Plane Crash Near Mar-a-Lago

85,149 Views | 658 Replies | Last: 6 days ago by CornAg
AggieFlyboy
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
HeyAbbott said:

It was a very severe thunderstorm even for South Florida area.

I've seen several just like it in the past 3 months. It's not atypical.
joerobert_pete06
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
It for sure looked like the tail was broken in that photo
joerobert_pete06
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Captain Steve mentioned that precipitation at that altitude is very rare and knowing that the copilot reported ice beforehand is a very bad situation…. Called out when the copilot started showing signs of stress. Then said there was probably a rapid buildup of ice on the right wing causing it to bank 60deg
Rocky Rider
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Teslag said:

AggieFlyboy said:

jeremiahjt said:

We can do whatever the hell we want. I love when somebody it whatever industry is being discussed comes in and tells all the non-industry people what they can and cannot discuss.

And then the obligatory "all the best (insert job) I know are women and are so much better than me at (insert job).


Dude, I've flown with good sticks and bad sticks. Men and women can fit both categories. All that matters in the airplane is skill; age and sex are pretty much irrelevant. I've flown with young guys that have more experience than guys sitting there for 40 years.


Skill can't make up for experience when **** goes south and you need quick, rational, and accurate decision making. And that's not just true for pilots. It's true for many similar occupations.


Gender isn't an issue IMO.
If I chartered the flight for my wife, 2 kids, 2 friends, and a nanny, I would question whether the co-pilot had the experience and chutzpah to support and question the pilots decisions. Per our laws, the co-pilot isn't responsible / mature enough to buy a beer, but can fly a Lear jet with 7 passengers- huh?
I'm not a pilot so I'll defer to those that have significant experience in the cockpit of a jet aircraft. But it seems like a copilot in a Lear jet should have more experience than in this case.
Featured Video Previews
Logos Stick
How long do you want to ignore this user?

So is the bottom line here that this guy flew into a storm area that he should not have flown into, for whatever reason?
Teslag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Rocky Rider said:

Teslag said:

AggieFlyboy said:

jeremiahjt said:

We can do whatever the hell we want. I love when somebody it whatever industry is being discussed comes in and tells all the non-industry people what they can and cannot discuss.

And then the obligatory "all the best (insert job) I know are women and are so much better than me at (insert job).


Dude, I've flown with good sticks and bad sticks. Men and women can fit both categories. All that matters in the airplane is skill; age and sex are pretty much irrelevant. I've flown with young guys that have more experience than guys sitting there for 40 years.


Skill can't make up for experience when **** goes south and you need quick, rational, and accurate decision making. And that's not just true for pilots. It's true for many similar occupations.


Gender isn't an issue IMO.
If I chartered the flight for my wife, 2 kids, 2 friends, and a nanny, I would question whether the co-pilot had the experience and chutzpah to support and question the pilots decisions. Per our laws, the co-pilot isn't responsible / mature enough to buy a beer, but can fly a Lear jet with 7 passengers- huh?
I'm not a pilot so I'll defer to those that have significant experience in the cockpit of a jet aircraft. But it seems like a copilot in a Lear jet should have more experience than in this case.


Agreed and I'm not holding on to the gender argument. I'd trust a 40 year old female pilot over a 20 year old male. Especially if that female pilot had military experience and the kid came from a billboard pilot mill.
BadMoonRisin
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
That's what I think, although I dont know s about f, but you can certainly see him bank right in the direction of the storm cell a minute before the mayday call instead of holding his initial heading that appears would have had him skirt or avoid the cell altogether.

Although, who knows what visibility was like up there, he might not have been able to see it.
infinity ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?

Learjet in doomed Palm Beach plane crash was involved in ANOTHER incident with female pilot weeks before… with chilling echoes of fatal maneuver that would go on to kill nine
https://www.dailymail.com/news/article-16259449/pilot-learjet-crash-florida-audio-downplaying-turbulence.html

Quote:

A female pilot flying the same Learjet that crashed in Florida was heard being scolded by air traffic control months before for downplaying turbulence.

The woman was flying over Newark in New Jersey in May when an air traffic controller asked 'Why are you climbing?'
'We are just about to call you, we are experiencing moderate [turbulence] and unable to hold altitude,' said the female pilot.


The exasperated controller responded firmly: 'That is not moderate, descend to 4,000 [feet] immediately.
'If you cant maintain altitude that is not moderate, that is severe turbulence, are you experiencing severe turbulence?' he added.


