Plane Crash Near Mar-a-Lago

85,145 Views | 658 Replies | Last: 6 days ago by CornAg
Cromagnum
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Good Lord, social media has some absolutely stupid MFers posting about this. It's unfortunate that their vote counts the same as anyone else's.
P.H. Dexippus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
agent-maroon said:

Could a recorder box withstand an impact that left that crater? That's a lot of impact energy to create a crater that size without an explosive being involved

My understanding is the boxes are designed to survive 3400G. Ground impact was likely 1/3 that.
akaggie05
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
From what I'm reading, it's not entirely required that the jet in question here was even required to have an FDR. A CVR looks more mandatory given the seating capacity along with multi-engine. But yeah, survivability of one or more of those units looks dicey given this crash.
agent-maroon
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
P.H. Dexippus said:

agent-maroon said:

Could a recorder box withstand an impact that left that crater? That's a lot of impact energy to create a crater that size without an explosive being involved

My understanding is the boxes are designed to survive 3400G. Ground impact was likely 1/3 that.

Confirmed on a casual Google search. That's pretty darned impressive!
No material on this site is intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. See full Medical Disclaimer.
insulator_king
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Here's the NTSB briefing



News reporters ask such stupid questions sometimes.
wangus12
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Gunny456 said:

Thing is there were thousands of those teenagers and barely 20 year olds that flew hundreds of missions and sorties during WWIl that got the job done and had not only bad weather to worry about but also people trying to shoot them down every day.


To be fair, there were also around 15,000 aviation deaths in training accidents in World War 2 as well
jkag89
How long do you want to ignore this user?
wangus12 said:

Gunny456 said:

Thing is there were thousands of those teenagers and barely 20 year olds that flew hundreds of missions and sorties during WWIl that got the job done and had not only bad weather to worry about but also people trying to shoot them down every day.


To be fair, there were also around 15,000 aviation deaths in training accidents in World War 2 as well

To be fair, there has also be a great deal of advancement in aviation technology since the 1940s. Heck it is much safer to fly today than 30 years ago.
Gunny456
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Yes sir. The majority of those accidents were mechanical failures and failure to control the aircraft and some weather related.
The training aircraft of the time…..Pt-17's, PT-19's, AT-6's were a handful for most young aviators. No easy way to learn to fly back then.
TAMU Wildlife and Fisheries Sciences

Boat racing is like a beautiful woman.......expensive, high maintenance, but well worth the fun!
GAC06
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
akaggie05 said:

Yeah good point. Just like the Valujet DC-9 which got swallowed up entirely.


They recovered parts of that plane and identified the majority of the deceased, so not swallowed up entirely
Aston04
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Jetpilot86 said:

If you look at the last 2 frames before impact, the plane is missing the horizontal stabilizer, and from the moment it ripped off, probably due to an overspeed, they were a crash, just looking for a place to happen, unfortunately.

My suspicion is that the ultimate cause will be flying into the top of thunderstorm over Palm Beach, icing up, stalling, and unable to recover before the speed ripped the tail off. In my world, we avoid red on the radar by 20 miles minimum at altitude. The copilot probably had at most between 509-750 Flight hours, certainly legal enough to fly the airplane, but not likely enough to fully comprehend what they were dealing with that caused the problems. That would most likely be the case if it was a he or she as copilot.

This will be a classic case of "get-there-itis", because the customer had to get there, and the crew didn't say "better if we wait"

The silly part is they were flying to the Bahamas. It just seems like there are so many different routes, even if central Florida was being lit up.
Aston04
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Last year when flying to DFW from Detroit- I go diverted to Memphis because of a bad system in Dallas. We took off again and then aimlessly flew around the coast of Texas - apparently waiting for an opportunity to go into Dallas. Out the window you could see lightning strikes periodically and had a fairly bumpy ride on that leg over Texas. We ended up being dumped for the night into Houston Hobby, even though AA doesn't fly out of there, because Bush was full...

The two men in our cockpit each looked fresh out of college... I'm sure we were fine, but incidents like this give me pause about that night for sure.
Jarrin Jay
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Well they were flying to Freeport, not Nassau, and were trying to go direct across FL for a straight shot.

They should have diverted WELL out of the way, south toward they Keyes then around the southern tip of FL, maybe adds an hour of flying, but a plane that size has no business flying into and around so much red on the radar. IMHO.
BadMoonRisin
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Jarrin Jay said:

Well they were flying to Freeport, not Nassau, and were trying to go direct across FL for a straight shot.

They should have diverted WELL out of the way, south toward they Keyes then around the southern tip of FL, maybe adds an hour of flying, but a plane that size has no business flying into and around so much red on the radar. IMHO.

Im surprised ATC allowed them to do that, they must have been diverting flights left and right around this thing, it was a huge storm or is that just up to the discretion of the pilot? Never actually thought about that.
AggieFlyboy
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
BadMoonRisin said:

Jarrin Jay said:

Well they were flying to Freeport, not Nassau, and were trying to go direct across FL for a straight shot.

