Duncan Idaho said:schmendeler said:
How about the guy that played Ramsay Bolton?
He isn't charismatic enough.
Exactly. In other movies, he still has zero oomph in the role.
Dune [Spoiler Thread]
62,886 Views |
817 Replies |
Last: 2 yr ago by Rocagnante
Exactly. In other movies, he still has zero oomph in the role.
He's Pennywise the Dancing HarkonnenOl Jock 99 said:
I do think Bill Skarsgrd could work really well. He's young enough, good looking enough, is in great shape, can do creepy really well. And his real life dad being the Baron is fun.
Plus he has an excellent first name.
You know who can pul off handsome, menacing, caring, loving, hated, hateful.... Antony Starr. The guys kills it on The Boys.
Now that's just cheating. The acting and casting and writing for that show are unreal.
HummingbirdSaltalamacchia
Joined:
Jan 10, 2006
Posts:
10,902
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I know he's already been suggested, but I like the idea of Harry Styles. I think he has the look, is of appropriate age, but also has the similar background as Sting which i think would be a great callback to the 1984 version. he acted well in Dunkirk but i dont know if he would have the gravitas to really play the role of Feyd, which is my only holdup. could very easily turn into an instance of stunt casting that would detract from the rest of the film
Feyd is 15 or 16 at the beginning of the first book ad about 18-19 when he meets Paul
Quote:
The Baron could see the path ahead of him. One day, a Harkonnen would be Emperor. Not himself, and no spawn of his loins. But a Harkonnen. Not this Rabban he'd summoned, of course. But Rabban's younger brother, young Feyd-Rautha. There was a sharpness to the boy that the Baron enjoyed ... a ferocity ... A year or two more say, by the time he's seventeen, I'll know for certain whether he's the tool that House Harkonnen requires to gain the throne
I really don't think Feyd's age makes any difference other than "youngish".
Ol Jock 99 said:
I really don't think Feyd's age makes any difference other than "youngish".
I could be remembering it wrong, but Feyd is about the same age as Paul, with the point being that Feyd may have just as easily been the Chosen One that the BG were trying to produce. I believe there were lines in the book by the old lady BG to that end.
Sure, in the book. But that is an extreme small plotpoint that wasn't explored much at all in the book and has a 0.00000001% chance of making it into the movie.
I think Feyd and the daughter of Duke Leto / Jessica
This.SpreadsheetAg said:
I think Feyd and the daughter of Duke Leto / Jessica
Yeah, I think the only explicitly referenced failed Kwisatch Haderach was Count Fenring.FL_Ag1998 said:Ol Jock 99 said:
I really don't think Feyd's age makes any difference other than "youngish".
I could be remembering it wrong, but Feyd is about the same age as Paul, with the point being that Feyd may have just as easily been the Chosen One that the BG were trying to produce. I believe there were lines in the book by the old lady BG to that end.
Claude! said:Yeah, I think the only explicitly referenced failed Kwisatch Haderach was Count Fenring.FL_Ag1998 said:Ol Jock 99 said:
I really don't think Feyd's age makes any difference other than "youngish".
I could be remembering it wrong, but Feyd is about the same age as Paul, with the point being that Feyd may have just as easily been the Chosen One that the BG were trying to produce. I believe there were lines in the book by the old lady BG to that end.
I thought Fenring said there were others in the past that had great abilities but failed the tests.
(I am unspoiler tagging since this is the spoilers thread, don't want precedence established)
FINALLY going to see it! 11:05 matinee in Cypress
Having not read past Dune (20 years ago), I dont understand the focus on the Kwisatch Haderach because the fremen focus on the Mahdi.
When Paul comes to full bloom as the Kwisatch Haderach he isnt what the Reverend Mother or the BG wanted....he is something beyond their grasp.
Yes he is the Kwisatch Haderach, but he is also something more.
DVs interpretation (saw it a 2nd time) makes the fremen myth just a reinterpretation of the BG myth...or rather the BG implanted the concept of the myth into the fremen mythos in order to aid in the fruition of a Kwisatch Haderach from their lands.
When Paul comes to full bloom as the Kwisatch Haderach he isnt what the Reverend Mother or the BG wanted....he is something beyond their grasp.
Yes he is the Kwisatch Haderach, but he is also something more.
