Plane Crash Near Mar-a-Lago

85,135 Views | 658 Replies | Last: 6 days ago by CornAg
Jarrin Jay
How long do you want to ignore this user?
A commercial airliner wouldn't fly directly into a storm cell at cruising altitude like this small Learjet did.

The Air France from Brazil that did fly into a storm that crash was 1000% pilot error and easily avoidable.
Infection_Ag11
How long do you want to ignore this user?
YokelRidesAgain said:

Infection_Ag11 said:

Nobody is saying they aren't, but it's indisputable that they are more susceptible to weather stressors than larger commercial jets. That's just a fact.

It's indisputable that the Empire State Building is more resistant to being blown over by a high wind than your house. That doesn't mean that the only safe place to live is a skyscraper in New York City.



Agreed! But if your worst fear is living in a house you're gonna have a rough life. If your greatest fear is having your plane broken up by turbulence you can just avoid the types of planes that are ever brought down by turbulence. Which was what I was responding to.
one safe place
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Ok, I have a question for you experts. Perhaps I have drawn the wrong conclusion from what I heard in the first audio that I saw posted. Others warned against not listening to another recording and I have not listened to it. But in the one I did listen to, it sounded like one of the pilots was in communication with an air traffic controller and he said to the pilot something along the lines of "let me know what you need" or something to that effect.

So, my question is if a pilot knows of imminent danger, something they feel will be catastrophic and needs to fly higher, or fly lower (say due to icing or terrible turbulence, or intense storm conditions) do they take it on themselves at some point to take the action they feel will solve the problem or are they trained to never do anything without air traffic control's instruction/permission/blessing?
Gunny456
How long do you want to ignore this user?
All aircraft manufacturers, whether it be a Piper Super Cub or a Lockheed C-5 Galaxy test their airframes for VA,VNE, VNO and other Indicated V speeds.
If flight conditions cause you to exceed them bad things happen… doesn't matter how small or big the plane is… they all have performance limitations.
TAMU Wildlife and Fisheries Sciences

Boat racing is like a beautiful woman.......expensive, high maintenance, but well worth the fun!
Esteban du Plantier
How long do you want to ignore this user?
one safe place said:

Ok, I have a question for you experts. Perhaps I have drawn the wrong conclusion from what I heard in the first audio that I saw posted. Others warned against not listening to another recording and I have not listened to it. But in the one I did listen to, it sounded like one of the pilots was in communication with an air traffic controller and he said to the pilot something along the lines of "let me know what you need" or something to that effect.

So, my question is if a pilot knows of imminent danger, something they feel will be catastrophic and needs to fly higher, or fly lower (say due to icing or terrible turbulence, or intense storm conditions) do they take it on themselves at some point to take the action they feel will solve the problem or are they trained to never do anything without air traffic control's instruction/permission/blessing?


Essentially, yes.

When a pilot declares a mayday, they have incredible latitude in what they can do. They state intentions rather than request permission. The controller then works with them to make sure everyone else is prepared and out of the way.

The pilots' priorities are to aviate, navigate, and then communicate, and in that order.
.
Kenneth_2003
How long do you want to ignore this user?
1) Aviate
2) Navigate
3) Communicate

I'm the clip you heard the pilot monitoring (on the radio) was talking to ATC. Before it's an evergreens you clear it with ATC. If you're emergency then you do it and tell them when you get a chance.

But even then with one pilot flying and one pilot monitoring, the pilot monitoring job is checklists and radios. But they're are times in emergencies when you'll hear a pilot tell ATC to "standby" or some other professional way of saying "I don't have time to talk to you right now."
one safe place
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Esteban du Plantier said:

one safe place said:

Ok, I have a question for you experts. Perhaps I have drawn the wrong conclusion from what I heard in the first audio that I saw posted. Others warned against not listening to another recording and I have not listened to it. But in the one I did listen to, it sounded like one of the pilots was in communication with an air traffic controller and he said to the pilot something along the lines of "let me know what you need" or something to that effect.

So, my question is if a pilot knows of imminent danger, something they feel will be catastrophic and needs to fly higher, or fly lower (say due to icing or terrible turbulence, or intense storm conditions) do they take it on themselves at some point to take the action they feel will solve the problem or are they trained to never do anything without air traffic control's instruction/permission/blessing?


