Trump and Russia Pivot - October 2026

55,095 Views | 1009 Replies | Last: 8 min ago by Teslag
1939
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Teslag said:

1939 said:

https://apnews.com/article/russia-ukraine-land-swap-trump-summit-e8e869d5d5ec672fee3e86022b20d11a


This article is over a year old.


It doesn't matter that it's a year old, his stance hasn't changed. Just accept that you're wrong.
Teslag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
1939 said:

Teslag said:

1939 said:

https://apnews.com/article/russia-ukraine-land-swap-trump-summit-e8e869d5d5ec672fee3e86022b20d11a


This article is over a year old.


It doesn't matter that it's a year old, his stance hasn't changed. Just accept that you're wrong.


I'm not wrong. I've literally posted multiple citations of him saying he would agree to a ceasefire today. Right now.

And you just put your fingers in your ears and say "no he hasn't"
GAC06
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Is someone going to have to throw in the towel for 1939 or are we going to have to wait until the next Russian data center blows up?
Rossticus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
1939 said:

It's 100% correct.

Their concession is that they stop the war and don't take the whole country.


And how do you hold them to that? You're handing over Ukraine's heaviest defensive fortifications such that if Russia chooses not to honor their agreement there's little to nothing Ukraine could do to stand in their way at that point.

Are you prepared to guarantee Russia's word with US forces? NATO forces? Do you trust Russia enough to risk that? And if you don't, then why would Ukraine trust them given their utter disregard for the prior agreements that Russia violated in starting the war in the first place. Not to mention Crimea. Not to mention little green men. Not to mention their prior track record in Georgia and Chechnya under Putin.

It's not logical and it's not something you'd do if you were in their place unless you were… you know…
Featured Video Previews
1939
How long do you want to ignore this user?
For God sakes a ceasefire is not an agreement to cede land.

I'm done with you. You're wrong and can't produce a single piece of evidence where he had agreed to cede land when every source out there says that he won't. Not only will he not but the Ukrainian constitution forbade it!

Have a good night.
Rossticus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
So… you're saying that he can't?
1939
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Do I trust them? I don't know, maybe.

What is the alternative though?

I can agree to disagree with you, you think Ukraine can win and I don't, that's fine. But I can't agree to disagree with your bro Tesla who refuses to admit he's wrong about a fact.
aggie93
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Jeeper79 said:

aggie93 said:

Teslag said:


Quote:

Sure, the population is different now though as is the attitudes there. The idea at that time was Ukraine was either a Russian ally or at worst neutral, certainly not trying to join NATO.


And right now, today, 99% of Luhansk is under Russian control. 85% of Donetsk is under Russian control. And as of right now, Zelenskyy is agreeable to a ceasefire under current lines. Under that agreement Russia would walk away with almost all of the Donbas and its people as newly recognized Russian lands.

But Russia won't agree. Why is that?



Putin is a bad guy. I also don't buy that Zelenskyy will agree to anything. He talks about it but he always pulls out or finds a reason not to or he asks for just a bit more than he knows Russia will agree to. I am not claiming either side are the good guys here, that's actually my point. It's going to take a lot of carrot and stick to get them to agree to peace and that's even harder because Trump doesn't want to spend our money or men on this and you have a LOT of folks with a vested interest in the war continuing.

Calling out Zelenskyy and calling him a bad guy doesn't mean Putin is not as well. Not sure why people can't understand that. Too many want this very gray war to be black and white.

Only one of them attacked the other.

Ok. So you are arguing Putin is a worse guy than Zelenskyy. My point is they both suck and more importantly it doesn't change any of the points about our interests.
Teslag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
1939 said:

Zelensky is an absolute fool. This war would have been over years ago and hundreds of of thousands of lives saved if he wasn't such a narcissist idiot.


So which is it? Is Zelenskyy a narcissistic idiot who refuses to end the war on his own?