DVs interpretation (saw it a 2nd time) makes the fremen myth just a reinterpretation of the BG myth...or rather the BG implanted the concept of the myth into the fremen mythos in order to aid in the fruition of a Kwisatch Haderach from their lands.
There is quite a bit of this concept shared in the novel though. It's not just DV's interpretation.The Debt said:
Having not read past Dune (20 years ago), I dont understand the focus on the Kwisatch Haderach because the fremen focus on the Mahdi.
When Paul comes to full bloom as the Kwisatch Haderach he isnt what the Reverend Mother or the BG wanted....he is something beyond their grasp.
Yes he is the Kwisatch Haderach, but he is also something more.
DVs interpretation (saw it a 2nd time) makes the fremen myth just a reinterpretation of the BG myth...or rather the BG implanted the concept of the myth into the fremen mythos in order to aid in the fruition of a Kwisatch Haderach from their lands.
Yep. Kind of like how Finkle is Einhorn and Einhorn is Finkle, the Madhi is the Kwisatch Haderach and vice versa.YouBet said:There is quite a bit of this concept shared in the novel though. It's not just DV's interpretation.The Debt said:
Having not read past Dune (20 years ago), I dont understand the focus on the Kwisatch Haderach because the fremen focus on the Mahdi.
When Paul comes to full bloom as the Kwisatch Haderach he isnt what the Reverend Mother or the BG wanted....he is something beyond their grasp.
Yes he is the Kwisatch Haderach, but he is also something more.
DVs interpretation (saw it a 2nd time) makes the fremen myth just a reinterpretation of the BG myth...or rather the BG implanted the concept of the myth into the fremen mythos in order to aid in the fruition of a Kwisatch Haderach from their lands.
But the Fremen version was never intended to be anything. It was a myth planted by the Missionaria Protectiva to ensure a common mythos in the event the BG ever needed to call upon it for their own needs.
They never believed that the KH or anything similar would come out of the Fremen.
They never believed that the KH or anything similar would come out of the Fremen.
I guess the BG aren't as in control of things as they think they are. Kind of like the Bene Tleilax, right...Duncan?Duncan Idaho said:
But the Fremen version was never intended to be anything. It was a myth planted by the Missionaria Protectiva to ensure a common mythos in the event the BG ever needed to call upon it for their own needs.
They never believed that the KH or anything similar would come out of the Fremen.
He didn't. Paul is an Atreides KH by birth, produced by the BG breeding program. The Fremen Mahdi prophecy specifies an "outworlder", not a native Fremen. There isn't a discrepancy.Duncan Idaho said:
But the Fremen version was never intended to be anything. It was a myth planted by the Missionaria Protectiva to ensure a common mythos in the event the BG ever needed to call upon it for their own needs.
They never believed that the KH or anything similar would come out of the Fremen.
Oh wow.... loved it. I think it hit all the major themes. The stuff about Yueh and Thufir are overblown; they fulfilled their plots with minimal interference on Pual's story.SpreadsheetAg said:
FINALLY going to see it! 11:05 matinee in Cypress
They touched on the political dangers adequately, IMO. I think DV struck a really good balance of making it followable and interesting to new viewers and staying pretty damned true to the actual story.
I LOVED it.
Ol Jock 99 said:MBAR said:
If only hair color could be changed.
Hair color?
The guy to the right of Bautista looks like Menard.
He looks like powder on a testosterone fueled goth and cyberpunk decade long trip
You'll flay me for this probably, but an actor who could pull off dark hair or shaved head and pouty lips and actually looks a tiny bit like he could be Dave Bautista's little brother from the nose up...
Taylor Lautner
**ducks**
Also, he's probably a swell guy, but he can easily pull off condescending hubris that compels him to challenge Muad'dib, cheat, and lose.
Taylor Lautner
**ducks**
Also, he's probably a swell guy, but he can easily pull off condescending hubris that compels him to challenge Muad'dib, cheat, and lose.
As a big Tool fan, I will choose to believe this henceforth.
MalfoyYouBet said:
Finally hit me that Haynes King looks like Joffrey.
Just saw it today. Read the book 30 years ago and it all came back - except the damn dinner scene!
Overall A+. Love SciFi, but to get to this level is very rare.
Most of the good points have bern covered but I'll chime in with a couple:
Losing Leto early was like losing Ned Stark early!
They didn't go in too much detail in the movie but I remember that B Hark was like Jabba with puss sores all over his body.