Essentially, yes.

When a pilot declares a mayday, they have incredible latitude in what they can do. They state intentions rather than request permission. The controller then works with them to make sure everyone else is prepared and out of the way.

Makes sense. Thanks for the information.
Infection_Ag11
How long do you want to ignore this user?
one safe place said:

Ok, I have a question for you experts. Perhaps I have drawn the wrong conclusion from what I heard in the first audio that I saw posted. Others warned against not listening to another recording and I have not listened to it. But in the one I did listen to, it sounded like one of the pilots was in communication with an air traffic controller and he said to the pilot something along the lines of "let me know what you need" or something to that effect.

So, my question is if a pilot knows of imminent danger, something they feel will be catastrophic and needs to fly higher, or fly lower (say due to icing or terrible turbulence, or intense storm conditions) do they take it on themselves at some point to take the action they feel will solve the problem or are they trained to never do anything without air traffic control's instruction/permission/blessing?


My understanding is that the pilots have near full discretion in those situations and the ATC's job is to tell everyone else to get the hell out of the way. Or at least that's what I've gathered from pilot commentary every time there's a notable crash.
Infection_Ag11
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Also, that audio is horrifying. Pretty sure you can hear the other pilot saying the Lord's Prayer in the background. Yikes.
BadMoonRisin
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Ya, basically. It's do whatever you have to do to maintain airspeed and control of the aircraft and I will do my best to get everyone out of the way.

This really sucks. It happened so fast. And it didnt even seem like a plane crash so much as a missile hitting the ground. fuuuuuuuuuuq.
YokelRidesAgain
How long do you want to ignore this user?
one safe place said:

So, my question is if a pilot knows of imminent danger, something they feel will be catastrophic and needs to fly higher, or fly lower (say due to icing or terrible turbulence, or intense storm conditions) do they take it on themselves at some point to take the action they feel will solve the problem or are they trained to never do anything without air traffic control's instruction/permission/blessing?

The ATC is responsible for all the traffic in the air and the pilot's knowledge of what other aircraft are or are planning to do is much more limited. So, you act before deviating from a planned course. "It feels like it would be safer 1000 feet lower" may be true, but it sure isn't true if it puts your plane directly in the path of a Boeing 747.

The only realistic situation where an immediate change in altitude is going to make a difference in the survivability of the airframe is impending collision with another aircraft, or terrain. Commercial jets are equipped with collision avoidance warning systems and generally the expectation is you do what the system says, immediately.

In this case, the pilot was calling Mayday (immediate, life threatening emergency) and telling ATC that they have lost control of the aircraft. That gives them absolute priority for communications and any course correction that the pilot feels would be helpful. By that point they were presumably in an unsurvivable situation, so unfortunately a moot point.
Gunny456
How long do you want to ignore this user?
My flight instructor drilled into our heads one thing. The first thing you do he said in an emergency is "Fly the damn plane!"

His other similar saying was that " Bernoulli's law makes planes fly, not Marconi."

In other words fly the damn plane first and foremost and don't worry about talking on a radio. His words, not mine.
TAMU Wildlife and Fisheries Sciences

Boat racing is like a beautiful woman.......expensive, high maintenance, but well worth the fun!
Kenneth_2003
How long do you want to ignore this user?
How many today understand that Marconi reference?
Triple S
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Infection_Ag11 said:

Also, that audio is horrifying. Pretty sure you can hear the other pilot saying the Lord's Prayer in the background. Yikes.



You absolutely can hear him praying…..


God bless all of them.
Gunny456
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Probably few.
TAMU Wildlife and Fisheries Sciences

Boat racing is like a beautiful woman.......expensive, high maintenance, but well worth the fun!
YokelRidesAgain
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Infection_Ag11 said:

Agreed! But if your worst fear is living in a house you're gonna have a rough life. If your greatest fear is having your plane broken up by turbulence you can just avoid the types of planes that are ever brought down by turbulence. Which was what I was responding to.

On an hour for hour basis I assure you that you are more likely to be killed by weather related damage to your home than by weather related destruction of a private jet.