Or is he simply bound by his constitution and unable to end it even if he wanted to?
Teslag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
aggie93 said:

Jeeper79 said:

aggie93 said:

Teslag said:


Quote:

Sure, the population is different now though as is the attitudes there. The idea at that time was Ukraine was either a Russian ally or at worst neutral, certainly not trying to join NATO.


And right now, today, 99% of Luhansk is under Russian control. 85% of Donetsk is under Russian control. And as of right now, Zelenskyy is agreeable to a ceasefire under current lines. Under that agreement Russia would walk away with almost all of the Donbas and its people as newly recognized Russian lands.

But Russia won't agree. Why is that?



Putin is a bad guy. I also don't buy that Zelenskyy will agree to anything. He talks about it but he always pulls out or finds a reason not to or he asks for just a bit more than he knows Russia will agree to. I am not claiming either side are the good guys here, that's actually my point. It's going to take a lot of carrot and stick to get them to agree to peace and that's even harder because Trump doesn't want to spend our money or men on this and you have a LOT of folks with a vested interest in the war continuing.

Calling out Zelenskyy and calling him a bad guy doesn't mean Putin is not as well. Not sure why people can't understand that. Too many want this very gray war to be black and white.

Only one of them attacked the other.

Ok. So you are arguing Putin is a worse guy than Zelenskyy. My point is they both suck and more importantly it doesn't change any of the points about our interests.


One can easily be critical of both sides in this war without having to make false equivalencies.

At the end of the day Zelenskyy has simply done the bare minimum of what every leader is expected to do since the dawn of time. And that's defend your national sovereignty and repel an invader.
Rossticus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
1939 said:

Do I trust them? I don't know, maybe.

What is the alternative though?

I can agree to disagree with you, you think Ukraine can win and I don't, that's fine. But I can't agree to disagree with your bro Tesla who refuses to admit he's wrong about a fact.


No. You're putting words in my mouth, there. I don't think they can "win" from the standpoint of taking back all their land nor have I ever. That's not realistic. I think they can be provided with an opportunity to negotiate from a position of strength to achieve a reasonable compromise that will ensure a long term future peace.

And I don't think that flipping to help Russia to achieve their goals out of frustration is the way to accomplish that. Ending the war doesn't equate to ending it correctly and history bears out that pursuing the easy route can prove to be exponentially as catastrophic as opposed to the risks involved in committing to the patience, will, and fortitude required to end it strategically and intelligently.

And I'd also say, when someone has shown you who they are over nearly 30 years in power, you should believe them. A leopard doesn't change his spots and dictators don't turn over new leaves at the end of their careers when a goal they've been aspiring to for decades is within reach. Go back and listen to his speeches at the beginning of the war. He thinks Ukraine is owed to Russia. He's not just walking away from that.
aggie93
How long do you want to ignore this user?
javajaws said:

aggie93 said:

GeorgiAg said:

1939 said:

Zelensky is an absolute fool. This war would have been over years ago and hundreds of of thousands of lives saved if he wasn't such a narcissist idiot.

Putin is an absolute fool. The war should have never been started, and millions of lives saved.

The wild thing to me is both of you are right. Both Putin and Zelensky are fools. Well not really, both are bloodthirsty and corrupt narcissists that are more than willing to sacrifice human life for power without flinching. Trying to pick a side between them is like trying to choose sides in the Iran/Iraq war.


You were close. Putin is bloodthirsty, Trump is a narcissist, and Zelensky is a fool stuck between the two of them. Z was not up to this task of defending his country from invasion yet despite his inadequacy he has still managed to do just that with the help of US and EU assistance.

I categorically disagree with your assessment though that Z is "sacrificing" his people. That's just some bizarre world view you have there. If the people were unhappy with him and wanted to be a part of Russia he would have been deposed by now.