And the desert suits recycled all body fluids including the unmentionable ones if you were female made me throw up a bit in the back of my mouth - but hey, Desert Power!
Actually, I'm reading it right now and at least through 60+% of the novel this isn't mentioned at all. Baron completely avoided Leto's poison attack and made it behind a door before the poison ever touched him.Southlake said:MalfoyYouBet said:
Finally hit me that Haynes King looks like Joffrey.
Just saw it today. Read the book 30 years ago and it all came back - except the damn dinner scene!
Overall A+. Love SciFi, but to get to this level is very rare.
Most of the good points have bern covered but I'll chime in with a couple:
Losing Leto early was like losing Ned Stark early!
They didn't go in too much detail in the movie but I remember that B Hark was like Jabba with puss sores all over his body.
And the desert suits recycled all body fluids including the unmentionable ones if you were female made me throw up a bit in the back of my mouth - but hey, Desert Power!
Different than DV's depiction.
But again, if he is the fruition of the BG plot, why is he hostile to the BG? Or rather why did the BG aid in the creation a monster they cannot control?Claude! said:Yep. Kind of like how Finkle is Einhorn and Einhorn is Finkle, the Madhi is the Kwisatch Haderach and vice versa.YouBet said:There is quite a bit of this concept shared in the novel though. It's not just DV's interpretation.The Debt said:
Having not read past Dune (20 years ago), I dont understand the focus on the Kwisatch Haderach because the fremen focus on the Mahdi.
When Paul comes to full bloom as the Kwisatch Haderach he isnt what the Reverend Mother or the BG wanted....he is something beyond their grasp.
Yes he is the Kwisatch Haderach, but he is also something more.
DVs interpretation (saw it a 2nd time) makes the fremen myth just a reinterpretation of the BG myth...or rather the BG implanted the concept of the myth into the fremen mythos in order to aid in the fruition of a Kwisatch Haderach from their lands.
I think of it as competing religious orders (BG and fremen), both have the foretelling of a god-man, but the fremen hold the true religion.
Perhaps the BG thought the Kwisatch Haderach was going to be one thing (and under their control or at least influence), but he turned out to be something that would not be guided or controlled.The Debt said:But again, if he is the fruition of the BG plot, why is he hostile to the BG? Or rather why did the BG aid in the creation a monster they cannot control?Claude! said:Yep. Kind of like how Finkle is Einhorn and Einhorn is Finkle, the Madhi is the Kwisatch Haderach and vice versa.YouBet said:There is quite a bit of this concept shared in the novel though. It's not just DV's interpretation.The Debt said:
Having not read past Dune (20 years ago), I dont understand the focus on the Kwisatch Haderach because the fremen focus on the Mahdi.
When Paul comes to full bloom as the Kwisatch Haderach he isnt what the Reverend Mother or the BG wanted....he is something beyond their grasp.
Yes he is the Kwisatch Haderach, but he is also something more.
DVs interpretation (saw it a 2nd time) makes the fremen myth just a reinterpretation of the BG myth...or rather the BG implanted the concept of the myth into the fremen mythos in order to aid in the fruition of a Kwisatch Haderach from their lands.
I think of it as competing religious orders (BG and fremen), both have the foretelling of a god-man, but the fremen hold the true religion.
The Debt said:But again, if he is the fruition of the BG plot, why is he hostile to the BG? Or rather why did the BG aid in the creation a monster they cannot control?Claude! said:Yep. Kind of like how Finkle is Einhorn and Einhorn is Finkle, the Madhi is the Kwisatch Haderach and vice versa.YouBet said:There is quite a bit of this concept shared in the novel though. It's not just DV's interpretation.The Debt said:
Having not read past Dune (20 years ago), I dont understand the focus on the Kwisatch Haderach because the fremen focus on the Mahdi.
When Paul comes to full bloom as the Kwisatch Haderach he isnt what the Reverend Mother or the BG wanted....he is something beyond their grasp.
Yes he is the Kwisatch Haderach, but he is also something more.
DVs interpretation (saw it a 2nd time) makes the fremen myth just a reinterpretation of the BG myth...or rather the BG implanted the concept of the myth into the fremen mythos in order to aid in the fruition of a Kwisatch Haderach from their lands.
I think of it as competing religious orders (BG and fremen), both have the foretelling of a god-man, but the fremen hold the true religion.
