Plane Crash Near Mar-a-Lago

85,140 Views | 658 Replies | Last: 6 days ago by CornAg
Teslag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
AggieFlyboy said:

jeremiahjt said:

We can do whatever the hell we want. I love when somebody it whatever industry is being discussed comes in and tells all the non-industry people what they can and cannot discuss.

And then the obligatory "all the best (insert job) I know are women and are so much better than me at (insert job).


Dude, I've flown with good sticks and bad sticks. Men and women can fit both categories. All that matters in the airplane is skill; age and sex are pretty much irrelevant. I've flown with young guys that have more experience than guys sitting there for 40 years.


Skill can't make up for experience when **** goes south and you need quick, rational, and accurate decision making. And that's not just true for pilots. It's true for many similar occupations.
AggieFlyboy
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Teslag said:

AggieFlyboy said:

jeremiahjt said:

We can do whatever the hell we want. I love when somebody it whatever industry is being discussed comes in and tells all the non-industry people what they can and cannot discuss.

And then the obligatory "all the best (insert job) I know are women and are so much better than me at (insert job).


Dude, I've flown with good sticks and bad sticks. Men and women can fit both categories. All that matters in the airplane is skill; age and sex are pretty much irrelevant. I've flown with young guys that have more experience than guys sitting there for 40 years.


Skill can't make up for experience when **** goes south and you need quick, rational, and accurate decision making. And that's not just true for pilots. It's true for many similar occupations.


I don't disagree that experience matters. I'm saying age isn't always a reliable indicator of experience
one safe place
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AggieT said:

one safe place said:

5Amp said:

If the pilot is not a cubby, middle age white dude, I ain't flying.

My family and I were flying back from Virginia Beach after going out for a wedding. We are sitting in the boarding area, and this pilot dude comes walking toward the counter, pulling his little suitcase and for some reason I watch him. Looked to be in his 50s. He goes to the door behind the counter and presses the keypad on the door, but it doesn't open. Tries it again and again and still can't get it open. As I focus on him, I get the feeling he is drunk. Eventually, after about a dozen tries, he opens the door. As we wait, the thought runs through my mind if it turns out he is the pilot, maybe stay another night and try again tomorrow. As we board the plane, I take a step to the left and lean over a bit so I can look in the cockpit, and he wasn't in either seat!

He disappeared?

I think the door he entered led to another plane is my guess.
Teslag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
AggieFlyboy said:

Teslag said:

AggieFlyboy said:

jeremiahjt said:

We can do whatever the hell we want. I love when somebody it whatever industry is being discussed comes in and tells all the non-industry people what they can and cannot discuss.

And then the obligatory "all the best (insert job) I know are women and are so much better than me at (insert job).


Dude, I've flown with good sticks and bad sticks. Men and women can fit both categories. All that matters in the airplane is skill; age and sex are pretty much irrelevant. I've flown with young guys that have more experience than guys sitting there for 40 years.


Skill can't make up for experience when **** goes south and you need quick, rational, and accurate decision making. And that's not just true for pilots. It's true for many similar occupations.


I don't disagree that experience matters. I'm saying age isn't always a reliable indicator of experience


True, but age is a reliable way to gauge development of the prefrontal cortex over a large population group.
FIDO95
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG


Blancolirio is up. I've waiting for his analysis.
No material on this site is intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. See full Medical Disclaimer.
Ag87H2O
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
bonfarr said:

Interesting if real, this makes it appear ATC tried to get them to divert clear of the weather and they declined saying they would maintain a direct course. They didn't ask for a change until they were already in it and it was too late





It just seems so pointless. There was plenty of space to go around that thunderstorm, in any direction. It's almost like they aimed the track of plane right at the storm.
insulator_king
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
AggieFlyboy said:

Teslag said:

AggieFlyboy said:

jeremiahjt said:

We can do whatever the hell we want. I love when somebody it whatever industry is being discussed comes in and tells all the non-industry people what they can and cannot discuss.

And then the obligatory "all the best (insert job) I know are women and are so much better than me at (insert job).


Dude, I've flown with good sticks and bad sticks. Men and women can fit both categories. All that matters in the airplane is skill; age and sex are pretty much irrelevant. I've flown with young guys that have more experience than guys sitting there for 40 years.


Skill can't make up for experience when **** goes south and you need quick, rational, and accurate decision making. And that's not just true for pilots. It's true for many similar occupations.


I don't disagree that experience matters. I'm saying age isn't always a reliable indicator of experience

I agree. If someone says I've been flying [or whatever other job] 20 years, is it 20 years experience, or 1 year experience repeated 20 times. In other words, is the person continually increasing their knowledge and skills each and every year, or are they remaining static.