That's fine. My point on "sacrificing" is in the end this is going to end up with an agreement that is pretty close to what it could have been a few years ago to end this war. Ukraine doesn't have the capability to truly defeat Russia. You also act like deposing a guy who has billions, control of the military, and support of Europe could just happen. If you think Zelenskyy's actions are out of some other motivation though ok. I just am way past caring and disagree and really don't see how it is relevant to what is in our best interests.
Teslag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Quote:

agreement that is pretty close to what it could have been a few years ago to end this war.


Which agreement was that? What did Russia offer in concession said agreement?
1939
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Thank you for the clarification, that's helpful and reasonable.

Unless we know the details of any proposed deal to end the war I don't think anyone can make the determination as to whether that deal is a good one or not.
Misplaced Aggie
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Silent For Too Long said:

Teslag said:


Quote:

People just want it end.


Russia doesn't. They could literally end this any day. Hell, they could literally end it along current lines, keep what they have gained, and walk away and Zelenskyy would be fine with it.

But they won't. Why is that?


What is your evidence for that?

Zelensky has been meeting with requests.
Putin hasnt...
aggie93
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Rossticus said:

Zelenskyy has dismissed surrendering. He hasn't dismissed peace. Russia's consistent and unchanging terms don't allow Ukraine to continue to exist as an independent nation. Surrendering to Russia isn't peace and everyone here knows that.

I disagree. That said it's really about what is in our interests at this point. The only way to defeat Russia involves things we aren't remotely willing to do and Ukraine isn't capable of doing. I don't think that an endless war is the right solution and that's really the only option I can see if we aren't working to find a peaceful solution that will inevitably not be what Ukraine wants to end it.
aggie93
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Teslag said:

aggie93 said:

Teslag said:


Quote:

He talks about it but he always pulls out or finds a reason not to or he asks for just a bit more than he knows Russia will agree to


Do you have a citable and solid example of him walking away from a reasonable deal?

"Reasonable" is the key word. What Zelenskyy sees as "reasonable" what Putin sees as "reasonable" what Europe sees as "reasonable" and what Trump sees as "reasonable" are all different answers. In terms of "citable" no I don't as it's damn near impossible to know what's real and what isn't in that conflict, every side seems to tell a different story. That said Zelenskyy has certainly dismissed peace deals before.


What deal did he walk away from that you found reasonable?

The only way to get a deal is to negotiate and be willing to make a deal. It's not like there are reliable an objective reports on what is really on the table or not either, it's impossible to see through the propaganda on all sides. As I said Putin is a bad guy but inevitably Ukraine can't defeat Russia. So "reasonable" is always going to be relative.
Teslag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Depends on what you mean by defeat Russia. If you mean holding lines at or near their present location Ukrainian probably do that for years or even decades. Like it or not, Ukraine at the moment has one of the strongest militaries on earth and is one of the most advanced drone warfare capable force on the planet. They don't need much to hold lines if that's their intent.
Rossticus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
It only seems endless until it ends and telling Russia outright that we're not willing to go the last mile ensures that they'll never negotiate. It puts both ourselves and Ukraine in a position of weakness and is the last thing I'd do in any negotiation for anything, much less to end a war. This administration has lacked discipline in its second term and it's creating unforced errors here and in other matters, IMO. I truly hope Trump remembers who he is and pulls it all together for the home stretch.
aggie93
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Teslag said:

Grok also disagrees with you.




He offered a 60 day for elections and he knew Putin would say no. Once again not saying Putin is a good guy. The logical thing would be to continue to negotiate and find a compromise.
Teslag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
aggie93 said:

Teslag said:

Grok also disagrees with you.




He offered a 60 day for elections and he knew Putin would say no. Once again not saying Putin is a good guy. The logical thing would be to continue to negotiate and find a compromise.


He did not offer a 60 day ceasefire. I listened to the entire 25 minute interview. Did you? I may have missed it. Can you give me the timestamp?
Misplaced Aggie
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Rossticus said:

It only seems endless until it ends and telling Russia outright that we're not willing to go the last mile ensures that they'll never negotiate. It puts both ourselves and Ukraine in a position of weakness and is the last thing I'd do in any negotiation for anything, much less to end a war. This administration has lacked discipline in its second term and it's creating unforced errors here and in other matters, IMO. I truly hope Trump remembers who he is and pulls it all together for the home stretch.

