Proposition Joe said:
We trotted out Will Smith because Ardolis Chapman (an all-star closer) became unreliable.
Which kind of supports the point that spending a lot on a closer doesn't make good financial sense. If your team is bad, an expensive closer doesn't help you. If your team is good, there's still a pretty good chance your expensive closer isn't dominant.
Look at what Houston is paying and he has not been the most reliable.