Super long update:
Well this weekend was unfortunately another tuning session that didn't go as planned.
I'm not sure the severity of what is happening, so any knowledgeable input would be appreciated.
Here is the rundown:
Tuning session started with troubleshooting a few issues with sensors and the like, as well as getting a good baseline idle established.
After that was sound, we headed out for a drive, going south on 288. The tuner would log data from me driving, then we would stop and he would edit the file, while I checked for leaks, issues or concerns. Things were going great, no issues.
I started hearing some increased engine noise that I initially thought was exhaust leak. I also was observing the oil pressure running a bit lower, maybe around 20 psi. I more or less attributed this to the engine reallly getting up to operating temperature for the first time.
We had almost finished the normal driving tuning and were only going to do the WOT (wide open throttle) runs to get the upper powerband tuned.
We did one 3rd gear pull to about 4k RPM. The engine noise got much louder and I immediately noticed the oil psi gauge on 0!
I shut it off and pulled over. No leaks, plenty of oil on dipstick that looked clean. After thinking and checking we decided to start it up again and the oil pressure came up to about 10 psi and stabilized. Mystery noise was present but not as loud.
We made decision to limp it home and psi stayed around 10 or so.
Made it home and started it again to listen through a hose to pinpoint noise. Seems to emanate from valve train area. I next drained oil, no obvious shavings, flakes, glittery appearance or anything. Oil was dirty for low miles, but otherwise fine.
Decided to pull valve cover, rockers were all fine, none lose or damaged. At this point, I figure I'm all in, so I go ahead and pull the head to inspect for cam, lifter or pushrod damage.
Cam lobes that I could see seemed fine, with minimal mating wear:
Same for lifters:
Pistons and bores look fine, as well as combustion chambers on the heads, save for some carbon build up probably from when it was running rich. Plugs also seem ok.
I also cut the oil filter open to look for any sign of internal wear.
At this point I'm honed in on the oil pump, as there are many documented occurrences of the early LS oil pump failures. The pump's bypass valve sticks open and you basically get a very low pressure condition.
My presumption is the pump started failing, and pressure was too low to get oil up (and keep it) in the valve train, which was cause the lifters to clatter.
So, that's where I am now. Got a Melling 10295 pump coming tomorrow, I'll pull the old one tonight, maybe it will be obvious.
I've spent hours on LS1tech forums reading about all the disasters that could be in play. Spun bearings being the worst I can think of. However, I for sure never heard any knocking.
I feel like at this point I can also rule out major cam damage, based on what I saw.
Any comforting words from the autoboard experts?
All issues aside, when the car was running, it felt GREAT! I didn't have a chance to really open it up, but it was definitely pulling very hard when I would get on it. Hoping it's just a pump so I can start seeing what this thing will do!!