Trump and Russia Pivot - October 2026

54,525 Views | 996 Replies | Last: 30 min ago by Rossticus
ChrisTAMU
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Old McDonald said:

turns out the russiagaters weren't wrong, just early



No. They were wrong. They fell for an elaborate hoax driven by the Obama admin and three letter agencies.
YouBet
How long do you want to ignore this user?
GAC06 said:

YouBet said:

Teslag said:

Any negotiable opportunity is good. It can and should be sought. But ask yourself this, what concession, any concession, has Russia made in this negotiations? Can you think of any?

Why do you think that is?


I understand this and don't care. Keep trying.

It's better than the alternative - forever war.


What do you mean by "forever war"?

Mankind has had some faction at war with another since forever. Ending the war in Ukraine would just leave us at war with Iran, and various terrorist sects, and we aren't even fighting in Ukraine.

Please stop with the "just stop the war" nonsense. There is an aggressor and a nation repelling an invasion. The war can stop when the invader stops invading.


Then it will be a forever war until someone gives. So, yes, I stand by my statement.
Rossticus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
aggie93 said:

Rossticus said:

And how much has Putin made in blood and corruption over his time? I'd wager he's a mite wealthier than Z. And Z made way more as a private citizen than Putin ever dreamed of. Trying to make this war a referendum on leadership fails on logic because it requires that you ignore one side who is inarguably worse (and was the cause of the other's systemic corruption in the first place). You can't say Z is a liar and ignore the habitual lies of Russian leadership over the years and pertaining to this war specifically.

Remove your personal feeling about leadership. What's left? The actions of each country and both the rights and fate of the actual people.

Once again I am not arguing that Putin is a good or trustworthy guy. What I have said is Zelensky is also a bad guy. This isn't a comparison contest of who is a bigger scumbag. It's about the reality of the situation. Ukraine isn't able to defeat Russia because they can't successfully invade Russia Neither Europe nor the US is willing to engage in an invasion of Russia. Yet all the anger seems to be at Trump when he seems to be the only guy who just wants the war to end and understands that is going to take Zelenskyy accepted a deal he doesn't want.

Otherwise we just stay in this endless cycle and the war never ends.


Read my response to 1939. I'm not arguing that Ukraine can defeat Russia and take everything back. And literally nobody, including Ukraine, advocates for an invasion of Russia. That's ridiculous. I'm arguing that putting ourselves and Ukraine in a position of weakness encourages Russia to decline good faith negotiations and hold out for full capitulation or full military victory. The way Trump is "negotiating" is not how one successfully negotiates anything. Trump isn't immune from criticism just because he wants to end the war some ol' way. If he's doing a piss poor job then it should be called out.

The end of this is going to be some sort of negotiated settlement but if it's a weak one then it will only be a pause with the potential for round 2 to be a larger problem. It needs to be permanent, and lasting, and uphold the credibility of the US as a trustworthy partner who can be counted on.
flown-the-coop
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Ukraine is part of Russia. This experiment over the past 35 years of most grand independent sovereign Ukraine has only wasted hundreds of thousands if not millions olives, wasted billions if not trillions in treasure, and has provided nothing but corruption, grafting, waste, and violence.

It needs to be brought to an end. And it may not be a popular opinion but Ukraine being brought back into Mother Russia.

Hell, if it wasn't for the warring Mongols then the Kremlin would have been in Kyiv to begin with.
Rossticus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Well, that's certainly an opinion. Congratulations. When are we giving Lithuania, Latvia, and Estonia back to the totally Not at all corrupt and violent country of Russia who in no way has a deeply embedded system of graft and waste.
YouBet
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Rossticus said:

Well, that's certainly an opinion. Congratulations. When are we giving Lithuania, Latvia, and Estonia back to the totally Not at all corrupt and violent country of Russia who in no way has a deeply embedded system of graft and waste.


Can certainly argue present day relevancy but Kiev was the capital and political center of the Rus people. Russia and Ukraine are ethnically tied at the hip.
UTExan
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Who the h-ll does Trump think he is meeting with dictators Putin and Xi to decide the fate of a sovereign country? These people sense his willingness to make a deal as weakness and have contempt for him.
“If you’re going to have crime it should at least be organized crime”
-Havelock Vetinari
nortex97
How long do you want to ignore this user?
UTExan said:

Who the h-ll does Trump think he is meeting with dictators Putin and Xi to decide the fate of a sovereign country? These people sense his willingness to make a deal as weakness and have contempt for him.

Leaders of the nuclear super powers (not economic super powers) meeting to resolve proxy wars etc. is a good thing.

It is that simple, to me.

