PatAg said:
My guess is it will be perfectly fine.
Hard to be worse than what they was done to the hobbit
There's a pretty big gulf between "perfectly fine" and "what was done to The Hobbit."
***** The Lord of the Rings: Official Thread *****
240,197 Views |
1956 Replies |
Last: 18 days ago by Brian Earl Spilner
There's a pretty big gulf between "perfectly fine" and "what was done to The Hobbit."
I had no idea they were remaking Highlander!Brian Earl Spilner said:
Life is better with a beagle
The Collective said:
Looks to be all based off quotes from the cast, and allegedly Amazon is doing damage control & trying to walk it all back. IDK, stuff just started showing up in my feed. Not sure why…
This. Some of the cast/crew have talked about how it's supposed to be more representative and inclusive.
Essentially, they're trying to
I will remain highly skeptical until it is released.
ABATTBQ11 said:The Collective said:
Looks to be all based off quotes from the cast, and allegedly Amazon is doing damage control & trying to walk it all back. IDK, stuff just started showing up in my feed. Not sure why…
This. Some of the cast/crew have talked about how it's supposed to be more representative and inclusive.
Essentially, they're trying tocopyrecreate the success of GOT by playing on the success of the LOTR trilogy, which they didn't create, and playing to a fan base of Tolkien's work, which they also didn't create, by ripping it off, trying to throw their own woke spin on it, and throwing a lot of money at it. It just smacks of desperation and unoriginality.
I will remain highly skeptical until it is released.
After some research, The Tolkien society stuff has me worried. I'm sure they gave an opinion on the show
Yep, Im just hoping to enjoy it, but not expecting it to be great. I expect there will be many scenes, or parts of the story that I think just aren't very good. But overall I hope to like it.DVC2010 said:PatAg said:
My guess is it will be perfectly fine.
Hard to be worse than what they was done to the hobbit
There's a pretty big gulf between "perfectly fine" and "what was done to The Hobbit."
Basically, for a frame of reference, I expect it to be better than Wheel of Time season 1, and I'm still going to watch season 2 of that show.
Premiering at a reasonable time. (8 pm CT on Thursday 9/1)
https://www.theonering.net/torwp/2022/08/16/114402-the-rings-of-power-full-airing-schedule-is-now-available/
11 pm for the rest of the episodes.
https://www.theonering.net/torwp/2022/08/16/114402-the-rings-of-power-full-airing-schedule-is-now-available/
11 pm for the rest of the episodes.
One day away from all the TexAgs arguments. It's about to go down on this thread...
I expect it to be bad but am open to being surprised.
?DallasTeleAg said:
One day away from all the TexAgs arguments. It's about to go down on this thread...
He thinks it means tomorrow
Lol.... yeah, I read Thursday and immediately thought "tomorrow".wangus12 said:
He thinks it means tomorrow
Fine... two weeks until the Thunderdome.
Why even make this series when they don't own the rights to the primary source material? So much of what I've heard/seen so far seems to directly contradict what Tolkien wrote in the Silmarillion.
They already have the rights to LOTR, including the appendices. What they don't have is The Silmarillion.
C@LAg said:
think of it as multiverse alt fan-fiction.
Life is better with a beagle
Top YT comment when I last checked, "When Galadriel pulled out her lightsaber and said, "Wakanda forever" sent shivers up my spine. Tolkien couldn't have written anything better."
This sale does not affect them is my point.
Galadriel looks great.
I kind of wish the hobbits weren't in it at all to be honest. It feels like that was the whole point of how crazy it was that they were so much in focus for The Hobbit and LOTR. Most people in Middle Earth didn't even know they were around, or had never met one.
I kind of wish the hobbits weren't in it at all to be honest. It feels like that was the whole point of how crazy it was that they were so much in focus for The Hobbit and LOTR. Most people in Middle Earth didn't even know they were around, or had never met one.
Life is better with a beagle
I think it still kind of tracks though because of how long before LOTR this stuff is occurring. Like they didn't settle in the Shire area until the beginning of the Third Age.
Shire reckoning years are marked from the original settlement. SR year 1 is Third Age year 1601.
Brian Earl Spilner said:
They already have the rights to LOTR, including the appendices. What they don't have is The Silmarillion.
That's not quite true.
By virtue of contracting with the Estate, if something is mentioned in the narrative of LOTR + Appendices, they can "look into" that particular narrative or item wherever more information can be gleaned.
But, if it only exists in UT or the Silmarillion, it's off-limits. Basically, it's complicated.
Which is what I said?
I do not like the style of this trailer at allThe Collective said:
Top YT comment when I last checked, "When Galadriel pulled out her lightsaber and said, "Wakanda forever" sent shivers up my spine. Tolkien couldn't have written anything better."
It definitely makes it tough to get excited when they don't say jack **** about what's going on. Give me some sort of narrative to latch onto.
Life is better with a beagle
This is my least favorite trailer but still very hopeful.
ABATTBQ11 said:The Collective said:
Looks to be all based off quotes from the cast, and allegedly Amazon is doing damage control & trying to walk it all back. IDK, stuff just started showing up in my feed. Not sure why…
This. Some of the cast/crew have talked about how it's supposed to be more representative and inclusive.
Essentially, they're trying tocopyrecreate the success of GOT by playing on the success of the LOTR trilogy, which they didn't create, and playing to a fan base of Tolkien's work, which they also didn't create, by ripping it off, trying to throw their own woke spin on it, and throwing a lot of money at it. It just smacks of desperation and unoriginality.
I will remain highly skeptical until it is released.
This show is going to be terrible. Almost every LOTR fan I have seen on nerd sites expects it to suck.
C@LAg said:think of it as multiverse alt fan-fiction.AmarilloBQ02 said:
Why even make this series when they don't own the rights to the primary source material? So much of what I've heard/seen so far seems to directly contradict what Tolkien wrote in the Silmarillion.
We are not on Middle Earth Prime, but on Middle Earth 69, because lolz.
but the good thing is that with the sale today of the rights, Amazon can now go and license them from someone else on top of the ones they got from the Tolkien Estate.
This is exactly why it's going to be horrifically bad. I am frankly amazed the Tolkien estate even allowed any of this to happen. Why allow your series name to be attached to fan fiction?
The Porkchop Express said:
Galadriel looks great.
I kind of wish the hobbits weren't in it at all to be honest. It feels like that was the whole point of how crazy it was that they were so much in focus for The Hobbit and LOTR. Most people in Middle Earth didn't even know they were around, or had never met one.
Except that Galadriel is not and never was a fighter. She was so powerful she never needed to pick up a sword. That's one of the main aspects of her character.
PatAg said:I do not like the style of this trailer at allThe Collective said:
Top YT comment when I last checked, "When Galadriel pulled out her lightsaber and said, "Wakanda forever" sent shivers up my spine. Tolkien couldn't have written anything better."
The modern music is a clear sign that they missed the entire point. This trailer may be the worst one yet.