Trump and Russia Pivot - October 2026

53,660 Views | 986 Replies | Last: 6 hrs ago by Rossticus
Jeeper79
How long do you want to ignore this user?
YouBet said:

eric76 said:

YouBet said:

Terrible optics but don't really care. If it brings Russia back into the world order and mitigates their aggression, then do it. We need Russia engaged with the western world and not be a pariah state. The way things are going we are likely going to have to replace Western Europe with someone new anyway. Will need a counter in Central and Eastern Europe to the coming Islamic States of Western Europe.

Bring Russia back into the world order? That isn't going to happen.

Our helping Russia takes away any reason for them to join the world order.

And Russia doesn't want to join the world order -- they want the world under their control.


lol. No they don't. They want to ensure they can rule their immediate sphere of influence and protect their borders. This is known.
Took me 47 years on this planet before I learned Cuba and Venezuela are on the Russian border.

We get it. Trump likes Russia and it would agitate your type 2 TDS to go against him.
Sq 17
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Putin also considers Latvia and a few other countries in Eastern Europe to be his to control
YouBet
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Jeeper79 said:

YouBet said:

Jeeper79 said:

YouBet said:

Aggie1205 said:

YouBet said:

Terrible optics but don't really care. If it brings Russia back into the world order and mitigates their aggression, then do it. We need Russia engaged with the western world and not be a pariah state. The way things are going we are likely going to have to replace Western Europe with someone new anyway. Will need a counter in Central and Eastern Europe to the coming Islamic States of Western Europe.

Russia has a much higher % of Muslim population than Western European countries. It's puzzling that people don't know that.

And when has Russia shown it can mitigate its own aggression? Just in the last 110 years its attacked or force annexed Finland, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, Poland, Romania, Armenia, Georgia, Afghanistan, Azerbaijan, Mongolia, and now Ukraine. Russia has shown who they are as a culture, they will have a strong-arm dictator, and they will always be trying to conquer their smaller neighbors. It's who they are.


I'm aware of their Muslim population. Most on here are. It's also a population they arent afraid to keep in check unlike Western Europe who is committing suicide over it.

If our current allies are going to voluntarily commit suicide by Muslim then the continent will need someone like Russia as an offset. That's the reality.
The only reason Russia isn't a greater threat is because it doesn't have the power to do more damage. The last thing we should be doing is strengthening them.


Who cares with Western Europe's trend. Russia will be lesser of evils.
They have a nuclear arsenal that's even bigger than ours, ICBMs, and don't actually like us.


And unlike Muslims who are trying to take over Western Europe, Russia is run by white, rationalist people.
YouBet
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Jeeper79 said:

YouBet said:

eric76 said:

YouBet said:

Terrible optics but don't really care. If it brings Russia back into the world order and mitigates their aggression, then do it. We need Russia engaged with the western world and not be a pariah state. The way things are going we are likely going to have to replace Western Europe with someone new anyway. Will need a counter in Central and Eastern Europe to the coming Islamic States of Western Europe.

Bring Russia back into the world order? That isn't going to happen.

Our helping Russia takes away any reason for them to join the world order.

And Russia doesn't want to join the world order -- they want the world under their control.


lol. No they don't. They want to ensure they can rule their immediate sphere of influence and protect their borders. This is known.
Took me 47 years on this planet before I learned Cuba and Venezuela are on the Russian border.

We get it. Trump likes Russia and it would agitate your type 2 TDS to go against him.


That was the communist USSR. Oligarchy Russia has no control or influence there.
Featured Video Previews
Jeeper79
How long do you want to ignore this user?
YouBet said:

Jeeper79 said:

YouBet said:

eric76 said:

YouBet said:

Terrible optics but don't really care. If it brings Russia back into the world order and mitigates their aggression, then do it. We need Russia engaged with the western world and not be a pariah state. The way things are going we are likely going to have to replace Western Europe with someone new anyway. Will need a counter in Central and Eastern Europe to the coming Islamic States of Western Europe.

Bring Russia back into the world order? That isn't going to happen.

Our helping Russia takes away any reason for them to join the world order.

