Trump and Russia Pivot - October 2026

54,524 Views | 996 Replies | Last: 30 min ago by Rossticus
samurai_science
How long do you want to ignore this user?
1939 said:

Teslag said:

1939 said:

Teslag said:


Quote:

What isn't true is that Zelenskyy is ready to make a deal right now, that is just flat out false.


On August 3rd, 2026 Zelenskyy proposed a ceasefire along current lines. Russia rejected it.


Please cite.


I did. It's on the previous a page, linking a literal speech by Zelenskyy to his ambassadors announcing the proposal.




I don't speak Ukrainian, so I don't know what he said in that speech, but from what I've read, it wasn't proposing an end to the war that was anywhere close to being realistic.



We know, its fan fiction.
FIDO_Ags
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Take a look at Ragoo's graph. Then go to the mirror before ringing up anyone as an imbecile.
1939
How long do you want to ignore this user?
FIDO_Ags said:

Quote:

The Ukrainians are destroying Russian refineries because it results in real tactical gains on the battlefield and liberates Ukrainian land and people.


1939, the guy above knows how to war. Reading your posts, you do not. I'm giving Teslag my blue star for today!


He knows how to war? Ok I guess it's settled then. Let's double down and check back in a year.
Teslag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
samurai_science said:

1939 said:

Teslag said:

1939 said:

Teslag said:


Quote:

What isn't true is that Zelenskyy is ready to make a deal right now, that is just flat out false.


On August 3rd, 2026 Zelenskyy proposed a ceasefire along current lines. Russia rejected it.


Please cite.


I did. It's on the previous a page, linking a literal speech by Zelenskyy to his ambassadors announcing the proposal.




I don't speak Ukrainian, so I don't know what he said in that speech, but from what I've read, it wasn't proposing an end to the war that was anywhere close to being realistic.



We know, its fan fiction.


Except it's not. It's not like Ukrainian can't be translated. And Zelenskyy has on more than one occasion proposed ceasefire along current lines.

Russia refuses. Why is that?


FIDO_Ags
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Why, it's clear Putin can't win this Special Military Operation.
Ragoo
How long do you want to ignore this user?
aginresearch said:

I highly suggest you don't look at the 1 year version of that chart because it's not good for your argument.
zoom out for more context to the trend.
TRX
How long do you want to ignore this user?
5Amp said:

Don't care


Agreed. Yawn.
Individual Patriot
1939
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Excellent, I suppose it's your belief Ukraine will have won by this time next year without concessions and the war will be over.
Silent For Too Long
How long do you want to ignore this user?
FIDO_Ags said:

False


So you think bombing plants that make diesel doesn't increase diesel prices?

And this makes sense? In your head?
FIDO_Ags
How long do you want to ignore this user?
No, and like I said, you can't war. Enjoy the midterms!
Teslag
How long do you want to ignore this user?

Quote:

What you and your cohorts are saying is that it is not effecting our diesel prices which is false.


I've actually never claimed this. I will even say that it has definitely affected our diesel prices. I am also saying that I cannot blame Ukraine for doing it since it's tilted the war in their favor and saves Ukrainian lives.

Over a year and a half ago Trump brazenly told Zelenskyy he "didn't have any cards". He kept burning Ukraine. Putting limitations on their strikes. Threatening to withhold aid, etc.

So the Ukrainians decided to "get some cards". They developed long range cheap drones that didn't rely on American intel or targeting. And didn't come with strings. They began systemically destroying the Russian heart that fed their supply lines. They began to rely more and more on Euro intelligence, euro funding, and euro targeting.

The resulting diesel increases became an albatross on Trump's neck. So he went back to the well of threatening Ukraine. Only this time they don't particularly give a ****. Sure, we could throttle Starshield, and have. But they Ukrainians will find a way around that too.

When people are threatened with extinction, they fight and adapt.
FIDO_Ags
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Sure it does. And closing a strait does too. Go look at Ragoos graph.
Teslag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
1939 said:

Excellent, I suppose it's your belief Ukraine will have won by this time next year without concessions and the war will be over.


If we pulled every bit of aid and intelligence assistance to Ukraine today we could check back in on this thread a year from now and the front line will not have moved in either direction much at all.
Silent For Too Long
How long do you want to ignore this user?
FIDO_Ags said:

Take a look at Ragoo's graph. Then go to the mirror before ringing up anyone as an imbecile.


Anyone who think destroying something doesn't increase the price of said something labels themselves.
FIDO_Ags
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Enjoy your maga talking points. You'll need them in a couple of more weeks cause Trump screwed the pooch.

If he was playing 4d chess he would've considered that before bombing Iran. But he didn't, so now he put you in the unfortunate position, hat in hand, to goaltend for him.
aginresearch
How long do you want to ignore this user?
What do we see at the 25 year max? We see general inflation that steadily increases prices until 2008 financial crisis that spikes prices. Then Obama era policies that constrain diesel production until late in his admin.

Next we get 1st Trump admin and prices rise due to natural inflation. Then we get Biden era policies which spike prices and set new floor of $3.50. Prices remain stable until early this year. Then what happens to spike prices to $6.30? Only one event this year caused that.

