Plane Crash Near Mar-a-Lago

85,146 Views | 658 Replies | Last: 6 days ago by CornAg
5Amp
How long do you want to ignore this user?
CanyonAg77 said:

Flagged your post

No one wants to read AI garbage

LMAO….it ain't going away…
BadMoonRisin
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
TexasAggie_02 said:

FYI, that has the ATC audio on it for those that don't want to hear it

Fair enough. I realize this is just a re-creation, but it's hard for me to ignore that they turn, with intention, into the rapidly upward-growing storm cell instead of just continuing on heading and avoiding the cell that caused or at least started the crash.

In the re-creation (ignore the windscreen, they didnt bother speculating on visibility, but that could make things easier to understand), it looks like they simulated what the radar said at altitude, which shows a green cell (precipitation) even at 35k feet (as they descend the radar gets more accurate, so i am assuming they would have been able to see this the further down they went). They start going down just a second or two after the SIC reports that they have encountered precipitation. They reduced the coffin corner parameters so tightly and then entered unstable air, so either up or down would have doomed them.

I dont think they will ever figure out if there were configuration problems with the aircraft since this plane did not have a FDR, but did have a CVR. Either way, you were only 20-30 minutes from destination; just fly around the precipitation? Just take that turn a few minutes later for a direct to Freeport.

The fact that she was texting her boyfriend about flight conditions while in the air seems both odd and concerning. Was she doing that when the pilot turned into the precipitation? She was attentive to ATC, so probably not, but still...begs the question, and she was known for filming and posting social media during flight operations. Im sure they will find this all out in the investigation.

There is a 1 minute gap between when they are flying fine, and vectored out of it, and then she picks up again after the plane has turned into FL350 precipitation, to respond to flight conditions. This leads me to believe that she might not have been paying full attention to what was going on; kids her age (male and female) do it all the time without even realizing. When she picks up to ATC again, they are headed straight to the precipitation event, and just a few seconds after reporting precipitation, they are doomed.

If cell phones are banned on commercial flights due to "instrumentation sensitivity" (i dont think this is the real reason, I think it's because they dont want people distracted during takeoff/landing, myself, and also dont want to deal with people having conversations on planes), surely they are banned in the cockpit?

The investigation will reveal everything, I suppose. But she seemed to be distracted. Why else would they, by choice, fly into abnormally high-altitude precipitation conditions?
zgolfz85
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
14 edits, I think that might be a record

You're making a boatload of assumptions there off of a simple text message. I agree that texting shouldn't be done up there, but I took it as more of a "hey we're going through some uncomfortable flight conditions and just sending a quick love you text here." You could be right, but quite the speculation there. She sounded pretty composed and collected until it quickly went sideways
zgolfz85
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
actually 15 edits
BadMoonRisin
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
zgolfz85 said:

actually 15 edits

The record exists elsewhere, also by me. It's part of my process, I guess.

Go look again.




Look at the nav radar. 1 minute of silence between the two.

I'll let the real pilots chime in, but it seems like a SIC would probably be telling you to avoid the green. Completely possible that I'm wrong, though, I've said it in almost every post here.

Heading 058 to a 096 turn is turning 38 degrees directly towards the storm.
TexasRebel
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Isn't this what would happen if the left elevator was gone?
BadMoonRisin
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
If the left elevator was lost at 35k feet, it would be located significantly further than 3.8 miles from the crash site, which is where they found it. The elevator was likely lost in overspeed conditions when the aircraft was between 20k-10kfeet of altitude.

Also, if it was the left side, it would result in overlift of the right side, which would not result in a right side 60 pitch angle. It seems like both elevator surfaces were not with the aircraft when it crashed, they just havent found the right side yet? Could be the right side tore off prior to the left, or potentially close to the same time. TBD.
TexasRebel
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
"Gone" as in malfunctioning. The hardware may have remained for a while.

Not creating equal and opposing drag as the right elevator across the vertical/axial plane.

Would it not also induce a roll?
BadMoonRisin
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I will leave this question to actual aviators. I dont know.

Doubtful that this was an issue with the aircraft, but again, we will never know since it does not have a FDR.
BadMoonRisin
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Are you talking about the 38 degree turn into the path of the storm? I dont think so, it looked controlled.
Jetpilot86
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Correct
5Amp
How long do you want to ignore this user?
5Amp said:


I will post the pictures



Second picture explains it all as they flew over the bad stuff but into clear ice. Pilot should have flown around the smaller cell like he did the larger.

maybe he knew he only had enough fuel to legally complete the mission so he requested direct but he knew from the reports that clear ice was in there. Light clear ice is a red flag, stay away from clear ice even wth deice equipment. Clear ice can turn an airplane into a block of ice very fast and she no fly.

Clear ice's combination of invisibility, weight, density, and tendency to form disruptive shapes is why it is widely regarded as the more dangerous common icing type for pilots.
TexasRebel
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Just waiting…
rjhtamu
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I realize this is like talking about Go-carts vs Semi Trucks, but how differently are hurricane weather planes outfitted differently to survive significantly worse conditions?
No material on this site is intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. See full Medical Disclaimer.
TexasRebel
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
First, no passenger seats.
P.H. Dexippus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Just off the top of my head, different wing profile and engine type.
aggieforester05
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I think those are four engine turbo props. Much slower speeds and likely much lower altitudes with warmer air. Probably outfitted with more robust deice systems as well. The best weather radars a plane can have. Also a hurricane is a very different beast than a severe thunderstorm.