Buddy... I hate to tell you this, but its going go get worse
1939
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Teslag said:

Grok also disagrees with you.





No, Grok does not disagree with me. you purposefully used the word ceasefire which you cannot seem to understand is not the same thing as a negotiated peace agreement.

https://imgur.com/gallery/putin-IRZ85hP
aggie93
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Teslag said:

aggie93 said:

Jeeper79 said:

aggie93 said:

Teslag said:


Quote:

Sure, the population is different now though as is the attitudes there. The idea at that time was Ukraine was either a Russian ally or at worst neutral, certainly not trying to join NATO.


And right now, today, 99% of Luhansk is under Russian control. 85% of Donetsk is under Russian control. And as of right now, Zelenskyy is agreeable to a ceasefire under current lines. Under that agreement Russia would walk away with almost all of the Donbas and its people as newly recognized Russian lands.

But Russia won't agree. Why is that?



Putin is a bad guy. I also don't buy that Zelenskyy will agree to anything. He talks about it but he always pulls out or finds a reason not to or he asks for just a bit more than he knows Russia will agree to. I am not claiming either side are the good guys here, that's actually my point. It's going to take a lot of carrot and stick to get them to agree to peace and that's even harder because Trump doesn't want to spend our money or men on this and you have a LOT of folks with a vested interest in the war continuing.

Calling out Zelenskyy and calling him a bad guy doesn't mean Putin is not as well. Not sure why people can't understand that. Too many want this very gray war to be black and white.

Only one of them attacked the other.

Ok. So you are arguing Putin is a worse guy than Zelenskyy. My point is they both suck and more importantly it doesn't change any of the points about our interests.


One can easily be critical of both sides in this war without having to make false equivalencies.

At the end of the day Zelenskyy has simply done the bare minimum of what every leader is expected to do since the dawn of time. And that's defend your national sovereignty and repel an invader.

Ok, he's also made billions in the process. This war is 5 years in now though and essentially they are just going back and forth over the same territory. I guess they can just go another 5 years?
aggie93
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Teslag said:

aggie93 said:

Teslag said:

Grok also disagrees with you.




He offered a 60 day for elections and he knew Putin would say no. Once again not saying Putin is a good guy. The logical thing would be to continue to negotiate and find a compromise.


He did not offer a 60 day ceasefire. I listened to the entire 25 minute interview. Did you? I may have missed it. Can you give me the timestamp?

No I didn't listen to Zelenskyy give a lengthy interview and I have no trust in him. Happy to admit I haven't followed the day to day on the war for sometime, when you have both sides throwing out constant propaganda and being willing to lie it's almost pointless. If you think Zelenskyy is the white knight who really wants peace that's fine.
Teslag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
1939 said:

Teslag said:

Grok also disagrees with you.





No, Grok does not disagree with me. you purposefully used the word ceasefire which you cannot seem to understand is not the same thing as a negotiated peace agreement.

https://imgur.com/gallery/putin-IRZ85hP


You told me to cite the literal ceasefire claim.

https://texags.com/forums/16/topics/3633093/replies/73117692
Rossticus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
And how much has Putin made in blood and corruption over his time? I'd wager he's a mite wealthier than Z. And Z made way more as a private citizen than Putin ever dreamed of. Trying to make this war a referendum on leadership fails on logic because it requires that you ignore one side who is inarguably worse (and was the cause of the other's systemic corruption in the first place). You can't say Z is a liar and ignore the habitual lies of Russian leadership over the years and pertaining to this war specifically.

Remove your personal feeling about leadership. What's left? The actions of each country and both the rights and fate of the actual people.
aggie93
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Rossticus said:

And how much has Putin made in blood and corruption over his time? I'd wager he's a mite wealthier than Z. And Z made way more as a private citizen than Putin ever dreamed of. Trying to make this war a referendum on leadership fails on logic because it requires that you ignore one side who is inarguably worse (and was the cause of the other's systemic corruption in the first place). You can't say Z is a liar and ignore the habitual lies of Russian leadership over the years and pertaining to this war specifically.

