Plane Crash Near Mar-a-Lago

85,138 Views | 658 Replies | Last: 6 days ago by CornAg
ts5641
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Charpie said:

Longer audio from beginning until crash.



It went from what sounded like normal storm turbulence to mayday in just a few seconds.
AggieFlyboy
How long do you want to ignore this user?
A few things I'll comment on after catching up:
- For safety reasons (ie traffic avoidance), we will request a weather deviation from ATC first. If denied (and it is absolutely necessary in my judgment) or there is no time, we will inform ATC that we are deviating for weather. It's then their job to get people out of our way.
- Severe icing is probably the most dangerous thing we can encounter. We take steps to avoid it and/or get out of it quickly. Icing changes the aerodynamics of the wing and can lead to a stall, erroneous instrument indications, engine flameouts and frozen control surfaces. Icing doesn't care about the size of the airplane.
- light and moderate turbulence is an annoyance. Severe turbulence can cause minor structural damage. What happened here was likely a combination of icing and severe turbulence. From flying through the core of a severe thunderstorm.
- weather radar has limitations (especially what ATC has on the ground). The radar in the airplane can lie to you. A high quality Doppler feed from an internet source can be delayed up to 15 minutes. At night, your eyeballs have a hard time judging distance of light sources (your brain says that brighter is closer)

Sometimes the perfect storm happens and all of the holes in the Swiss cheese line up (google swiss cheese model of risk management). I suspect that this was the case in this crash. While it was completely avoidable, that point may have occurred 30 minutes before the crash
New World Ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
The amount of people on social media wondering why there are no plane parts visible in the crater is ridiculous. Likely the same 9/11 troofers who ask the same thing about the UA93 crash site.
lb3
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I'm not fully caught up on this story but is it a safe assumption that the voice on the ATC audio wasn't the pilot in command?

I don't see how the pilot would have time to communicate anything.

Aviate - Navigate - Communicate
torrid
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Based on what you are saying, the pilots may have potentially lost control of the plane due to turbulence and icing. But the root cause was pilot error in flying through the storm.
TexasAggie_02
How long do you want to ignore this user?


If this post is correct, there were young, inexperienced pilots on that plane. Such a horrible situation.
UTExan
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AggieFlyboy said:

A few things I'll comment on after catching up:
- For safety reasons (ie traffic avoidance), we will request a weather deviation from ATC first. If denied (and it is absolutely necessary in my judgment) or there is no time, we will inform ATC that we are deviating for weather. It's then their job to get people out of our way.
- Severe icing is probably the most dangerous thing we can encounter. We take steps to avoid it and/or get out of it quickly. Icing changes the aerodynamics of the wing and can lead to a stall, erroneous instrument indications, engine flameouts and frozen control surfaces. Icing doesn't care about the size of the airplane.
- light and moderate turbulence is an annoyance. Severe turbulence can cause minor structural damage. What happened here was likely a combination of icing and severe turbulence. From flying through the core of a severe thunderstorm.
- weather radar has limitations (especially what ATC has on the ground). The radar in the airplane can lie to you. A high quality Doppler feed from an internet source can be delayed up to 15 minutes. At night, your eyeballs have a hard time judging distance of light sources (your brain says that brighter is closer)

Sometimes the perfect storm happens and all of the holes in the Swiss cheese line up (google swiss cheese model of risk management). I suspect that this was the case in this crash. While it was completely avoidable, that point may have occurred 30 minutes before the crash

Great points. I am not a pilot but wonder if airspace management around Mar a Lago and the weather combined to prevent diversion and landing at a nearby airport (plus landing fees/FBO costs adding to trip expense) all played into this? i.e. the plane had to follow a designated route which led into the path of the weather?
This may be a classic example of how AI might have made the decision to divert the aircraft during ongoing analysis of all variable in play ahead of time.
“If you’re going to have crime it should at least be organized crime”
-Havelock Vetinari
Gunny456
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I remember reading a book that I think was called "The Anatomy of a Crash". My flight instructor gave us a number of books to read like it.
Basically the book covered many crash causes and the main point was that plane crashes are usually caused by the culmination of many events that lead up to the eventual crash. ( Hence the title "Anatomy of a Crash") Events that may start as much as a day or so ahead of the crash.
TAMU Wildlife and Fisheries Sciences

Boat racing is like a beautiful woman.......expensive, high maintenance, but well worth the fun!
GAC06
How long do you want to ignore this user?
If that post is correct, there was A young inexperienced pilot on board. The other pilots background will come out eventually.
VegasAg86
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Kenneth_2003 said:

https://www.facebook.com/share/p/198kqVucPW/



FB post, if someone on X can go get the Tweet I'd appreciate it.
Weather chaser page indicates they flew into the core of this storm. It makes me wonder if perhaps the storm blew up as they were heading into it or otherwise intensified around them. I know pilots get reports during takeoffs and especially landings as planes ahead of them report real time conditions and intensities.