The lear jets on the other hand are like the sport bikes of the business jet world. Fast with small wings and control surfaces.
TexasRebel
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
OKC has a retired A-10 outfitted for tornado research.
SoulSlaveAG2005
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
TexasRebel said:

OKC has a retired A-10 outfitted for tornado research.


Strafing runs to shoot the sharks out of the twister. Smart


TexasAggie_02
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Hey Nav
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Quote:

I realize this is like talking about Go-carts vs Semi Trucks, but how differently are hurricane weather planes outfitted differently to survive significantly worse conditions?

The USAFR uses the WC-130J. They have an Aerial Reconnaissance Weather Officer (ARWO) and equipment that is specialized in this mission, but as far as the wings and engines, it's like all the other C-130s out there. The NOAA has 2 WP-3D (modified P-3s, named Kermit and Miss Piggy) and NOAA also has Gonzo, a Gulfstream IV. They are in the process of getting a few new WC-130s and a few G550s (I think they already have one of those.)

I think the usual penetration altitudes are in the 5,000 to 10,000 ' range and fly at about 170 to 180 kias. They have some interesting techniques to crab into the center of the hurricanes / typhoons. When they think they are going to get into "extreme" turbulence, they get out . In Hugo (1989), a WP-3 registered close to +6 Gs and -4Gs on a mission.

The Gulfstreams usually have a different mission - they fly up around 40,000' or higher, and do tasks like dropwindsondes deployment.

The USAF did lose a WC-130 in 1974 in the South China Sea. They had completed one penetration of the typhoon,, and were never heard from again after starting their 2nd penetration.
eric76
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Jetpilot86 said:

Correct

I asked my younger brother about it and he agreed with you that radar is not required in the business aircraft that he is familiar with, but he said that he doesn't know the rules on what they can't do if the radar is not installed or is inoperable. He's strictly a GA pilot.

His familiarity is based on about 25 years of producing MELs for business aircraft for a wide variety of aviation departments. He has never done one for a Part 121 operation.

I thought radar or at least a storm scope would be one of the must have to operate. Now I know better.

Thanks.
TyHolden
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Does anybody have a synopsis of what caused the crash? Maybe we should include it in the first post?


stay low boys. keep those feet moving. go be perfect.

- chavez (fnl)
eric76
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
TyHolden said:

Does anybody have a synopsis of what caused the crash? Maybe we should include it in the first post?

That hasn't been released and won't be for quite a while.

If I were to bet on it, I would bet that it was because of icing leading to a dangerous stall leading to more damage from overspeed.
TyHolden
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
eric76 said:

TyHolden said:

Does anybody have a synopsis of what caused the crash? Maybe we should include it in the first post?

That hasn't been released and won't be for quite a while.

If I were to bet on it, I would bet that it was because of icing leading to a dangerous stall leading to more damage from overspeed.

thanks


stay low boys. keep those feet moving. go be perfect.

- chavez (fnl)
Wings007Ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
They flew dead straight into a thunderstorm not smart.
Langley
How long do you want to ignore this user?
eric76 said:

TyHolden said:

Does anybody have a synopsis of what caused the crash? Maybe we should include it in the first post?

That hasn't been released and won't be for quite a while.

If I were to bet on it, I would bet that it was because of icing leading to a dangerous stall leading to more damage from overspeed.


The pilot error of ignoring and/or choosing to fly into a storm led to the icing.
W
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
and if the cockpit voice recorder survived...

if will be interesting to hear the discussion about the storm or radar between the pilot and co-pillot

remember in the Miami crash...the co-pilot was dropping hints to the pilot that the plane was going too fast for landing
eric76
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Langley said:

eric76 said:

TyHolden said:

Does anybody have a synopsis of what caused the crash? Maybe we should include it in the first post?

That hasn't been released and won't be for quite a while.

If I were to bet on it, I would bet that it was because of icing leading to a dangerous stall leading to more damage from overspeed.


The pilot error of ignoring and/or choosing to fly into a storm led to the icing.

Exactly.

They could have flown around the tip of Florida and back up and would presumably have skipped the storm entirely (the weather map I saw didn't show as much down there) and it shouldn't have added all that much time to the flight.
BadMoonRisin
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
They could have also navigated around the comically small area of severe thunderstorm that ended up dooming their flight instead of turning to fly directly into it, and they didnt.

I agree, just go around the entire Floridian peninsula with a jet-ski class PJ instead of flying direct to Freeport when the weather was bad.
BadMoonRisin
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Langley
How long do you want to ignore this user?
BadMoonRisin said:




5 edits and counting.

Impressive
BadMoonRisin
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Langley said:

BadMoonRisin said:




5 edits and counting.

Impressive


I deleted things that would potentially draw criticism to true victims of this accident, which was never my intent.
Langley
How long do you want to ignore this user?
BadMoonRisin said:

Langley said:

BadMoonRisin said:




5 edits and counting.

Impressive


I deleted things that would potentially draw criticism to true victims of this accident, which was never my intent.


All good I just found it funny on a Friday night after a couple

eric76
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
BadMoonRisin said:

They could have also navigated around the comically small area of severe thunderstorm that ended up dooming their flight instead of turning to fly directly into it, and they didnt.

I agree, just go around the entire Floridian peninsula with a jet-ski class PJ instead of flying direct to Freeport when the weather was bad.

I think that the thunderstorms pretty much ran the length of Florida, north to south, with some gaps between the worst. The shortest way around appears to have been to round the bottom tip of Florida and then head to the destination.

I may be wrong about that, though.
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.