Plane Crash Near Mar-a-Lago

85,132 Views | 658 Replies | Last: 6 days ago by CornAg
YokelRidesAgain
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I was just reading last night about the crash of American Eagle 4184 on Halloween night in 1994, another icing event that killed all 68 passengers and crew.

The safety record of commercial passenger aviation in this country at present is astounding when you consider the number of things that can go wrong and the unforgiving reality of catastrophic failure at cruising altitude.

Incidents like the one today are a reminder that the history of aviation is written in blood, and show what can happen when the stringent safety protocols used in commercial air travel are not followed.
Sid Farkas
How long do you want to ignore this user?
News stations are actually playing cockpit audio without viewer warnings
Rockdoc
How long do you want to ignore this user?
JFABNRGR said:

Crazy how fast it went from requesting new altitude to 20,000'+ plunge with total loss of flight.

That why I think their horizontal stab might have been snapped off by really severe turbulence in that thunderstorm core. Happened in a blink.
Brewskis
How long do you want to ignore this user?
One of my most memorable flights was getting stuck above FL420ish trying to get back to Jordan at night during a massive weather pattern. I remember throwing on my NVGs to see what the system looked like through those and had to take the off because there was so much lightning.
Featured Video Previews
Ag87H2O
How long do you want to ignore this user?


Yes, this bottom photo is a little clearer, and the horizontal stabilizer appears to be gone.
stetson
How long do you want to ignore this user?
bonfarr said:

A former AF pilot on X is saying the plane was missing the tail before impact. Would it have sheared off in the storm?

When flying in bad weather, the aircraft should be flown below a certain speed (maneuvering speed) so that the aircraft will stall before exceeding its limit load factor and suffering structural damage. If there was structural damage, it likely happened on the way down after they lost control of the aircraft.
Infection_Ag11
How long do you want to ignore this user?
GAC06 said:

Quote:

A commercial airliner has never been brought down by weather based turbulence in the history of modern aviation.


No. Fly into a severe thunderstorm and any plane is in deep trouble


Commercial airliners are still designed to withstand such forces, and essentially always do in the unfortunate circumstances in which it occurs.
Infection_Ag11
How long do you want to ignore this user?
CanyonAg77 said:

Quote:

A commercial airliner has never been brought down by weather based turbulence in the history of modern aviation.


Delta flight 191 says "Hi!"


The plane was blown out of the path of the runway just above the ground and crashed because it touched down in a field instead. The plane was completely undamaged by the wind sheer itself, and it wouldn't have caused a crash had it occurred any earlier in the descent.

Again, the point is that no commercial airliner has ever been brought down like this plane was (structural damage due to weather based turbulence). Larger commercial airliners are designed to withstand far, far more punishment and are essentially impossible for weather to break apart.
Infection_Ag11
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Gator92 said:

Infection_Ag11 said:

wangus12 said:

Conspiracy nuts already running with it being a missile and everything has already been doctored to look like a plane.

One of my worst fears with flying.


This sort of thing is unique to small passenger planes though. Based on posts from pilots on social media it sounds like turbulence from the weather tore off the horizontal stabilizer which effectively turned the plane into a lawn dart. A commercial airliner has never been brought down by weather based turbulence in the history of modern aviation.

It's really not something to worry about for the typical airline passenger and why I'll never fly on one of those little Learjets.

Delta 191 wind shear at DFW???

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Delta_Air_Lines_Flight_191


The plane crashed because it landed in a field instead of the runway. The wind gust didn't actually damage the plane at all.
Gator92
How long do you want to ignore this user?


Looks like they tried to fly south around the weather, but they then turned back North East.

As for turbulence "snapping off" control surfaces, I think it more plausible they entered a stall in a weather cell and the horizontal stabilizer came off plunging 20K/min. Maybe it was ice, maybe not. But Delta 191 stalled b/c they went through the cell encountering a strong tail wind followed rapidly by a strong head wind.
Gunny456
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Appears that that model Lear is in fact a T-tail design? Horizontal stabilizer/elevators would have been at the top of the vertical stabilizer… not at the bottom attached to the fuselage.
TAMU Wildlife and Fisheries Sciences

Boat racing is like a beautiful woman.......expensive, high maintenance, but well worth the fun!
Gator92
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Infection_Ag11 said:

Gator92 said:

Infection_Ag11 said:

wangus12 said:

Conspiracy nuts already running with it being a missile and everything has already been doctored to look like a plane.

