Drone technology doesn't exist in the future? Why are the fighters piloted by humans? Why couldn't the hyper-space technique used as a stand-alone weapon with purple hair on top?
*** SW: The Last Jedi - FULL SPOILERS BE IN HERE ***
356,392 Views |
3129 Replies |
Last: 7 mo ago by Definitely Not A Cop
Uh, you mean drone technology didn't exist a long time ago?SlackerAg said:
Drone technology doesn't exist in the future? Why are the fighters piloted by humans? Why couldn't the hyper-space technique used as a stand-alone weapon with purple hair on top?
Bruce Almighty said:
So it's ok to have bad space physics as long as it's the same bad space physics from the original trilogy?
Yes. Have you never watched a space movie?
VanZandt92 said:Bruce Almighty said:
So it's ok to have bad space physics as long as it's the same bad space physics from the original trilogy?
Yes. Have you never watched a space movie?
I think you missed my point.
Haven't read the thread. Just popped in to say that I enjoyed this movie more than the last 2, and it's a shame that they killed the attractive sister during the bombing run at the beginning of the movie and left Finn with the ugly stalker one.
"...again a misunderstanding, I killed at Young Ling's, the most kick a** Asian comedy club in the galaxy!" Jimmy Fallon as Anakin in Ep III SkitCJS4715 said:dave94 said:Who did Luke murder?Dr. Teeth said:
TLJ turned one of my biggest childhood heroes into a murderous cowardly POS
Younglings
Trident 88 said:
Haven't read the thread. Just popped in to say that I enjoyed this movie more than the last 2, and it's a shame that they killed the attractive sister during the bombing run at the beginning of the movie and left Finn with the ugly stalker one.
The attractive one was a foreign actress with no English, so they probably didn't want to give her any lines but sell the "international" angle for ticket sales. The ugly one is from America, unfortunately.
Not that anyone should give a dang, but here are my opinions (SPOILER WARNING):
* The prequels sucked, terrible movies, all CGI, walking and talking, sitting and talking. Terrible
* I liked rogue one, but you knew how it started and ended so it doesn't add much to the story. Good movie
* I liked TFA, much better than the prequels and was the quality of a "real" movie. However, I hated the fact that the plot once again centered on blowing up a death star/super weapon. I liked the new characters. Enjoyed it.
* I liked TLJ, more the second time. However, I wish:
** Leia would've done the suicide mission at the end instead of Jurassic Park lady
** Get rid of the casino scenes. Simple say "we need a hacker"... "I know Bob in the weapons group is a hacker"... "Great, I'll go get him". Accomplishes the same thing.
** It kind of bums me out how Fin/Poe's plan did nothing to help the Rebels (it actually hurt it). They should've done nothing. Similar to Raiders of the Last Ark
** Instead of focusing on the dice from the falcon, I wish they would've used Han's medal from A New Hope. I knew there were dice before, but never really cared about them. The medal means something
** I wish Rose would've been played by someone more attractive. I know that sounds shallow, but in Hollywood, you should always use attractive people unless the script calls for it. She was likeable I guess, but the entire romance arc wasn't something I bought into or cared about.
*Leia flying was stupid
With that said, I am a bit shocked at the negative takes on TLJ. Was it perfect? No. Was it a good movie? I definitely think so. I liked it more than TFA as it at least had an original plot.
Original trilogy > TLJ > R1 > TFA >>>> prequels >>>>>>>> Holiday special
I tend to agree with hellogreedo on most of this.
* The prequels sucked, terrible movies, all CGI, walking and talking, sitting and talking. Terrible
* I liked rogue one, but you knew how it started and ended so it doesn't add much to the story. Good movie
* I liked TFA, much better than the prequels and was the quality of a "real" movie. However, I hated the fact that the plot once again centered on blowing up a death star/super weapon. I liked the new characters. Enjoyed it.
* I liked TLJ, more the second time. However, I wish:
** Leia would've done the suicide mission at the end instead of Jurassic Park lady
** Get rid of the casino scenes. Simple say "we need a hacker"... "I know Bob in the weapons group is a hacker"... "Great, I'll go get him". Accomplishes the same thing.