The woman and a man then both respond 'affirmative sir', as the audio clip ended.
It is unclear if the woman heard on the audio was Nathalia Gadelha Filgueiras, 20. She was co-pilot of the Learjet when it crashed in Palm Beach on Sunday, killing her and eight others, amid speculation the plane was downed by severe weather.
The Learjet whose pilot was scolded for downplaying turbulence bore the same tail number N7226D as the plane that smashed into the ground while flying from Austin in Texas to the Bahamas.

Rapier108
How long do you want to ignore this user?
If the female pilot was working the radio, then she wasn't the one flying the aircraft.
"If you will not fight for right when you can easily win without blood shed; if you will not fight when your victory is sure and not too costly; you may come to the moment when you will have to fight with all the odds against you and only a precarious chance of survival. There may even be a worse case. You may have to fight when there is no hope of victory, because it is better to perish than to live as slaves." - Sir Winston Churchill
aggieforester05
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
The girl did an excellent job of communicating with ATC and ultimately the PIC is responsible for flying into that storm cell. I do wonder though if she was the one operating the weather radar and had some incorrect settings. They could have been fixated on the larger storm to the north and never saw the cell they turned into that killed them. Especially if an inexperienced pilot was operating a weather radar that wasn't part of her flight training up until she started flying jets. Unless there's clues in the audio, we'll probably never know.
AgsMnn
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
lb3
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Rocky Rider said:

Teslag said:

AggieFlyboy said:

jeremiahjt said:

We can do whatever the hell we want. I love when somebody it whatever industry is being discussed comes in and tells all the non-industry people what they can and cannot discuss.

And then the obligatory "all the best (insert job) I know are women and are so much better than me at (insert job).


Dude, I've flown with good sticks and bad sticks. Men and women can fit both categories. All that matters in the airplane is skill; age and sex are pretty much irrelevant. I've flown with young guys that have more experience than guys sitting there for 40 years.


Skill can't make up for experience when **** goes south and you need quick, rational, and accurate decision making. And that's not just true for pilots. It's true for many similar occupations.


Gender isn't an issue IMO.
If I chartered the flight for my wife, 2 kids, 2 friends, and a nanny, I would question whether the co-pilot had the experience and chutzpah to support and question the pilots decisions. Per our laws, the co-pilot isn't responsible / mature enough to buy a beer, but can fly a Lear jet with 7 passengers- huh?
I'm not a pilot so I'll defer to those that have significant experience in the cockpit of a jet aircraft. But it seems like a copilot in a Lear jet should have more experience than in this case.
You have to get your experience somewhere. What you don't want, regardless of experience, is a 22 year old pilot in command with an 18 year old co-pilot.

That leads to doing touch-n-gos in subdivisions.
Logos Stick
How long do you want to ignore this user?
BadMoonRisin said:

That's what I think, although I dont know s about f, but you can certainly see him bank right in the direction of the storm cell a minute before the mayday call instead of holding his initial heading that appears would have had him skirt or avoid the cell altogether.

Although, who knows what visibility was like up there, he might not have been able to see it.


Yeah, I watched Hoover;'s vid on it and it seems had they continued from FEMID directly to Freeport, they might have made it. That's the direction they headed after reaching FEMID, but then they turned north toward PBI for some reason which put them closer to the main system.

I'm just wondering why they didn't go completely south around the whole thing.
Ag with kids
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
AggieFlyboy said:

HeyAbbott said:

It was a very severe thunderstorm even for South Florida area.

I've seen several just like it in the past 3 months. It's not atypical.

I got to Melbourne on Sunday and met up with my cousin who's lived here for 6 years. He said this weather and rain was beyond unusual here.

He joked about dropping his flood insurance yesterday since he just survived a 1000 year flood.
You can turn off signatures, btw
Ellis Wyatt
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Joe Mixon shattered a woman's face and suffered ZERO consequences. Don't care how he feels about anything.
AggieFlyboy
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Ag with kids said:

AggieFlyboy said:

HeyAbbott said:

It was a very severe thunderstorm even for South Florida area.

I've seen several just like it in the past 3 months. It's not atypical.

I got to Melbourne on Sunday and met up with my cousin who's lived here for 6 years. He said this weather and rain was beyond unusual here.

He joked about dropping his flood insurance yesterday since he just survived a 1000 year flood.
. While the amount of rain might be unusual, massive thunderstorms over South Florida are not
Maybe Next Year
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
That was my first thought when I saw that post as well.