One of my worst fears with flying.


This sort of thing is unique to small passenger planes though. Based on posts from pilots on social media it sounds like turbulence from the weather tore off the horizontal stabilizer which effectively turned the plane into a lawn dart. A commercial airliner has never been brought down by weather based turbulence in the history of modern aviation.

It's really not something to worry about for the typical airline passenger and why I'll never fly on one of those little Learjets.

Delta 191 wind shear at DFW???

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Delta_Air_Lines_Flight_191


The plane crashed because it landed in a field instead of the runway. The wind gust didn't actually damage the plane at all.

I guess you didn't read the part where the NTSB said wind shear and a micro burst caused the crash...

ETA Why do you think we have Doppler Radar???
91AggieLawyer
How long do you want to ignore this user?
CanyonAg77 said:

Quote:

A commercial airliner has never been brought down by weather based turbulence in the history of modern aviation.


Delta flight 191 says "Hi!"

Yeah, you can't say D191 wasn't brought down by the microburst/wind shear. You can argue that other factors may have been involved in the crash (pilots decisions to attempt to land, etc.) but it was the weather pattern that caused the crash. Without that, they would have landed safely. Maybe shaken and damaged, but no loss of life.

What's wild about D191 was, the news were interviewing passengers who survived and could talk. One guy, strapped to a gurney said something like, "I think it was wind shear." Who that wasn't an expert in either aviation or weather prior to 1985 knew anything about wind shear? At least enough to suspect it just crashed your plane.
CanyonAg77
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Quote:

Larger commercial airliners are designed to withstand far, far more punishment and are essentially impossible for weather to break apart

Nonsense
Gunny456
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Yep. That determination caused wind shear detection equipment to be installed at lots of airports along with upgrading to new technology Doppler radar.
TAMU Wildlife and Fisheries Sciences

Boat racing is like a beautiful woman.......expensive, high maintenance, but well worth the fun!
Infection_Ag11
How long do you want to ignore this user?
91AggieLawyer said:

CanyonAg77 said:

Quote:

A commercial airliner has never been brought down by weather based turbulence in the history of modern aviation.


Delta flight 191 says "Hi!"

Yeah, you can't say D191 wasn't brought down by the microburst/wind shear. You can argue that other factors may have been involved in the crash (pilots decisions to attempt to land, etc.) but it was the weather pattern that caused the crash. Without that, they would have landed safely. Maybe shaken and damaged, but no loss of life.

What's wild about D191 was, the news were interviewing passengers who survived and could talk. One guy, strapped to a gurney said something like, "I think it was wind shear." Who that wasn't an expert in either aviation or weather prior to 1985 knew anything about wind shear? At least enough to suspect it just crashed your plane.


But again, the weather didn't damage the plane at all. Which is the entire point. This plane was brought down by structural damage that occurred at cruising altitude from my understanding. That is, literally, unheard of for commercial airliners.
YokelRidesAgain
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Infection_Ag11 said:

Again, the point is that no commercial airliner has ever been brought down like this plane was (structural damage due to weather based turbulence).

First, what you are stating is entirely speculative. If the plane indeed lost the horizontal stabilizer it is at least (probably more) likely that it tore off as the plane was descending at a rate vastly exceeding design specifications rather than this caused the crash.

And if it did suffer a catastrophic mechanical failure, this could have been due to any one of a number of factors unrelated to the design of the airframe (Japan Airlines 123, AA 191, etc.).

You are drawing the wrong conclusion from the data: commercial airlines don't crash because they are indestructible; they don't crash because there are a host of very well designed safety procedures designed to keep people from doing things that cause the aircraft to be destroyed.
91AggieLawyer
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Infection_Ag11 said:

Gator92 said:

Infection_Ag11 said:

wangus12 said:

Conspiracy nuts already running with it being a missile and everything has already been doctored to look like a plane.

One of my worst fears with flying.


This sort of thing is unique to small passenger planes though. Based on posts from pilots on social media it sounds like turbulence from the weather tore off the horizontal stabilizer which effectively turned the plane into a lawn dart. A commercial airliner has never been brought down by weather based turbulence in the history of modern aviation.