And the PIC; Pilot In Command, who was a 55yo male, should have been sharing his advanced ADM [Aeronautical Decision Making] to the young but pretty sharp 20 yo female co-pilot about the dangers of convective weather, and avoiding it by significant margins, and not cut it so close to the edge. Alas, he did not do that, perhaps due to complacency or hubris or Get-there-itis, and they all died.
Sea Speed
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I'm not sure why it is so controversial to say you want a male pilot over a female pilot.

insulator_king
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Teslag said:

AggieFlyboy said:

Teslag said:

AggieFlyboy said:

jeremiahjt said:

We can do whatever the hell we want. I love when somebody it whatever industry is being discussed comes in and tells all the non-industry people what they can and cannot discuss.

And then the obligatory "all the best (insert job) I know are women and are so much better than me at (insert job).


Dude, I've flown with good sticks and bad sticks. Men and women can fit both categories. All that matters in the airplane is skill; age and sex are pretty much irrelevant. I've flown with young guys that have more experience than guys sitting there for 40 years.


Skill can't make up for experience when **** goes south and you need quick, rational, and accurate decision making. And that's not just true for pilots. It's true for many similar occupations.


I don't disagree that experience matters. I'm saying age isn't always a reliable indicator of experience


True, but age is a reliable way to gauge development of the prefrontal cortex over a large population group.

The age and experience of the 55 yo pilot didn't seem to help in this situation. See my prev post.
CanyonAg77
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Gunny456 said:

Thing is there were thousands of those teenagers and barely 20 year olds that flew hundreds of missions and sorties during WWIl that got the job done and had not only bad weather to worry about but also people trying to shoot them down every day.

And more of them died in training accidents than in combat

Disclaimer: going off memory here, I could be wrong, but I recall reading that a few years ago
AggieFlyboy
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Sea Speed said:

I'm not sure why it is so controversial to say you want a male pilot over a female pilot.


. Because the females that actually make it through tend to have those traits.
insulator_king
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Sea Speed said:

I'm not sure why it is so controversial to say you want a male pilot over a female pilot.



Probably because that doesn't guarantee better outcomes. I mean, look at the 55 yo male pilot of the Lear Jet. Poor decision making skills on his part as PIC.

And what I want, as a ~65 yo male [Caucasian if you want to know, not that it matters], is someone who is competent, proficient, & skilled. IOW, merit based, & nothing else. And culture plays a large role too, I don't ever intend to fly Air India, Vietnam Air, Malaysian airlines, etc.
EFR
How long do you want to ignore this user?
And yet "the binary surfer", obviously a great scientific source, can't show any actual statistics.
The airforce appears to disagree with him.
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9293351/
Logos Stick
How long do you want to ignore this user?
EFR said:

And yet "the binary surfer", obviously a great scientific source, can't show any actual statistics.
The airforce appears to disagree with him.
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9293351/


That study doesn't disagree at all.
CanyonAg77
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
My guess is that either through culture or genetics, not that many women want to fly. Even fewer want to fly fighters. Maybe those few really want to do it, or they are genetically predisposed to be able to fly well, and that leads them to that profession
Daddy
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Sea Speed said:

You couldn't pay me enough to get on an airplane with a 20 year old female in the cockpit.



Bingo
Experience is something you can't buy
On airplane you better know what you are doing

That plane hit almost straight down

That tells me you called as a father {Chris Rock}
joerobert_pete06
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I've been waiting all day for captain steeve to post his video

Gunny456
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I looked up some stats that CAF has in their archives and they have, according to USAAF, that 52,173 air crew lost their lives during combat or missing and later declared dead in WWII.
The Navy and Marines lost 2,891 airmen in combat.
Globally 25,844 USAAF airmen died in training and other accidents including ferrying aircraft. Of that number,15,000 died in the continental U.S. in training accidents.

What you might be remembering is that another shocking statistic is that 65,164 total aircraft were lost by the U.S. in WWII but of that number only 22,948 were lost in combat.
Here is good link on some of this data and more.
https://www.realclearhistory.com/articles/2019/02/12/staggering_statistics_15000_us_airmen_killed_in_training_in_ww_ii_412.html
TAMU Wildlife and Fisheries Sciences

Boat racing is like a beautiful woman.......expensive, high maintenance, but well worth the fun!
GAC06
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
The Eighth Air Force lost more men than the entire Marine Corps in WWII
bmks270
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Florida thunderstorms are very erratic. Sunshine, then hail for 20 minutes, then sunshine. Or driving, all clear, then drive through a wall of water for 10 miles back to clear and in my on the other side.

The whole state was under a massive storm system. They probably hit a severe patch of weather they didn't anticipate.