They should have diverted WELL out of the way, south toward they Keyes then around the southern tip of FL, maybe adds an hour of flying, but a plane that size has no business flying into and around so much red on the radar. IMHO.

Im surprised ATC allowed them to do that, they must have been diverting flights left and right around this thing, it was a huge storm or is that just up to the discretion of the pilot? Never actually thought about that.


I've had weather that ATC called severe that is a non-factor. I've also had weather that ATC didn't see at all. It's an imprecise business, which is why I chuckle when people say "AI could have done it better"
BadMoonRisin
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I guess that is my question. They are only there to keep you from crashing into other vehicles, but most of the decisions are left up to the pilot? I did see that they alerted them to weather, but when they pushed back and said they were going to hit a particular waypoint and then continue straight to Freeport, ATC was cool with it.
GAC06
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Generally those decisions are up to the pilots, as they typically have better awareness of the conditions around them. However there are times ATC will make flow/traffic decisions based on weather and just start routing everyone a certain way they think is safe and efficient. The final authority is always the pilot in command, but that's generally if they have to deviate from a clearance.
jeremiahjt
How long do you want to ignore this user?
We can do whatever the hell we want. I love when somebody it whatever industry is being discussed comes in and tells all the non-industry people what they can and cannot discuss.

And then the obligatory "all the best (insert job) I know are women and are so much better than me at (insert job).
agracer
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Duckhook
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
The black box from the Philly Lear crash last year was recovered. Very similar crash profile to this one, so not out of the question it might be recovered here.

Also, here's a horizontal representation of the weather this flight flew into. Definitely a convective storm with its associated issues, but they didn't necessarily fly into the worst "red" part. This is from a Pilot Debrief video.

[url=https://ibb.co/RpTFwYQm][/url]
TexasAggie_02
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Blancoliro vid is up

TexasRebel
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I wonder if the initial event that made them want a "smoother ride" did any contributing damage.
one safe place
How long do you want to ignore this user?
agent-maroon said:

New World Ag said:

agent-maroon said:

Could a recorder box withstand an impact that left a crater? That's a lot of impact energy to create a crater that size without an explosive being involved

Possibly, yes. Both boxes from UA93 were found and had good data/recordings on them.

What are those boxes made of? Really hard to comprehend them surviving at all, much less having recoverable data.

I certainly have no technical expertise in any of this, but I have always wondered why the data that gets stored on the FDR and the CVR isn't somehow transmitted (via the cloud, satellite, etc.) to somewhere other than the plane. I guess it is a cost matter and there are not many crashes and even the crashes that do happen it seems these things are generally recovered.
AggieFlyboy
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Picard said:

Agsquatch said:

To be clear age and sex had absolutely nothing to do with competence.


Gonna have to disagree with you there, ace.




And you'd be wrong, hope that helps.
Brewskis
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
one safe place said:

agent-maroon said:

New World Ag said:

agent-maroon said:

Could a recorder box withstand an impact that left a crater? That's a lot of impact energy to create a crater that size without an explosive being involved

Possibly, yes. Both boxes from UA93 were found and had good data/recordings on them.

What are those boxes made of? Really hard to comprehend them surviving at all, much less having recoverable data.

I certainly have no technical expertise in any of this, but I have always wondered why the data that gets stored on the FDR and the CVR isn't somehow transmitted (via the cloud, satellite, etc.) to somewhere other than the plane. I guess it is a cost matter and there are not many crashes and even the crashes that do happen it seems these things are generally recovered.


Via what means? That's a massive amount of info to transmit constantly. Seamless highspeed wifi airborne is only becoming a 'thing' today with Starlink and even that has its problems.
AggieFlyboy
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
jeremiahjt said:

We can do whatever the hell we want. I love when somebody it whatever industry is being discussed comes in and tells all the non-industry people what they can and cannot discuss.

And then the obligatory "all the best (insert job) I know are women and are so much better than me at (insert job).


Dude, I've flown with good sticks and bad sticks. Men and women can fit both categories. All that matters in the airplane is skill; age and sex are pretty much irrelevant. I've flown with young guys that have more experience than guys sitting there for 40 years.
one safe place
How long do you want to ignore this user?
5Amp said:

If the pilot is not a cubby, middle age white dude, I ain't flying.

My family and I were flying back from Virginia Beach after going out for a wedding. We are sitting in the boarding area, and this pilot dude comes walking toward the counter, pulling his little suitcase and for some reason I watch him. Looked to be in his 50s. He goes to the door behind the counter and presses the keypad on the door, but it doesn't open. Tries it again and again and still can't get it open. As I focus on him, I get the feeling he is drunk. Eventually, after about a dozen tries, he opens the door. As we wait, the thought runs through my mind if it turns out he is the pilot, maybe stay another night and try again tomorrow. As we board the plane, I take a step to the left and lean over a bit so I can look in the cockpit, and he wasn't in either seat!
TA-OP
How long do you want to ignore this user?
one safe place said:

5Amp said:

If the pilot is not a cubby, middle age white dude, I ain't flying.

