Plane Crash Near Mar-a-Lago

85,150 Views | 658 Replies | Last: 6 days ago by CornAg
bonfarr
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Would her age and the fact she had only had a pilot license for 3 years make her hesitant to argue with the captain and insist on a detour?
Agsquatch
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
And one more thing especially about weather:

I am not type rated or familiar with the Lear, if any of yall are please correct me.

I don't know if it has an onboard weather radar. My airplanes are not, and I have TIS-B weather radar sent up via ground radio towers. The radar overlay on my display is delayed by up to 15 minutes.

You have to "lead" pockets of bad wx to shoot the gap. Here's a picture for reference.

Editing picture bc it had the N number and don't want to dox myself LOL
bonfarr
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
5Amp said:

If the pilot is not a cubby, middle age white dude, I ain't flying.


I stepped onto an American Eagle flight at Easterwood and glanced into the cockpit and the first thing I saw was a blonde ponytail and I admit it gave me pause. Then I saw the salt and pepper crew cut sitting in the left seat and I relaxed.
joerobert_pete06
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
bonfarr said:

Interesting if real, this makes it appear ATC tried to get them to divert clear of the weather and they declined saying they would maintain a direct course. They didn't ask for a change until they were already in it and it was too late






Question: During that whole mayday conversation, can the other planes hear that? Afterwards when the ATC was calling for the girl pilot, it seemed like he was asking if the other planes can hear them?
Featured Video Previews
Agsquatch
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
CRM (crew resource management) and open comms are key. Some people are better than others. In a healthy environment cap and fo have stop authority. Both are qualified to fly the aircraft obviously. Yes the capt has more experience per se than the FO but there are two sets of eyes for a reason. I am not gonna speculate on anything until we get a cockpit voice recorder.
Kenneth_2003
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
EVERYONE on that frequency could hear that.
EVERYONE that controller was talking to could hear that
Agsquatch
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Yes you can hear it on whatever frequency you're on and they also would look for you on common emergency frequency (called guard) on 121.5
Agsquatch
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
They're trained to be that way. You can't get worked up even hearing something like that because you are generally working multiple frequencies / sectors and could have a domino effect. Why we need to keep praying for him. ATC are the voice of reason in chaos.
Cromagnum
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Agsquatch said:

They're trained to be that way. You can't get worked up even hearing something like that because you are generally working multiple frequencies / sectors and could have a domino effect. Why we need to keep praying for him. ATC are the voice of reason in chaos.


I figured its 100% training to clearly communicate and listen. I didnt expect a panic or anything, but it just comes across as a cold sense of no urgency.
GAC06
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
bonfarr said:

5Amp said:

If the pilot is not a cubby, middle age white dude, I ain't flying.


I stepped onto an American Eagle flight at Easterwood and glanced into the cockpit and the first thing I saw was a blonde ponytail and I admit it gave me pause. Then I saw the salt and pepper crew cut sitting in the left seat and I relaxed.


Someone still flying for a regional with salt and pepper hair might give me more pause
Agsquatch
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
When you're in an emergency situation and trained to aviate navigate then communicate it's so reassuring to have that still soft voice on the other end.

I had an engine failure in a single engine aircraft a few years ago and it really does ease the stress of a very stressful situation.
Picard
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Agsquatch said:

To be clear age and sex had absolutely nothing to do with competence.


Gonna have to disagree with you there, ace.

Agsquatch
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Funny enough all the old head airshow pilots I know are all regional Capts with a seniority # in the single digits. Fly 3 days a month to pay bills then hit wings over Houston or AirVenture. Although 6 + hrs XC in a pitts special or mig 15 sounds awful
Agsquatch
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I'd agree with you but we'd both be wrong.

Wait for the NTSB report.
awh
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
This was the whole premise of that Nathan Fielder show
JFABNRGR
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
joerobert_pete06 said:

bonfarr said:

Interesting if real, this makes it appear ATC tried to get them to divert clear of the weather and they declined saying they would maintain a direct course. They didn't ask for a change until they were already in it and it was too late






Question: During that whole mayday conversation, can the other planes hear that? Afterwards when the ATC was calling for the girl pilot, it seemed like he was asking if the other planes can hear them?

Observations

She is calm until you can hear stress in her voice as she confirms clearance to FL370 and the overlay showing them about centered in the storm. Seems like it went from manageable to terrifying very quickly.