I also think a great many people have difficulty discerning when DEI practices play a detrimental role in an outcome and when they don't.
Rapier108
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Maybe Next Year said:

That was my first thought when I saw that post as well.


I also think a great many people have difficulty discerning when DEI practices play a detrimental role in an outcome and when they don't.

Too many people on the right will automatically yell "DEI!" when anyone involved isn't a white male. (No different than the left who screams "RACIST/RACISM!" about pretty much everything.)

That's why DEI is so destructive. It makes people assume that anyone who isn't a white male isn't qualified and only got the job because of race and/or gender.
"If you will not fight for right when you can easily win without blood shed; if you will not fight when your victory is sure and not too costly; you may come to the moment when you will have to fight with all the odds against you and only a precarious chance of survival. There may even be a worse case. You may have to fight when there is no hope of victory, because it is better to perish than to live as slaves." - Sir Winston Churchill
Reginald Cousins
How long do you want to ignore this user?
S
Rapier108 said:

Maybe Next Year said:

That was my first thought when I saw that post as well.


I also think a great many people have difficulty discerning when DEI practices play a detrimental role in an outcome and when they don't.

Too many people on the right will automatically yell "DEI!" when anyone involved isn't a white male. (No different than the left who screams "RACIST/RACISM!" about pretty much everything.)

That's why DEI is so destructive. It makes people assume that anyone who isn't a white male isn't qualified and only got the job because of race and/or gender.


It's destructive in more ways that.
Rapier108
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Reginald Cousins said:

Rapier108 said:

Maybe Next Year said:

That was my first thought when I saw that post as well.


I also think a great many people have difficulty discerning when DEI practices play a detrimental role in an outcome and when they don't.

Too many people on the right will automatically yell "DEI!" when anyone involved isn't a white male. (No different than the left who screams "RACIST/RACISM!" about pretty much everything.)

That's why DEI is so destructive. It makes people assume that anyone who isn't a white male isn't qualified and only got the job because of race and/or gender.


It's destructive in more ways that.

Of course. My comment was about how it hurts people who are qualified and good at their jobs, but still get questioned and blamed because they're not white males. It hurts them as much as it hurts others when it puts unqualified people into positions they have no business being in.
"If you will not fight for right when you can easily win without blood shed; if you will not fight when your victory is sure and not too costly; you may come to the moment when you will have to fight with all the odds against you and only a precarious chance of survival. There may even be a worse case. You may have to fight when there is no hope of victory, because it is better to perish than to live as slaves." - Sir Winston Churchill
Aston04
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
infinity ag said:


Learjet in doomed Palm Beach plane crash was involved in ANOTHER incident with female pilot weeks before… with chilling echoes of fatal maneuver that would go on to kill nine
https://www.dailymail.com/news/article-16259449/pilot-learjet-crash-florida-audio-downplaying-turbulence.html

Quote:

A female pilot flying the same Learjet that crashed in Florida was heard being scolded by air traffic control months before for downplaying turbulence.

The woman was flying over Newark in New Jersey in May when an air traffic controller asked 'Why are you climbing?'
'We are just about to call you, we are experiencing moderate [turbulence] and unable to hold altitude,' said the female pilot.


The exasperated controller responded firmly: 'That is not moderate, descend to 4,000 [feet] immediately.
'If you cant maintain altitude that is not moderate, that is severe turbulence, are you experiencing severe turbulence?' he added.


The woman and a man then both respond 'affirmative sir', as the audio clip ended.
It is unclear if the woman heard on the audio was Nathalia Gadelha Filgueiras, 20. She was co-pilot of the Learjet when it crashed in Palm Beach on Sunday, killing her and eight others, amid speculation the plane was downed by severe weather.
The Learjet whose pilot was scolded for downplaying turbulence bore the same tail number N7226D as the plane that smashed into the ground while flying from Austin in Texas to the Bahamas.



It is interesting because it seems she learned from that experience... She waited for clearance to adjust altitude.

I am very troubled by reports that she texted her boyfriend about the conditions they were flying through prior... Her sole focus should have been navigating out of that situation/assisting the captain fly. Collectively, the two of them really dropped the ball in navigating around that system.