The "greater risk" of a private jet versus Delta Airlines is near entirely attributable to the qualifications of the pilot and the pressure that the clients of said private jet exert over the pilot's better judgment. (If the yokel in 1A tells the commercial captain "I demand you land in the Bahamas in the next hour!!!, and the captain doesn't feel it's safe, he says LOL no. If your best customer says the same thing and oh by the way if you don't I'm never hiring you again, the case may be altered.)
torrid
How long do you want to ignore this user?
insulator_king said:

Sounds like they were in heavy icing and entered a stall. Nothing you can do about that.
As BlancoLirio says, sometimes it is just better to not fly in those conditions. Wait a day & try again.

It happened so fast I figured some sort of mechanical failure, but I'm certainly no pilot.
Triple S
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Question about the audio….

Is it cut? Or is that continuous? It just seemed very fast from ATC clearing her to go to 37000 to her declaring an emergency. It is hard to tell …. But that would indicate a catastrophic event at that moment if the audio is continuous. I thought it was going to be ice….. but wonder if it was horizontal stabilizer damage due to the turbulence….. then it gave way when they tried to climb…..


Just curious how this timeline plays out.


I just feel like we are going to find out that icing and turbulence damaged the stabilizer and it broke off…. Started the spiral of loss of control……. So sad.

God bless them.
Rockdoc
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Kenneth_2003 said:

How many today understand that Marconi reference?

Gunny is aging himself, and I am aging myself because I got it.
mts6175
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Triple S said:

Question about the audio….

Is it cut? Or is that continuous? It just seemed very fast from ATC clearing her to go to 37000 to her declaring an emergency. It is hard to tell …. But that would indicate a catastrophic event at that moment if the audio is continuous. I thought it was going to be ice….. but wonder if it was horizontal stabilizer damage due to the turbulence….. then it gave way when they tried to climb…..


Just curious how this timeline plays out.


God bless them.

Factor in that jet's cruising speed is about 500 mph, depending at 22,000 feet per minute they were probably approaching 650-700 mph uncontrolled, a decent from 37,000 feet would take just over a minute/1.5 minutes. Pilots on here can correct my math, just a guess.
Infection_Ag11
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Absolutely, but again you have to live somewhere. You don't ever have to fly in a pack of gum with 15 people in it if you don't want to.

Personally I have zero fear of flying because it's statistically an absurd thing to be afraid of. I'm far less stressed in a plane than when I'm driving on the interstate. I was responding to someone who said this was their worst fear.
BadMoonRisin
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Triple S said:

Question about the audio….

Is it cut? Or is that continuous? It just seemed very fast from ATC clearing her to go to 37000 to her declaring an emergency. It is hard to tell …. But that would indicate a catastrophic event at that moment if the audio is continuous. I thought it was going to be ice….. but wonder if it was horizontal stabilizer damage due to the turbulence….. then it gave way when they tried to climb…..


Just curious how this timeline plays out.


I just feel like we are going to find out that icing and turbulence damaged the stabilizer and it broke off…. Started the spiral of loss of control……. So sad.

God bless them.

If you look at the flight profile that Sid Farkas posted on the first or second page, there was a 18k descent in about 1 minute, so they were basically heading straight towards the ground.
Infection_Ag11
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Triple S said:

Question about the audio….

Is it cut? Or is that continuous? It just seemed very fast from ATC clearing her to go to 37000 to her declaring an emergency. It is hard to tell …. But that would indicate a catastrophic event at that moment if the audio is continuous. I thought it was going to be ice….. but wonder if it was horizontal stabilizer damage due to the turbulence….. then it gave way when they tried to climb…..


Just curious how this timeline plays out.


I just feel like we are going to find out that icing and turbulence damaged the stabilizer and it broke off…. Started the spiral of loss of control……. So sad.

God bless them.


IIRC the estimates are that they hit the ground at around 600 MPH, so for much of that descent they'd have been going down at over 300-500 feet per second or so and by the time of impact were at around 900 feet per second.
Fightin_Aggie
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Based on the flight log it looks like it was a charter plane. So who its registered to might not be any relation to the passengers


The world needs mean tweets

My Pronouns Ultra and MAGA

Trump 2024
GAC06
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Infection_Ag11 said:

GAC06 said:

Quote:

A commercial airliner has never been brought down by weather based turbulence in the history of modern aviation.


