Trump and Russia Pivot - October 2026

53,889 Views | 986 Replies | Last: 11 hrs ago by Rossticus
Rossticus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
aggie93 said:

GeorgiAg said:

aggie93 said:

GeorgiAg said:

1939 said:

Zelensky is an absolute fool. This war would have been over years ago and hundreds of of thousands of lives saved if he wasn't such a narcissist idiot.

Putin is an absolute fool. The war should have never been started, and millions of lives saved.

The wild thing to me is both of you are right. Both Putin and Zelensky are fools. Well not really, both are bloodthirsty and corrupt narcissists that are more than willing to sacrifice human life for power without flinching. Trying to pick a side between them is like trying to choose sides in the Iran/Iraq war.

Iraq.

That's what we did, being Saddam's buddy was great. Still ended up getting ourselves in 2 wars with Iraq with very little to show for either in the end.

Zelenskyy has made it clear he is not our friend and is only interested in what money and supplies we can give him. That's never going to change.


Indulge me. How has he made it clear? The country, without money and supplies, ceases to exist. Of course that's his primary interest right now. They have, however, shared an awful lot of intel with us and have offered to assist in the maturation of our drone combat capabilities (where, frankly, we still lag behind them quite a bit. BTW, do you think we just really, really liked the French during the American revolution?
aggie93
How long do you want to ignore this user?
aginresearch said:

I don't buy we are on the brink of nuclear holocaust because Russia falls into civil war. I think they will all be fighting for their own power or survival. I don't want a land invasion that would be foolish. Just let Ukraine hollow them out. They've done a fabulous job of doing so with one hand tied behind their back and one of the legs knee capped. Stop doing that and just give them the funds to rain drones down on Moscow and St. Petersburg day and night, destroy their entire oil/gas infrastructure and slaughter their conscripts via drones on the front lines.

It'll be multiple generations before Russia is any real threat if they ever recover demographically. All I'm proposing is accelerating their demographic death. Who cares what they think? I don't. Next time start a war you can actually finish.

My point on civil war is we have no idea where that leads and more importantly there is little to gain by antagonizing Russia. If Ukraine wants to keep fighting ok, it's tragic to see hundreds of thousands of people die for a pointless war but it doesn't really impact us so I guess we can look away. The problem with supplying Ukraine is it makes it clear to Russia they are our enemy and they will continue to respond in kind. That means cyber attacks. That means supporting terrorism and Iran. That means allying with China and supplying them cheap oil and other resources. I don't think that's worth it so Ukraine can blow up refineries and bomb randomly around Russia.

I would rather just not have Russia as an enemy any more than necessary, especially because we have no real intention of actually defeating them. Lobbing drones isn't doing anything but really pissing them off and making them find ways to hurt us back.
aggie93
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Rossticus said:

aggie93 said:

GeorgiAg said:

aggie93 said:

GeorgiAg said:

1939 said:

Zelensky is an absolute fool. This war would have been over years ago and hundreds of of thousands of lives saved if he wasn't such a narcissist idiot.

Putin is an absolute fool. The war should have never been started, and millions of lives saved.

The wild thing to me is both of you are right. Both Putin and Zelensky are fools. Well not really, both are bloodthirsty and corrupt narcissists that are more than willing to sacrifice human life for power without flinching. Trying to pick a side between them is like trying to choose sides in the Iran/Iraq war.

Iraq.

That's what we did, being Saddam's buddy was great. Still ended up getting ourselves in 2 wars with Iraq with very little to show for either in the end.

Zelenskyy has made it clear he is not our friend and is only interested in what money and supplies we can give him. That's never going to change.


Indulge me. How has he made it clear? The country, without money and supplies, ceases to exist. Of course that's his primary interest right now. They have, however, shared an awful lot of intel with us and have offered to assist in the maturation of our drone combat capabilities (where, frankly, we still lag behind them quite a bit. BTW, do you think we just really, really liked the French during the American revolution?

Zelenskyy has thrown us under the bus and ignored us the moment it wasn't convenient for him. He has no interest in a peaceful solution. Every time we have threatened to slow money or supplies or support he tries to punish us and go against our interests. He isn't remotely our friend.
aggie93
How long do you want to ignore this user?
aginresearch said:

200B? It's actually $127B in direct funds, but I don't care about the exact number. We spend $20B+ a day. That's 10 days of expenditures of the federal government over almost 5 years! It's a rounding error of the US FedGov budget. I'd probably have spent 4 times that amount over 4 years. So about $800B and I'd pay for production of drone weaponry for the US military. It would be worth every penny. So about 5 days of spending per year.

Also, yeah, the Iran war was mismanaged from the drop. You blockade the SoH day 0. You eliminate their port facilities. You destroy their railyards. You destroy their energy/water infrastructure. Russia ain't keeping Iran afloat singlehandedly but every little bit helps towards Iran's capitulation.

You also claim that we have no strategic interest but I outlined how I see our strategic interest in Ukraine. There is strategic interest if you believe that Europe has strategic interest to us. If you don't then good luck because they've been the cause of most of the world's instability over the past 120 years

The problem with going after too much infrastructure is it works against the regime change idea. Iran is a very divided country and we aren't looking to hurt the many inside of Iran that want to get rid of the IRGC and mullahs. Destroying all of their civilian infrastructure takes the war to a completely different level. Now you can argue we should do it anyway and that's a decent point but realize doing so hurts a lot of innocent people who otherwise may be our allies.
Featured Video Previews
flown-the-coop
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Gordo14 said:

This is not a sudden flip. This has always been who Trump is and what Trump wants. It's been obvious for a long time his goal in getting peace is he and his family to make deals with Moscow at the expense of Europe. He's always admired and fantasized about Putin - Putin helps meet Trump's narcissistic supply needs. And losing the war in Iran means Ukraine has another purpose…. to blame for the situation he caused. Every step since day one has been against Ukraine and NATO and toward Russia. All that's happening is that it is accelerating.