No one has said we are going to depose the leadership in Kiev if they refuse any deal offered (again), but demands we continue to support and encourage/finance/equip these conflicts ad infinitum at the behest of others, whether that be Israel, the EU, the arab powers, or Ukraine to me should and are being rightfully dismissed.
aggie93
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Rossticus said:

aggie93 said:

Rossticus said:

And how much has Putin made in blood and corruption over his time? I'd wager he's a mite wealthier than Z. And Z made way more as a private citizen than Putin ever dreamed of. Trying to make this war a referendum on leadership fails on logic because it requires that you ignore one side who is inarguably worse (and was the cause of the other's systemic corruption in the first place). You can't say Z is a liar and ignore the habitual lies of Russian leadership over the years and pertaining to this war specifically.

Remove your personal feeling about leadership. What's left? The actions of each country and both the rights and fate of the actual people.

Once again I am not arguing that Putin is a good or trustworthy guy. What I have said is Zelensky is also a bad guy. This isn't a comparison contest of who is a bigger scumbag. It's about the reality of the situation. Ukraine isn't able to defeat Russia because they can't successfully invade Russia Neither Europe nor the US is willing to engage in an invasion of Russia. Yet all the anger seems to be at Trump when he seems to be the only guy who just wants the war to end and understands that is going to take Zelenskyy accepted a deal he doesn't want.

Otherwise we just stay in this endless cycle and the war never ends.


Read my response to 1939. I'm not arguing that Ukraine can defeat Russia and take everything back. And literally nobody, including Ukraine, advocates for an invasion of Russia. That's ridiculous. I'm arguing that putting ourselves and Ukraine in a position of weakness encourages Russia to decline good faith negotiations and hold out for full capitulation or full military victory. The way Trump is "negotiating" is not how one successfully negotiates anything. Trump isn't immune from criticism just because he wants to end the war some ol' way. If he's doing a piss poor job then it should be called out.

The end of this is going to be some sort of negotiated settlement but if it's a weak one then it will only be a pause with the potential for round 2 to be a larger problem. It needs to be permanent, and lasting, and uphold the credibility of the US as a trustworthy partner who can be counted on.

The problem is Russia is not going to capitulate, they are way too invested and having a hostile neighbor in easy driving distance of Moscow that they just capitulated to isn't going to happen, especially with Putin in charge. So the only way to change that is to force submission on Russia or to remove Putin. The only way that happens is with a full scale invasion of Russia. Until you face that reality it's pointless. Russia is not like the US. They are a very proud and very hard people that don't look at life as fair and are more than willing to make sacrifices we can't comprehend.

Now is it rewarding Putin or does he deserve it or is Zelenskyy better or whatever you want to talk about is all irrelevant. Until you realize there are 2 choices you are tilting at windmills. One is to give Putin enough of what he wants to feel like he had a degree of success and can feel like his border is secure long term so he cuts a deal and ends the war. The second is to go for regime change in Russia which would involve a full scale invasion. Even assassinating Putin won't work because that would likely provoke a nuclear reaction from Russia or at a minimum a far more severe/total war response.

In the meantime you can keep thinking that "well if we just send a few more bombs at some factories or a refinery Putin will decide to give up" all you want but if 5 years of war hasn't shown you that won't work I don't know what to tell you.
FWTXAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
flown-the-coop
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I think it says more about you that you have an opinion on the competency of your Sonic manager.

But seriously, the concept that Trump is a bad negotiator and gets led around by the nose by foreign dictators is simply not based in reality.
Rossticus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
YouBet said:

Rossticus said:

Well, that's certainly an opinion. Congratulations. When are we giving Lithuania, Latvia, and Estonia back to the totally Not at all corrupt and violent country of Russia who in no way has a deeply embedded system of graft and waste.


Can certainly argue present day relevancy but Kiev was the capital and political center of the Rus people. Russia and Ukraine are ethnically tied at the hip.


So are Texas and Mexico, Taiwan and China. The US and England during independence and when the war of 1812 came around (which is pretty analogous to this conflict). Big friggidy whoop.

Ukraine has pushed for their independence for centuries from under the heel of Russia. They finally got it and Russia agreed to it when they lost the Cold War. Now since it's convenient for us we want to say "eh, you don't really deserve it and since Russia didn't want to it doesn't count". That just doesn't seem to be a logical way to approach this, IMO.
Teslag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Quote:

One is to give Putin enough of what he wants to feel like he had a degree of success


What if what he wants is the totality of Ukraine?
Rossticus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
aggie93 said:

Rossticus said:

aggie93 said:

Rossticus said:

And how much has Putin made in blood and corruption over his time? I'd wager he's a mite wealthier than Z. And Z made way more as a private citizen than Putin ever dreamed of. Trying to make this war a referendum on leadership fails on logic because it requires that you ignore one side who is inarguably worse (and was the cause of the other's systemic corruption in the first place). You can't say Z is a liar and ignore the habitual lies of Russian leadership over the years and pertaining to this war specifically.