I know some of the weather info was discussed back on Pg 2, but i hadn't seen this graphic

Red, you're dead.
Aggie95
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Fightin_Aggie said:

Based on the flight log it looks like it was a charter plane. So who its registered to might not be any relation to the passengers





That's quite a bit of recent activity. Looks like a Netjet or other fractional ownership type situation.
IslanderAg04
How long do you want to ignore this user?
TexasAggie_02 said:



If this post is correct, there were young, inexperienced pilots on that plane. Such a horrible situation.


Not just her but apparently J which is what she screams out , is her partner who was the other individual in the cockpit. Who the eff just throws an extremely young crew into the cockpit of a leerjet with actual passengers. What is she like 19?
CanyonAg77
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Quote:

Who the eff just throws an extremely young crew into the cockpit of a leerjet with actual passengers.

U.S. Air Force?

Army helicopter pilots are probably younger, I don't think they require a college degree to fly choppers.
Kenneth_2003
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AggieFlyboy said:

A few things I'll comment on after catching up:
- For safety reasons (ie traffic avoidance), we will request a weather deviation from ATC first. If denied (and it is absolutely necessary in my judgment) or there is no time, we will inform ATC that we are deviating for weather. It's then their job to get people out of our way.
- Severe icing is probably the most dangerous thing we can encounter. We take steps to avoid it and/or get out of it quickly. Icing changes the aerodynamics of the wing and can lead to a stall, erroneous instrument indications, engine flameouts and frozen control surfaces. Icing doesn't care about the size of the airplane.
- light and moderate turbulence is an annoyance. Severe turbulence can cause minor structural damage. What happened here was likely a combination of icing and severe turbulence. From flying through the core of a severe thunderstorm.
- weather radar has limitations (especially what ATC has on the ground). The radar in the airplane can lie to you. A high quality Doppler feed from an internet source can be delayed up to 15 minutes. At night, your eyeballs have a hard time judging distance of light sources (your brain says that brighter is closer)

Sometimes the perfect storm happens and all of the holes in the Swiss cheese line up (google swiss cheese model of risk management). I suspect that this was the case in this crash. While it was completely avoidable, that point may have occurred 30 minutes before the crash

Question for you...
Is it possible that the storm core they entered could have blown up in front of or around them?
The graphic I pulled from a storm chasing social media page used radar imagery from Miami, 75 miles away, and bracketed +/- 2 minutes for the crash.

Either way, flying into that storm core.... They would have entered significant updrafts. Those updrafts would have a lot of rapidly cooling warm humid air with plenty of moisture condensing to water and then to ice. That would be wet and sticky and primed to rapidly accumulate on the very cold airplane that had been in the extreme cold.

Pilots... You don't typically fly around with anti-ice systems engaged correct? The bleed air used reduces engine efficiency and as I understand you can also overheat some surfaces if it's left on too long without water to pull the heat away? Pretty sure I've heard about that on engine cowl heat.... So from the time you turn on anti-ice systems how long would it take to warm up a wing surface? These are typically only used at lower altitude? At cruse you'd be better served to divert and avoid? Can they put enough heat into a surface to melt ice at cruise altitudes?
CanyonAg77
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Quote:

Great points. I am not a pilot but wonder if airspace management around Mar a Lago

Unlikely. Trump wasn't there, and most airspace limitations like that don't reach up to 30,000 feet
nortex97
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Corporate jet charters are often some of the more dangerous ones in the aviation world, maintenance, crew, nothing is as 'consistent' as at majors etc. I am curious if they wind up finding any of the horizontal stabilizer. I imagine if in fact it ripped off it could have been lifted in the updrafts etc. to be many miles away/at sea when it came down.
Logos Stick
How long do you want to ignore this user?
This assessment claims overspeed/Mach tuck was the most likely cause, not the loss of the horizontal stabilizer...