Delta 1965 asks for a left deviation but ATC approves him a right deviation (under stress of what he just witnessed). Also understanding, Delta 1965 just goes with it and confirms right deviation.

“You can resolve to live your life with integrity. Let your credo be this: Let the lie come into the world, let it even triumph. But not through me.”
- Alexander Solzhenitsyn
Pinochet
How long do you want to ignore this user?
GAC06 said:

Pinochet said:

GAC06 said:

aggieforester05 said:

AgNav93 said:

Infection_Ag11 said:

GAC06 said:

Quote:

A commercial airliner has never been brought down by weather based turbulence in the history of modern aviation.


No. Fly into a severe thunderstorm and any plane is in deep trouble


Commercial airliners are still designed to withstand such forces, and essentially always do in the unfortunate circumstances in which it occurs.

THis is absolutely not true. I was a 20 year navigator r in the Air Force. Look up mountain wave turbulence. And it caused this crash of a Boening 707: BOAC Flight 911 (1966) A Boeing707 disintegrated near Mount Fuji after encountering severe mountain wave turbulence, killing all 124 on board

Mountain wave turbulence also tore the rudder off a B-52 once and they successfully landed it using the gear for yaw. That story was legend in the bomber community.

I'm pretty sure the Dubai Air Max-8 crew used the nose wheel for yaw control, since the rudder was gone. I think Captain Steve mentioned it in one of his videos.


I admit I haven't tried it but I strongly doubt the nose wheel would do anything at all for yaw control (airborne of course). Unless there's asymmetric thrust or landing or taking off with a crosswind, there's not much need for rudder inputs at all.

Found the airbus captain.


Jokes aside, what I said is correct. Outside of crosswinds on takeoff or landing or asymmetric thrust, there's basically no need for rudder input on a 737, and in fact there isn't any in cruise flight (outside trim and yaw damper inputs) on autopilot which cannot control the rudder at all.

I don't disagree with you. Just trying to insert levity into a tough situation.

A buddy of mine was a captain on the A320 and a wife's friend's husband tried to start a conversation with him at a party by saying he thought he could land an airliner in an emergency. He looks at my buddy and says it's pretty basic stuff and asks for his thoughts. My buddy looked at him and goes "I don't think I could land a 737 in an emergency." I haven't laughed that hard in a while. Even funnier is that my buddy had to move to the 737 when Spirit went under and he got a job at SWA. Now he complains that he has to coordinate his own turns now.
agent-maroon
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Could a recorder box withstand an impact that left that crater? That's a lot of impact energy to create a crater that size without an explosive being involved
No material on this site is intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. See full Medical Disclaimer.
GAC06
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Giving up a sidestick and tray table for a yoke and a Boeing seat is the real tragedy
BadMoonRisin
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I was also wondering about this. I know they were made to survive crashes, but at that angle and speed, it didnt look like many pieces of the plane were left around the crater
rjhtamu
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I can't imagine anything surviving intact at that impact angle and velocity….
No material on this site is intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. See full Medical Disclaimer.
bonfarr
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
awh said:

This was the whole premise of that Nathan Fielder show


I watched the doc on Flight Disasters of the JFK Jr crash and he let the pressure of trying to get to a wedding on time kill himself, his wife, and SIL. They departed hours after his plan which would have left much more daylight for visibility. I don't think he was instrument rated and should never have taken off when he did but he felt pressure to get to their destination and just ignored all better judgment
AvsB
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Didn't read each post on this thread so sorry if it has been discussed...but in the still shot doesn't it look like the horizontal stabilizer is gone?
bonfarr
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Agsquatch said:

They're trained to be that way. You can't get worked up even hearing something like that because you are generally working multiple frequencies / sectors and could have a domino effect. Why we need to keep praying for him. ATC are the voice of reason in chaos.


Here is an excellent example of ATC remaining calm and getting a pilot out of a jam. I hope this pilot sent the ATac a case of his favorite spirits after this.




Here is the longer transcript. He calls later that day to thank the controllers then asked to file another flight plan that day. I think if I was him I would have needed a new pair of pants and underwear and a little break before going back up in the air.

fc2112
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AvsB said:

Didn't read each post on this thread so sorry if it has been discussed...but in the still shot doesn't it look like the horizontal stabilizer is gone?

The still shot is one frame from a standard video camera trying to interpolate what it's seeing between frames. The HT missing could just be a digital artifact.
Hardcore Greg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
MAROON said:

Hardcore Greg said:

Dang, grew up playing basketball against one of the deceased (Adam Robinson). Not sure yet if that was his family on board with him, but assuming so. He went to Memorial High School.

reports say his wife, kids, nanny and dog were on board.