Remove your personal feeling about leadership. What's left? The actions of each country and both the rights and fate of the actual people.

Once again I am not arguing that Putin is a good or trustworthy guy. What I have said is Zelensky is also a bad guy. This isn't a comparison contest of who is a bigger scumbag. It's about the reality of the situation. Ukraine isn't able to defeat Russia because they can't successfully invade Russia Neither Europe nor the US is willing to engage in an invasion of Russia. Yet all the anger seems to be at Trump when he seems to be the only guy who just wants the war to end and understands that is going to take Zelenskyy accepted a deal he doesn't want.

Otherwise we just stay in this endless cycle and the war never ends.


Read my response to 1939. I'm not arguing that Ukraine can defeat Russia and take everything back. And literally nobody, including Ukraine, advocates for an invasion of Russia. That's ridiculous. I'm arguing that putting ourselves and Ukraine in a position of weakness encourages Russia to decline good faith negotiations and hold out for full capitulation or full military victory. The way Trump is "negotiating" is not how one successfully negotiates anything. Trump isn't immune from criticism just because he wants to end the war some ol' way. If he's doing a piss poor job then it should be called out.

The end of this is going to be some sort of negotiated settlement but if it's a weak one then it will only be a pause with the potential for round 2 to be a larger problem. It needs to be permanent, and lasting, and uphold the credibility of the US as a trustworthy partner who can be counted on.

The problem is Russia is not going to capitulate, they are way too invested and having a hostile neighbor in easy driving distance of Moscow that they just capitulated to isn't going to happen, especially with Putin in charge. So the only way to change that is to force submission on Russia or to remove Putin. The only way that happens is with a full scale invasion of Russia. Until you face that reality it's pointless. Russia is not like the US. They are a very proud and very hard people that don't look at life as fair and are more than willing to make sacrifices we can't comprehend.

Now is it rewarding Putin or does he deserve it or is Zelenskyy better or whatever you want to talk about is all irrelevant. Until you realize there are 2 choices you are tilting at windmills. One is to give Putin enough of what he wants to feel like he had a degree of success and can feel like his border is secure long term so he cuts a deal and ends the war. The second is to go for regime change in Russia which would involve a full scale invasion. Even assassinating Putin won't work because that would likely provoke a nuclear reaction from Russia or at a minimum a far more severe/total war response.

In the meantime you can keep thinking that "well if we just send a few more bombs at some factories or a refinery Putin will decide to give up" all you want but if 5 years of war hasn't shown you that won't work I don't know what to tell you.


I never said that the goal was for Russia to capitulate. Where are you pulling that from? Do you feel that a reasonable negotiated settlement or anything less than full victory is Russian capitulation?

Or are you saying that Russia will never agree to a compromise so we have no choice but to force Ukraine to sacrifice themselves?
aggie93
How long do you want to ignore this user?
flown-the-coop said:

Ukraine is part of Russia. This experiment over the past 35 years of most grand independent sovereign Ukraine has only wasted hundreds of thousands if not millions olives, wasted billions if not trillions in treasure, and has provided nothing but corruption, grafting, waste, and violence.

It needs to be brought to an end. And it may not be a popular opinion but Ukraine being brought back into Mother Russia.

Hell, if it wasn't for the warring Mongols then the Kremlin would have been in Kyiv to begin with.

I don't think making Ukraine into Russia is viable. What is viable is to either make Ukraine into a Belarus type puppet state (which is less preferable) or a neutral country (most preferable). The problem is flirting with making Ukraine into a NATO country. BTW, it was idiotic to add the Baltics and Finland to NATO. They also should be neutral. Let them be well armed to protect themselves but also don't have Russian or NATO troops or bases in those countries. That's how you actually get peace. Unfortunately there are a lot of folks who have a vested interest in NOT having peace with Russia yet many refuse to understand that.

This isn't about making Russia into an ally or some idiocy of "Trump is Putin's puppet!". It's about creating a stable Europe without war and that encourages trade and prosperity for everyone. Russia is never going to be part of NATO or a Western European coalition, that ship sailed after the Cold War when Clinton and the West blew it though to be fair it was always going to be extremely difficult to pull off (look at how hard it was to integrate East Germany back in to Germany). What we can have now is a detente of sorts to think in Cold War terms, though not nearly as hostile. Let both Russia and Western Europe stop feeling threatened by each other and focus on commerce. Or we can just have these endless proxy wars forever while the Chinese laugh at us.
Teslag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Rossticus said:

YouBet said:

Rossticus said:

Well, that's certainly an opinion. Congratulations. When are we giving Lithuania, Latvia, and Estonia back to the totally Not at all corrupt and violent country of Russia who in no way has a deeply embedded system of graft and waste.