It's really not something to worry about for the typical airline passenger and why I'll never fly on one of those little Learjets.

Delta 191 wind shear at DFW???

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Delta_Air_Lines_Flight_191


The plane crashed because it landed in a field instead of the runway. The wind gust didn't actually damage the plane at all.

I think you need to read the report instead of wikipedia. It didn't really CRASH in a field. It HIT the ground north of the runway (actual report gives distance that I think is inaccurate, but it was still on track for the runway), then up, then back down on the highway just north of the runway. At that point, it veered off to the left, came back to the ground, was out of control at about 180mph, and started to turn. It then hit the water tower, which took off the back quarter of the plane, saving many in those sections. The rest of the plane kept rolling and exploded, killing just about everyone in those sections. I highlight all this because the final area it crashed in was only 2-3 hundred yards from the actual runway.

The wind shear brought the plane down. There's no manual for hop-skipping a plane from a field to a highway to left of the runway with a water tower right there.
91AggieLawyer
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Infection_Ag11 said:

91AggieLawyer said:

CanyonAg77 said:

Quote:

A commercial airliner has never been brought down by weather based turbulence in the history of modern aviation.


Delta flight 191 says "Hi!"

Yeah, you can't say D191 wasn't brought down by the microburst/wind shear. You can argue that other factors may have been involved in the crash (pilots decisions to attempt to land, etc.) but it was the weather pattern that caused the crash. Without that, they would have landed safely. Maybe shaken and damaged, but no loss of life.

What's wild about D191 was, the news were interviewing passengers who survived and could talk. One guy, strapped to a gurney said something like, "I think it was wind shear." Who that wasn't an expert in either aviation or weather prior to 1985 knew anything about wind shear? At least enough to suspect it just crashed your plane.


But again, the weather didn't damage the plane at all. Which is the entire point. This plane was brought down by structural damage that occurred at cruising altitude from my understanding. That is, literally, unheard of for commercial airliners.

Now you're changing what you said (or what was said): originally, it was "never been brought down by weather based turbulence." That is factually INCORRECT. No one said the weather did any structural damage to the Delta L1011 in Dallas (actually, it was Irving).
Infection_Ag11
How long do you want to ignore this user?
CanyonAg77 said:

Quote:

Larger commercial airliners are designed to withstand far, far more punishment and are essentially impossible for weather to break apart

Nonsense


The last time a commercial airliner broke apart due to weather, or was even structurally damaged severely enough by weather to potentially bring it down, was in 1981 and that was a 80 seat Fokker F28 that literally flew into a tornado. Before that you have to go back to like 1966.

None of the standard commercial airline models used anywhere in the world today have ever been broken up by weather. Is it possible? Sure, but those planes are designed to withstand extraordinary stressors.
Gunny456
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Won't ever forget that day. My boss and myself flew out of DFW on a Delta flight about 20 minutes or so before the Delta crash. We were heading to Long Beach to work a boat show.
Thunderstorms were all around DFW when we lifted off. We didn't hear about the crash till we landed.
TAMU Wildlife and Fisheries Sciences

Boat racing is like a beautiful woman.......expensive, high maintenance, but well worth the fun!
Langley
How long do you want to ignore this user?
91AggieLawyer said:

Infection_Ag11 said:

Gator92 said:

Infection_Ag11 said:

wangus12 said:

Conspiracy nuts already running with it being a missile and everything has already been doctored to look like a plane.

One of my worst fears with flying.


This sort of thing is unique to small passenger planes though. Based on posts from pilots on social media it sounds like turbulence from the weather tore off the horizontal stabilizer which effectively turned the plane into a lawn dart. A commercial airliner has never been brought down by weather based turbulence in the history of modern aviation.

It's really not something to worry about for the typical airline passenger and why I'll never fly on one of those little Learjets.

Delta 191 wind shear at DFW???

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Delta_Air_Lines_Flight_191


The plane crashed because it landed in a field instead of the runway. The wind gust didn't actually damage the plane at all.