And Russia doesn't want to join the world order -- they want the world under their control.


lol. No they don't. They want to ensure they can rule their immediate sphere of influence and protect their borders. This is known.
Took me 47 years on this planet before I learned Cuba and Venezuela are on the Russian border.

We get it. Trump likes Russia and it would agitate your type 2 TDS to go against him.


That was the communist USSR. Oligarchy Russia has no control or influence there.


https://thehill.com/policy/international/5889903-russia-cuba-support-us-embargo/

What strategic value could Cuba possibly provide to Russia on the other side of the world if its only interested in protecting its borders? They aren't exactly known for their humanitarian work.
Rocky Rider
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Dims like placing the spotlight on Russia because it takes attention off their relationships in China to include the money that's being spent to undermine our society and economy.
YouBet
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Jeeper79 said:

YouBet said:

Jeeper79 said:

YouBet said:

eric76 said:

YouBet said:

Terrible optics but don't really care. If it brings Russia back into the world order and mitigates their aggression, then do it. We need Russia engaged with the western world and not be a pariah state. The way things are going we are likely going to have to replace Western Europe with someone new anyway. Will need a counter in Central and Eastern Europe to the coming Islamic States of Western Europe.

Bring Russia back into the world order? That isn't going to happen.

Our helping Russia takes away any reason for them to join the world order.

And Russia doesn't want to join the world order -- they want the world under their control.


lol. No they don't. They want to ensure they can rule their immediate sphere of influence and protect their borders. This is known.
Took me 47 years on this planet before I learned Cuba and Venezuela are on the Russian border.

We get it. Trump likes Russia and it would agitate your type 2 TDS to go against him.


That was the communist USSR. Oligarchy Russia has no control or influence there.


https://thehill.com/policy/international/5889903-russia-cuba-support-us-embargo/

What strategic value could Cuba possibly provide to Russia on the other side of the world if its only interested in protecting its borders? They aren't exactly known for their humanitarian work.


Yes, I recall that from 5 months ago as well and It never materialized because Russia has no reach beyond their immediate sphere. That was leftover vain glory talk that meant nothing.

Russia has been run out of Syria and Africa in the last several years which were their other global outposts. They have no global reach anymore. It's a dying, sick country and is one of the main reasons they are desperate to take Ukraine back because it's adjacent for borders, historically Russian, and resource rich. They've lost everything else.
nortex97
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Our ostensible non-partisan 'ally' on Meet the Press Democrat media this am:


This is the guy who has driven this 'pivot.' Every interview denigrates/threatens Trump/the GOP in some way at this point.
flown-the-coop
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Aggie1205 said:

YouBet said:

Terrible optics but don't really care. If it brings Russia back into the world order and mitigates their aggression, then do it. We need Russia engaged with the western world and not be a pariah state. The way things are going we are likely going to have to replace Western Europe with someone new anyway. Will need a counter in Central and Eastern Europe to the coming Islamic States of Western Europe.

Russia has a much higher % of Muslim population than Western European countries. It's puzzling that people don't know that.

And when has Russia shown it can mitigate its own aggression? Just in the last 110 years its attacked or force annexed Finland, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, Poland, Romania, Armenia, Georgia, Afghanistan, Azerbaijan, Mongolia, and now Ukraine. Russia has shown who they are as a culture, they will have a strong-arm dictator, and they will always be trying to conquer their smaller neighbors. It's who they are.

Huge difference is Russian Muslims are largely if not primarily indigenous and not immigrants and are concentrated in those indigenous areas.

It's not like a bunch of Somalians took up shop in Moscow la Minneapolis.
Phatbob
How long do you want to ignore this user?
This thread is ridiculous. You don't judge foreign policy on a single decision the day it is signed. That act is part of a long term global strategy to acheive goals. Is this decision a disaster? Is it capitulating to Russia? We don't know that and won't for a while. There are plenty of scenarios where this is a good move (and plenty where it isn't). All this thread has proven is who is unwilling or unable to think past this weekend.
Jeeper79
How long do you want to ignore this user?
YouBet said:

Jeeper79 said:

YouBet said:

Jeeper79 said:

YouBet said:

Aggie1205 said:

YouBet said:

Terrible optics but don't really care. If it brings Russia back into the world order and mitigates their aggression, then do it. We need Russia engaged with the western world and not be a pariah state. The way things are going we are likely going to have to replace Western Europe with someone new anyway. Will need a counter in Central and Eastern Europe to the coming Islamic States of Western Europe.