Can certainly argue present day relevancy but Kiev was the capital and political center of the Rus people. Russia and Ukraine are ethnically tied at the hip.


So are Texas and Mexico, Taiwan and China. The US and England during independence and when the war of 1812 came around (which is pretty analogous to this conflict). Big friggidy whoop.

Ukraine has pushed for their independence for centuries from under the heel of Russia. They finally got it and Russia agreed to it when they lost the Cold War. Now since it's convenient for us we want to say "eh, you don't really deserve it and since Russia didn't want to it doesn't count". That just doesn't seem to be a logical way to approach this, IMO.


Further, the Ukrainians don't want to be Russians. And they'll probably keep fighting to the death to keep that from happening. That's the core of this entire war. We could pull all aid and intel and they still fight to the death and this war would continue on that very truth.
YouBet
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Rossticus said:

YouBet said:

Rossticus said:

Well, that's certainly an opinion. Congratulations. When are we giving Lithuania, Latvia, and Estonia back to the totally Not at all corrupt and violent country of Russia who in no way has a deeply embedded system of graft and waste.


Can certainly argue present day relevancy but Kiev was the capital and political center of the Rus people. Russia and Ukraine are ethnically tied at the hip.


So are Texas and Mexico, Taiwan and China. The US and England during independence and when the war of 1812 came around (which is pretty analogous to this conflict). Big friggidy whoop.

Ukraine has pushed for their independence for centuries from under the heel of Russia. They finally got it and Russia agreed to it when they lost the Cold War. Now since it's convenient for us we want to say "eh, you don't really deserve it and since Russia didn't want to it doesn't count". That just doesn't seem to be a logical way to approach this, IMO.


I'm not saying it is which is why I said we can argue relevancy because it's a thin argument this far away from it.

Just pointing out some history many may not be aware of. There are strong ties there historically.
aggie93
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Teslag said:

Quote:

One is to give Putin enough of what he wants to feel like he had a degree of success


What if what he wants is the totality of Ukraine?

I don't think that is the case, he has never indicated that to be the case. Still he has better cards to play here and we can choose to acknowledge that or not. It has nothing to do with what is fair or right. The far more likely scenario is some type of agreement of autonomy of Eastern Ukraine and a further agreement of neutrality for the rest of Ukraine with a lot of assurances. That will be seen as rewarding Putin and a defeat for Ukraine and isn't what Western Europe wants.

So it's either take a deal like that or invade Russia or we can keep having this conversation 5 years from now.
flown-the-coop
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Then pull all aid and intel and let them give it a go. If they die, they die.
aggie93
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Rossticus said:

aggie93 said:

Rossticus said:

aggie93 said:

Rossticus said:

And how much has Putin made in blood and corruption over his time? I'd wager he's a mite wealthier than Z. And Z made way more as a private citizen than Putin ever dreamed of. Trying to make this war a referendum on leadership fails on logic because it requires that you ignore one side who is inarguably worse (and was the cause of the other's systemic corruption in the first place). You can't say Z is a liar and ignore the habitual lies of Russian leadership over the years and pertaining to this war specifically.

Remove your personal feeling about leadership. What's left? The actions of each country and both the rights and fate of the actual people.

Once again I am not arguing that Putin is a good or trustworthy guy. What I have said is Zelensky is also a bad guy. This isn't a comparison contest of who is a bigger scumbag. It's about the reality of the situation. Ukraine isn't able to defeat Russia because they can't successfully invade Russia Neither Europe nor the US is willing to engage in an invasion of Russia. Yet all the anger seems to be at Trump when he seems to be the only guy who just wants the war to end and understands that is going to take Zelenskyy accepted a deal he doesn't want.

Otherwise we just stay in this endless cycle and the war never ends.


Read my response to 1939. I'm not arguing that Ukraine can defeat Russia and take everything back. And literally nobody, including Ukraine, advocates for an invasion of Russia. That's ridiculous. I'm arguing that putting ourselves and Ukraine in a position of weakness encourages Russia to decline good faith negotiations and hold out for full capitulation or full military victory. The way Trump is "negotiating" is not how one successfully negotiates anything. Trump isn't immune from criticism just because he wants to end the war some ol' way. If he's doing a piss poor job then it should be called out.

The end of this is going to be some sort of negotiated settlement but if it's a weak one then it will only be a pause with the potential for round 2 to be a larger problem. It needs to be permanent, and lasting, and uphold the credibility of the US as a trustworthy partner who can be counted on.

