NoahAg said:
There are certainly worse fouls deserving of flagrants. But there's a difference between guys banging down low or incidental contact through the paint and something like this. There's no "basketball play" here. From the moment Castle moved, his intent was to run into Brunson. Had he just kept his arm down I'd be fine with the common foul.
I had this thought too. One of the broadcasters said it was like taking a charge on a ballhandler. I didn't see it that way at all, because I thought Castle's sole intent was to put Brunson on the ground. We do have to infer a little, so maybe the refs didn't want to do play the game of attributing motive.
Quote:
What's really troublesome is giving Brunson a flagrant for his closeout after letting this go. I can live with letting both slide.
Hated this call and thought it's not the purpose of the Zaza rule. There was a sequence later in the game where the same thing happened to Clarkson, I think, with no call, then he got called for a non-foul on the other end on the ensuing Spurs possession.
Quote:
Just saying, b/t this, Wemby getting away with blatant shoves, and the overall foul call disparity I can see how conspiracy theorists are thinking "Adam Silver made a call and said, fellas, we need to extend the series."
At one point in the 4th Q, the 2nd half FTs were 18 to 3 for the Spurs. Brunson was in foul trouble in the 3rd quarter and the Spurs were in the penalty 3 minutes in to the 4th quarter.
The Knicks were absolutely fouling the Spurs, but they weren't calling the Spurs for similarly physical play. Everybody was grabbing and shoving everybody on every rebound attempt. Keep it consistent.
Quote:
Now, to be unbiased, I thought the offensive foul call when Keldon "pushed" Mitchel Robinson into Wemby's 3 pointer was kinda weak.
Keldon shoved the guy and it resulted in Robinson fouling Wemby for a 4 point play. It was either call Keldon for the push (which is absolutely illegal) or give the Spurs a 4 point play because Robinson got pushed in to Wemby. They got it right. Also Knicks had to keep challenging terrible calls and eventually ran out of challenges despite winning all of them. What a dumb rule.