Plane Crash Near Mar-a-Lago

85,181 Views | 658 Replies | Last: 6 days ago by CornAg
inconvenient truth
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Queso1 said:

Texags: where no matter the subject, you can find experts.


I too have flown in a plane. Even in bad weather. Really makes you think.
W
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
aggieforester05 said:

The girl did an excellent job of communicating with ATC and ultimately the PIC is responsible for flying into that storm cell. I do wonder though if she was the one operating the weather radar and had some incorrect settings. They could have been fixated on the larger storm to the north and never saw the cell they turned into that killed them. Especially if an inexperienced pilot was operating a weather radar that wasn't part of her flight training up until she started flying jets. Unless there's clues in the audio, we'll probably never know.

it's small consolation...

but her accurate play-by-play of the final 2 minutes should provide benefit or value to the aerospace community

meteorology and R&D as well
TX04Aggie
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
If I was in a private jet and money was no option, I would take the scenic route and flown outside and around all the convective boxes that were stamped over Florida that day, especially coming from Texas, they could have altered the flight path from the outset and avoided it all.
infinity ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Teslag said:

How are these business jet pilots usually employed? Full time? Scheduled? On call? Independent contractors?


I hope they don't get the bright idea of outsourcing to foreign "talent" because they are half the cost while lowering the threshold bar..
But then, I know that is where we are heading everywhere.
Featured Video Previews
5Amp
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Twenty year old was responsible for communicating with tower/center and if she didn't ask for a weather update before pilot turned direct to destination, that is on her. Pilot busy flying the plane.

Tower/center primary job is to keep separation on planes that are flying on a clearance but they do give weather updates with very good radar service.



Not speaking as a professional pilot but that is my opinion.

Krazykat
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
infinity ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
So turns out that the pilot was 55 year old Jeff Gregory and the girl was his copilot.
If a 55 year old could not navigate the plane I don't think anyone could have done anything. How very sad.
zgolfz85
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I think there's way too many people thinking this older pilot just stubbornly chose this insane route based on arrogance, etc. Everything I've seen about this PIC is that he was a good Christian family man and experienced pilot. If I had to guess, I think it's a case of underestimating these storm systems and thinking they could find a way through, albeit it a bumpy one, only to find out that they were closed in with insanely quickly developing systems running into each other and by the time they realized what they were up against, it was far too late. Maybe the attenuation aspect had something to do with it as well.

In listening to the ATC warning about the weather ahead of them, there was no mention of anything overly severe, but it was enough for the pilot to deviate to FIMED. I'm sure in his heart of hearts, he'd have never anticipated an insane convection cell quickly rising from 30k feet to 40k plus feet. I'm sure he's been there, done that, and just figured it was another stormy south Florida day that would make for an annoying ride that had to be managed and taken seriously, but probably not a freakish and fatal one. If he were still here, I'm sure he'd agree to a lesson learned and not to underestimate any storm again, but...
zgolfz85
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I don't have X, but saw on IG that this pilot put up a good read on the Lear Jet 60 specifically...in case anyone can link it? Basically saying of all the planes he's flown, this model is easily the most sensitive and easily the most dangerous to try and fly through or over a storm.

https://x.com/HangryDBowman
P.H. Dexippus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Jarrin Jay said:


From the second it went nose- down it was not recoverable and it happened too quickly to do anything about it.

I do not know how anyone can state this as fact, at least at this point. There's a reason UPRT exists. I would not be surprised if we were to learn at some point that the steep, spiraling descent was made worse by the pilot pulling back on the controls while the plane was heavily banked.
Logos Stick
How long do you want to ignore this user?
zgolfz85 said:

I don't have X, but saw on IG that this pilot put up a good read on the Lear Jet 60 specifically...in case anyone can link it? Basically saying of all the planes he's flown, this model is easily the most sensitive and easily the most dangerous to try and fly through or over a storm.

https://x.com/HangryDBowman


Its not him, its his buddy who has flown them and said this:

Quote:

Long post worth the read. I have a close friend who flies private jets. He flew Lear 60 for over 15 years and now flies a Gulfstream. This is a copy and paste of his response to me asking him if I thought Ice was the issue.