You can't post a 25 year chart and say look at the trend when there is a massive spike in the chart that is a direct result of a certain action. The trend said it should be around $3.50 not almost $6.50.
Silent For Too Long
How long do you want to ignore this user?
FIDO_Ags said:

Enjoy your maga talking points. You'll need them in a couple of more weeks cause Trump screwed the pooch.

If he was playing 4d chess he would've considered that before bombing Iran. But he didn't, so now he put you in the unfortunate position, hat in hand, to goaltend for him.


Oh brother. I'm not goaltending anything. I'm discussing basic economics.

You posted something incredibly stupid and don't have the testicular fortitude to admit it.
FIDO_Ags
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Look at the post above yours. Aginresearch explains it well. If your nice, he may let borrow his Econ 101 book.

Have a good evening!
Sq 17
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Silent For Too Long said:

FIDO_Ags said:

False


So you think bombing plants that make diesel doesn't increase diesel prices?

And this makes sense? In your head?


If the diesel that has been destroyed was for domestic Russian use and the domestic market is unable to buy diesel from the international market

then yes the international price of diesel would be unchanged. The domestic Russia market would under go shortages and rationing and the lack of fuel would impact the Russians ability to make war with Ukraine
Silent For Too Long
How long do you want to ignore this user?
FIDO_Ags said:

Look at the post above yours. Aginresearch explains it well. If your nice, he may let borrow his Econ 101 book.

Have a good evening!


Of course the Iran war was a contributing factor. Its you who is arguing that Zelensky bombing diesel refeneries wasn't one.
Silent For Too Long
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Sq 17 said:

Silent For Too Long said:

FIDO_Ags said:

False


So you think bombing plants that make diesel doesn't increase diesel prices?

And this makes sense? In your head?


If the diesel that has been destroyed was for domestic Russian use and the domestic market is unable to buy diesel from the international market

then yes the international price of diesel would be unchanged. The domestic Russia market would under go shortages and rationing and the lack of fuel would impact the Russians ability to make war with Ukraine


Yeah. Sure. And if Russia existed in an alternate reality then none of this is relevant.

However, we live in reality where Russia is a major global energy producer and bombing their refineries effects energy prices.
Sq 17
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Not sure how major they are after 4-5 years of not being able to finish off the Ukes

of course we are talking about Russia Ukraine war because Trump authorized a second round of attacks on Iran

Midnight Hammer was likely justifiable

Epic Fury is an Epic Failure and we are back to talking about Zelensky to change the narratives

This is all about trying to change which war is being discussed
Jeeper79
How long do you want to ignore this user?
aggie93 said:

Teslag said:


Quote:

Sure, the population is different now though as is the attitudes there. The idea at that time was Ukraine was either a Russian ally or at worst neutral, certainly not trying to join NATO.


And right now, today, 99% of Luhansk is under Russian control. 85% of Donetsk is under Russian control. And as of right now, Zelenskyy is agreeable to a ceasefire under current lines. Under that agreement Russia would walk away with almost all of the Donbas and its people as newly recognized Russian lands.

But Russia won't agree. Why is that?



Putin is a bad guy. I also don't buy that Zelenskyy will agree to anything. He talks about it but he always pulls out or finds a reason not to or he asks for just a bit more than he knows Russia will agree to. I am not claiming either side are the good guys here, that's actually my point. It's going to take a lot of carrot and stick to get them to agree to peace and that's even harder because Trump doesn't want to spend our money or men on this and you have a LOT of folks with a vested interest in the war continuing.

Calling out Zelenskyy and calling him a bad guy doesn't mean Putin is not as well. Not sure why people can't understand that. Too many want this very gray war to be black and white.
Only one of them attacked the other.
samurai_science
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Jeeper79 said:

aggie93 said:

Teslag said:


Quote:

Sure, the population is different now though as is the attitudes there. The idea at that time was Ukraine was either a Russian ally or at worst neutral, certainly not trying to join NATO.


And right now, today, 99% of Luhansk is under Russian control. 85% of Donetsk is under Russian control. And as of right now, Zelenskyy is agreeable to a ceasefire under current lines. Under that agreement Russia would walk away with almost all of the Donbas and its people as newly recognized Russian lands.

But Russia won't agree. Why is that?



Putin is a bad guy. I also don't buy that Zelenskyy will agree to anything. He talks about it but he always pulls out or finds a reason not to or he asks for just a bit more than he knows Russia will agree to. I am not claiming either side are the good guys here, that's actually my point. It's going to take a lot of carrot and stick to get them to agree to peace and that's even harder because Trump doesn't want to spend our money or men on this and you have a LOT of folks with a vested interest in the war continuing.

Calling out Zelenskyy and calling him a bad guy doesn't mean Putin is not as well. Not sure why people can't understand that. Too many want this very gray war to be black and white.

Only one of them attacked the other.

Does it matter? Let them fight if they want, as long as we dont fund it.
japantiger
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Ukraine is not our friend.
Russia is not our friend.

But there is an old adage, never be on the other side of Russia in a world war.