It's depressing not only for how much this undermines America's interests for Donald Trump's interests…. But because Russia actively has helped Iran kill Americans, and Donald Trump actually doesn't care at all. Russia has been helping Iran with their ballistic missiles and providing updated satellite imagery of American military positions. Not only has Pete Hegseth stated this as fact to Congress, it's the only way that Iran could possibly have hit our AWACs in Saudi Arabia (as it was constantly being repositioned).

So my question is, how does this further America's interests? This will further Russia/Ukraine from peace (the closest path to peace is to make Russia realize it's against their interests to continue the war). Russia will be emboldened so why would they head to peace? This is the cost of personalized foreign policy from an "American interest" foreign policy. Trump now wants Ukraine to collapse as the fastest solution to "peace". Read between the lines. It's right in front of you, and accepting that truth is the first step to fixing this disaster. As the civilian population gets murdered by ballistic missiles, we are complicit.

The world is destabilizing at an accelerating rate and Donald Trump is the leading cause. The consequences are only going to continue to get worse. Destabilization will lead to less peace and deteriorating quality of life.

Tl;dr
Trump is Putins puppet and always has been. Trump hates Ukraine, always has. Trump is a grifter, always has been. Trump is worse than Hitler and is destroying the world.

How do we stop Trump? He must be stopped at all costs before he ruins the world!!!"
aggie93
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Gordo14 said:

This is not a sudden flip. This has always been who Trump is and what Trump wants. It's been obvious for a long time his goal in getting peace is he and his family to make deals with Moscow at the expense of Europe. He's always admired and fantasized about Putin - Putin helps meet Trump's narcissistic supply needs. And losing the war in Iran means Ukraine has another purpose…. to blame for the situation he caused. Every step since day one has been against Ukraine and NATO and toward Russia. All that's happening is that it is accelerating.

It's depressing not only for how much this undermines America's interests for Donald Trump's interests…. But because Russia actively has helped Iran kill Americans, and Donald Trump actually doesn't care at all. Russia has been helping Iran with their ballistic missiles and providing updated satellite imagery of American military positions. Not only has Pete Hegseth stated this as fact to Congress, it's the only way that Iran could possibly have hit our AWACs in Saudi Arabia (as it was constantly being repositioned).

So my question is, how does this further America's interests? This will further Russia/Ukraine from peace (the closest path to peace is to make Russia realize it's against their interests to continue the war). Russia will be emboldened so why would they head to peace? This is the cost of personalized foreign policy from an "American interest" foreign policy. Trump now wants Ukraine to collapse as the fastest solution to "peace". Read between the lines. It's right in front of you, and accepting that truth is the first step to fixing this disaster. As the civilian population gets murdered by ballistic missiles, we are complicit.

The world is destabilizing at an accelerating rate and Donald Trump is the leading cause. The consequences are only going to continue to get worse. Destabilization will lead to less peace and deteriorating quality of life.

If you think this is about Trump loving Putin or wanting to make money off of Russia that's beyond laughable. Trump has hit Putin harder than Obama or Biden ever did and done so multiple times. He just also understands the reality that Putin isn't going anywhere the same as Xi or Kim so it's a lot smarter to deal with the reality of the situation. He also understands that Zelenskyy is just as bad as Putin, he just doesn't have as much power.

Of course Russia i hurting us any way they can. We are supplying Ukraine to bomb them. Did you think they would just sit back and take it? We can never trust Russia but antagonizing them is foolish if we have no realistic plan of defeating them. The only US interests served by that is the military industrial complex that desperately misses the Cold War still.
Teslag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
aggie93 said:

Rossticus said:

aggie93 said:

GeorgiAg said:

aggie93 said:

GeorgiAg said:

1939 said:

Zelensky is an absolute fool. This war would have been over years ago and hundreds of of thousands of lives saved if he wasn't such a narcissist idiot.

Putin is an absolute fool. The war should have never been started, and millions of lives saved.

The wild thing to me is both of you are right. Both Putin and Zelensky are fools. Well not really, both are bloodthirsty and corrupt narcissists that are more than willing to sacrifice human life for power without flinching. Trying to pick a side between them is like trying to choose sides in the Iran/Iraq war.

Iraq.

That's what we did, being Saddam's buddy was great. Still ended up getting ourselves in 2 wars with Iraq with very little to show for either in the end.

Zelenskyy has made it clear he is not our friend and is only interested in what money and supplies we can give him. That's never going to change.


Indulge me. How has he made it clear? The country, without money and supplies, ceases to exist. Of course that's his primary interest right now. They have, however, shared an awful lot of intel with us and have offered to assist in the maturation of our drone combat capabilities (where, frankly, we still lag behind them quite a bit. BTW, do you think we just really, really liked the French during the American revolution?

Zelenskyy has thrown us under the bus and ignored us the moment it wasn't convenient for him. He has no interest in a peaceful solution. Every time we have threatened to slow money or supplies or support he tries to punish us and go against our interests. He isn't remotely our friend.


This narrative needs to stop. Zelenskyy has stated he's open to a ceasefire along CURRENT lines even as his forces continue to make gains against Russia. Putin has rejected that and has stated they will not accept any deal where Ukraine doesn't give up land that Russia doesn't even currently occupy in the Donbas.
Teslag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
We also need to drop this idea that the war is being pushed by Zelenskyy and him alone. If he's removed, the most popular man in Ukraine to replace him is former General Valerii Zaluzhnyi who is even more anti Russia than Zelenskyy. Ukraine will keep fighting. Without Zelenskyy and without our help. It's for their survival. And history shows people will literally fight to their own deaths for that.
Jeeper79
How long do you want to ignore this user?
aggie93 said:

Gordo14 said:

This is not a sudden flip. This has always been who Trump is and what Trump wants. It's been obvious for a long time his goal in getting peace is he and his family to make deals with Moscow at the expense of Europe. He's always admired and fantasized about Putin - Putin helps meet Trump's narcissistic supply needs. And losing the war in Iran means Ukraine has another purpose…. to blame for the situation he caused. Every step since day one has been against Ukraine and NATO and toward Russia. All that's happening is that it is accelerating.