My family and I were flying back from Virginia Beach after going out for a wedding. We are sitting in the boarding area, and this pilot dude comes walking toward the counter, pulling his little suitcase and for some reason I watch him. Looked to be in his 50s. He goes to the door behind the counter and presses the keypad on the door, but it doesn't open. Tries it again and again and still can't get it open. As I focus on him, I get the feeling he is drunk. Eventually, after about a dozen tries, he opens the door. As we wait, the thought runs through my mind if it turns out he is the pilot, maybe stay another night and try again tomorrow. As we board the plane, I take a step to the left and lean over a bit so I can look in the cockpit, and he wasn't in either seat!
Why not say something? You'd have never forgiven yourself had something happened.
AggieT
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
one safe place said:

5Amp said:

If the pilot is not a cubby, middle age white dude, I ain't flying.

My family and I were flying back from Virginia Beach after going out for a wedding. We are sitting in the boarding area, and this pilot dude comes walking toward the counter, pulling his little suitcase and for some reason I watch him. Looked to be in his 50s. He goes to the door behind the counter and presses the keypad on the door, but it doesn't open. Tries it again and again and still can't get it open. As I focus on him, I get the feeling he is drunk. Eventually, after about a dozen tries, he opens the door. As we wait, the thought runs through my mind if it turns out he is the pilot, maybe stay another night and try again tomorrow. As we board the plane, I take a step to the left and lean over a bit so I can look in the cockpit, and he wasn't in either seat!

He disappeared?
FTAG 2000
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
akaggie05 said:

I'm of the opinion that the horizontal stabilizer was no longer with the aircraft upon impact, but assuming that's the case it will likely turn up somewhere nearby sooner rather than later. Should be a key piece of the investigation if it does.


Lots of good sized ponds around that area. Could be underwater somewhere too
zgolfz85
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
AggieFlyboy said:

Picard said:

Agsquatch said:

To be clear age and sex had absolutely nothing to do with competence.


Gonna have to disagree with you there, ace.




And you'd be wrong, hope that helps.


That's the stuff on f16 that gives it the bad reputation and ruins it. Just such an asinine statement from that guy…and I'm as anti-feminazi as it comes. I honestly don't know what your beliefs would have to be to be that dense and hateful. And, in a situation like this, just so unnecessary.
InternetFan02
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG


Same X account that found the co-pilot this morning now has info on the pilot

Also per my X feed looks like the co-pilot was very active on social media promoting her career as many in Gen Z like to do. Very sad.
TexasRebel
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
one safe place said:

agent-maroon said:

New World Ag said:

agent-maroon said:

Could a recorder box withstand an impact that left a crater? That's a lot of impact energy to create a crater that size without an explosive being involved

Possibly, yes. Both boxes from UA93 were found and had good data/recordings on them.

What are those boxes made of? Really hard to comprehend them surviving at all, much less having recoverable data.

I certainly have no technical expertise in any of this, but I have always wondered why the data that gets stored on the FDR and the CVR isn't somehow transmitted (via the cloud, satellite, etc.) to somewhere other than the plane. I guess it is a cost matter and there are not many crashes and even the crashes that do happen it seems these things are generally recovered.


You can't rely on wireless transmission of vital live records. No matter how advanced the technology, there will be gaps. In-situ hard-wired recording is a must.
bonfarr
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Watch some YouTube videos about TNFlygirl. She wasn't a commercial pilot she was an amateur private pilot but she chronicled her journey to become a pilot on YouTube and had a lot of followers before she crashed and died with her father in the plane. Sad story.

She apparently was a terrible pilot but loved the engagement and following. She would post flight videos and non pilots would cheer her on and actual pilots would tear apart her flying skills and she had a lot of near misses captured on video
Jetpilot86
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
BadMoonRisin said:

Jarrin Jay said:

Well they were flying to Freeport, not Nassau, and were trying to go direct across FL for a straight shot.

They should have diverted WELL out of the way, south toward they Keyes then around the southern tip of FL, maybe adds an hour of flying, but a plane that size has no business flying into and around so much red on the radar. IMHO.

Im surprised ATC allowed them to do that, they must have been diverting flights left and right around this thing, it was a huge storm or is that just up to the discretion of the pilot? Never actually thought about that.


ATC does not tell me I/they "can't". They tell me what is there and tell me to let them know what I need to avoid them.
Jetpilot86
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
It's best to stay 20 miles upwind or more if you're downwind of the storm. The FL storms can move in nearly any direction and can turn on a dime.

One flooded the ramp my Mooney was on at FXE IN Ft. Lauderdale. It was headed due east and turned due south. This was over 30 minutes.




 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.