In general, not a big fan of of people that young and inexperienced flying jets like this.
Iraq2xVeteran
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
The flight was en route from Austin, Texas, to Eleuthera Island in the Bahamas, with seven passengers and two crew members. Filgueiras, the 20-year-old co-pilot who was in the cockpit, died in the crash, her stepfather Thiago Corteleti said. Captain Jeff Gregory, the other pilot on the flight, also died in the crash, according to East Coast Jets, his former employer. Family members identified the passengers as Austin, Texas tech entrepreneur Adam Robinson, his wife Helen Sharp and their two children ages 4 and 2. The family was flying with the children's caretaker, Anita Maria Cetina, and friends Rachael Reed and Charmi Fehr, according to a joint statement from the families.

The plane involved in the accidenta Learjet 60was operated by Aurora Aviation, doing business as Upper Jets. An Aurora Aviation representative said the company is cooperating with the investigation.

A significant storm system capable of producing strong updrafts, heavy precipitation and icing moved over Southern Florida on Sunday. It consisted of cumulonimbus clouds with some cells reaching relatively high intensity, according to aviation data provider AirNav Systems.

One storm cell moved from west to east and intensified significantly near where the aircraft passed, according to AirNav Systems, which said its weather data indicated moderate to severe icing conditions as well as moderate turbulence in the area.

Aviation safety experts said the thunderstorm appeared to play a critical role in the crash, questioning why the flight crew entered severe weather in the first place.

"The airplane was seen to have entered a very powerful, isolated thunderstorm that was high as to where that airplane was flying," said Jeff Guzzetti, a former top U.S. aircraft accident investigator. "Typically, these business jets can fly over the weather. But in this case, this weather was building up so much that it was reaching some very high altitudes."

That exposed the aircraft to potential icing, hail and turbulence. Icing at such high altitudes is rare, experts said, and a quick buildup of ice from upward-flowing air on the wings and tail can result in a loss of aerodynamic lift and control of the airplane.

"You can accumulate ice really quickly that way, but if you are in an airplanea jet particularlyand you see liquid water like that, it is a real big red flag that this is very unusual and very, very dangerous," said John Cox, an aviation safety consultant and former airline pilot union official.

Learjet Crash Investigation Focuses on Severe Weather, NTSB Says - WSJ
Jarrin Jay
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Yes, 100%. Any icing and resulting mechanical or hardware issues will be a direct result of human pilot error, which is almost always the case.

HOWEVER, I don't think the flight crew could see the storm they flew into as their whole environment was just white cloud, they weren't above it, they could not see any sky or ground. They didn't know they were turning into a cell with an updaft going well above their altitude which caused the event. They had been skirting a larger storm prior.

But just looking at the radar at the time, they should have just gone due south and around the tip of FL, it was very risky especially for such a small plane. Should not have been anywhere near such storms.

+/- 600-700 feet is NOT mild turbulence, and if you listen to the co-pilot voice recorder, there is an immediate shift in tone and concern right after she asks for a "better ride" to the point they know it's a huge problem. She did an excellent job and kept her composure n a terrible situation.

From the second it went nose- down it was not recoverable and it happened too quickly to do anything about it. They were fine (though turbulent) and 5-7 seconds later the end was already in motion (icing, lost lift, stall, breakup on the way down, etc.)

Horrific. I am not afraid to die, not afraid to fly, but terrified of dying in a plane crash. Those last 30 seconds had to be the most terrifying thing a human could ever experience.

18-25 year olds are not mature, make poor decisions, and have less impulse control just as a general rule. HOWEVER age and experience had nothing to do with it given the 20 year old girl was not flying it, but in general yes 20 is too young to be in such a position, though experience has to be gained somewhere which is why it was a small 10 person plain, not a 75 person regional jet or 737/A319-320.

Age and experience is always better than education and learned technical skills, in anything really, driving, engineering, performing music, whatever. Education and learned technical skills is the foundation.
Jarrin Jay
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Man I caught that also and it hasn't been repeated or discussed much, WTF was she doing texting?!?!? Again, she wasn't flying it and not an immediate cause, but maybe if she wasn't texting she could have said to the pilot this is getting bad and we need to divert or do something immediately.
Teslag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
How are these business jet pilots usually employed? Full time? Scheduled? On call? Independent contractors?
TX_COWDOC
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Jarrin Jay said:

Man I caught that also and it hasn't been repeated or discussed much, WTF was she doing texting?!?!? Again, she wasn't flying it and not an immediate cause, but maybe if she wasn't texting she could have said to the pilot this is getting bad and we need to divert or do something immediately.


