Go book a flight on JSX. Strong possibility the captain is over 65 and the first officer is 23
Teslag said:
I see these billboards for accelerated pilot training to airlines all over the place, and my feed is full of young pilots like these trying to accrue time as fast as possible to jump to airlines. About a year ago I took a discovery flight at Parker County airport when considering a private license. My would be instructor was basically a child. It was a bit unnerving and I decided not to do it. She was in one of those accelerated programs.
While looking around for flight schools my social media feed was inundated by young female pilots in full runway makeup filming themselves with every hastag you can imagine. Most couldn't be over 21. Even in the airport I'm a little uncomfortable when I see two young adults barely old enough to buy beer walk down the jetway to an American Eagle connection flight. And they are the pilots.
Experience and professionalism matter, and I'm not sure it's always there now.
Infection_Ag11 said:GAC06 said:Quote:
A commercial airliner has never been brought down by weather based turbulence in the history of modern aviation.
No. Fly into a severe thunderstorm and any plane is in deep trouble
Commercial airliners are still designed to withstand such forces, and essentially always do in the unfortunate circumstances in which it occurs.
AgNav93 said:Infection_Ag11 said:GAC06 said:Quote:
A commercial airliner has never been brought down by weather based turbulence in the history of modern aviation.
No. Fly into a severe thunderstorm and any plane is in deep trouble
Commercial airliners are still designed to withstand such forces, and essentially always do in the unfortunate circumstances in which it occurs.
THis is absolutely not true. I was a 20 year navigator r in the Air Force. Look up mountain wave turbulence. And it caused this crash of a Boening 707: BOAC Flight 911 (1966) A Boeing707 disintegrated near Mount Fuji after encountering severe mountain wave turbulence, killing all 124 on board
Mountain wave turbulence also tore the rudder off a B-52 once and they successfully landed it using the gear for yaw. That story was legend in the bomber community.
Kenneth_2003 said:AggieFlyboy said:
A few things I'll comment on after catching up:
- For safety reasons (ie traffic avoidance), we will request a weather deviation from ATC first. If denied (and it is absolutely necessary in my judgment) or there is no time, we will inform ATC that we are deviating for weather. It's then their job to get people out of our way.
- Severe icing is probably the most dangerous thing we can encounter. We take steps to avoid it and/or get out of it quickly. Icing changes the aerodynamics of the wing and can lead to a stall, erroneous instrument indications, engine flameouts and frozen control surfaces. Icing doesn't care about the size of the airplane.
- light and moderate turbulence is an annoyance. Severe turbulence can cause minor structural damage. What happened here was likely a combination of icing and severe turbulence. From flying through the core of a severe thunderstorm.
- weather radar has limitations (especially what ATC has on the ground). The radar in the airplane can lie to you. A high quality Doppler feed from an internet source can be delayed up to 15 minutes. At night, your eyeballs have a hard time judging distance of light sources (your brain says that brighter is closer)
Sometimes the perfect storm happens and all of the holes in the Swiss cheese line up (google swiss cheese model of risk management). I suspect that this was the case in this crash. While it was completely avoidable, that point may have occurred 30 minutes before the crash
Question for you...
Is it possible that the storm core they entered could have blown up in front of or around them?
The graphic I pulled from a storm chasing social media page used radar imagery from Miami, 75 miles away, and bracketed +/- 2 minutes for the crash.
Either way, flying into that storm core.... They would have entered significant updrafts. Those updrafts would have a lot of rapidly cooling warm humid air with plenty of moisture condensing to water and then to ice. That would be wet and sticky and primed to rapidly accumulate on the very cold airplane that had been in the extreme cold.
Pilots... You don't typically fly around with anti-ice systems engaged correct? The bleed air used reduces engine efficiency and as I understand you can also overheat some surfaces if it's left on too long without water to pull the heat away? Pretty sure I've heard about that on engine cowl heat.... So from the time you turn on anti-ice systems how long would it take to warm up a wing surface? These are typically only used at lower altitude? At cruse you'd be better served to divert and avoid? Can they put enough heat into a surface to melt ice at cruise altitudes?
Squadron7 said:
This is out there. I'd wait for corroboration, though. Seems a bit....internetty.
https://instagr.am/p/DfPlfDfIZlB
Teslag said:
Now confirmed it was the 20 year old
https://nypost.com/2026/11/02/us-news/nathalia-gadelha-identified-as-learjet-co-pilot-in-florida-crash/
zgolfz85 said:Squadron7 said:
This is out there. I'd wait for corroboration, though. Seems a bit....internetty.
https://instagr.am/p/DfPlfDfIZlB
they already confirmed the other gal. Sounds like her co pilot was a man, so I think this is fake news
insulator_king said:
I'd also recommend this forum, geared towards professional Airline Pilots.
https://www.pprune.org/accidents-close-calls/674728-lear-60-crash-florida-8.html
Several posts have discussed that severe convective activity can updraft moist warm air which then gets supercooled to -40 to near -50 deg C. When it hits the cold aircraft it can turn to ice in only a few seconds, which degrades the lift of the airfoil shape of the wings, and a stall that is UNRECOVERABLE.
Then the plane falls like a rock, exceeds the mach limit [I believe it is .81M for this learjet], and exceeds the structural strength of the stab, which is torn off the tail of the plane.