Remove your personal feeling about leadership. What's left? The actions of each country and both the rights and fate of the actual people.

Once again I am not arguing that Putin is a good or trustworthy guy. What I have said is Zelensky is also a bad guy. This isn't a comparison contest of who is a bigger scumbag. It's about the reality of the situation. Ukraine isn't able to defeat Russia because they can't successfully invade Russia Neither Europe nor the US is willing to engage in an invasion of Russia. Yet all the anger seems to be at Trump when he seems to be the only guy who just wants the war to end and understands that is going to take Zelenskyy accepted a deal he doesn't want.

Otherwise we just stay in this endless cycle and the war never ends.
Teslag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
What specifically makes Zelenskyy a "bad guy" in this war?
EastSideAg2002
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Teslag said:

What specifically makes Zelenskyy a "bad guy" in this war?

Or a legit source of this so called person skimming of billions of dollars.
nortex97
How long do you want to ignore this user?

He actually did have some supportive thanks from his talk with Rubio though, fwiw.

ETA: VP Vance take is as usual outstanding. The pivot arguably started with Z trying to re-negotiate in the oval office/cursing at JD.

ts5641
How long do you want to ignore this user?
nortex97 said:


He actually did have some supportive thanks from his talk with Rubio though, fwiw.

ETA: VP Vance take is as usual outstanding. The pivot arguably started with Z trying to re-negotiate in the oval office/cursing at JD.



I'll believe it when I see it but I'm glad he's saying it at least. Should've been done a long time ago.
FIDO_Ags
How long do you want to ignore this user?
See you posted your daily propaganda piece here too. This administration's foreign policy is incompetent on a good day, worse on others. Trump et al dont even realize they're in someone else's decision matrix. Never thought I'd see that from a U.S. President.
ETFan
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Teslag said:

aggie93 said:

Jeeper79 said:

aggie93 said:

Teslag said:


Quote:

Sure, the population is different now though as is the attitudes there. The idea at that time was Ukraine was either a Russian ally or at worst neutral, certainly not trying to join NATO.


And right now, today, 99% of Luhansk is under Russian control. 85% of Donetsk is under Russian control. And as of right now, Zelenskyy is agreeable to a ceasefire under current lines. Under that agreement Russia would walk away with almost all of the Donbas and its people as newly recognized Russian lands.

But Russia won't agree. Why is that?



Putin is a bad guy. I also don't buy that Zelenskyy will agree to anything. He talks about it but he always pulls out or finds a reason not to or he asks for just a bit more than he knows Russia will agree to. I am not claiming either side are the good guys here, that's actually my point. It's going to take a lot of carrot and stick to get them to agree to peace and that's even harder because Trump doesn't want to spend our money or men on this and you have a LOT of folks with a vested interest in the war continuing.

Calling out Zelenskyy and calling him a bad guy doesn't mean Putin is not as well. Not sure why people can't understand that. Too many want this very gray war to be black and white.

Only one of them attacked the other.

Ok. So you are arguing Putin is a worse guy than Zelenskyy. My point is they both suck and more importantly it doesn't change any of the points about our interests.


One can easily be critical of both sides in this war without having to make false equivalencies.

At the end of the day Zelenskyy has simply done the bare minimum of what every leader is expected to do since the dawn of time. And that's defend your national sovereignty and repel an invader.


The fact that this is being argued in here is insane.

The propaganda really does go deep on the right. This is the easiest issue there is to be on the right side, but conservatives have bought the narrative and are team Russia. Absolutely incredible.


Russia Russia Russia was always right, always will be.
Rossticus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
My prediction, Russia shoots down whatever is presented to them as a non-starter. I'm willing and hopeful to be surprised.

 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.