** It kind of bums me out how Fin/Poe's plan did nothing to help the Rebels (it actually hurt it). They should've done nothing. Similar to Raiders of the Last Ark
** Instead of focusing on the dice from the falcon, I wish they would've used Han's medal from A New Hope. I knew there were dice before, but never really cared about them. The medal means something
** I wish Rose would've been played by someone more attractive. I know that sounds shallow, but in Hollywood, you should always use attractive people unless the script calls for it. She was likeable I guess, but the entire romance arc wasn't something I bought into or cared about.
*Leia flying was stupid
With that said, I am a bit shocked at the negative takes on TLJ. Was it perfect? No. Was it a good movie? I definitely think so. I liked it more than TFA as it at least had an original plot.
Original trilogy > TLJ > R1 > TFA >>>> prequels >>>>>>>> Holiday special
I tend to agree with hellogreedo on most of this.
Disney had to do the dice thing as I am sure it will be featured(beat over our heads) in the Solo movie "Han uses THOSE dice to win the Falcon, has them memorialized like some baby shoes in bronze carbonite"
Caring more about the dice than the medal is completely in line with han's character.
Matt_ag98 said:
Disney had to do the dice thing as I am sure it will be featured(beat over our heads) in the Solo movie "Han uses THOSE dice to win the Falcon, has them memorialized like some baby shoes in bronze carbonite"
I fear you are correct. This movie is a bad idea. Yesterday at the theater, my mom saw a poster for it and asked what it was. I explained it to her, and she said, who wants to see someone else play Han Solo? I'm sure many non-nerds (and even nerds) will feel similarly. This is a case where I fear that a good cast on paper will not be able to salvage a terrible idea.
A better object to exchange would have been Han's blaster, but I suppose we won't see it until Maz finds it and locks it away for 30 years.
Edit, meant to use sad face.
Edit, meant to use sad face.
Wanted to let Rey and Ren stay together and try to bring peace to the galaxy
Also Leia dying in space would have been fitting, now she is back in charge but RL dead
Also Leia dying in space would have been fitting, now she is back in charge but RL dead
Bockaneer said:
Wanted to let Rey and Ren stay together and try to bringpeaceorder to the galaxy
Ftfy
Rey and kylo rising to power and crushing all of the jihadists would have been glorious
For those saying they wish the lightspeed suicide mission was Leia instead.....
I have an alternative to that I prefer, similar but more elaborate.....and this is how I now think of it in my mind.
- Haldo (purple haired lady) leads the escape after the explosion that blows up the bridge.
- Ackbar is spared and he stays behind instead of Haldo
- Ackbar is the one who notices/finds Leia floating in space by detecting the ring beacon she is wearing.
- He uses some tractor beam on the ring to pull her in (instead of the horrible force thing) and she is treated in med bay by automated machines
- She has a visit from Luke which we think might be a dream at this point as she appears unconscious still and this mirrors the Rey/Kylo interactions so we assume they are connected subconsciously.
- Leia then "wakes up" suddenly, goes to the bridge, sees the situation and Ackbar says there is only one way....
- Leia nods and Ackbar blasts them through the dreadnaught
- Luke then senses her death on the island...and we see him (we think) heading toward the sunken X-wing...maybe even trying to raise it but then he drops it (we think he failed, but in reality he had a better idea).....
- The forces on Crait go through their battle as seen before and then Luke shows up - we assume he succeeded in raising the X-wing only realizing it is a projection later as it was originally shown. He already had a conversation with Leia so he simply goes out to face Kylo.
This solves so many things:
1. Haldo is there to lead the resistance in the future in ep. IX
2. Ackbar gets a badass ending
3. Leia's death is written into this episode
Now the Po thing I don't know about....I mean I guess Haldo could just be the one to stifle his coup attempt instead of Leia by stunning him.
Now this is all based on knowing Carrie Fisher dies of course.
But I think they could have reshot just a few scenes and made this work instead. Ackbar on the bridge instead, Haldo breaching the door and stunning Po, Haldo on the base on Crait instead of Leia. Use the Leia floating footage but make it appear as though she is drawn back instead of using the force.
Luke was the true Phantom Menace . . . To the first order
Pate 66. Time to execute order 66 on this movie and thread.
Matt_ag98 said:
Disney had to do the dice thing as I am sure it will be featured(beat over our heads) in the Solo movie "Han uses THOSE dice to win the Falcon, has them memorialized like some baby shoes in bronze carbonite"
No worries. Han beat Lando in a Sabaac tournament (card game), unless they retconn that.