I think you need to read the report instead of wikipedia. It didn't really CRASH in a field. It HIT the ground north of the runway (actual report gives distance that I think is inaccurate, but it was still on track for the runway), then up, then back down on the highway just north of the runway. At that point, it veered off to the left, came back to the ground, was out of control at about 180mph, and started to turn. It then hit the water tower, which took off the back quarter of the plane, saving many in those sections. The rest of the plane kept rolling and exploded, killing just about everyone in those sections. I highlight all this because the final area it crashed in was only 2-3 hundred yards from the actual runway.

The wind shear brought the plane down. There's no manual for hop-skipping a plane from a field to a highway to left of the runway with a water tower right there.


If only the pilots would've pulled the dip dodge dive dodge lever.
YokelRidesAgain
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Gunny456 said:

Appears that that model Lear is in fact a T-tail design?

Correct.

Philip J Fry
How long do you want to ignore this user?
You ever see the Boeing ultimate wing bending test? Ain't no way that airplane sees loads like that from weather
Gator92
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Infection_Ag11 said:

91AggieLawyer said:

CanyonAg77 said:

Quote:

A commercial airliner has never been brought down by weather based turbulence in the history of modern aviation.


Delta flight 191 says "Hi!"

Yeah, you can't say D191 wasn't brought down by the microburst/wind shear. You can argue that other factors may have been involved in the crash (pilots decisions to attempt to land, etc.) but it was the weather pattern that caused the crash. Without that, they would have landed safely. Maybe shaken and damaged, but no loss of life.

What's wild about D191 was, the news were interviewing passengers who survived and could talk. One guy, strapped to a gurney said something like, "I think it was wind shear." Who that wasn't an expert in either aviation or weather prior to 1985 knew anything about wind shear? At least enough to suspect it just crashed your plane.


But again, the weather didn't damage the plane at all. Which is the entire point. This plane was brought down by structural damage that occurred at cruising altitude from my understanding. That is, literally, unheard of for commercial airliners.

You don't know that and nothing from the ATC recording says so. It is more likely it broke up in the 20K/min plunge. Frankly, the fact that both wings look intact at impact should tell you that these "little Lear Jets" are built to withstand weather turbulence...
Infection_Ag11
How long do you want to ignore this user?
YokelRidesAgain said:

Infection_Ag11 said:

Again, the point is that no commercial airliner has ever been brought down like this plane was (structural damage due to weather based turbulence).

You are drawing the wrong conclusion from the data: commercial airlines don't crash because they are indestructible; they don't crash because there are a host of very well designed safety procedures designed to keep people from doing things that cause the aircraft to be destroyed.


Sure, but it does occasionally happen. And when it does, the planes essentially always survive. These passenger planes are far more prone to such things.
Emotional Support Cobra
How long do you want to ignore this user?
YokelRidesAgain said:

I was just reading last night about the crash of American Eagle 4184 on Halloween night in 1994, another icing event that killed all 68 passengers and crew.

The safety record of commercial passenger aviation in this country at present is astounding when you consider the number of things that can go wrong and the unforgiving reality of catastrophic failure at cruising altitude.

Incidents like the one today are a reminder that the history of aviation is written in blood, and show what can happen when the stringent safety protocols used in commercial air travel are not followed.


My neighbor died in this crash.
Kenneth_2003
How long do you want to ignore this user?
bonfarr said:

A former AF pilot on X is saying the plane was missing the tail before impact. Would it have sheared off in the storm?


Turbulence would have to have been very severe.

My thoughts... This is from a geologist, not a pilot, and not a meteorologist...

Was in turbulence. Requested higher altitude. Storm grew as they flew into it. Updraft brought massive quantities of wet ice and liquid water up with it. The wet liquid water and wet ice instantly froze on the plane. Ice built up on control surfaces. Ice on the horizontal stabilizers radically affected trim and put the plane into a steep and ultimately unrecoverable dive. This could have been exacerbated by ice buildup on wings affecting lift creating a stall condition in level flight.

Dropping a wing and rolling over i believe it's a classic characteristic of an unrecovered stall.

If ice affected trim and they're trying to get nose down and as power for airspeed in a stall... We know (from the audio i wish I hadn't heard) they were over speed...