Russia has a much higher % of Muslim population than Western European countries. It's puzzling that people don't know that.

And when has Russia shown it can mitigate its own aggression? Just in the last 110 years its attacked or force annexed Finland, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, Poland, Romania, Armenia, Georgia, Afghanistan, Azerbaijan, Mongolia, and now Ukraine. Russia has shown who they are as a culture, they will have a strong-arm dictator, and they will always be trying to conquer their smaller neighbors. It's who they are.


I'm aware of their Muslim population. Most on here are. It's also a population they arent afraid to keep in check unlike Western Europe who is committing suicide over it.

If our current allies are going to voluntarily commit suicide by Muslim then the continent will need someone like Russia as an offset. That's the reality.
The only reason Russia isn't a greater threat is because it doesn't have the power to do more damage. The last thing we should be doing is strengthening them.


Who cares with Western Europe's trend. Russia will be lesser of evils.
They have a nuclear arsenal that's even bigger than ours, ICBMs, and don't actually like us.


And unlike Muslims who are trying to take over Western Europe, Russia is run by white, rationalist people.
Assuming you meant "nationalists"…

Yes, they are white nationalists. The exact same sort of white nationalists we fought a Cold War against to prevent their spread of power and influence. Their leader is literally former KGB.
Jeeper79
How long do you want to ignore this user?
nortex97 said:

Our ostensible non-partisan 'ally' on Meet the Press Democrat media this am:


This is the guy who has driven this 'pivot.' Every interview denigrates/threatens Trump/the GOP in some way at this point.
You have your order of events backwards. This is a defensive maneuver on his part in light of the new Russia diesel news and renewed pressure from the U.S. for Ukraine to capitulate. What else do you expect a guy in that situation to say?
Jeeper79
How long do you want to ignore this user?
YouBet said:

Jeeper79 said:

YouBet said:

Jeeper79 said:

YouBet said:

eric76 said:

YouBet said:

Terrible optics but don't really care. If it brings Russia back into the world order and mitigates their aggression, then do it. We need Russia engaged with the western world and not be a pariah state. The way things are going we are likely going to have to replace Western Europe with someone new anyway. Will need a counter in Central and Eastern Europe to the coming Islamic States of Western Europe.

Bring Russia back into the world order? That isn't going to happen.

Our helping Russia takes away any reason for them to join the world order.

And Russia doesn't want to join the world order -- they want the world under their control.


lol. No they don't. They want to ensure they can rule their immediate sphere of influence and protect their borders. This is known.
Took me 47 years on this planet before I learned Cuba and Venezuela are on the Russian border.

We get it. Trump likes Russia and it would agitate your type 2 TDS to go against him.


That was the communist USSR. Oligarchy Russia has no control or influence there.


https://thehill.com/policy/international/5889903-russia-cuba-support-us-embargo/

What strategic value could Cuba possibly provide to Russia on the other side of the world if its only interested in protecting its borders? They aren't exactly known for their humanitarian work.


Yes, I recall that from 5 months ago as well and It never materialized because Russia has no reach beyond their immediate sphere. That was leftover vain glory talk that meant nothing.

Russia has been run out of Syria and Africa in the last several years which were their other global outposts. They have no global reach anymore. It's a dying, sick country and is one of the main reasons they are desperate to take Ukraine back because it's adjacent for borders, historically Russian, and resource rich. They've lost everything else.
So you're saying its Russia's weakness that's preventing their sphere of influence from growing in the Americas. Gee… Maybe we shouldn't be helping them do that. You know… While they're providing support and weapons to the country we're actively fighting a war against. A country that's been our heated adversary for 80 years.
nortex97
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Jeeper79 said:

You have your order of events backwards. This is a defensive maneuver on his part in light of the new Russia diesel news and renewed pressure from the U.S. for Ukraine to capitulate. What else do you expect a guy in that situation to say?