It's depressing not only for how much this undermines America's interests for Donald Trump's interests…. But because Russia actively has helped Iran kill Americans, and Donald Trump actually doesn't care at all. Russia has been helping Iran with their ballistic missiles and providing updated satellite imagery of American military positions. Not only has Pete Hegseth stated this as fact to Congress, it's the only way that Iran could possibly have hit our AWACs in Saudi Arabia (as it was constantly being repositioned).

So my question is, how does this further America's interests? This will further Russia/Ukraine from peace (the closest path to peace is to make Russia realize it's against their interests to continue the war). Russia will be emboldened so why would they head to peace? This is the cost of personalized foreign policy from an "American interest" foreign policy. Trump now wants Ukraine to collapse as the fastest solution to "peace". Read between the lines. It's right in front of you, and accepting that truth is the first step to fixing this disaster. As the civilian population gets murdered by ballistic missiles, we are complicit.

The world is destabilizing at an accelerating rate and Donald Trump is the leading cause. The consequences are only going to continue to get worse. Destabilization will lead to less peace and deteriorating quality of life.

If you think this is about Trump loving Putin or wanting to make money off of Russia that's beyond laughable. Trump has hit Putin harder than Obama or Biden ever did and done so multiple times. He just also understands the reality that Putin isn't going anywhere the same as Xi or Kim so it's a lot smarter to deal with the reality of the situation. He also understands that Zelenskyy is just as bad as Putin, he just doesn't have as much power.

Of course Russia i hurting us any way they can. We are supplying Ukraine to bomb them. Did you think they would just sit back and take it? We can never trust Russia but antagonizing them is foolish if we have no realistic plan of defeating them. The only US interests served by that is the military industrial complex that desperately misses the Cold War still.
You think Russia's antagonism towards started with this war?
aggie93
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Teslag said:

aggie93 said:

Rossticus said:

aggie93 said:

GeorgiAg said:

aggie93 said:

GeorgiAg said:

1939 said:

Zelensky is an absolute fool. This war would have been over years ago and hundreds of of thousands of lives saved if he wasn't such a narcissist idiot.

Putin is an absolute fool. The war should have never been started, and millions of lives saved.

The wild thing to me is both of you are right. Both Putin and Zelensky are fools. Well not really, both are bloodthirsty and corrupt narcissists that are more than willing to sacrifice human life for power without flinching. Trying to pick a side between them is like trying to choose sides in the Iran/Iraq war.

Iraq.

That's what we did, being Saddam's buddy was great. Still ended up getting ourselves in 2 wars with Iraq with very little to show for either in the end.

Zelenskyy has made it clear he is not our friend and is only interested in what money and supplies we can give him. That's never going to change.


Indulge me. How has he made it clear? The country, without money and supplies, ceases to exist. Of course that's his primary interest right now. They have, however, shared an awful lot of intel with us and have offered to assist in the maturation of our drone combat capabilities (where, frankly, we still lag behind them quite a bit. BTW, do you think we just really, really liked the French during the American revolution?

Zelenskyy has thrown us under the bus and ignored us the moment it wasn't convenient for him. He has no interest in a peaceful solution. Every time we have threatened to slow money or supplies or support he tries to punish us and go against our interests. He isn't remotely our friend.


This narrative needs to stop. Zelenskyy has stated he's open to a ceasefire along CURRENT lines even as his forces continue to make gains against Russia. Putin has rejected that and has stated they will not accept any deal where Ukraine doesn't give up land that Russia doesn't even currently occupy in the Donbas.

Zelenskyy has walked away from every peace deal and anytime it gets close he finds a reason to blow it up. Has Putin done the same at times? Sure, they both suck is the point. Yet it seems people think that because Putin is bad that means Zelenkyy is good which couldn't be more wrong. These are terrible people.
GeorgiAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I haven't seen any good arguments for why we would support Russia over Ukraine. Or why we would NOT support Ukraine.

We have key and good Allies all over Europe that we worked very hard to cultivate - WWII, Cold War and since. Why are we going to throw that in the toilet? So we can cozy up to a dictator that would throw us under the bus in a heartbeat? Russia needs to get with the program or at least stay in their little corner and play nice-nice. A return to Russia controlling the Eastern Bloc is a recipe for disaster. A strong Russia is not our ally.

Trump has always had a weird fascination with Russia. No one has figured out why. Pee pee tapes or he just thinks he personally can enrich himself or his family. I think he sees Putin and how the oligarchy saddles up to him as a roadmap for ideal governance in the US.

Biden, Burisma, blah, blah, blah. All corruption should be rooted out and prosecuted.
aggie93
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Jeeper79 said:

aggie93 said:

Gordo14 said:

This is not a sudden flip. This has always been who Trump is and what Trump wants. It's been obvious for a long time his goal in getting peace is he and his family to make deals with Moscow at the expense of Europe. He's always admired and fantasized about Putin - Putin helps meet Trump's narcissistic supply needs. And losing the war in Iran means Ukraine has another purpose…. to blame for the situation he caused. Every step since day one has been against Ukraine and NATO and toward Russia. All that's happening is that it is accelerating.

It's depressing not only for how much this undermines America's interests for Donald Trump's interests…. But because Russia actively has helped Iran kill Americans, and Donald Trump actually doesn't care at all. Russia has been helping Iran with their ballistic missiles and providing updated satellite imagery of American military positions. Not only has Pete Hegseth stated this as fact to Congress, it's the only way that Iran could possibly have hit our AWACs in Saudi Arabia (as it was constantly being repositioned).