What about showing Han's ""Kessler Run" under 12 parsecs?
SlackerAg said:
What about showing Han's ""Kessler Run" under 12 parsecs?
*Kessel
That was the Jewish one.
Not bad, but that way we got almost zero good Leia scenes.BernArnold said:
For those saying they wish the lightspeed suicide mission was Leia instead.....
I have an alternative to that I prefer, similar but more elaborate.....and this is how I now think of it in my mind.
- Haldo (purple haired lady) leads the escape after the explosion that blows up the bridge.
- Ackbar is spared and he stays behind instead of Haldo
- Ackbar is the one who notices/finds Leia floating in space by detecting the ring beacon she is wearing.
- He uses some tractor beam on the ring to pull her in (instead of the horrible force thing) and she is treated in med bay by automated machines
- She has a visit from Luke which we think might be a dream at this point as she appears unconscious still and this mirrors the Rey/Kylo interactions so we assume they are connected subconsciously.
- Leia then "wakes up" suddenly, goes to the bridge, sees the situation and Ackbar says there is only one way....
- Leia nods and Ackbar blasts them through the dreadnaught
- Luke then senses her death on the island...and we see him (we think) heading toward the sunken X-wing...maybe even trying to raise it but then he drops it (we think he failed, but in reality he had a better idea).....
- The forces on Crait go through their battle as seen before and then Luke shows up - we assume he succeeded in raising the X-wing only realizing it is a projection later as it was originally shown. He already had a conversation with Leia so he simply goes out to face Kylo.
This solves so many things:
1. Haldo is there to lead the resistance in the future in ep. IX
2. Ackbar gets a badass ending
3. Leia's death is written into this episode
Now the Po thing I don't know about....I mean I guess Haldo could just be the one to stifle his coup attempt instead of Leia by stunning him.
Now this is all based on knowing Carrie Fisher dies of course.
But I think they could have reshot just a few scenes and made this work instead. Ackbar on the bridge instead, Haldo breaching the door and stunning Po, Haldo on the base on Crait instead of Leia. Use the Leia floating footage but make it appear as though she is drawn back instead of using the force.
Rian better be damn happy he had that Luke and Leia scene. Imagine how pissed people would be if that entire opp was missed.
While we're talking physics, do you die immediately when you get cut in half? A force user to snokes extent could have inflicted some major damage even if he had a 5 second window.
And maybe even put himself back together.
TCTTS said:Bockaneer said:
Just saw the movie - good time f the whole family
Maybe my favorite take yet. F 'em all.
Well done!!!
If you're talking real physics and lightsabers, then you would die just by turning it on. It puts out enough heat energy to immediately melt through blast doors, remember?BCG Disciple said:
While we're talking physics, do you die immediately when you get cut in half? A force user to snokes extent could have inflicted some major damage even if he had a 5 second window.
Aside from his terrible voice that guy made solid points.
Agreed. Just watched that video earlier today.Farmer1906 said:
Aside from his terrible voice that guy made solid points.
I agree with everything he said...
Edit: and I made almost all those arguments on this thread from the beginning. Which is why the same posters agreeing with me are agreeing with him too.
Edit: and I made almost all those arguments on this thread from the beginning. Which is why the same posters agreeing with me are agreeing with him too.
That video may explain the dislike for some, but my problems wjth the film are the "MAJOR ISSUES" that he acknowledges it has. Plot issues, pacing, red herrings, some bad short-shrifted characters. I think it's kind of silly to say "this movie has all
sorts of major, fundamental problems but your reasons for not liking it are just because you are a sentimental codger that cant he pleased. ".
sorts of major, fundamental problems but your reasons for not liking it are just because you are a sentimental codger that cant he pleased. ".
That's not a bad point, but if that's the case, how can you feel any different for any of the other StarWars movies? 'Cus they're pretty much all like that...DannyDuberstein said:
That video may explain the dislike for some, but my problems wjth the film are the "MAJOR ISSUES" that he acknowledges it has. Plot issues, pacing, red herrings, some bad short-shrifted characters. I think it's kind of silly to say "this movie has major problems but your reasons for not liking it suck".
Featured Stories
See All
Second CFP rankings of 2024 sees Texas A&M move down to No. 15
by Richard Zane
10:53
16h ago
2.2k
5 Thoughts: No. 23 Texas A&M 97, Lamar 71
by Luke Evangelist