"We always fly in ridiculous cold temperatures."

"Usually you get the bad ice when the temperatures are like 0 to negative 20. Believe it or not, there's a point where it gets too cold for ice. At negative 40, you pretty much can't get ice. Besides that, the airplane is equipped with hot wings and hot tail."

"I flew the Lear 60 for like 15 years. It's a no joke airplane and probably the most dangerous airplane I've ever flown. It has a super critical wing. The airflow has to be perfect. When it gets into rough air and turbulence, it will easily stall. It has stalled on me at 41,000 feet just because we got into some turbulence. (On the way to Palm Beach as a matter of fact. ) we recovered and got her flying again around 30,000 ft. Scary

But here's the problem. This airplane has a terrible coffin corner. (At high altitudes) what that means is, you fly in a really narrow window where if you lose 20 knots, it stalls. And if you gain 20 knots, it goes into overspeed. The air goes supersonic over the wing and it goes into a high speed stall, or worse, a Mach tuck.

So if you stall, the normal recovery is to push the yoke forward to lower the nose and gain air speed again. At low altitude, you can push really hard and recover quickly. But in the 60... if you push hard, it will gain air speed and go into a high speed stall, it doesn't take much. It's very sensitive. The 60 has super short wings that don't make much lift. So then you high speed stall, and the computer is yelling at you... OVERSPEED! So then you pull back and enter a low speed stall. And you go back and forth trying to keep it in the air speed window.

This whole thing is pretty scary. And you should recover basically by using your finger tips using super small corrections. You can't over do it. If you try to muscle the recovery, she gets mad and will become unrecoverable. If she enters a mach tuck. You're done."

"I taught the Lear 60 to other pilots and mentored them. I told them... this airplane has a soul and it's trying to kill you. Do not ever try to top the weather. Don't go over a thunderstorm. Go around it. If it means a half hour longer, then do it. Going over the thunderstorm will go into turbulence that you might not recover from.

These pilots went right over a thunderstorm. I think it stalled which caused them to drop down into the thunderstorm and ended up in mach tuck. They picked up so much speed that it ripped off the horizontal stabilizer. At that point... chuck Yeager can't fix it.

These same pilots did something similar a couple months ago. ATC got mad at them. They poked the bear one too many times.

This is not a beginner airplane. The Gulfstream would never do this. It has HUGE margins of error and won't stall like that. But then again... it's got HUGE wings. It's a ***** cat.

The Gulfstream is like driving a 4 wheeler. The Lear 60 is like riding a uni cycle."

BadMoonRisin
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Lear 60 was the same plane that Travis Barker and DJ AM crashed in back in 2008.
eric76
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Rocky Rider said:

Teslag said:

AggieFlyboy said:

jeremiahjt said:

We can do whatever the hell we want. I love when somebody it whatever industry is being discussed comes in and tells all the non-industry people what they can and cannot discuss.

And then the obligatory "all the best (insert job) I know are women and are so much better than me at (insert job).


Dude, I've flown with good sticks and bad sticks. Men and women can fit both categories. All that matters in the airplane is skill; age and sex are pretty much irrelevant. I've flown with young guys that have more experience than guys sitting there for 40 years.


Skill can't make up for experience when **** goes south and you need quick, rational, and accurate decision making. And that's not just true for pilots. It's true for many similar occupations.


Gender isn't an issue IMO.
If I chartered the flight for my wife, 2 kids, 2 friends, and a nanny, I would question whether the co-pilot had the experience and chutzpah to support and question the pilots decisions. Per our laws, the co-pilot isn't responsible / mature enough to buy a beer, but can fly a Lear jet with 7 passengers- huh?
I'm not a pilot so I'll defer to those that have significant experience in the cockpit of a jet aircraft. But it seems like a copilot in a Lear jet should have more experience than in this case.

I think that someone said she had 1300 hours. We don't know how many hours she had in type.
BadMoonRisin
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
According to the 2nd NTSB briefing a few minutes ago, the left elevator was found in 3 pieces ranging from 1.6 - 3.8miles from the crash site. Indicates that it separated prior to impact (as the videos confirm), potentially between 10-15k ft altitude.