So my question is, how does this further America's interests? This will further Russia/Ukraine from peace (the closest path to peace is to make Russia realize it's against their interests to continue the war). Russia will be emboldened so why would they head to peace? This is the cost of personalized foreign policy from an "American interest" foreign policy. Trump now wants Ukraine to collapse as the fastest solution to "peace". Read between the lines. It's right in front of you, and accepting that truth is the first step to fixing this disaster. As the civilian population gets murdered by ballistic missiles, we are complicit.

The world is destabilizing at an accelerating rate and Donald Trump is the leading cause. The consequences are only going to continue to get worse. Destabilization will lead to less peace and deteriorating quality of life.

If you think this is about Trump loving Putin or wanting to make money off of Russia that's beyond laughable. Trump has hit Putin harder than Obama or Biden ever did and done so multiple times. He just also understands the reality that Putin isn't going anywhere the same as Xi or Kim so it's a lot smarter to deal with the reality of the situation. He also understands that Zelenskyy is just as bad as Putin, he just doesn't have as much power.

Of course Russia i hurting us any way they can. We are supplying Ukraine to bomb them. Did you think they would just sit back and take it? We can never trust Russia but antagonizing them is foolish if we have no realistic plan of defeating them. The only US interests served by that is the military industrial complex that desperately misses the Cold War still.

You think Russia's antagonism towards started with this war?

The war was started because that idiot Biden effectively said he wouldn't do anything if Russia invaded Ukraine and Putin decided to test him out. This war started under Biden not Trump and there is no way Russia would have invaded had Trump won in 2020. Trump kicked the crap out of Putin in Syria and hit him in the nuts multiple times and Putin just waited him out. The problem now is trying to find a way out when both sides can't afford to be seen as surrendering. You always see people default to Putin is evil and we can't let him win! Ok, well are you ready to invade Russia or not? No, well you better find a way to suck it up and make a peace deal then because he isn't going to just quit. Folks just don't want to face that reality because it is much easier just to keep sending young men on both sides into the meat grinder because it doesn't impact them.
Teslag
How long do you want to ignore this user?

Quote:

Zelenskyy has walked away from every peace deal and anytime it gets close he finds a reason to blow it up


This simply isn't rooted in fact. Zelenskyy has been consistent with his ceasefire request along current lines. Lavrov and Putin rebufff every time. Most recently he even agreed to an "energy ceasefire" that Trump proposed only to have Russia immediately hit Ukrainian electrical infrastructure claiming they only meant refineries knowing full Ukraine has none working at the moment.
twelve12twelve
How long do you want to ignore this user?
aggie93 said:

Jeeper79 said:

aggie93 said:

Gordo14 said:

This is not a sudden flip. This has always been who Trump is and what Trump wants. It's been obvious for a long time his goal in getting peace is he and his family to make deals with Moscow at the expense of Europe. He's always admired and fantasized about Putin - Putin helps meet Trump's narcissistic supply needs. And losing the war in Iran means Ukraine has another purpose…. to blame for the situation he caused. Every step since day one has been against Ukraine and NATO and toward Russia. All that's happening is that it is accelerating.

It's depressing not only for how much this undermines America's interests for Donald Trump's interests…. But because Russia actively has helped Iran kill Americans, and Donald Trump actually doesn't care at all. Russia has been helping Iran with their ballistic missiles and providing updated satellite imagery of American military positions. Not only has Pete Hegseth stated this as fact to Congress, it's the only way that Iran could possibly have hit our AWACs in Saudi Arabia (as it was constantly being repositioned).

So my question is, how does this further America's interests? This will further Russia/Ukraine from peace (the closest path to peace is to make Russia realize it's against their interests to continue the war). Russia will be emboldened so why would they head to peace? This is the cost of personalized foreign policy from an "American interest" foreign policy. Trump now wants Ukraine to collapse as the fastest solution to "peace". Read between the lines. It's right in front of you, and accepting that truth is the first step to fixing this disaster. As the civilian population gets murdered by ballistic missiles, we are complicit.

The world is destabilizing at an accelerating rate and Donald Trump is the leading cause. The consequences are only going to continue to get worse. Destabilization will lead to less peace and deteriorating quality of life.

If you think this is about Trump loving Putin or wanting to make money off of Russia that's beyond laughable. Trump has hit Putin harder than Obama or Biden ever did and done so multiple times. He just also understands the reality that Putin isn't going anywhere the same as Xi or Kim so it's a lot smarter to deal with the reality of the situation. He also understands that Zelenskyy is just as bad as Putin, he just doesn't have as much power.

Of course Russia i hurting us any way they can. We are supplying Ukraine to bomb them. Did you think they would just sit back and take it? We can never trust Russia but antagonizing them is foolish if we have no realistic plan of defeating them. The only US interests served by that is the military industrial complex that desperately misses the Cold War still.

You think Russia's antagonism towards started with this war?

The war was started because that idiot Biden effectively said he wouldn't do anything if Russia invaded Ukraine and Putin decided to test him out. This war started under Biden not Trump and there is no way Russia would have invaded had Trump won in 2020. Trump kicked the crap out of Putin in Syria and hit him in the nuts multiple times and Putin just waited him out. The problem now is trying to find a way out when both sides can't afford to be seen as surrendering. You always see people default to Putin is evil and we can't let him win! Ok, well are you ready to invade Russia or not? No, well you better find a way to suck it up and make a peace deal then because he isn't going to just quit. Folks just don't want to face that reality because it is much easier just to keep sending young men on both sides into the meat grinder because it doesn't impact them.

He isn't making a peace deal no matter how much you want to opine and act like you know anything about Russia or this conflict.
GeorgiAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
aggie93 said:

Jeeper79 said:

aggie93 said:

Gordo14 said:

This is not a sudden flip. This has always been who Trump is and what Trump wants. It's been obvious for a long time his goal in getting peace is he and his family to make deals with Moscow at the expense of Europe. He's always admired and fantasized about Putin - Putin helps meet Trump's narcissistic supply needs. And losing the war in Iran means Ukraine has another purpose…. to blame for the situation he caused. Every step since day one has been against Ukraine and NATO and toward Russia. All that's happening is that it is accelerating.

