Several thoughts on this:
First off I hate the post and think it created an unwanted distraction politically. That said:
First off I hate the post and think it created an unwanted distraction politically. That said:
- Most of these kids are 2nd Gen and their parents came here on visa. Some are not but most are citizens. These are overwhelmingly extremely bright kids.
- I do not like how they are a solid block with no integration. If they had white and other kids mixed in this wouldn't be noticed and it is noteworthy that many Asian kids don't mix. My neighbor for instance outright told me her daughter wouldn't go to A&M because there aren't enough Asians. Lack of integration is a very real problem and there seems to be little expectation for the people who aren't integrating to change.
- Cheating is very real among Asian kids in competitive HS's both overtly and more covertly. My son was a Top 5% kid at a top HS and he knew multiple groups of Asian kids that shared test answers and homework and he had to compete against them. Very hard to prove because the kids were smart in how they did it but it frustrated my son to feel like he was often competing against a hive mind.
- Some of these kids are fantastic. Some of my son's best friends are Asian and have been wonderful. Some absolutely are not though and they have a very different idea of "high trust" society and generosity. Many of my neighbors I have done many favors for but it's never returned.
- The Top 10/5% rules are what has caused this. It hurts bright kids at quality suburban HS's the most where it is insanely competitive to be in those ranges. Thus you have large numbers of kids that could be successful at A&M/Texas that have to go Blinn Team or System/CAP and it creates resentment. The issue though isn't the Asian kids getting those slots, it's generally other minorities from poor performing HS's that also are the most likely to fail out. It makes the merit argument very confusing, especially to people who aren't from Texas and don't understand it. Thus X is filled with ignorance.
- Anyone that praises diversity or criticizes anything about white kids or males getting preference on anything or cheering minorities or females being successful is a hypocrite if they are going after French. Either race and sex matters or it doesn't.
"The most terrifying words in the English language are: I'm from the government and I'm here to help."
Ronald Reagan
Ronald Reagan