GAC06 said:
Go book a flight on JSX. Strong possibility the captain is over 65 and the first officer is 23
fullback44 said:
That white car is very very very lucky if they are still alive…. That car seems very close to the actual plane.. after reviewing the still pics the car was near the light pole going into the parking lot and the plane crashed near the second light pole, so they probably are alive and they probably crapped in their pants
Aggie95 said:
The airlines were very fortunate to have a great built in training system known as the Navy and Air Force. Sadly that is virtually gone now.
Infection_Ag11 said:Principal Uncertainty said:Gunny456 said:
Statistically speaking air travel is very safe.
I've heard many folks say that the most dangerous part of flying is driving to and from the airport.
Hell I seldom have a day of driving that some idiot doesn't come into my lane while texting on their damn phones!
I know you should never tempt God are make fool hardy decisions….but I also believe that when it's your time, it's your time.
Statistically, air travel on large commercial planes is very safe per passenger mile. However, small private planes and helicopters are relatively unsafe.
They're not unsafe by any normal, everyday standard. They are just less safe than flying on commercial airliners. All forms of air travel are still much safer than any form of ground transportation, including walking in major urban centers.
Flying in a commercial airliner in 2026 is just about the safest thing you can do. You're statistically more likely to be murdered in your bed as you sleep than to die in a commercial plane crash.
aggieforester05 said:AgNav93 said:Infection_Ag11 said:GAC06 said:Quote:
A commercial airliner has never been brought down by weather based turbulence in the history of modern aviation.
No. Fly into a severe thunderstorm and any plane is in deep trouble
Commercial airliners are still designed to withstand such forces, and essentially always do in the unfortunate circumstances in which it occurs.
THis is absolutely not true. I was a 20 year navigator r in the Air Force. Look up mountain wave turbulence. And it caused this crash of a Boening 707: BOAC Flight 911 (1966) A Boeing707 disintegrated near Mount Fuji after encountering severe mountain wave turbulence, killing all 124 on board
Mountain wave turbulence also tore the rudder off a B-52 once and they successfully landed it using the gear for yaw. That story was legend in the bomber community.
I'm pretty sure the Dubai Air Max-8 crew used the nose wheel for yaw control, since the rudder was gone. I think Captain Steve mentioned it in one of his videos.
We've reviewed radar and temperature data surrounding the crash of N722BD. This loop depicts the rapid vertical development of a convective cell, which lofted plentiful moisture.
— MyRadar Weather (@MyRadarWX) November 2, 2026
The aircraft entered this cell at 12:47-48 p.m., encountering severe icing and turbulence. pic.twitter.com/7qzeOsLAYO
Quote:
If the actual rate was 99%, we would be reading about 6 major airline crashes PER DAY.
BadMoonRisin said:We've reviewed radar and temperature data surrounding the crash of N722BD. This loop depicts the rapid vertical development of a convective cell, which lofted plentiful moisture.
— MyRadar Weather (@MyRadarWX) November 2, 2026
The aircraft entered this cell at 12:47-48 p.m., encountering severe icing and turbulence. pic.twitter.com/7qzeOsLAYO
Looks like they tried to fly over it, but the storm was rapidly ascending up and towards them and when the wings iced, they couldnt do anything about it.
GAC06 said:
Go book a flight on JSX. Strong possibility the captain is over 65 and the first officer is 23
GAC06 said:
Their pay is atrocious so it definitely happens. Guys that can't fly for an airline anymore and/or guys that can't fly for an airline yet. Just the nature of that kind of operation and regulation involved.
GAC06 said:aggieforester05 said:AgNav93 said:Infection_Ag11 said:GAC06 said:Quote:
A commercial airliner has never been brought down by weather based turbulence in the history of modern aviation.
No. Fly into a severe thunderstorm and any plane is in deep trouble
Commercial airliners are still designed to withstand such forces, and essentially always do in the unfortunate circumstances in which it occurs.
THis is absolutely not true. I was a 20 year navigator r in the Air Force. Look up mountain wave turbulence. And it caused this crash of a Boening 707: BOAC Flight 911 (1966) A Boeing707 disintegrated near Mount Fuji after encountering severe mountain wave turbulence, killing all 124 on board
Mountain wave turbulence also tore the rudder off a B-52 once and they successfully landed it using the gear for yaw. That story was legend in the bomber community.
I'm pretty sure the Dubai Air Max-8 crew used the nose wheel for yaw control, since the rudder was gone. I think Captain Steve mentioned it in one of his videos.
I admit I haven't tried it but I strongly doubt the nose wheel would do anything at all for yaw control (airborne of course). Unless there's asymmetric thrust or landing or taking off with a crosswind, there's not much need for rudder inputs at all.
GAC06 said:Infection_Ag11 said:GAC06 said:Quote:
A commercial airliner has never been brought down by weather based turbulence in the history of modern aviation.
No. Fly into a severe thunderstorm and any plane is in deep trouble
Commercial airliners are still designed to withstand such forces, and essentially always do in the unfortunate circumstances in which it occurs.
Here's two from the same airline
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Braniff_International_Airways_Flight_250
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Braniff_International_Airways_Flight_352
Yes, they both happened in the 60's. No, they aren't making planes magically stronger now so that they're impervious to severe/extreme turbulence and other hazards of powerful thunderstorms. The Electra in the second mishap is the plane they based the P-3 off of. Same P-3 they use as "hurricane hunters" because it was so robust.
What changed is that we know that flying into a severe thunderstorm will kill you, and we have weather radar good enough that it shouldn't ever happen. Airlines mandate deviating around severe storms by 20 miles or more depending on the conditions.