The problem is Russia is not going to capitulate, they are way too invested and having a hostile neighbor in easy driving distance of Moscow that they just capitulated to isn't going to happen, especially with Putin in charge. So the only way to change that is to force submission on Russia or to remove Putin. The only way that happens is with a full scale invasion of Russia. Until you face that reality it's pointless. Russia is not like the US. They are a very proud and very hard people that don't look at life as fair and are more than willing to make sacrifices we can't comprehend.

Now is it rewarding Putin or does he deserve it or is Zelenskyy better or whatever you want to talk about is all irrelevant. Until you realize there are 2 choices you are tilting at windmills. One is to give Putin enough of what he wants to feel like he had a degree of success and can feel like his border is secure long term so he cuts a deal and ends the war. The second is to go for regime change in Russia which would involve a full scale invasion. Even assassinating Putin won't work because that would likely provoke a nuclear reaction from Russia or at a minimum a far more severe/total war response.

In the meantime you can keep thinking that "well if we just send a few more bombs at some factories or a refinery Putin will decide to give up" all you want but if 5 years of war hasn't shown you that won't work I don't know what to tell you.


I never said that the goal was for Russia to capitulate. Where are you pulling that from? Do you feel that a reasonable negotiated settlement or anything less than full victory is Russian capitulation?

Or are you saying that Russia will never agree to a compromise so we have no choice but to force Ukraine to sacrifice themselves?

I'm saying Putin has the leverage and more importantly the will to keep fighting until he gets what he wants and he has the backing of the Russian people in that. So once again it's 3 options:

1. Take a deal with Russia that feels like Ukraine lost and they give up more than they want in the East and agree to become neutral and not a threat to Russia.

2. Go all out to win against Russia which almost certainly involves a full scale invasion.

3. Keep arguing about this for another 5 years while not wanting to face options 1 or 2.

BTW, this was the choice 4 years ago. 3 years ago. 2 years ago. Last year. So far the choice has been 3 because that is the easiest choice politically.
GeorgiAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
aggie93 said:

Rossticus said:

aggie93 said:

Rossticus said:

aggie93 said:

Rossticus said:

And how much has Putin made in blood and corruption over his time? I'd wager he's a mite wealthier than Z. And Z made way more as a private citizen than Putin ever dreamed of. Trying to make this war a referendum on leadership fails on logic because it requires that you ignore one side who is inarguably worse (and was the cause of the other's systemic corruption in the first place). You can't say Z is a liar and ignore the habitual lies of Russian leadership over the years and pertaining to this war specifically.

Remove your personal feeling about leadership. What's left? The actions of each country and both the rights and fate of the actual people.

Once again I am not arguing that Putin is a good or trustworthy guy. What I have said is Zelensky is also a bad guy. This isn't a comparison contest of who is a bigger scumbag. It's about the reality of the situation. Ukraine isn't able to defeat Russia because they can't successfully invade Russia Neither Europe nor the US is willing to engage in an invasion of Russia. Yet all the anger seems to be at Trump when he seems to be the only guy who just wants the war to end and understands that is going to take Zelenskyy accepted a deal he doesn't want.

Otherwise we just stay in this endless cycle and the war never ends.


Read my response to 1939. I'm not arguing that Ukraine can defeat Russia and take everything back. And literally nobody, including Ukraine, advocates for an invasion of Russia. That's ridiculous. I'm arguing that putting ourselves and Ukraine in a position of weakness encourages Russia to decline good faith negotiations and hold out for full capitulation or full military victory. The way Trump is "negotiating" is not how one successfully negotiates anything. Trump isn't immune from criticism just because he wants to end the war some ol' way. If he's doing a piss poor job then it should be called out.

The end of this is going to be some sort of negotiated settlement but if it's a weak one then it will only be a pause with the potential for round 2 to be a larger problem. It needs to be permanent, and lasting, and uphold the credibility of the US as a trustworthy partner who can be counted on.

The problem is Russia is not going to capitulate, they are way too invested and having a hostile neighbor in easy driving distance of Moscow that they just capitulated to isn't going to happen, especially with Putin in charge. So the only way to change that is to force submission on Russia or to remove Putin. The only way that happens is with a full scale invasion of Russia. Until you face that reality it's pointless. Russia is not like the US. They are a very proud and very hard people that don't look at life as fair and are more than willing to make sacrifices we can't comprehend.

Now is it rewarding Putin or does he deserve it or is Zelenskyy better or whatever you want to talk about is all irrelevant. Until you realize there are 2 choices you are tilting at windmills. One is to give Putin enough of what he wants to feel like he had a degree of success and can feel like his border is secure long term so he cuts a deal and ends the war. The second is to go for regime change in Russia which would involve a full scale invasion. Even assassinating Putin won't work because that would likely provoke a nuclear reaction from Russia or at a minimum a far more severe/total war response.