Quote:

"The most likely cause, based on the available tracking data, ATC audio, weather context, and the physics of the final trajectory, is this:

The Learjet 60 penetrated the core of a strong convective cell (tops reported near 47,000 ft while the aircraft was around 35,000 ft). Inside the cell it encountered a rapid updraft-to-downdraft transition that drove the nose down. The aircraft then accelerated past its Mach limits, entered Mach tuck (the aerodynamic nose-down force that becomes strong once a Learjet is overspeed at high altitude), and developed a steep spiral. Descent rates exceeded 30,000 ft/min and the final attitude was near-vertical. Recovery was not possible once that sequence was established.

Ice was reported by the crew and may have added workload or minor performance degradation, but at approximately 47 C classic structural icing is improbable and is not required to explain the observed behavior. Claims of an isolated negative-G pushover specifically shearing the horizontal stabilizer are aerodynamically possible in severe turbulence but remain secondary and unconfirmed; the dominant, data-supported chain is cell penetration upset overspeed/Mach tuck unrecoverable dive.

The critical decision was the failure to deviate around a cell that was visible on radar and associated with ground stops at FLL. Once inside the core, the margin for recovery disappeared within roughly 30 seconds."

CanyonAg77
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Quote:

If this post is correct, there were young, inexperienced pilots

Minimum for commercial license is 250 hours. Your airline pilot might have as few as 1000 hours, though 1500 is more common
fc2112
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Pilots - it was alluded to above, but please confirm this:

1. You see really bad stuff and ask ATC to divert.
2. If it happens too fast or STC doesn't get back soon enough, you TELL ATC how you're diverting and do so.

Obviously, 2 entails risk and later criticism, but it's ultimately your call.
P.H. Dexippus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Confirmed

https://nypost.com/2026/11/02/us-news/nathalia-gadelha-identified-as-learjet-co-pilot-in-florida-crash/



Quote:

The doomed Learjet co-pilot heard pleading for help in harrowing air traffic control audio before the fiery Florida crash has been identified as Nathalia Gadelha a 20-year-old who got her pilot license while still in high school.

Gadelha's mother, Camila, and her stepfather confirmed to The Post that she was the co-pilot flying a Learjet 60 from Austin, Texas, to the Bahamas when it entered a steep nosedive plummeting at over 20,000 feet per minute and smashed into the ground in Palm Beach County on Sunday afternoon.

The young aviator, who grew up in Palm Beach County, was previously featured in local media when she got her private pilot's license at just 17 back in October 2023 before she even had her driver's license.


IslanderAg04
How long do you want to ignore this user?
CanyonAg77 said:

Quote:

Who the eff just throws an extremely young crew into the cockpit of a leerjet with actual passengers.

U.S. Air Force?

Army helicopter pilots are probably younger, I don't think they require a college degree to fly choppers.


Airforce, navy, marine core, and CS require a degree to go to go into ots/ocs. You must be an officer to be admitted to flight school.
fc2112
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Beginner pilots are usually around 23. They don't get ina jet for a while either.
GAC06
How long do you want to ignore this user?
fc2112 said:

Beginner pilots are usually around 23. They don't get ina jet for a while either.


Minimum age for an unrestricted ATP is 23. "Beginner" pilots can be younger and it's not uncommon for them to be in jets, just not airlines.
fullback44
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Well the "charter jet" business just lost a lot of money. People who charter jets will now see the inherent problems these charter companies are operating with and instead opt to use commercial. There are many very wealthy people that won't touch charters now I would bet. Just my 2 cents guess
Rapier108
How long do you want to ignore this user?
fullback44 said:

Well the "charter jet" business just lost a lot of money. People who charter jets will now see the inherent problems these charter companies are operating with and instead opt to use commercial. There are many very wealthy people that won't touch charters now I would bet. Just my 2 cents guess

Many will just buy their own aircraft and hire their own pilots.

