AggieFlyboy said:
A few things I'll comment on after catching up:
- For safety reasons (ie traffic avoidance), we will request a weather deviation from ATC first. If denied (and it is absolutely necessary in my judgment) or there is no time, we will inform ATC that we are deviating for weather. It's then their job to get people out of our way.
- Severe icing is probably the most dangerous thing we can encounter. We take steps to avoid it and/or get out of it quickly. Icing changes the aerodynamics of the wing and can lead to a stall, erroneous instrument indications, engine flameouts and frozen control surfaces. Icing doesn't care about the size of the airplane.
- light and moderate turbulence is an annoyance. Severe turbulence can cause minor structural damage. What happened here was likely a combination of icing and severe turbulence. From flying through the core of a severe thunderstorm.
- weather radar has limitations (especially what ATC has on the ground). The radar in the airplane can lie to you. A high quality Doppler feed from an internet source can be delayed up to 15 minutes. At night, your eyeballs have a hard time judging distance of light sources (your brain says that brighter is closer)
Sometimes the perfect storm happens and all of the holes in the Swiss cheese line up (google swiss cheese model of risk management). I suspect that this was the case in this crash. While it was completely avoidable, that point may have occurred 30 minutes before the crash
Question for you...
Is it possible that the storm core they entered could have blown up in front of or around them?
The graphic I pulled from a storm chasing social media page used radar imagery from Miami, 75 miles away, and bracketed +/- 2 minutes for the crash.
Either way, flying into that storm core.... They would have entered significant updrafts. Those updrafts would have a lot of rapidly cooling warm humid air with plenty of moisture condensing to water and then to ice. That would be wet and sticky and primed to rapidly accumulate on the very cold airplane that had been in the extreme cold.
Pilots... You don't typically fly around with anti-ice systems engaged correct? The bleed air used reduces engine efficiency and as I understand you can also overheat some surfaces if it's left on too long without water to pull the heat away? Pretty sure I've heard about that on engine cowl heat.... So from the time you turn on anti-ice systems how long would it take to warm up a wing surface? These are typically only used at lower altitude? At cruse you'd be better served to divert and avoid? Can they put enough heat into a surface to melt ice at cruise altitudes?