In the meantime you can keep thinking that "well if we just send a few more bombs at some factories or a refinery Putin will decide to give up" all you want but if 5 years of war hasn't shown you that won't work I don't know what to tell you.


I never said that the goal was for Russia to capitulate. Where are you pulling that from? Do you feel that a reasonable negotiated settlement or anything less than full victory is Russian capitulation?

Or are you saying that Russia will never agree to a compromise so we have no choice but to force Ukraine to sacrifice themselves?

I'm saying Putin has the leverage and more importantly the will to keep fighting until he gets what he wants and he has the backing of the Russian people in that. So once again it's 3 options:

1. Take a deal with Russia that feels like Ukraine lost and they give up more than they want in the East and agree to become neutral and not a threat to Russia.

2. Go all out to win against Russia which almost certainly involves a full scale invasion.

3. Keep arguing about this for another 5 years while not wanting to face options 1 or 2.

BTW, this was the choice 4 years ago. 3 years ago. 2 years ago. Last year. So far the choice has been 3 because that is the easiest choice politically.

You left out:

4. Putin gets assassinated and they quit this stupid war. This is destroying their country and economy and killing every soldier age male they have.
GeorgiAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
How is NATO a threat to Russia? If Russia acts like a normal country and doesn't invade the others around it, nothing happens.

JUST ACT NORMAL. All of this goes away. You sell gas to everybody and live like kings.



ThunderCougarFalconBird
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Teslag said:

Rossticus said:

YouBet said:

Rossticus said:

Well, that's certainly an opinion. Congratulations. When are we giving Lithuania, Latvia, and Estonia back to the totally Not at all corrupt and violent country of Russia who in no way has a deeply embedded system of graft and waste.


Can certainly argue present day relevancy but Kiev was the capital and political center of the Rus people. Russia and Ukraine are ethnically tied at the hip.


So are Texas and Mexico, Taiwan and China. The US and England during independence and when the war of 1812 came around (which is pretty analogous to this conflict). Big friggidy whoop.

Ukraine has pushed for their independence for centuries from under the heel of Russia. They finally got it and Russia agreed to it when they lost the Cold War. Now since it's convenient for us we want to say "eh, you don't really deserve it and since Russia didn't want to it doesn't count". That just doesn't seem to be a logical way to approach this, IMO.


We could pull all aid and intel and they still fight to the death and this war would continue on that very truth.

I don't know whether that is true. The simplistic version of the message from the Trump administration to Ukraine seems to be, "get a deal done and put an end to this. We're tired of paying for it. The longer you wait, the worse it gets." If the support dries up, the willpower will probably dry up along with it. In spite of what many around here are shouting, the position isn't pro-Russian, it's pro-reality. On a long enough timeline, the survival rate for everyone is zero. For Ukraine, a deal you "like" isn't realistic. A deal you can live with can happen. It comes with terms you won't like. No deal at all means eventual capitulation and death. You can rally democrat and EU leaders to stomp and cry about it as long as you want, but it just isn't realistic. Or do you keep funding and escalating the thing and end up with a hot war with Russia?
MouthBQ98
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Russia is culturally sensitive to being wide open country relatively easy to invade.

They also have a nationalist movement that believes Russia is entitled to be the dominant empire in Eurasia.
YouBet
How long do you want to ignore this user?
aggie93 said:

Rossticus said:

aggie93 said:

Rossticus said:

aggie93 said:

Rossticus said:

And how much has Putin made in blood and corruption over his time? I'd wager he's a mite wealthier than Z. And Z made way more as a private citizen than Putin ever dreamed of. Trying to make this war a referendum on leadership fails on logic because it requires that you ignore one side who is inarguably worse (and was the cause of the other's systemic corruption in the first place). You can't say Z is a liar and ignore the habitual lies of Russian leadership over the years and pertaining to this war specifically.

Remove your personal feeling about leadership. What's left? The actions of each country and both the rights and fate of the actual people.

Once again I am not arguing that Putin is a good or trustworthy guy. What I have said is Zelensky is also a bad guy. This isn't a comparison contest of who is a bigger scumbag. It's about the reality of the situation. Ukraine isn't able to defeat Russia because they can't successfully invade Russia Neither Europe nor the US is willing to engage in an invasion of Russia. Yet all the anger seems to be at Trump when he seems to be the only guy who just wants the war to end and understands that is going to take Zelenskyy accepted a deal he doesn't want.

Otherwise we just stay in this endless cycle and the war never ends.


Read my response to 1939. I'm not arguing that Ukraine can defeat Russia and take everything back. And literally nobody, including Ukraine, advocates for an invasion of Russia. That's ridiculous. I'm arguing that putting ourselves and Ukraine in a position of weakness encourages Russia to decline good faith negotiations and hold out for full capitulation or full military victory. The way Trump is "negotiating" is not how one successfully negotiates anything. Trump isn't immune from criticism just because he wants to end the war some ol' way. If he's doing a piss poor job then it should be called out.