I saw that it said (and two friends)...I was hoping he was one of the friends, but you appear to be right. I cannot imagine how terrified the passengers must have been. Hopefully they all blacked out upon descent.
New World Ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
agent-maroon said:

Could a recorder box withstand an impact that left a crater? That's a lot of impact energy to create a crater that size without an explosive being involved

Possibly, yes. Both boxes from UA93 were found and had good data/recordings on them.
AvsB
How long do you want to ignore this user?
fc2112 said:

AvsB said:

Didn't read each post on this thread so sorry if it has been discussed...but in the still shot doesn't it look like the horizontal stabilizer is gone?

The still shot is one frame from a standard video camera trying to interpolate what it's seeing between frames. The HT missing could just be a digital artifact.

I hope so...
Rapier108
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Quote:

"A joint statement from the families of Adam Robinson, Helen Sharp, Emma and Charlie Robinson, Rachael Reed, Charmi Fehr and Anita Maria Apellido Cetina:

"With broken hearts, our families share that Adam Robinson and Helen Sharp, their children Emma and Charlie, Rachael Reed and Charmi Fehr, and Anita Maria Apellido Cetina were among those lost aboard the flight that went down near Greenacres, Florida, on November 1.

"Adam and Helen were devoted parents, and Emma, 4, and Charlie, 2, were the light of their lives. Helen and Adam were the love affair that will last forever. Their warmth, generosity and gift for making people feel welcome touched so many lives. Their loss will be felt deeply by all those who loved them and who they loved in return.

"Charmi and Rachel were full of joy and adventure. They loved their people fiercely, fully and without hesitation. From the moment they met, they were all in on each other and the life they were building. They are deeply loved, and we will miss them endlessly.

"Anita Maria cared for Emma and Charlie with tenderness and devotion, and she was truly part of the family. She showed us a legacy of unconditional love and devotion.


"We are deeply grateful to the first responders, investigators, and the Palm Beach County community for their care, and to everyone who has reached out with love. Our hearts are also with the families of the pilots, who are grieving alongside us.

<snip>

The captain was identified by TMZ as 55-year-old Jeff Gregory.

His co-pilot was 20-year-old Nathalia Gadelha who earned her pilot's license while still in high school. She was identified by her family, according to reports.

https://www.fox7austin.com/news/family-identifies-20-year-old-co-pilot-nathalia-gadelha-among-nine-killed-florida-learjet-crash
"If you will not fight for right when you can easily win without blood shed; if you will not fight when your victory is sure and not too costly; you may come to the moment when you will have to fight with all the odds against you and only a precarious chance of survival. There may even be a worse case. You may have to fight when there is no hope of victory, because it is better to perish than to live as slaves." - Sir Winston Churchill
akaggie05
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I'm of the opinion that the horizontal stabilizer was no longer with the aircraft upon impact, but assuming that's the case it will likely turn up somewhere nearby sooner rather than later. Should be a key piece of the investigation if it does.
Jetpilot86
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
If you look at the last 2 frames before impact, the plane is missing the horizontal stabilizer, and from the moment it ripped off, probably due to an overspeed, they were a crash, just looking for a place to happen, unfortunately.

My suspicion is that the ultimate cause will be flying into the top of thunderstorm over Palm Beach, icing up, stalling, and unable to recover before the speed ripped the tail off. In my world, we avoid red on the radar by 20 miles minimum at altitude. The copilot probably had at most between 509-750 Flight hours, certainly legal enough to fly the airplane, but not likely enough to fully comprehend what they were dealing with that caused the problems. That would most likely be the case if it was a he or she as copilot.

This will be a classic case of "get-there-itis", because the customer had to get there, and the crew didn't say "better if we wait"
jsc8116
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Could be somewhere in a swamp/everglades
agent-maroon
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
New World Ag said:

agent-maroon said:

Could a recorder box withstand an impact that left a crater? That's a lot of impact energy to create a crater that size without an explosive being involved

Possibly, yes. Both boxes from UA93 were found and had good data/recordings on them.

What are those boxes made of? Really hard to comprehend them surviving at all, much less having recoverable data.
No material on this site is intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. See full Medical Disclaimer.
akaggie05
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Yeah good point. Just like the Valujet DC-9 which got swallowed up entirely.
bonfarr
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
News reports say she had 1300 hours.
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.