No. Fly into a severe thunderstorm and any plane is in deep trouble


Commercial airliners are still designed to withstand such forces, and essentially always do in the unfortunate circumstances in which it occurs.


Here's two from the same airline

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Braniff_International_Airways_Flight_250

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Braniff_International_Airways_Flight_352

Yes, they both happened in the 60's. No, they aren't making planes magically stronger now so that they're impervious to severe/extreme turbulence and other hazards of powerful thunderstorms. The Electra in the second mishap is the plane they based the P-3 off of. Same P-3 they use as "hurricane hunters" because it was so robust.

What changed is that we know that flying into a severe thunderstorm will kill you, and we have weather radar good enough that it shouldn't ever happen. Airlines mandate deviating around severe storms by 20 miles or more depending on the conditions.
mts6175
How long do you want to ignore this user?
This came up on my FB. Not sure if embed will work.

<iframe src="https://www.facebook.com/plugins/post.php?href=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.facebook.com%2Fmatthew.cappucci%2Fposts%2Fpfbid022P3HqvMCW2QGQDKyo8JQMmV6XPfGxJeRNmzftoLQtz2jooBpexCBfNdTnspqxPnCl&show_text=true&width=500" width="500" height="533" style="border:none;overflow:hidden" scrolling="no" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen="true" allow="autoplay; clipboard-write; encrypted-media; picture-in-picture; web-share"></iframe>

Quote:

We're saddened to hear about the tragedy involving a Learjet 60 near West Palm Beach, Florida on Sunday evening, November 1. Weather was likely a contributing factor; while the NTSB has a long investigation ahead, here's what the meteorological and flight tracking data tell us:

At 12:47-48 p.m. ET, the aircraft passed over Royal Palm Beach/Loxahatchee Groves/Westlake, Florida, about 8 miles west of Palm Beach.
A developing thunderstorm was present at that location slowly drifting northwest
Pilots were given permission from Miami Center Air Traffic Control to "deviate left and right" due to "moderate precipitation... to the southeast."
ATC described the weather as "pretty nasty" as the aircraft was crossing the Florida Peninsula
At 12:36 p.m., that thunderstorm was just under 33,000 feet tall. By 12:56 p.m., it was 48,300 feet tall. That's an increase of more than 15,000 feet in 20 minutes, signifying VERY intense updrafts
At 12:37 p.m., the captain said "[we] may need a slight left deviation for that weather up ahead". Deviations were approved by Air Traffic Control. The aircraft was still about 8 minutes, and 80 miles, away from the thunderstorm cell it would later enter
The rapid vertical development of the thunderstorm was likely accompanied by extreme turbulence
Temperatures at the aircraft's altitude were probably around minus-45 degrees Fahrenheit OUTSIDE the storm. Ordinarily, that would be too cold to support robust icing. (Clear glaze is most prevalent between 14 and 32 degrees, with mixing of clear/rime ice at colder temperatures. Rime ice is a danger below 0 Fahrenheit, but once you get to colder temperatures, there aren't many supercooled water droplets left. HOWEVER, a rapidly-growing thunderstorm cloud can lift warmer temperatures, and more liquid water content, vertically upward. That can lead to extremely rapid icing in environments at altitudes where it otherwise would be a lesser concern.
Within the cloud, it's probable that severe turbulence was present
At 12:47 p.m., the first officer said "we have light clear ice that is manageable and moderate turbulence." The aircraft was entering the convective cell.
At 12:48 p.m., the first officer asked to climb to 37,000 feet from 35,000 feet, noting an increase in precipitation
The mayday call came approximately 20 seconds later
Icing can occur extremely quickly, leading to rapid changes in the aerodynamic behavior of the aircraft. In severe icing situations, entire loss of maneuverability can occur.
The NTSB will be tasked with determining the cause and contributing factors. It's likely that entering the rapidly-growing convective cloud played a role. The NTSB will investigate whether icing was a factor.
There are multiple accounts on social media, as well as compelling video footage, that appears to show the ill-fated aircraft missing its horizontal stabilizer moments before impact. It's impossible to confirm if that was the case, but it's reasonable to infer that extreme force may have caused substantial, or crippling, damage to the airframe. It's unclear if damage occurred in the convective cloud or during the dive and it's unknown if any damage was a cause, or result, of said dive.

fullback44
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I read somewhere else that this was a charter jet, so maybe not super wealthy just people with some money chartering a flight.
Texas12&0
How long do you want to ignore this user?
White Privilege - The ability to suffer whatever life throws at you without blaming another ethnic group.
deddog
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Kenneth_2003 said:

How many today understand that Marconi reference?