The end of this is going to be some sort of negotiated settlement but if it's a weak one then it will only be a pause with the potential for round 2 to be a larger problem. It needs to be permanent, and lasting, and uphold the credibility of the US as a trustworthy partner who can be counted on.

The problem is Russia is not going to capitulate, they are way too invested and having a hostile neighbor in easy driving distance of Moscow that they just capitulated to isn't going to happen, especially with Putin in charge. So the only way to change that is to force submission on Russia or to remove Putin. The only way that happens is with a full scale invasion of Russia. Until you face that reality it's pointless. Russia is not like the US. They are a very proud and very hard people that don't look at life as fair and are more than willing to make sacrifices we can't comprehend.

Now is it rewarding Putin or does he deserve it or is Zelenskyy better or whatever you want to talk about is all irrelevant. Until you realize there are 2 choices you are tilting at windmills. One is to give Putin enough of what he wants to feel like he had a degree of success and can feel like his border is secure long term so he cuts a deal and ends the war. The second is to go for regime change in Russia which would involve a full scale invasion. Even assassinating Putin won't work because that would likely provoke a nuclear reaction from Russia or at a minimum a far more severe/total war response.

In the meantime you can keep thinking that "well if we just send a few more bombs at some factories or a refinery Putin will decide to give up" all you want but if 5 years of war hasn't shown you that won't work I don't know what to tell you.


I never said that the goal was for Russia to capitulate. Where are you pulling that from? Do you feel that a reasonable negotiated settlement or anything less than full victory is Russian capitulation?

Or are you saying that Russia will never agree to a compromise so we have no choice but to force Ukraine to sacrifice themselves?

I'm saying Putin has the leverage and more importantly the will to keep fighting until he gets what he wants and he has the backing of the Russian people in that. So once again it's 3 options:

1. Take a deal with Russia that feels like Ukraine lost and they give up more than they want in the East and agree to become neutral and not a threat to Russia.

2. Go all out to win against Russia which almost certainly involves a full scale invasion.

3. Keep arguing about this for another 5 years while not wanting to face options 1 or 2.

BTW, this was the choice 4 years ago. 3 years ago. 2 years ago. Last year. So far the choice has been 3 because that is the easiest choice politically.


This is such an obvious and easy analysis that a cave man could do it.

I'm not sure why this is so hard for everyone to grasp.

How we got here is irrelevant. This is where we are now and is reality. And, in reality, it's been this way for 12 years if you go back to Crimea.
GeorgiAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
MouthBQ98 said:

Russia is culturally sensitive to being wide open country relatively easy to invade.

They also have a nationalist movement that believes Russia is entitled to be the dominant empire in Eurasia.

Under threat of invasion from whom? Luxembourg? Poland?

I believe I am entitled to a harem including Sydney Sweeney, and all the Victorias Secret supermodels (not the fat one). So what?

They are concerned their citizens will see what the other people of Europe (democratic) have and will want a similar government there. No more Autocrat-Oligarchy. The old USSR KGB guys all need to die off.
YouBet
How long do you want to ignore this user?
GeorgiAg said:

MouthBQ98 said:

Russia is culturally sensitive to being wide open country relatively easy to invade.

They also have a nationalist movement that believes Russia is entitled to be the dominant empire in Eurasia.

Under threat of invasion from whom? Luxembourg? Poland?

I believe I am entitled to a harem including Sydney Sweeney, and all the Victorias Secret supermodels (not the fat one). So what?

They are concerned their citizens will see what the other people of Europe (democratic) have and will want a similar government there. No more Autocrat-Oligarchy. The old USSR KGB guys all need to die off.


Practically, you are obviously correct, but a practical take here is irrelevant.

It's the way Russia thinks. It's in their DNA.

Edit: Looking the other direction, China is a real threat for invasion if and when China gets cocky or desperate.
Sq 17
How long do you want to ignore this user?
flown-the-coop said:

I think it says more about you that you have an opinion on the competency of your Sonic manager.

But seriously, the concept that Trump is a bad negotiator and gets led around by the nose by foreign dictators is simply not based in reality.


Operation Epic Fury says "hi"
GeorgiAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
YouBet said:

GeorgiAg said:

MouthBQ98 said:

Russia is culturally sensitive to being wide open country relatively easy to invade.

They also have a nationalist movement that believes Russia is entitled to be the dominant empire in Eurasia.

Under threat of invasion from whom? Luxembourg? Poland?

I believe I am entitled to a harem including Sydney Sweeney, and all the Victorias Secret supermodels (not the fat one). So what?