Might not have made a difference if they were in mach tuck anyway.
Wings007Ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Why is it wrong to say overall men probably make better pilots? There are other things women do better than men in life, not sure why that's so controversial.
eric76
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG


Pay attention to when it talks about ice crystals at about 7 minutes in.

Aggie95
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Logos Stick said:

zgolfz85 said:

I don't have X, but saw on IG that this pilot put up a good read on the Lear Jet 60 specifically...in case anyone can link it? Basically saying of all the planes he's flown, this model is easily the most sensitive and easily the most dangerous to try and fly through or over a storm.

https://x.com/HangryDBowman


Its not him, its his buddy who has flown them and said this:

Quote:

Long post worth the read. I have a close friend who flies private jets. He flew Lear 60 for over 15 years and now flies a Gulfstream. This is a copy and paste of his response to me asking him if I thought Ice was the issue.

"We always fly in ridiculous cold temperatures."

"Usually you get the bad ice when the temperatures are like 0 to negative 20. Believe it or not, there's a point where it gets too cold for ice. At negative 40, you pretty much can't get ice. Besides that, the airplane is equipped with hot wings and hot tail."

"I flew the Lear 60 for like 15 years. It's a no joke airplane and probably the most dangerous airplane I've ever flown. It has a super critical wing. The airflow has to be perfect. When it gets into rough air and turbulence, it will easily stall. It has stalled on me at 41,000 feet just because we got into some turbulence. (On the way to Palm Beach as a matter of fact. ) we recovered and got her flying again around 30,000 ft. Scary

But here's the problem. This airplane has a terrible coffin corner. (At high altitudes) what that means is, you fly in a really narrow window where if you lose 20 knots, it stalls. And if you gain 20 knots, it goes into overspeed. The air goes supersonic over the wing and it goes into a high speed stall, or worse, a Mach tuck.

So if you stall, the normal recovery is to push the yoke forward to lower the nose and gain air speed again. At low altitude, you can push really hard and recover quickly. But in the 60... if you push hard, it will gain air speed and go into a high speed stall, it doesn't take much. It's very sensitive. The 60 has super short wings that don't make much lift. So then you high speed stall, and the computer is yelling at you... OVERSPEED! So then you pull back and enter a low speed stall. And you go back and forth trying to keep it in the air speed window.

This whole thing is pretty scary. And you should recover basically by using your finger tips using super small corrections. You can't over do it. If you try to muscle the recovery, she gets mad and will become unrecoverable. If she enters a mach tuck. You're done."

"I taught the Lear 60 to other pilots and mentored them. I told them... this airplane has a soul and it's trying to kill you. Do not ever try to top the weather. Don't go over a thunderstorm. Go around it. If it means a half hour longer, then do it. Going over the thunderstorm will go into turbulence that you might not recover from.

These pilots went right over a thunderstorm. I think it stalled which caused them to drop down into the thunderstorm and ended up in mach tuck. They picked up so much speed that it ripped off the horizontal stabilizer. At that point... chuck Yeager can't fix it.

These same pilots did something similar a couple months ago. ATC got mad at them. They poked the bear one too many times.

This is not a beginner airplane. The Gulfstream would never do this. It has HUGE margins of error and won't stall like that. But then again... it's got HUGE wings. It's a ***** cat.

The Gulfstream is like driving a 4 wheeler. The Lear 60 is like riding a uni cycle."




That's pretty wild. Why would any pilot take on the risk of flying that version? Why won't the FAA review its air worthiness (or whatever the term is).
zgolfz85
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Logos Stick said:

zgolfz85 said:

I don't have X, but saw on IG that this pilot put up a good read on the Lear Jet 60 specifically...in case anyone can link it? Basically saying of all the planes he's flown, this model is easily the most sensitive and easily the most dangerous to try and fly through or over a storm.

https://x.com/HangryDBowman


Its not him, its his buddy who has flown them and said this:

Quote:

Long post worth the read. I have a close friend who flies private jets. He flew Lear 60 for over 15 years and now flies a Gulfstream. This is a copy and paste of his response to me asking him if I thought Ice was the issue.