At the very least, you'll have the high $$$ passengers demand to be able to select their flight crews.
"If you will not fight for right when you can easily win without blood shed; if you will not fight when your victory is sure and not too costly; you may come to the moment when you will have to fight with all the odds against you and only a precarious chance of survival. There may even be a worse case. You may have to fight when there is no hope of victory, because it is better to perish than to live as slaves." - Sir Winston Churchill
Queso1
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Texags: where no matter the subject, you can find experts.
insulator_king
How long do you want to ignore this user?
When an aircraft stalls, especially in icing conditions and extreme turbulence, it can be nearly instantaneous.
fc2112
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Forgive me - beginner military pilots.
bobbranco
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Sid Farkas said:

News stations are actually playing cockpit audio without viewer warnings

Can not fathom the passenger's fear and anguish in their last moments.
HollywoodBQ
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Quote:

The School District of Palm Beach County's Aviation Academy paid for her pilot's license after introducing the program that year, in 2023.

"I like being different than everyone, so to me I think it's cool that like it's not really an opportunity," Gadelha said.

"I just didn't do it, and this is how it ended up. But I think it's cool. Some people think that it's weird that I can fly planes, but I can't drive a car, I mean I can but, a lot of people think it's funny. I think it's funny, and I now want my [driver's] license really bad," she added.

Wow. Still waiting for more details but... if you're boarding a PJ and one of the pilots is 20... I'd think twice.
fullback44
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Rapier108 said:

fullback44 said:

Well the "charter jet" business just lost a lot of money. People who charter jets will now see the inherent problems these charter companies are operating with and instead opt to use commercial. There are many very wealthy people that won't touch charters now I would bet. Just my 2 cents guess

Many will just buy their own aircraft and hire their own pilots.

At the very least, you'll have the high $$$ passengers demand to be able to select their flight crews.

I have some friends that are not super wealthy that pool their money to take charters because they think "it's cool" and "look at us- we have a private charter".. that's the crowd I'm talking about, not the super wealthy that can afford their own jet. That "I'm cool" charter crowd will shrink I would think. Just my 2 cents. I'm gonna call an Aggie friend that does these "charter jets" from time to time and ask him his thoughts.

Let me add I think my friends are part of some type of "fractional sharing" type of plan where they can get on these charter jets. Hell he will text me and say " we can get a charter this Friday for X price to go here if some of you want to go".. I've always turned the offers down because I was Leary of these type services.
Rapier108
How long do you want to ignore this user?
fullback44 said:

Rapier108 said:

fullback44 said:

Well the "charter jet" business just lost a lot of money. People who charter jets will now see the inherent problems these charter companies are operating with and instead opt to use commercial. There are many very wealthy people that won't touch charters now I would bet. Just my 2 cents guess

Many will just buy their own aircraft and hire their own pilots.

At the very least, you'll have the high $$$ passengers demand to be able to select their flight crews.

I have some friends that are not super wealthy that pool their money to take charters because they think "it's cool" and "look at us- we have a private charter".. that's the crowd I'm talking about, not the super wealthy that can afford their own jet. That "I'm cool" charter crowd will shrink I would think. Just my 2 cents. I'm gonna call an Aggie friend that does these "charter jets" from time to time and ask him his thoughts.

Yep, there I agree. At the very least, they'll demand to select their pilots ahead of time, although until we know who the other pilot was (as he or she was the pilot flying), no way to say her being young and still new had anything to do with it.
"If you will not fight for right when you can easily win without blood shed; if you will not fight when your victory is sure and not too costly; you may come to the moment when you will have to fight with all the odds against you and only a precarious chance of survival. There may even be a worse case. You may have to fight when there is no hope of victory, because it is better to perish than to live as slaves." - Sir Winston Churchill
CanyonAg77
How long do you want to ignore this user?
IslanderAg04 said:

CanyonAg77 said:

Quote:

Who the eff just throws an extremely young crew into the cockpit of a leerjet with actual passengers.

U.S. Air Force?

Army helicopter pilots are probably younger, I don't think they require a college degree to fly choppers.


Airforce, navy, marine core, and CS require a degree to go to go into ots/ocs. You must be an officer to be admitted to flight school.

To some of us, 21 is pretty young,

And I am aware of the requirements, which is why I mentioned Army warrant officers who are younger
bobbranco
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Kenneth_2003 said:

How many today understand that Marconi reference?

Me.
fc2112
How long do you want to ignore this user?
The private jet companies have really been hustling the occasional business jet flyer - only pay a little more than first class to fly to The Bahamas and avoid TSA, be like rich people, etc.

I've also seen deals of leasing your private jet to these companies as a great way to offset your ownership costs.

As was said above, sounds like all the holes lined up and she didn't have the experience to get out of it before she hit that point in the sky.
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.