They are concerned their citizens will see what the other people of Europe (democratic) have and will want a similar government there. No more Autocrat-Oligarchy. The old USSR KGB guys all need to die off.


Practically, you are obviously correct, but a practical take here is irrelevant.

It's the way Russia thinks. It's in their DNA.

Edit: Looking the other direction, China is a real threat for invasion if and when China gets cocky or desperate.

That DNA needs to be removed then. Letting Ukraine have missiles, intel and Starlink are a pretty cheap way to do that.

I do not understand the appeasement crowd. Peace in our time, eh? We've seen how that works with those hell-bent on territorial expansion. The more military Putin keeps, the more he will seek to expand. He's an old KGB guy who misses the old days.
flown-the-coop
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Sq 17 said:

flown-the-coop said:

I think it says more about you that you have an opinion on the competency of your Sonic manager.

But seriously, the concept that Trump is a bad negotiator and gets led around by the nose by foreign dictators is simply not based in reality.


Operation Epic Fury says "hi"

It sure does. Wrapping up the most ferocious of hostilities then starving them out with Economic Fury all whilst not putting boots on the ground.

Sorry your boys in the IRGC are going down.
YouBet
How long do you want to ignore this user?
GeorgiAg said:

YouBet said:

GeorgiAg said:

MouthBQ98 said:

Russia is culturally sensitive to being wide open country relatively easy to invade.

They also have a nationalist movement that believes Russia is entitled to be the dominant empire in Eurasia.

Under threat of invasion from whom? Luxembourg? Poland?

I believe I am entitled to a harem including Sydney Sweeney, and all the Victorias Secret supermodels (not the fat one). So what?

They are concerned their citizens will see what the other people of Europe (democratic) have and will want a similar government there. No more Autocrat-Oligarchy. The old USSR KGB guys all need to die off.


Practically, you are obviously correct, but a practical take here is irrelevant.

It's the way Russia thinks. It's in their DNA.

Edit: Looking the other direction, China is a real threat for invasion if and when China gets cocky or desperate.

That DNA needs to be removed then. Letting Ukraine have missiles, intel and Starlink are a pretty cheap way to do that.

I do not understand the appeasement crowd. Peace in our time, eh? We've seen how that works with those hell-bent on territorial expansion. The more military Putin keeps, the more he will seek to expand. He's an old KGB guy who misses the old days.

Impossible to remove without them evolving on their own and not really a relevant or effective strategy as aggie93 has eloquently laid out.

It's either full on invasion or a peace deal with less-than-ideal terms.

Sucks but that's reality.
GeorgiAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Yep, Iran needed to be dealt with.
MouthBQ98
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I didn't say it was rational or reasonable. They are paranoid about it and it drives the behavior of their nationalist leadership. They want their regional hegemony and buffer states back.

It makes them a big problem to deal with long term because they will keep trying to subjugate their neighbors if they believe they can.
1939
How long do you want to ignore this user?
GeorgiAg said:

YouBet said:

GeorgiAg said:

MouthBQ98 said:

Russia is culturally sensitive to being wide open country relatively easy to invade.

They also have a nationalist movement that believes Russia is entitled to be the dominant empire in Eurasia.

Under threat of invasion from whom? Luxembourg? Poland?

I believe I am entitled to a harem including Sydney Sweeney, and all the Victorias Secret supermodels (not the fat one). So what?

They are concerned their citizens will see what the other people of Europe (democratic) have and will want a similar government there. No more Autocrat-Oligarchy. The old USSR KGB guys all need to die off.


Practically, you are obviously correct, but a practical take here is irrelevant.

It's the way Russia thinks. It's in their DNA.

Edit: Looking the other direction, China is a real threat for invasion if and when China gets cocky or desperate.

That DNA needs to be removed then. Letting Ukraine have missiles, intel and Starlink are a pretty cheap way to do that.

I do not understand the appeasement crowd. Peace in our time, eh? We've seen how that works with those hell-bent on territorial expansion. The more military Putin keeps, the more he will seek to expand. He's an old KGB guy who misses the old days.


I don't understand how you think this is going to end. It seems that you still believe that Ukraine is going to drive Russia out and "win" the war. That is not going to happen.

And quit with the false equivalency that recognizing the situation on the ground and wanting a negotiated end to the war is somehow siding with Putin.

You have offered Zero realistic scenarios to end this and are now advocating for assassinating Putin.
flown-the-coop
How long do you want to ignore this user?
The corruption in Ukraine should not be ignored, including their de facto dictator who refuses to hold elections lest he lose out on his graft.

Ukraine is better off as part of Russia or as a puppet-state a la Belarus.

aggie93 has provided some reasonable takes as have you.

The whole we must "stand with Ukraine" has never, ever made any sense.
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.