Overspend can rip parts off the plane. (Fly Dubai rudder)...
Ice can also affect pitot static instruments (Hello Air France)
CanyonAg77
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Infection_Ag11 said:

CanyonAg77 said:

Quote:

Larger commercial airliners are designed to withstand far, far more punishment and are essentially impossible for weather to break apart

Nonsense


The last time a commercial airliner broke apart due to weather, or was even structurally damaged severely enough by weather to potentially bring it down, was in 1981 and that was a 80 seat Fokker F28 that literally flew into a tornado. Before that you have to go back to like 1966.

None of the standard commercial airline models used anywhere in the world today have ever been broken up by weather. Is it possible? Sure, but those planes are designed to withstand extraordinary stressors.

1993 March 31 Japan Air Lines Cargo Flight 46E, a Boeing 747-121F flying from Anchorage to Chicago, encountered severe turbulence over Alaska that caused the detachment of its number-two engine. The aircraft made a successful emergency landing in Anchorage, with no injuries among the five on board.

2001 November 12 American Airlines Flight 587, an Airbus A300, crashed into a Queens neighbourhood in New York City when the plane's vertical tail fin snapped off just after takeoff, due to overuse of the rudder by the first officer during a wake turbulence encounter. All 251 passengers and nine crew members were killed, as well as five people on the ground.
HollywoodBQ
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Pilot Debrief "Hoover" just published an initial summary of the facts, especially weather to his Facebook.
Infection_Ag11
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Gator92 said:

Infection_Ag11 said:

91AggieLawyer said:

CanyonAg77 said:

Quote:

A commercial airliner has never been brought down by weather based turbulence in the history of modern aviation.


Delta flight 191 says "Hi!"

Yeah, you can't say D191 wasn't brought down by the microburst/wind shear. You can argue that other factors may have been involved in the crash (pilots decisions to attempt to land, etc.) but it was the weather pattern that caused the crash. Without that, they would have landed safely. Maybe shaken and damaged, but no loss of life.

What's wild about D191 was, the news were interviewing passengers who survived and could talk. One guy, strapped to a gurney said something like, "I think it was wind shear." Who that wasn't an expert in either aviation or weather prior to 1985 knew anything about wind shear? At least enough to suspect it just crashed your plane.


But again, the weather didn't damage the plane at all. Which is the entire point. This plane was brought down by structural damage that occurred at cruising altitude from my understanding. That is, literally, unheard of for commercial airliners.

You don't know that and nothing from the ATC recording says so. It is more likely it broke up in the 20K/min plunge. Frankly, the fact that both wings look intact at impact should tell you that these "little Lear Jets" are built to withstand weather turbulence...


Nobody is saying they aren't, but it's indisputable that they are more susceptible to weather stressors than larger commercial jets. That's just a fact.

You should go check out videos of the testing they put those planes through, and in particular the testing they do on the wings and tails. It's incredible how much they can withstand.
Jarrin Jay
How long do you want to ignore this user?
The vast majority of aviation accidents are due to pilot error, either bad decision making, negligence, or operating out of protocol either by fault or failure.

A large amount of caution also needs to be applied and always err on the side of extreme caution. Looking at that flight path and the weather pattern in south FL, no idea why they didn't fly well out of the way or divert and land elsewhere well out of the way, then continued on to the Bahamas.

It makes zero sense when flying to enter a weather pattern or situation where you think it will be OK, it need to be a 100000000% certainty.

This plane certainly could have experienced technical or mechanical issues, that were likely a result of the pilots doing something they should not have done.
Teslag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Infection_Ag11 said:

GAC06 said:

Quote:

A commercial airliner has never been brought down by weather based turbulence in the history of modern aviation.


No. Fly into a severe thunderstorm and any plane is in deep trouble


Commercial airliners are still designed to withstand such forces, and essentially always do in the unfortunate circumstances in which it occurs.


GAC06 was a Marine combat veteran pilot and current commercial airline pilot. You might want to defer to him on this one.
Kenneth_2003
How long do you want to ignore this user?
If any parts were separated from the plane the NTSB will find them and be able to figure out their point of separation
YokelRidesAgain
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Infection_Ag11 said:

Nobody is saying they aren't, but it's indisputable that they are more susceptible to weather stressors than larger commercial jets. That's just a fact.

It's indisputable that the Empire State Building is more resistant to being blown over by a high wind than your house. That doesn't mean that the only safe place to live is a skyscraper in New York City.
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.