"We always fly in ridiculous cold temperatures."

"Usually you get the bad ice when the temperatures are like 0 to negative 20. Believe it or not, there's a point where it gets too cold for ice. At negative 40, you pretty much can't get ice. Besides that, the airplane is equipped with hot wings and hot tail."

"I flew the Lear 60 for like 15 years. It's a no joke airplane and probably the most dangerous airplane I've ever flown. It has a super critical wing. The airflow has to be perfect. When it gets into rough air and turbulence, it will easily stall. It has stalled on me at 41,000 feet just because we got into some turbulence. (On the way to Palm Beach as a matter of fact. ) we recovered and got her flying again around 30,000 ft. Scary

But here's the problem. This airplane has a terrible coffin corner. (At high altitudes) what that means is, you fly in a really narrow window where if you lose 20 knots, it stalls. And if you gain 20 knots, it goes into overspeed. The air goes supersonic over the wing and it goes into a high speed stall, or worse, a Mach tuck.

So if you stall, the normal recovery is to push the yoke forward to lower the nose and gain air speed again. At low altitude, you can push really hard and recover quickly. But in the 60... if you push hard, it will gain air speed and go into a high speed stall, it doesn't take much. It's very sensitive. The 60 has super short wings that don't make much lift. So then you high speed stall, and the computer is yelling at you... OVERSPEED! So then you pull back and enter a low speed stall. And you go back and forth trying to keep it in the air speed window.

This whole thing is pretty scary. And you should recover basically by using your finger tips using super small corrections. You can't over do it. If you try to muscle the recovery, she gets mad and will become unrecoverable. If she enters a mach tuck. You're done."

"I taught the Lear 60 to other pilots and mentored them. I told them... this airplane has a soul and it's trying to kill you. Do not ever try to top the weather. Don't go over a thunderstorm. Go around it. If it means a half hour longer, then do it. Going over the thunderstorm will go into turbulence that you might not recover from.

These pilots went right over a thunderstorm. I think it stalled which caused them to drop down into the thunderstorm and ended up in mach tuck. They picked up so much speed that it ripped off the horizontal stabilizer. At that point... chuck Yeager can't fix it.

These same pilots did something similar a couple months ago. ATC got mad at them. They poked the bear one too many times.

This is not a beginner airplane. The Gulfstream would never do this. It has HUGE margins of error and won't stall like that. But then again... it's got HUGE wings. It's a ***** cat.

The Gulfstream is like driving a 4 wheeler. The Lear 60 is like riding a uni cycle."



ah thanks!
HollywoodBQ
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
BadMoonRisin said:

Lear 60 was the same plane that Travis Barker and DJ AM crashed in back in 2008.

Wow. I had no idea Travis Barker survived a plane crash. That's a crazy story.

Tex100
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
https://aerocorner.com/blog/hollywood-celebrities-with-private-jets/

Don't see a Lear on this list
stetson
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
zgolfz85 said:

Logos Stick said:

zgolfz85 said:

I don't have X, but saw on IG that this pilot put up a good read on the Lear Jet 60 specifically...in case anyone can link it? Basically saying of all the planes he's flown, this model is easily the most sensitive and easily the most dangerous to try and fly through or over a storm.

https://x.com/HangryDBowman


Its not him, its his buddy who has flown them and said this:

Quote:

Long post worth the read. I have a close friend who flies private jets. He flew Lear 60 for over 15 years and now flies a Gulfstream. This is a copy and paste of his response to me asking him if I thought Ice was the issue.

"We always fly in ridiculous cold temperatures."

"Usually you get the bad ice when the temperatures are like 0 to negative 20. Believe it or not, there's a point where it gets too cold for ice. At negative 40, you pretty much can't get ice. Besides that, the airplane is equipped with hot wings and hot tail."