No, the BG's implanted various religions all across the Galaxy over thousands of years in order to influence events. They implication is the more hostile the living conditions, the more drastic the prophecies put in place. And it makes sense, especially when looking at arrakis. The Fremen believe in an outworlder son and mother that will come save them from their hardships. That would apply to Paul and Jessica, but it's also set up to apply to almost anyone new the emperor would have put in place, especially after a bunch of hostilities from the Harkonens. If it turns out to not be the true Mahdi, no big deal, the true one will be there eventually.
Paul was not intended to be the KH by the BG's. They wanted Jessica to have a daughter so they could marry her off to the Harkonnens, end the blood feud, and have the child be a strong likelihood of being the KH. The fact that Jessica defied them, then training Paul in his powers, means that he's naturally outside of their control a little bit. And since they basically plotted, influenced, or at least were accepting of the Harkonnens murdering his father with imperial troops, he will not be happy with the BG for the foreseeable future.
They didn't plan on Paul being the KH. Jessica was supposed to produce a daughter. I believe she may have trained Paul beyond what the BG expected as well which led the BG to test whether he was "human."The Debt said:But again, if he is the fruition of the BG plot, why is he hostile to the BG? Or rather why did the BG aid in the creation a monster they cannot control?Claude! said:Yep. Kind of like how Finkle is Einhorn and Einhorn is Finkle, the Madhi is the Kwisatch Haderach and vice versa.YouBet said:There is quite a bit of this concept shared in the novel though. It's not just DV's interpretation.The Debt said:
Having not read past Dune (20 years ago), I dont understand the focus on the Kwisatch Haderach because the fremen focus on the Mahdi.
When Paul comes to full bloom as the Kwisatch Haderach he isnt what the Reverend Mother or the BG wanted....he is something beyond their grasp.
Yes he is the Kwisatch Haderach, but he is also something more.
DVs interpretation (saw it a 2nd time) makes the fremen myth just a reinterpretation of the BG myth...or rather the BG implanted the concept of the myth into the fremen mythos in order to aid in the fruition of a Kwisatch Haderach from their lands.
I think of it as competing religious orders (BG and fremen), both have the foretelling of a god-man, but the fremen hold the true religion.
All BG take the test of humanity. They tested him to see if he had the potential to be the KHThe Dog Lord said:They didn't plan on Paul being the KH. Jessica was supposed to produce a daughter. I believe she may have trained Paul beyond what the BG expected as well which led the BG to test whether he was "human."The Debt said:But again, if he is the fruition of the BG plot, why is he hostile to the BG? Or rather why did the BG aid in the creation a monster they cannot control?Claude! said:Yep. Kind of like how Finkle is Einhorn and Einhorn is Finkle, the Madhi is the Kwisatch Haderach and vice versa.YouBet said:There is quite a bit of this concept shared in the novel though. It's not just DV's interpretation.The Debt said:
Having not read past Dune (20 years ago), I dont understand the focus on the Kwisatch Haderach because the fremen focus on the Mahdi.
When Paul comes to full bloom as the Kwisatch Haderach he isnt what the Reverend Mother or the BG wanted....he is something beyond their grasp.
Yes he is the Kwisatch Haderach, but he is also something more.
DVs interpretation (saw it a 2nd time) makes the fremen myth just a reinterpretation of the BG myth...or rather the BG implanted the concept of the myth into the fremen mythos in order to aid in the fruition of a Kwisatch Haderach from their lands.
I think of it as competing religious orders (BG and fremen), both have the foretelling of a god-man, but the fremen hold the true religion.
YouBet said:Actually, I'm reading it right now and at least through 60+% of the novel this isn't mentioned at all. Baron completely avoided Leto's poison attack and made it behind a door before the poison ever touched him.Southlake said:MalfoyYouBet said:
Finally hit me that Haynes King looks like Joffrey.
Just saw it today. Read the book 30 years ago and it all came back - except the damn dinner scene!
Overall A+. Love SciFi, but to get to this level is very rare.
Most of the good points have bern covered but I'll chime in with a couple:
Losing Leto early was like losing Ned Stark early!
They didn't go in too much detail in the movie but I remember that B Hark was like Jabba with puss sores all over his body.
And the desert suits recycled all body fluids including the unmentionable ones if you were female made me throw up a bit in the back of my mouth - but hey, Desert Power!
Different than DV's depiction.
