Thoughts:
1. Why must every episode "suck" or be "classic"? I have never seen such a critical and inconsistent audience judging on a weekly basis. Ultimately, this show tends to polarize the audience every week. "The Dinner Party" from last season is a perfect example- it's considered both the best and worst by different sets of fans. Every week this season has turned into a vairation of that criticism. Why can't the show just be what it is. If we get 5 in a row that "suck", it might be cause for alarm. We certainly haven't seen that though.
2.
quote:
this is NBC forcing Jim/Pam into a "ross/rachel" situation.
Isn't this the complete opposite of that? Friends was ALWAYS a show that relied on the "will they or won't they" every single time they couldn't generate fresh storylines. Every time. By just letting Jim and Pam be together and mostly happy for the last season and this season thus far, they are letting that go and using other characters/storylines to push the story forward. We are in season 5 now, and while it was a factor the first few seasons, we haven't relied on the Jim/Pam relationship tension since the season 3 finale. This is completely the opposite of what Friends did.
3. The geniusness of this show is that "side characters" like Creed, Angela, Oscar, Phyllis, Kevin remain side characters. Creed's 2 lines per episode tend to be the best of the show. Anymore would turn into overuse. We don't need "Creed-centric" episodes, because ultimately, that would butcher the humor the character provides. Michael is a caricature, but that's fine, because generally, who's boss isn't a caricature? But in order to ground the series to some degree, we have to limit the screentime of smaller players before they become over-the top. I'd much rather see Creed's lines hit 100% of the time than him have 2x as many lines and only half of them hitting.
4. "I need to ***** that this wasn't a Halloween-centered episode"- Are you ****ing kidding me? Does your office celebrate Halloween? We've seen Halloween episodes before, but wouldn't every year be overkill? Obviously the writers had about 3 Halloween jokes in them, they got them all out, and then it was done. How many years can a Halloween episode be funny? Christmas is funny every year because the Christmas party manages to be an event at most offices. Not so much on Halloween though, so using it much beyond a cold open is just ridiculous.
5. Seeing a female version of Michael is hillarious. I probably wouldn't want to see 3 solid season of her and Michael imitating each other, but Amy Ryan has in no way overstayed her welcome. *****ing about Holly is completely premature at this point. Clearly she isn't a permanent addition. Clearly Toby will be back. Chill out and enjoy the ride.
[This message has been edited by 20ag07 (edited 11/2/2008 1:59a).]