It's depressing not only for how much this undermines America's interests for Donald Trump's interests…. But because Russia actively has helped Iran kill Americans, and Donald Trump actually doesn't care at all. Russia has been helping Iran with their ballistic missiles and providing updated satellite imagery of American military positions. Not only has Pete Hegseth stated this as fact to Congress, it's the only way that Iran could possibly have hit our AWACs in Saudi Arabia (as it was constantly being repositioned).

So my question is, how does this further America's interests? This will further Russia/Ukraine from peace (the closest path to peace is to make Russia realize it's against their interests to continue the war). Russia will be emboldened so why would they head to peace? This is the cost of personalized foreign policy from an "American interest" foreign policy. Trump now wants Ukraine to collapse as the fastest solution to "peace". Read between the lines. It's right in front of you, and accepting that truth is the first step to fixing this disaster. As the civilian population gets murdered by ballistic missiles, we are complicit.

The world is destabilizing at an accelerating rate and Donald Trump is the leading cause. The consequences are only going to continue to get worse. Destabilization will lead to less peace and deteriorating quality of life.

If you think this is about Trump loving Putin or wanting to make money off of Russia that's beyond laughable. Trump has hit Putin harder than Obama or Biden ever did and done so multiple times. He just also understands the reality that Putin isn't going anywhere the same as Xi or Kim so it's a lot smarter to deal with the reality of the situation. He also understands that Zelenskyy is just as bad as Putin, he just doesn't have as much power.

Of course Russia i hurting us any way they can. We are supplying Ukraine to bomb them. Did you think they would just sit back and take it? We can never trust Russia but antagonizing them is foolish if we have no realistic plan of defeating them. The only US interests served by that is the military industrial complex that desperately misses the Cold War still.

You think Russia's antagonism towards started with this war?

The war was started because that idiot Biden effectively said he wouldn't do anything if Russia invaded Ukraine and Putin decided to test him out. This war started under Biden not Trump and there is no way Russia would have invaded had Trump won in 2020. Trump kicked the crap out of Putin in Syria and hit him in the nuts multiple times and Putin just waited him out. The problem now is trying to find a way out when both sides can't afford to be seen as surrendering. You always see people default to Putin is evil and we can't let him win! Ok, well are you ready to invade Russia or not? No, well you better find a way to suck it up and make a peace deal then because he isn't going to just quit. Folks just don't want to face that reality because it is much easier just to keep sending young men on both sides into the meat grinder because it doesn't impact them.

B.S. Trump publicly said Putin was "smart" for invading Ukraine.

Trump "kicked the crap out of Putin in Syria." So why isn't he doing that now? Dang, all you have to do is let him have Starlink and Starshield and a little support and Ukraine is winning. The longer this drags on, the more pressure on Putin.

No one is "invading Russia."
Silent For Too Long
How long do you want to ignore this user?
twelve12twelve said:

aggie93 said:

Jeeper79 said:

aggie93 said:

Gordo14 said:

This is not a sudden flip. This has always been who Trump is and what Trump wants. It's been obvious for a long time his goal in getting peace is he and his family to make deals with Moscow at the expense of Europe. He's always admired and fantasized about Putin - Putin helps meet Trump's narcissistic supply needs. And losing the war in Iran means Ukraine has another purpose…. to blame for the situation he caused. Every step since day one has been against Ukraine and NATO and toward Russia. All that's happening is that it is accelerating.

It's depressing not only for how much this undermines America's interests for Donald Trump's interests…. But because Russia actively has helped Iran kill Americans, and Donald Trump actually doesn't care at all. Russia has been helping Iran with their ballistic missiles and providing updated satellite imagery of American military positions. Not only has Pete Hegseth stated this as fact to Congress, it's the only way that Iran could possibly have hit our AWACs in Saudi Arabia (as it was constantly being repositioned).

So my question is, how does this further America's interests? This will further Russia/Ukraine from peace (the closest path to peace is to make Russia realize it's against their interests to continue the war). Russia will be emboldened so why would they head to peace? This is the cost of personalized foreign policy from an "American interest" foreign policy. Trump now wants Ukraine to collapse as the fastest solution to "peace". Read between the lines. It's right in front of you, and accepting that truth is the first step to fixing this disaster. As the civilian population gets murdered by ballistic missiles, we are complicit.

The world is destabilizing at an accelerating rate and Donald Trump is the leading cause. The consequences are only going to continue to get worse. Destabilization will lead to less peace and deteriorating quality of life.

If you think this is about Trump loving Putin or wanting to make money off of Russia that's beyond laughable. Trump has hit Putin harder than Obama or Biden ever did and done so multiple times. He just also understands the reality that Putin isn't going anywhere the same as Xi or Kim so it's a lot smarter to deal with the reality of the situation. He also understands that Zelenskyy is just as bad as Putin, he just doesn't have as much power.

Of course Russia i hurting us any way they can. We are supplying Ukraine to bomb them. Did you think they would just sit back and take it? We can never trust Russia but antagonizing them is foolish if we have no realistic plan of defeating them. The only US interests served by that is the military industrial complex that desperately misses the Cold War still.

You think Russia's antagonism towards started with this war?

The war was started because that idiot Biden effectively said he wouldn't do anything if Russia invaded Ukraine and Putin decided to test him out. This war started under Biden not Trump and there is no way Russia would have invaded had Trump won in 2020. Trump kicked the crap out of Putin in Syria and hit him in the nuts multiple times and Putin just waited him out. The problem now is trying to find a way out when both sides can't afford to be seen as surrendering. You always see people default to Putin is evil and we can't let him win! Ok, well are you ready to invade Russia or not? No, well you better find a way to suck it up and make a peace deal then because he isn't going to just quit. Folks just don't want to face that reality because it is much easier just to keep sending young men on both sides into the meat grinder because it doesn't impact them.