"I flew the Lear 60 for like 15 years. It's a no joke airplane and probably the most dangerous airplane I've ever flown. It has a super critical wing. The airflow has to be perfect. When it gets into rough air and turbulence, it will easily stall. It has stalled on me at 41,000 feet just because we got into some turbulence. (On the way to Palm Beach as a matter of fact. ) we recovered and got her flying again around 30,000 ft. Scary

But here's the problem. This airplane has a terrible coffin corner. (At high altitudes) what that means is, you fly in a really narrow window where if you lose 20 knots, it stalls. And if you gain 20 knots, it goes into overspeed. The air goes supersonic over the wing and it goes into a high speed stall, or worse, a Mach tuck.

So if you stall, the normal recovery is to push the yoke forward to lower the nose and gain air speed again. At low altitude, you can push really hard and recover quickly. But in the 60... if you push hard, it will gain air speed and go into a high speed stall, it doesn't take much. It's very sensitive. The 60 has super short wings that don't make much lift. So then you high speed stall, and the computer is yelling at you... OVERSPEED! So then you pull back and enter a low speed stall. And you go back and forth trying to keep it in the air speed window.

This whole thing is pretty scary. And you should recover basically by using your finger tips using super small corrections. You can't over do it. If you try to muscle the recovery, she gets mad and will become unrecoverable. If she enters a mach tuck. You're done."

"I taught the Lear 60 to other pilots and mentored them. I told them... this airplane has a soul and it's trying to kill you. Do not ever try to top the weather. Don't go over a thunderstorm. Go around it. If it means a half hour longer, then do it. Going over the thunderstorm will go into turbulence that you might not recover from.

These pilots went right over a thunderstorm. I think it stalled which caused them to drop down into the thunderstorm and ended up in mach tuck. They picked up so much speed that it ripped off the horizontal stabilizer. At that point... chuck Yeager can't fix it.

These same pilots did something similar a couple months ago. ATC got mad at them. They poked the bear one too many times.

This is not a beginner airplane. The Gulfstream would never do this. It has HUGE margins of error and won't stall like that. But then again... it's got HUGE wings. It's a ***** cat.

The Gulfstream is like driving a 4 wheeler. The Lear 60 is like riding a uni cycle."



ah thanks!

Good explanation of Mach tuck. I think this is exactly what happened…
https://poptvculture.com/mach-tuck/
BadMoonRisin
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
He came out with a memoir not too long ago i listened to on audio book and a recent doc (hulu/disney+) that is very good if you are interested. The crash plays a big part of it. He didnt fly for years afterwards, understandably and would only tour by bus.

DJ AM survived as well, but his recovery resulted in him relapsing on a pain med addiction that he kicked a few years earlier and he died of an overdose a year after.
Logos Stick
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Wow, listen to this exchange. Same vicinity as the Leer crash but happened back in September. Pilot says nope.

BadMoonRisin
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Wow and it was even inbound to austin.
78669AG
How long do you want to ignore this user?
infinity ag said:


Learjet in doomed Palm Beach plane crash was involved in ANOTHER incident with female pilot weeks before… with chilling echoes of fatal maneuver that would go on to kill nine
https://www.dailymail.com/news/article-16259449/pilot-learjet-crash-florida-audio-downplaying-turbulence.html

Quote:

A female pilot flying the same Learjet that crashed in Florida was heard being scolded by air traffic control months before for downplaying turbulence.

The woman was flying over Newark in New Jersey in May when an air traffic controller asked 'Why are you climbing?'
'We are just about to call you, we are experiencing moderate [turbulence] and unable to hold altitude,' said the female pilot.


The exasperated controller responded firmly: 'That is not moderate, descend to 4,000 [feet] immediately.
'If you cant maintain altitude that is not moderate, that is severe turbulence, are you experiencing severe turbulence?' he added.


The woman and a man then both respond 'affirmative sir', as the audio clip ended.
It is unclear if the woman heard on the audio was Nathalia Gadelha Filgueiras, 20. She was co-pilot of the Learjet when it crashed in Palm Beach on Sunday, killing her and eight others, amid speculation the plane was downed by severe weather.
The Learjet whose pilot was scolded for downplaying turbulence bore the same tail number N7226D as the plane that smashed into the ground while flying from Austin in Texas to the Bahamas.