How much experience did they have with central Florida summer storms? This was also not a not a normal storm system, it was much larger than average.
Gunny456
How long do you want to ignore this user?
ShaggySLC
How long do you want to ignore this user?
After watching explaintion videos, update videos, etc... Is there any chance 55 year old had a death wish? It just seems like most of the pros are saying, what the hell was this guy doing. Just seems crazy how fast they came down, and him saying the lords prayer while the co-poilet is trying to figure it out.
samurai_science
How long do you want to ignore this user?
ShaggySLC said:

After watching explaintion videos, update videos, etc... Is there any chance 55 year old had a death wish? It just seems like most of the pros are saying, what the hell was this guy doing. Just seems crazy how fast they came down, and him saying the lords prayer while the co-poilet is trying to figure it out.

Flying through the storm seems to have been a judgement failure, but at that point maybe he knew there was no recovering so defaulted to prayer.
TexasRebel
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
He would have been the first one to know they were no longer in controlled flight.
AggieFlyboy
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
joerobert_pete06 said:

I've been waiting all day for captain steeve to post his video




Said no one ever
AggieFlyboy
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
bmks270 said:

Florida thunderstorms are very erratic. Sunshine, then hail for 20 minutes, then sunshine. Or driving, all clear, then drive through a wall of water for 10 miles back to clear and in my on the other side.

The whole state was under a massive storm system. They probably hit a severe patch of weather they didn't anticipate.

How much experience did they have with central Florida summer storms? This was also not a not a normal storm system, it was much larger than average.


That was a normal Florida storm
HeyAbbott
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
It was a very severe thunderstorm even for South Florida area.
joerobert_pete06
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
What were her comments about the over speed condition? I'm assuming that was the first indication that they lost control of the airplane and no longer had lift.
W
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
2 million views on Captain Steeeve's video in 8 hours
Blonde Coffee Beans
How long do you want to ignore this user?
bonfarr said:

Agsquatch said:

They're trained to be that way. You can't get worked up even hearing something like that because you are generally working multiple frequencies / sectors and could have a domino effect. Why we need to keep praying for him. ATC are the voice of reason in chaos.


Here is an excellent example of ATC remaining calm and getting a pilot out of a jam. I hope this pilot sent the ATac a case of his favorite spirits after this.




Here is the longer transcript. He calls later that day to thank the controllers then asked to file another flight plan that day. I think if I was him I would have needed a new pair of pants and underwear and a little break before going back up in the air.




This reminds me of a friend of mine. We were in the Navy, back when HM-15 was at Corpus. He survives a helicopter crash into the Gulf. There were two survivors and I believe 4 died? This was back in 2000 or 2001?

I later found out by him that once he recovered from his injuries he decided to start flying again (Air crew) On his very next flight, they lost an engine, began to spin and prepared for a crash only to regain the engine and then land it. He walked back into the hangar and gave up his wings
"I don't care about your feelings OP. I'm not going to let fandom replace reason, thought, and history"
Ag with kids
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
HeyAbbott said:

It was a very severe thunderstorm even for South Florida area.

The weather here in central/south Florida has been ****ed up over the last few days. I think there was 21+ inches of rain here in Melbourne in the past 24 hrs...
You can turn off signatures, btw
Ramdiesel
How long do you want to ignore this user?
jkag89 said:

wangus12 said:

Gunny456 said:

Thing is there were thousands of those teenagers and barely 20 year olds that flew hundreds of missions and sorties during WWIl that got the job done and had not only bad weather to worry about but also people trying to shoot them down every day.


To be fair, there were also around 15,000 aviation deaths in training accidents in World War 2 as well

To be fair, there has also be a great deal of advancement in aviation technology since the 1940s. Heck it is much safer to fly today than 30 years ago.


That's a scary thought, I was flying a lot 30 years ago, like 2 times a week. Had a flight over Oklahoma in stormy weather back then in a prop engine plane that scared the tar out of me an everyone else on the flight. Major turbulence, felt like the plane dropped many many hundred feet a few times. Lightning all over the place and the pilot advised we were flying around a big tornadic supercell but also flying close to another severe cell that was near it and was going to be landing in OKC while it was under a tornado warning for part of the other side of the city away from the airport. It was nuts. Could hear tornado sirens going off while exiting the plane.

After living in Oklahoma City for 6 years, I got used to the Tornado Sirens going off 4 or 5 times a year.It was a magnet for bad weather.
ErnestEndeavor
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Ryan Hall weather analysis of crash.

aggiedata
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
BBRex
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
ShaggySLC said:

After watching explaintion videos, update videos, etc... Is there any chance 55 year old had a death wish? It just seems like most of the pros are saying, what the hell was this guy doing. Just seems crazy how fast they came down, and him saying the lords prayer while the co-poilet is trying to figure it out.


Judging from one of the videos posted here, it appears he navigated around the big storm, then caught a much smaller cell after skirting the big one. Maybe it was harder to detect in the plane, or maybe they let their guard down after getting around the main part of the storm? Maybe we'll find out.
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.