He isn't making a peace deal no matter how much you want to opine and act like you know anything about Russia or this conflict.


Ironic post is ironic
joekm3
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Ellis Wyatt said:

Old McDonald said:

turns out the russiagaters weren't wrong, just early

nonsense


And you expected anything else from this fraudulent farmer?
aggie93
How long do you want to ignore this user?
GeorgiAg said:

I haven't seen any good arguments for why we would support Russia over Ukraine. Or why we would NOT support Ukraine.

We have key and good Allies all over Europe that we worked very hard to cultivate - WWII, Cold War and since. Why are we going to throw that in the toilet? So we can cozy up to a dictator that would throw us under the bus in a heartbeat? Russia needs to get with the program or at least stay in their little corner and play nice-nice. A return to Russia controlling the Eastern Bloc is a recipe for disaster. A strong Russia is not our ally.

Trump has always had a weird fascination with Russia. No one has figured out why. Pee pee tapes or he just thinks he personally can enrich himself or his family. I think he sees Putin and how the oligarchy saddles up to him as a roadmap for ideal governance in the US.

Biden, Burisma, blah, blah, blah. All corruption should be rooted out and prosecuted.

We shouldn't "support" Russia or Ukraine is the point. Both are deeply corrupt countries fighting a war that has little impact on us. Both are led by dictators that have stolen billions from their people and are fine with sending hundreds of thousands to die with no reservations about it.

The rest of your argument is based around a Cold War mindset of a Europe and USSR that aren't remotely what they were. I lived in Germany in the '80s btw and went to the Wall both on the East/West border and to Berlin and through Checkpoint Charlie into East Berlin with Russian soldiers pointing guns at my teenage self. My Dad was in the HQ building at Ramstein when a Russian funded terrorist bombed it (he was fine). That world doesn't exist anymore. Russia is a declining power that has gotten back to it's roots prior to the USSR, they aren't communist and aren't spreading communism. Russia is now very nationalistic and trying to protect itself as it is in a demographic death spiral. They have nearly impossible to defend borders and a GDP smaller than Texas. They are dangerous but mostly dangerous if you tangle with them, they have little ability to project power outside of cyber, nukes, and selling weapons to bad guys.

Europe also isn't the same. They are incredibly weak with pathetic militaries. They are hostile to the US as often as they are our friends. They have refused to help in Iran in spite of it also being in their interests because they have allowed so many muslims to come into their countries they fear what is happening in Paris right now. It is a one way friendship.
Silent For Too Long
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Tarponfly said:

I can't believe there are people here that will contort themselves into believing that Trump supporting Putin through a deal that most of the Congress and the American people oppose is somehow MAGA. The entire notion is insulting and throwing Ukraine under the bust to help Russia is stupid. Trump needs to get over his love of foreign dictators. Zelenski has not sown for peace because Putin will not agree to end the war without Ukraine losing their sovereignty. Period. Trump cannot leave office fast enough for me after this debacle.


2.5 more years. Better stock up on tissues and tampons.
Red Fishing Ag93
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Zelensky walked because of "security guarantees" that read like Article 5 of NATO.

That's NATO, MIC, and EU talking, not Zelenksky.

This whole conflict started when NATO, the MIC, and Ukraine money launderers pushed for entry into NATO. Can't remember if that was before or after Ukraine bombed it's own people in Eastern Ukraine and killed thousands. About the same time, I believe.

And there's so much more to the conflict.

But Zelensky is a puppet. And now he bombing fuel depots that supply the world just before mid-terms. Has yet to call out Europe for the 10x that "support" that they give Russia.

Might as well have CHINA build a base in Mexico City and sit and watch if we blame Putin here.
joekm3
How long do you want to ignore this user?
t_J_e_C_x said:

Queso1 said:

He's trying to fix the Iran fuel disaster.


That he created... By going to a bad faith actor whose been supplying Iran with the means to continue said disaster??


I appreciate your contributions. It makes life so easy. All I need to do is see your posts and choose the opposite position and know that I will be on the RIGHT side of history. Many thanks!
twelve12twelve
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Red Fishing Ag93 said:

Zelensky walked because of "security guarantees" that read like Article 5 of NATO.

That's NATO, MIC, and EU talking, not Zelenksky.

This whole conflict started when NATO, the MIC, and Ukraine money launderers pushed for entry into NATO. Can't remember if that was before or after Ukraine bombed it's own people in Eastern Ukraine and killed thousands. About the same time, I believe.

And there's so much more to the conflict.

But Zelensky is a puppet. And now he bombing fuel depots that supply the world just before mid-terms. Has yet to call out Europe for the 10x that "support" that they give Russia.

Might as well have CHINA build a base in Mexico City and sit and watch if we blame Putin here.

Oh wow, the country that was invaded wants some kind of guarantee that it won't happen in the immediate future. The horror!
Teslag
How long do you want to ignore this user?

Quote:

Both are led by dictators that have stolen billions from their people and are fine with sending hundreds of thousands to die with no reservations about it.



This is terrible equivocation. The Ukrainians aren't being "sent" anywhere. They are home, fighting a foreign enemy on their doorstep and in their very own backyard. And no, I'm not for a single second going to believe the Russian state media narratives that most Ukrainian soldiers are rounded up against their will. Are some conscripted? Of course, just an as in all wars (included us with WW2 and The Civil War). But by and large these are people literally defending their homeland against foreign invasion.

And they'll keep doing that with or without Zelenskyy.
AuditAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Red Fishing Ag93 said:

Zelensky walked because of "security guarantees" that read like Article 5 of NATO.

That's NATO, MIC, and EU talking, not Zelenksky.