Just because it was the same tail number and a female does not mean it was the same crew. These charter companies have multiple crews
torrid
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
That sounds like an air traffic control problem, the JetBlue plane.
insulator_king
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
BadMoonRisin said:

According to the 2nd NTSB briefing a few minutes ago, the left elevator was found in 3 pieces ranging from 1.6 - 3.8miles from the crash site. Indicates that it separated prior to impact (as the videos confirm), potentially between 10-15k ft altitude.

Might not have made a difference if they were in mach tuck anyway.


TexasRebel
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Is it common for a Lear to have WiFi/Sat communications?

Cell doesn't really work that far/fast.
BadMoonRisin
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
This plane was a 2004 model so not stock, but im sure you can have one installed fairly easily. If you have PJ money you would certainly expect to have it on your flight.
Logos Stick
How long do you want to ignore this user?
torrid said:

That sounds like an air traffic control problem, the JetBlue plane.


The point is that the pilot said "hell no" to trying to fly through a thunderstorm despite the ATC telling him it was OK.

The Leer pilot/copilot decided to risk it.
Langley
How long do you want to ignore this user?
torrid said:

That sounds like an air traffic control problem, the JetBlue plane.


Sounds like radar was delayed for atc and not accurate for what the JetBlue cabin was seeing.

They gave no issues to the request and put on a ground stop.

That JetBlue audio seemed like everyone did what you want them to do…and that's see something, say something.

They JetBlue pilot reiterated why it was an issue, making a point that she doesn't send more aircraft that way.

ATC said they saw light precip (on radar) and pilot gave them an eye in the sky report it was severe. ATC revised their actions and put in a ground stop.
one safe place
How long do you want to ignore this user?
The only time I flew on a small plane I did question my decision. My first trip to Tarawa included a flight to Butaritari (known as Makin Island during the war). The airport we departed from was the Bonriki International Airport which was not your typical airport. There were 8 or 9 of us and a couple of island girl tour guides. Our plane was a De Havilland DH-6 Twin Otter operated by Air Kirabati.

I was not all that impressed and when we got ready to take off, one of the pilots reached up and grabbed this D handle thing, I called it a yoke. (You had a pretty much unobstructed view into the cockpit.) I figured it as meant to be there, after all it was hanging right there and all. Then the other pilot guy or first officer or whatever he was called, reached up and put his little finger or ring finger on one side of the yoke and thumb on the other, as if he was holding it together, so it wouldn't come apart. So, at this point, I am wondering how badly I wanted to visit Butaritari.

But we made it. And actually, that very Twin Otter was used in Bond's Casino Royale.
zgolfz85
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Puddle jumpers are wild to me. Feels like flying in a glorified riding mower.

Also, Ryan Air….not sure how their planes are up to code. They're not even air tight
bonfarr
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
The girl also posted a message on SM after she flew Lenny Kravitz on the jet.
5Amp
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Logos Stick said:

torrid said:

That sounds like an air traffic control problem, the JetBlue plane.


The point is that the pilot said "hell no" to trying to fly through a thunderstorm despite the ATC telling him it was OK.

The Leer pilot/copilot decided to risk it.


The JetBlue pilot asked if center was trying to put them thru a storm, he did not report turbulence or ice. If he is in IMC he sees nothing out his window but a white out. I think what JetBlue pilot sees is a large cell ahead on his current heading per his onboard radar and ask for a different heading. Center radar is delayed for whatever reason.

We do not know what type of radar the Lear had or even if it was functional. We can assume center had him fly around the large cell per the pictures from FlightAware. After getting around the large cell, pilot requested direct to his destination which put him directly into the smaller cell. Now center is busy, very busy due to this large cell and while the pilot is out of the large cell, he is still in choppy IMC and real busy flying the plane (heading and altitude). His first officer should have been working the radios, getting weather updates before requesting heading changes.

Maybe she declared an Emergency after the plane loses its horizontal stabilizer which is a waste of breath.

I listen to Pilot Debrief with Hoover on YouTube, once he gets the full story, he will put out a debrief and I will post it.
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.