changed?
If you are a fan of character development, then I assume that you must have HATED TFA? That movie has about as much character development as an episode of Barney (which is more than the prequels, BTW).
Dude, please.Quote:
most are way better than TLJ
letters at random said:Dude, please.Quote:
most are way better than TLJ