This whole conflict started when NATO, the MIC, and Ukraine money launderers pushed for entry into NATO. Can't remember if that was before or after Ukraine bombed it's own people in Eastern Ukraine and killed thousands. About the same time, I believe.

And there's so much more to the conflict.

But Zelensky is a puppet. And now he bombing fuel depots that supply the world just before mid-terms. Has yet to call out Europe for the 10x that "support" that they give Russia.

Might as well have CHINA build a base in Mexico City and sit and watch if we blame Putin here.



Some of this is a fair debate, some of it isn't.
NATO expansion as a Russian grievance? Sure, serious people argue that. But "Ukraine bombed its own people in 2014" skips the part where Russian-backed armed groups seized government buildings first, and Russian troops were documented fighting there. About 14k died on all sides, including roughly 3,400 civilians killed by shelling from both directions. That's a war, not a massacre.
The "Europe gives Russia 10x" line was half-true in 2022, when the EU paid more for Russian gas than it sent Kyiv. That flipped a couple years ago. And Zelensky has called out Hungary and Slovakia over Russian energy repeatedly.
On the oil strikes: they've been running since 2024, not timed to midterms, and Trump himself said they could help end the war.
The Mexico analogy is worth thinking about. But the invasion put Finland and Sweden in NATO, so if the goal was keeping NATO away, it backfired.
Jeeper79
How long do you want to ignore this user?
aggie93 said:

GeorgiAg said:

I haven't seen any good arguments for why we would support Russia over Ukraine. Or why we would NOT support Ukraine.

We have key and good Allies all over Europe that we worked very hard to cultivate - WWII, Cold War and since. Why are we going to throw that in the toilet? So we can cozy up to a dictator that would throw us under the bus in a heartbeat? Russia needs to get with the program or at least stay in their little corner and play nice-nice. A return to Russia controlling the Eastern Bloc is a recipe for disaster. A strong Russia is not our ally.

Trump has always had a weird fascination with Russia. No one has figured out why. Pee pee tapes or he just thinks he personally can enrich himself or his family. I think he sees Putin and how the oligarchy saddles up to him as a roadmap for ideal governance in the US.

Biden, Burisma, blah, blah, blah. All corruption should be rooted out and prosecuted.

We shouldn't "support" Russia or Ukraine is the point.

Then why are we supporting Russia? (And you seem pretty ok with that.)
1939
How long do you want to ignore this user?
GeorgiAg said:

I haven't seen any good arguments for why we would support Russia over Ukraine. Or why we would NOT support Ukraine.

We have key and good Allies all over Europe that we worked very hard to cultivate - WWII, Cold War and since. Why are we going to throw that in the toilet? So we can cozy up to a dictator that would throw us under the bus in a heartbeat? Russia needs to get with the program or at least stay in their little corner and play nice-nice. A return to Russia controlling the Eastern Bloc is a recipe for disaster. A strong Russia is not our ally.

Trump has always had a weird fascination with Russia. No one has figured out why. Pee pee tapes or he just thinks he personally can enrich himself or his family. I think he sees Putin and how the oligarchy saddles up to him as a roadmap for ideal governance in the US.

Biden, Burisma, blah, blah, blah. All corruption should be rooted out and prosecuted.


People just want it end. That doesn't mean you support Russia. They realize that Ukraine can't win, so the option is continue to do the same thing for who knows how long until Putin eventually gets what he wants or negotiate an end to it now so Ukraine least continue to exist in some form.

Your TDS is in the way of clear thinking. You have continually made it clear that you want this to go on indefinitely and that you have no answers as to what we should do other than doubling down and trying to overthrow Putin. This garbage about Trump loving Putin is just that, garbage. It's been drilled into your head by the left and you lapped it up like an obedient dog capitulating to your master. What good is going to come from that?
Teslag
How long do you want to ignore this user?

Quote:

People just want it end.


Russia doesn't. They could literally end this any day. Hell, they could literally end it along current lines, keep what they have gained, and walk away and Zelenskyy would be fine with it.

But they won't. Why is that?
Silent For Too Long
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Teslag said:


Quote:

People just want it end.


Russia doesn't. They could literally end this any day. Hell, they could literally end it along current lines, keep what they have gained, and walk away and Zelenskyy would be fine with it.

But they won't. Why is that?


What is your evidence for that?
aggie93
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Teslag said:


Quote:

Both are led by dictators that have stolen billions from their people and are fine with sending hundreds of thousands to die with no reservations about it.



This is terrible equivocation. The Ukrainians aren't being "sent" anywhere. They are home, fighting a foreign enemy on their doorstep and in their very own backyard. And no, I'm not for a single second going to believe the Russian state media narratives that most Ukrainian soldiers are rounded up against their will. Are some conscripted? Of course, just an as in all wars (included us with WW2 and The Civil War). But by and large these are people literally defending their homeland against foreign invasion.

And they'll keep doing that with or without Zelenskyy.

You do realize Ukraine has barely ever been a country alone, right? The Donbass region especially is at best disputed. Crimea even moreso which never made sense as being Ukrainian. It made little sense when the Soviet Union broke up to make them Ukranian and the only way it worked was for Ukraine to either be a Russian ally or neutral. This war is also about who controls Ukraine not Ukraine's independence unless you honestly think that's the intent with Zelenskyy and Ukraine from the European countries. It is a bone being fought over just as it has for 1000 years as a resource rich land with no natural protective borders.

There are no good guys in this war. I know many really want there to be because Putin is a bad guy but Zelenskyy is every bit as ruthless. He's just a different style of ruthless. He is also definitely a dictator who sure as hell doesn't want elections or anyone threatening his power.

It's very difficult for most but it is really important to step back and look at the big picture in this and not assume either side is the "good guys". At best is is about who is "least bad". What we should care about though is about what matters to the US interests though and not jumping in the middle of a war that seems to have no end.
1939
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Teslag said:


Quote:

People just want it end.