My question on the texting is was there a pattern of similar activity on prior flights or was she sensing she was in grave danger. If the latter, then the situation takes the appearance of a much junior pilot not able to influence or correct the older PIC's potentially poor judgment on his part. As mentioned by others - get there 'itis' may explain the decision to fly through a 100 mile wide system versus going around.
www.southpawprecision.com
Type 07 FFL / Class 2 SOT
Nightforce Optics Dealer
AGM Night Vision Dealer
Wheatables02
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
This feels like a situation where the pilot(s) wanted the passengers to get somewhere on a time deadline and ego took over and they pushed through the storm...
fc2112
How long do you want to ignore this user?
My question about the texting - they tell us all in the cabin to put our phones on airplane mode. Flight attendants insist it's an operational thing for the aircraft but apparently that's a load of it.
fc2112
How long do you want to ignore this user?
https://www.afar.com/magazine/what-does-airplane-mode-do-and-why-do-you-need-to-use-it

Quote:

Phones emit radio signals that can affect sensitive avionics such as navigation receivers and radio altimeters. Even if rare, interference is possible, which is why FAA rules require disabling cellular service in flight.


So did her texting contribute to the crash?
torrid
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
fc2112 said:

My question about the texting - they tell us all in the cabin to put our phones on airplane mode. Flight attendants insist it's an operational thing for the aircraft but apparently that's a load of it.


Private aircraft.
Mr President Elect
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
fc2112 said:

https://www.afar.com/magazine/what-does-airplane-mode-do-and-why-do-you-need-to-use-it

Quote:

Phones emit radio signals that can affect sensitive avionics such as navigation receivers and radio altimeters. Even if rare, interference is possible, which is why FAA rules require disabling cellular service in flight.


So did her texting contribute to the crash?

She would have had to use wifi at that altitude for texting, which is allowed. I am pretty sure that is non-sense about airplane mode anyways; they just don't want a cabin full of people trying to talk on the phone. At least there have been rumors that the FAA was looking into doing away with that rule, but kept it for that reason.
Mr President Elect
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I'm sure her texting is probably not ideal, especially given what the outcome of this was, but I am guessing that is somewhat common. Heck, check out Northwest Airlines Flight 188 for distracted pilots, lol
Mr President Elect
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
infinity ag said:


Learjet in doomed Palm Beach plane crash was involved in ANOTHER incident with female pilot weeks before… with chilling echoes of fatal maneuver that would go on to kill nine
https://www.dailymail.com/news/article-16259449/pilot-learjet-crash-florida-audio-downplaying-turbulence.html

Quote:

A female pilot flying the same Learjet that crashed in Florida was heard being scolded by air traffic control months before for downplaying turbulence.

The woman was flying over Newark in New Jersey in May when an air traffic controller asked 'Why are you climbing?'
'We are just about to call you, we are experiencing moderate [turbulence] and unable to hold altitude,' said the female pilot.


The exasperated controller responded firmly: 'That is not moderate, descend to 4,000 [feet] immediately.
'If you cant maintain altitude that is not moderate, that is severe turbulence, are you experiencing severe turbulence?' he added.


The woman and a man then both respond 'affirmative sir', as the audio clip ended.
It is unclear if the woman heard on the audio was Nathalia Gadelha Filgueiras, 20. She was co-pilot of the Learjet when it crashed in Palm Beach on Sunday, killing her and eight others, amid speculation the plane was downed by severe weather.
The Learjet whose pilot was scolded for downplaying turbulence bore the same tail number N7226D as the plane that smashed into the ground while flying from Austin in Texas to the Bahamas.



Was it confirmed it was actually her on that flight though? It sounded like that woman had an accent that wasn't present in the current incident.
aggieforester05
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Wheatables02 said:

This feels like a situation where the pilot(s) wanted the passengers to get somewhere on a time deadline and ego took over and they pushed through the storm...

I suspect it was more of a blindness to the small cell they flew through. The weather subscription services are l****, the only thing they can rely on is their radar. If that isn't working correctly, the settings are wrong, there is attenuation, etc. then they might not have realized they were turning into the worst of it. They had already made several turns adding time to the trip to avoid weather. The big mistake was not going south to begin with.
Aggie95
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
fc2112 said:

My question about the texting - they tell us all in the cabin to put our phones on airplane mode. Flight attendants insist it's an operational thing for the aircraft but apparently that's a load of it.

I can still text on Delta wi-fi with my phone on airplane mode.

That said, I'd rather my pilots be locked in, especially when dealing with weather. It's not like she texted earlier saying..."smooth flight so far but looks like some weather ahead", no, they were actively flying through bad weather when she texted.
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.