Good Lord, social media has some absolutely stupid MFers posting about this. It's unfortunate that their vote counts the same as anyone else's.
agent-maroon said:
Could a recorder box withstand an impact that left that crater? That's a lot of impact energy to create a crater that size without an explosive being involved
P.H. Dexippus said:agent-maroon said:
Could a recorder box withstand an impact that left that crater? That's a lot of impact energy to create a crater that size without an explosive being involved
My understanding is the boxes are designed to survive 3400G. Ground impact was likely 1/3 that.
Gunny456 said:
Thing is there were thousands of those teenagers and barely 20 year olds that flew hundreds of missions and sorties during WWIl that got the job done and had not only bad weather to worry about but also people trying to shoot them down every day.
wangus12 said:Gunny456 said:
Thing is there were thousands of those teenagers and barely 20 year olds that flew hundreds of missions and sorties during WWIl that got the job done and had not only bad weather to worry about but also people trying to shoot them down every day.
To be fair, there were also around 15,000 aviation deaths in training accidents in World War 2 as well
akaggie05 said:
Yeah good point. Just like the Valujet DC-9 which got swallowed up entirely.
Jetpilot86 said:
If you look at the last 2 frames before impact, the plane is missing the horizontal stabilizer, and from the moment it ripped off, probably due to an overspeed, they were a crash, just looking for a place to happen, unfortunately.
My suspicion is that the ultimate cause will be flying into the top of thunderstorm over Palm Beach, icing up, stalling, and unable to recover before the speed ripped the tail off. In my world, we avoid red on the radar by 20 miles minimum at altitude. The copilot probably had at most between 509-750 Flight hours, certainly legal enough to fly the airplane, but not likely enough to fully comprehend what they were dealing with that caused the problems. That would most likely be the case if it was a he or she as copilot.
This will be a classic case of "get-there-itis", because the customer had to get there, and the crew didn't say "better if we wait"
Jarrin Jay said:
Well they were flying to Freeport, not Nassau, and were trying to go direct across FL for a straight shot.
They should have diverted WELL out of the way, south toward they Keyes then around the southern tip of FL, maybe adds an hour of flying, but a plane that size has no business flying into and around so much red on the radar. IMHO.
BadMoonRisin said:Jarrin Jay said:
Well they were flying to Freeport, not Nassau, and were trying to go direct across FL for a straight shot.
They should have diverted WELL out of the way, south toward they Keyes then around the southern tip of FL, maybe adds an hour of flying, but a plane that size has no business flying into and around so much red on the radar. IMHO.
Im surprised ATC allowed them to do that, they must have been diverting flights left and right around this thing, it was a huge storm or is that just up to the discretion of the pilot? Never actually thought about that.
[/url] agent-maroon said:New World Ag said:agent-maroon said:
Could a recorder box withstand an impact that left a crater? That's a lot of impact energy to create a crater that size without an explosive being involved
Possibly, yes. Both boxes from UA93 were found and had good data/recordings on them.
What are those boxes made of? Really hard to comprehend them surviving at all, much less having recoverable data.
Picard said:Agsquatch said:
To be clear age and sex had absolutely nothing to do with competence.
Gonna have to disagree with you there, ace.
one safe place said:agent-maroon said:New World Ag said:agent-maroon said:
Could a recorder box withstand an impact that left a crater? That's a lot of impact energy to create a crater that size without an explosive being involved
Possibly, yes. Both boxes from UA93 were found and had good data/recordings on them.
What are those boxes made of? Really hard to comprehend them surviving at all, much less having recoverable data.
I certainly have no technical expertise in any of this, but I have always wondered why the data that gets stored on the FDR and the CVR isn't somehow transmitted (via the cloud, satellite, etc.) to somewhere other than the plane. I guess it is a cost matter and there are not many crashes and even the crashes that do happen it seems these things are generally recovered.
jeremiahjt said:
We can do whatever the hell we want. I love when somebody it whatever industry is being discussed comes in and tells all the non-industry people what they can and cannot discuss.
And then the obligatory "all the best (insert job) I know are women and are so much better than me at (insert job).
5Amp said:
If the pilot is not a cubby, middle age white dude, I ain't flying.
Why not say something? You'd have never forgiven yourself had something happened.one safe place said:5Amp said:
If the pilot is not a cubby, middle age white dude, I ain't flying.
My family and I were flying back from Virginia Beach after going out for a wedding. We are sitting in the boarding area, and this pilot dude comes walking toward the counter, pulling his little suitcase and for some reason I watch him. Looked to be in his 50s. He goes to the door behind the counter and presses the keypad on the door, but it doesn't open. Tries it again and again and still can't get it open. As I focus on him, I get the feeling he is drunk. Eventually, after about a dozen tries, he opens the door. As we wait, the thought runs through my mind if it turns out he is the pilot, maybe stay another night and try again tomorrow. As we board the plane, I take a step to the left and lean over a bit so I can look in the cockpit, and he wasn't in either seat!
one safe place said:5Amp said:
If the pilot is not a cubby, middle age white dude, I ain't flying.
My family and I were flying back from Virginia Beach after going out for a wedding. We are sitting in the boarding area, and this pilot dude comes walking toward the counter, pulling his little suitcase and for some reason I watch him. Looked to be in his 50s. He goes to the door behind the counter and presses the keypad on the door, but it doesn't open. Tries it again and again and still can't get it open. As I focus on him, I get the feeling he is drunk. Eventually, after about a dozen tries, he opens the door. As we wait, the thought runs through my mind if it turns out he is the pilot, maybe stay another night and try again tomorrow. As we board the plane, I take a step to the left and lean over a bit so I can look in the cockpit, and he wasn't in either seat!
akaggie05 said:
I'm of the opinion that the horizontal stabilizer was no longer with the aircraft upon impact, but assuming that's the case it will likely turn up somewhere nearby sooner rather than later. Should be a key piece of the investigation if it does.
AggieFlyboy said:Picard said:Agsquatch said:
To be clear age and sex had absolutely nothing to do with competence.
Gonna have to disagree with you there, ace.
And you'd be wrong, hope that helps.
BREAKING:
— Evan Kilgore đŸ‡ºđŸ‡¸ (@EvanAKilgore) November 2, 2026
Jeff Gregory, a 55-year-old pilot from Pennsylvania, has been identified as the pilot of the LearJet 60 that crashed yesterday in Palm Beach County, Florida.
Jeff had 2 decades of flying experience, according to those familiar with him.
His family are devout… pic.twitter.com/lD4T3FJ6f6
one safe place said:agent-maroon said:New World Ag said:agent-maroon said:
Could a recorder box withstand an impact that left a crater? That's a lot of impact energy to create a crater that size without an explosive being involved
Possibly, yes. Both boxes from UA93 were found and had good data/recordings on them.
What are those boxes made of? Really hard to comprehend them surviving at all, much less having recoverable data.
I certainly have no technical expertise in any of this, but I have always wondered why the data that gets stored on the FDR and the CVR isn't somehow transmitted (via the cloud, satellite, etc.) to somewhere other than the plane. I guess it is a cost matter and there are not many crashes and even the crashes that do happen it seems these things are generally recovered.
BadMoonRisin said:Jarrin Jay said:
Well they were flying to Freeport, not Nassau, and were trying to go direct across FL for a straight shot.
They should have diverted WELL out of the way, south toward they Keyes then around the southern tip of FL, maybe adds an hour of flying, but a plane that size has no business flying into and around so much red on the radar. IMHO.
Im surprised ATC allowed them to do that, they must have been diverting flights left and right around this thing, it was a huge storm or is that just up to the discretion of the pilot? Never actually thought about that.

