https://highposthoops.com/sophie-cunninghams-trans-comments-violate-the-ws-no-space-for-hate-policy
Quote:
Cunningham insisted she is "here to extend love," but almost in the same breath added that "love is truth, being honest." She then said, "And I want to protect young girls in a locker room, or young girls in sport who shouldn't have to go against biological men."
Cunningham's comments, at best, indicate a lack of understanding about the health and lives of transgender girls and women, and they also support an ideology that is considered transphobic by many allies and members of the LGBTQ+ community. They also show little understanding of the true nature of biology, an enormously complex scienceeven the question of what sex means biologically is confounding.
For example, the phrase "biological sex" may be a reference to reproductive organs, but could also be a reference to hormones or chromosomes, or perhaps secondary sex characteristics (physical aspects that tend to show up during puberty, but that have little impact on reproduction). When people say gender is a construct, this is the general idea they are circlinghow we've conceptualized sex and gender is largely based on science that few of us really understand, and instead, we have constructed definitions and gender presentations that tend to fit pretty neatly within our own worldviews to try to make sense of something that is larger than ourselves.
So that brings us back to Cunningham. She can claim to love any community or group of people she wishes, but her actual words offer insight into how far that "love" really goes. Because, at worst, her comments could reflect a genuine bigotry against transgender people, even if it's a bigotry due to a lack of understanding. The phrase "biological men" or "biological women" in this context is often used in a way that is derogatory and, frankly, meanand Cunningham offered no clarification on what context she's learned the phrase, why she continues to use it, and how she uses it when she's not being interviewed by a major news organization.