Russia doesn't. They could literally end this any day. Hell, they could literally end it along current lines, keep what they have gained, and walk away and Zelenskyy would be fine with it.

But they won't. Why is that?


Of course they could. The same could be said about Zelenskyy. That's the point, neither of them want it end.

What isn't true is that Zelenskyy is ready to make a deal right now, that is just flat out false.

Yes, this war is Putin's fault. Everyone agrees with that, but at this point it doesn't matter.
aggie93
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Jeeper79 said:

aggie93 said:

GeorgiAg said:

I haven't seen any good arguments for why we would support Russia over Ukraine. Or why we would NOT support Ukraine.

We have key and good Allies all over Europe that we worked very hard to cultivate - WWII, Cold War and since. Why are we going to throw that in the toilet? So we can cozy up to a dictator that would throw us under the bus in a heartbeat? Russia needs to get with the program or at least stay in their little corner and play nice-nice. A return to Russia controlling the Eastern Bloc is a recipe for disaster. A strong Russia is not our ally.

Trump has always had a weird fascination with Russia. No one has figured out why. Pee pee tapes or he just thinks he personally can enrich himself or his family. I think he sees Putin and how the oligarchy saddles up to him as a roadmap for ideal governance in the US.

Biden, Burisma, blah, blah, blah. All corruption should be rooted out and prosecuted.

We shouldn't "support" Russia or Ukraine is the point.

Then why are we supporting Russia? (And you seem pretty ok with that.)

We aren't. We are supporting peace and an end to the conflict. That means working with both sides and protecting our interests.
1939
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Jeeper79 said:

aggie93 said:

GeorgiAg said:

I haven't seen any good arguments for why we would support Russia over Ukraine. Or why we would NOT support Ukraine.

We have key and good Allies all over Europe that we worked very hard to cultivate - WWII, Cold War and since. Why are we going to throw that in the toilet? So we can cozy up to a dictator that would throw us under the bus in a heartbeat? Russia needs to get with the program or at least stay in their little corner and play nice-nice. A return to Russia controlling the Eastern Bloc is a recipe for disaster. A strong Russia is not our ally.

Trump has always had a weird fascination with Russia. No one has figured out why. Pee pee tapes or he just thinks he personally can enrich himself or his family. I think he sees Putin and how the oligarchy saddles up to him as a roadmap for ideal governance in the US.

Biden, Burisma, blah, blah, blah. All corruption should be rooted out and prosecuted.

We shouldn't "support" Russia or Ukraine is the point.

Then why are we supporting Russia? (And you seem pretty ok with that.)


Please explain how we are supporting Russia when we've spend hundreds of billions supplying Ukraine. That's just more stupidity and TDS.
Silent For Too Long
How long do you want to ignore this user?
aggie93 said:

Jeeper79 said:

aggie93 said:

GeorgiAg said:

I haven't seen any good arguments for why we would support Russia over Ukraine. Or why we would NOT support Ukraine.

We have key and good Allies all over Europe that we worked very hard to cultivate - WWII, Cold War and since. Why are we going to throw that in the toilet? So we can cozy up to a dictator that would throw us under the bus in a heartbeat? Russia needs to get with the program or at least stay in their little corner and play nice-nice. A return to Russia controlling the Eastern Bloc is a recipe for disaster. A strong Russia is not our ally.

Trump has always had a weird fascination with Russia. No one has figured out why. Pee pee tapes or he just thinks he personally can enrich himself or his family. I think he sees Putin and how the oligarchy saddles up to him as a roadmap for ideal governance in the US.

Biden, Burisma, blah, blah, blah. All corruption should be rooted out and prosecuted.

We shouldn't "support" Russia or Ukraine is the point.

Then why are we supporting Russia? (And you seem pretty ok with that.)

We aren't. We are supporting peace and an end to the conflict. That means working with both sides and protecting our interests.
Teslag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Silent For Too Long said:

Teslag said:


Quote:

People just want it end.


Russia doesn't. They could literally end this any day. Hell, they could literally end it along current lines, keep what they have gained, and walk away and Zelenskyy would be fine with it.

But they won't. Why is that?


What is your evidence for that?


Zelenskyy's own words proposing a ceasefire along current lines to his very own ambassadors on August 3rd.



Jeeper79
How long do you want to ignore this user?
aggie93 said:

Teslag said:


Quote:

Both are led by dictators that have stolen billions from their people and are fine with sending hundreds of thousands to die with no reservations about it.



This is terrible equivocation. The Ukrainians aren't being "sent" anywhere. They are home, fighting a foreign enemy on their doorstep and in their very own backyard. And no, I'm not for a single second going to believe the Russian state media narratives that most Ukrainian soldiers are rounded up against their will. Are some conscripted? Of course, just an as in all wars (included us with WW2 and The Civil War). But by and large these are people literally defending their homeland against foreign invasion.

And they'll keep doing that with or without Zelenskyy.

You do realize Ukraine has barely ever been a country alone, right? The Donbass region especially is at best disputed. Crimea even moreso which never made sense as being Ukrainian. It made little sense when the Soviet Union broke up to make them Ukranian and the only way it worked was for Ukraine to either be a Russian ally or neutral. This war is also about who controls Ukraine not Ukraine's independence unless you honestly think that's the intent with Zelenskyy and Ukraine from the European countries. It is a bone being fought over just as it has for 1000 years as a resource rich land with no natural protective borders.

There are no good guys in this war. I know many really want there to be because Putin is a bad guy but Zelenskyy is every bit as ruthless. He's just a different style of ruthless. He is also definitely a dictator who sure as hell doesn't want elections or anyone threatening his power.

It's very difficult for most but it is really important to step back and look at the big picture in this and not assume either side is the "good guys". At best is is about who is "least bad". What we should care about though is about what matters to the US interests though and not jumping in the middle of a war that seems to have no end.
You've been thoroughly programmed so I guess…. congratulations?
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.