Bush, Clinton and Bush all bungled the post Soviet opportunity. It's a shame.
javajaws
How long do you want to ignore this user?
aggie93 said:

GeorgiAg said:

1939 said:

Zelensky is an absolute fool. This war would have been over years ago and hundreds of of thousands of lives saved if he wasn't such a narcissist idiot.

Putin is an absolute fool. The war should have never been started, and millions of lives saved.

The wild thing to me is both of you are right. Both Putin and Zelensky are fools. Well not really, both are bloodthirsty and corrupt narcissists that are more than willing to sacrifice human life for power without flinching. Trying to pick a side between them is like trying to choose sides in the Iran/Iraq war.


You were close. Putin is bloodthirsty, Trump is a narcissist, and Zelensky is a fool stuck between the two of them. Z was not up to this task of defending his country from invasion yet despite his inadequacy he has still managed to do just that with the help of US and EU assistance.

I categorically disagree with your assessment though that Z is "sacrificing" his people. That's just some bizarre world view you have there. If the people were unhappy with him and wanted to be a part of Russia he would have been deposed by now.
"Those who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety." - Ben Franklin
Red Fishing Ag93
How long do you want to ignore this user?
GeorgiAg said:

Everyone is ignoring the timing of why Trump is jumping into this now. It's because he's scared of the mid terms, nothing more.

He could not care less about US long-term interest. He only cares about himself.
Well.......if true, maybe, just maybe the mid terms are important to our country? Good grief.
Teslag
How long do you want to ignore this user?

Quote:

Does it matter? Let them fight if they want, as long as we dont fund it.


For the most part, we aren't anymore. Ukraine is destroying Russian refineries with in-house long range drones and their own cruise missiles. They adapted to our lack of aid.
YouBet
How long do you want to ignore this user?
aginresearch said:

200B? It's actually $127B in direct funds, but I don't care about the exact number. We spend $20B+ a day. That's 10 days of expenditures of the federal government over almost 5 years! It's a rounding error of the US FedGov budget. I'd probably have spent 4 times that amount over 4 years. So about $800B and I'd pay for production of drone weaponry for the US military. It would be worth every penny. So about 5 days of spending per year.

Also, yeah, the Iran war was mismanaged from the drop. You blockade the SoH day 0. You eliminate their port facilities. You destroy their railyards. You destroy their energy/water infrastructure. Russia ain't keeping Iran afloat singlehandedly but every little bit helps towards Iran's capitulation.

You also claim that we have no strategic interest but I outlined how I see our strategic interest in Ukraine. There is strategic interest if you believe that Europe has strategic interest to us. If you don't then good luck because they've been the cause of most of the world's instability over the past 120 years


We've authorized ~$200B. We haven't spent/sent all of it.

Your flippant attitude about spending tax dollars is why we are $40T in debt and climbing. I don't support my tax dollars being spent somewhere that is irrelevant to us. That's Russia's backyard and Europe's neighborhood. Didn't see how you outlined it was relevant but it has nothing to do with us.

I agree with you on management of Iran.
GAC06
How long do you want to ignore this user?
japantiger said:


But there is an old adage, never be on the other side of Russia in a world war.



They got their asses kicked in WWI. They would have collapsed in WWII without us. Russia is doing what they've always done, feeding meat into the grinder. This time it's not working when quadcopters mow their men down.
Teslag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
A significant portion of that "aid" was book value of weapons we sent, and much of it outdated and wont' be replaced. More of it was even spent on replacing and ramping up our own military spending and replacement with better weapons, which goes back into our own economy.
YouBet
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Teslag said:

A significant portion of that "aid" was book value of weapons we sent, and much of it outdated and wont' be replaced. More of it was even spent on replacing and ramping up our own military spending and replacement with better weapons, which goes back into our own economy.


Sure. Whatever money this doesn't apply to is still money that shouldn't be wasted over there. Not our problem.
1939
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Teslag said:

1939 said:

Excellent, I suppose it's your belief Ukraine will have won by this time next year without concessions and the war will be over.


If we pulled every bit of aid and intelligence assistance to Ukraine today we could check back in on this thread a year from now and the front line will not have moved in either direction much at all.


Exactly my point!!!

Let's just get a deal done and end it. Have you ever heard the phrase cut your loses? But you care much more about Trump being wrong and supposedly sticking it to Russia while thousands a week die in a pointless unwinnable war.
FIDO_Ags
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Quote:

Have you ever heard the phrase cut your loses?


You should send that to Putin. He started the endless Special Military Operation and bit off more than he could chew.
Teslag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
1939 said:

Teslag said:

1939 said:

Excellent, I suppose it's your belief Ukraine will have won by this time next year without concessions and the war will be over.


If we pulled every bit of aid and intelligence assistance to Ukraine today we could check back in on this thread a year from now and the front line will not have moved in either direction much at all.


Exactly my point!!!

Let's just get a deal done and end it. Have you ever heard the phrase cut your loses? But you care much more about Trump being wrong and supposedly sticking it to Russia while thousands a week die in a pointless unwinnable war.


Again, Zelenskyy is ready to cut his losses and accept a ceasefire along current lines.

Why isn't Russia ready to do the same?
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.