This is Texags.

We know stuff.
Duckhook
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Infection_Ag11 said:



A commercial airliner has never been brought down by weather based turbulence in the history of modern aviation.

Rarely, but not never. 1968 in Texas.

Braniff International Airways Flight 352 - Wikipedia https://share.google/Q0jljsndJQstaYLx1

Edit: GAC posted this one just ahead of me. Missed it.
CharlieBrown17
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Triple S said:

Question about the audio….

Is it cut? Or is that continuous? It just seemed very fast from ATC clearing her to go to 37000 to her declaring an emergency. It is hard to tell …. But that would indicate a catastrophic event at that moment if the audio is continuous. I thought it was going to be ice….. but wonder if it was horizontal stabilizer damage due to the turbulence….. then it gave way when they tried to climb…..


Just curious how this timeline plays out.


I just feel like we are going to find out that icing and turbulence damaged the stabilizer and it broke off…. Started the spiral of loss of control……. So sad.

God bless them.


It did happen fast, but there's also probably some dead space clipped out of the recording. Websites recording transmissions 24/7 is a lot less storage than 24/7 of mostly silence.
rackmonster
How long do you want to ignore this user?
CharlieBrown17 said:

RebelE91 said:

Why would the pilots have entered a storm like that? Wouldn't it be normal to ask ATC to be routed around the storm?


Embedded storms don't usually show well on airborne radar.

It's called Radar Attenuation, and something that good radar skill can recognize. A storm in front of you can be so loaded with water, that it absorbs all the radar energy and return. So you get lulled into thinking " this is just a small storm, we'll be in the clear in a minute or two". With attenuation, you have no idea what is behind that storm. What you do is turn the radar tilt down, to see if the return is casting a "shadow". If it is, then you have no idea what is behind that storm. it could be clear, or more likely, even a bigger storm.
Total Avoidance. One day, I was crossing the North Atlantic westbound. There was a huge line of weather just in front of me and towards the right. I requested a deviation to the left. Gander wouldn't give it to me. They wanted me to deviate right towards all the nasty stuff. I refused. I told them I needed a deviation to the left, and if i didn't get it, I was going to utilize my Captain's Emergency Authority and do what I had to do, not what they wanted me to do.
My butt is in the aircraft...not in a building in Newfoundland.
Just before I acted on my own, Gander cleared me to the South.
nortex97
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I think that is what happened also with that AF A330 crash over the atlantic years ago. They (well, the co-pilot, the pilot had gone back to take a nap) thought the storm was small as it was masked by a small one in front when they flew into it.
rackmonster
How long do you want to ignore this user?
one safe place said:

Ok, I have a question for you experts. Perhaps I have drawn the wrong conclusion from what I heard in the first audio that I saw posted. Others warned against not listening to another recording and I have not listened to it. But in the one I did listen to, it sounded like one of the pilots was in communication with an air traffic controller and he said to the pilot something along the lines of "let me know what you need" or something to that effect.

So, my question is if a pilot knows of imminent danger, something they feel will be catastrophic and needs to fly higher, or fly lower (say due to icing or terrible turbulence, or intense storm conditions) do they take it on themselves at some point to take the action they feel will solve the problem or are they trained to never do anything without air traffic control's instruction/permission/blessing?

You try as best you can to comply with ATC instructions. and plenty of time they'll tell you " do whatever you need". But if you are in a situation where IN YOUR BEST JUDGEMENT, you can't comply, then declare Captain Emergency Authority and do what you have to do. Okay. You'll get a call on the ground from ATC...them wanting to know your reasoning for non-compliance. You'll have to fill out some paperwork for the FAA explaining the situation. I'd much rather do that then to fly into something nasty. I'd rather use my brain, plan ahead, and use good judgement so I can avoid demonstrating my superior flying skills in a thunderstorm.
ts5641
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Horn_in_Aggieland said:

Not sure if this is real but sounds scary as hell.



Good lord that is horrifying!
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.