On BVH; I think you're remembering the 1984 movie... that dude was hard to look at with all the oozing. And I think Pitre at one point is playing Dr. Pimple Popper.
One scene that stuck out to me was a cool minute detail; when BVH is eating dinner at the fortress on Arakkis after the takeover and Leto is incapacitated in the chair. Your hear the repulsor sound engage (a low arachnid popping sound) and he floats over the table and as he's getting closer his feet drag on the table lifeless... it just really stayed with me that they sold out on the little things.
Also, every time the Baron was about to move his monstrous form you also hear the same spider-clacking popping sound. Very cool and I assume are emanating from the cyborg attachment on his back engaging.
I assume you are replying to Southlake.SpreadsheetAg said:YouBet said:Actually, I'm reading it right now and at least through 60+% of the novel this isn't mentioned at all. Baron completely avoided Leto's poison attack and made it behind a door before the poison ever touched him.Southlake said:MalfoyYouBet said:
Finally hit me that Haynes King looks like Joffrey.
Just saw it today. Read the book 30 years ago and it all came back - except the damn dinner scene!
Overall A+. Love SciFi, but to get to this level is very rare.
Most of the good points have bern covered but I'll chime in with a couple:
Losing Leto early was like losing Ned Stark early!
They didn't go in too much detail in the movie but I remember that B Hark was like Jabba with puss sores all over his body.
And the desert suits recycled all body fluids including the unmentionable ones if you were female made me throw up a bit in the back of my mouth - but hey, Desert Power!
Different than DV's depiction.
On BVH; I think you're remembering the 1984 movie... that dude was hard to look at with all the oozing. And I think Pitre at one point is playing Dr. Pimple Popper.
One scene that stuck out to me was a cool minute detail; when BVH is eating dinner at the fortress on Arakkis after the takeover and Leto is incapacitated in the chair. Your hear the repulsor sound engage (a low arachnid popping sound) and he floats over the table and as he's getting closer his feet drag on the table lifeless... it just really stayed with me that they sold out on the little things.
Also, every time the Baron was about to move his monstrous form you also hear the same spider-clacking popping sound. Very cool and I assume are emanating from the cyborg attachment on his back engaging.
But I don't think they would have needed to test Paul if Jessica had trained him so much, correct? I don't think they were expecting him to be trained up in BG ways which is why they weren't controlling over his upbringing. Once they found out he had been trained so much, they decided to test him. I may be making all of that up, but I could have sworn that was the explanation for why they weren't trying to control him sooner as a potential KH.powerbelly said:All BG take the test of humanity. They tested him to see if he had the potential to be the KHThe Dog Lord said:They didn't plan on Paul being the KH. Jessica was supposed to produce a daughter. I believe she may have trained Paul beyond what the BG expected as well which led the BG to test whether he was "human."The Debt said:But again, if he is the fruition of the BG plot, why is he hostile to the BG? Or rather why did the BG aid in the creation a monster they cannot control?Claude! said:Yep. Kind of like how Finkle is Einhorn and Einhorn is Finkle, the Madhi is the Kwisatch Haderach and vice versa.YouBet said:There is quite a bit of this concept shared in the novel though. It's not just DV's interpretation.The Debt said:
Having not read past Dune (20 years ago), I dont understand the focus on the Kwisatch Haderach because the fremen focus on the Mahdi.
When Paul comes to full bloom as the Kwisatch Haderach he isnt what the Reverend Mother or the BG wanted....he is something beyond their grasp.
Yes he is the Kwisatch Haderach, but he is also something more.
DVs interpretation (saw it a 2nd time) makes the fremen myth just a reinterpretation of the BG myth...or rather the BG implanted the concept of the myth into the fremen mythos in order to aid in the fruition of a Kwisatch Haderach from their lands.
I think of it as competing religious orders (BG and fremen), both have the foretelling of a god-man, but the fremen hold the true religion.
Featured Stories
See All
Ags host Buckeyes with an early-season Quad 1 opportunity at stake
by Olin Buchanan
Players to Watch: No. 15 Texas A&M vs. New Mexico State
by Olin Buchanan
8:22
15h ago
1.6k
34:11
9h ago
684
Reed Report: Preparing for Friday's marquee showdown vs. Ohio State
by Luke Evangelist
Bid on Legacy Club tickets to Saturday's Texas A&M vs. NMSU game!
by Texas Aggies United