No, I don't. This is a tiny amount of revenue compared to spend from Europe just this year on Russian energy (to say nothing of China/India/Canada), and Z knows that. He's on a leftist American TV show (in his best black T-shirt, LOL) to try to harm American interests (and efforts to end the war/diesel crisis he wants to further) to support Democrats/war.

That's something he is consistent on, and has been for quite some time.
Sq 17
How long do you want to ignore this user?
The revenue is not relevant. The fact that we are lifting sanctions on Russia after passing a very tough sanction. Bill shows we are not a serious country and someone our allies cannot trust.
aggie93
How long do you want to ignore this user?
flown-the-coop said:

Aggie1205 said:

YouBet said:

Terrible optics but don't really care. If it brings Russia back into the world order and mitigates their aggression, then do it. We need Russia engaged with the western world and not be a pariah state. The way things are going we are likely going to have to replace Western Europe with someone new anyway. Will need a counter in Central and Eastern Europe to the coming Islamic States of Western Europe.

Russia has a much higher % of Muslim population than Western European countries. It's puzzling that people don't know that.

And when has Russia shown it can mitigate its own aggression? Just in the last 110 years its attacked or force annexed Finland, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, Poland, Romania, Armenia, Georgia, Afghanistan, Azerbaijan, Mongolia, and now Ukraine. Russia has shown who they are as a culture, they will have a strong-arm dictator, and they will always be trying to conquer their smaller neighbors. It's who they are.

Huge difference is Russian Muslims are largely if not primarily indigenous and not immigrants and are concentrated in those indigenous areas.

It's not like a bunch of Somalians took up shop in Moscow la Minneapolis.

Correct
BlackGold
How long do you want to ignore this user?
t_J_e_C_x said:

BigRobSA said:

I support leaving Russia and Ukraine to their own devices. F both of them. Let them nuke each other.


Good opinion, but why are we going out of our way to support a bad faith actor whose been openly supporting Iran in their fight against us?


We've been supporting the other Vlad, a bad faith actor, this whole time. Same could be asked from the Russian perspective since we've been supporting Ukraine via cash, weapons and intel.

Russia could be way more of a strategic partner to the US than Ukraine ever could. Unless you want to launder money.
YouBet
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Jeeper79 said:

YouBet said:

Jeeper79 said:

YouBet said:

Jeeper79 said:

YouBet said:

eric76 said:

YouBet said:

Terrible optics but don't really care. If it brings Russia back into the world order and mitigates their aggression, then do it. We need Russia engaged with the western world and not be a pariah state. The way things are going we are likely going to have to replace Western Europe with someone new anyway. Will need a counter in Central and Eastern Europe to the coming Islamic States of Western Europe.

Bring Russia back into the world order? That isn't going to happen.

Our helping Russia takes away any reason for them to join the world order.

And Russia doesn't want to join the world order -- they want the world under their control.


lol. No they don't. They want to ensure they can rule their immediate sphere of influence and protect their borders. This is known.
Took me 47 years on this planet before I learned Cuba and Venezuela are on the Russian border.

We get it. Trump likes Russia and it would agitate your type 2 TDS to go against him.


That was the communist USSR. Oligarchy Russia has no control or influence there.


https://thehill.com/policy/international/5889903-russia-cuba-support-us-embargo/

What strategic value could Cuba possibly provide to Russia on the other side of the world if its only interested in protecting its borders? They aren't exactly known for their humanitarian work.


Yes, I recall that from 5 months ago as well and It never materialized because Russia has no reach beyond their immediate sphere. That was leftover vain glory talk that meant nothing.

Russia has been run out of Syria and Africa in the last several years which were their other global outposts. They have no global reach anymore. It's a dying, sick country and is one of the main reasons they are desperate to take Ukraine back because it's adjacent for borders, historically Russian, and resource rich. They've lost everything else.
So you're saying its Russia's weakness that's preventing their sphere of influence from fluency from growing in the Americas. Gee… Maybe we shouldn't be helping them do that. You know… While they're providing support and weapons to the country we're actively fighting a war against. A country that's been our heated adversary for 80 years.


I realize I'm coming across as some sort of Russian supporter, but I'm not. Putin is a bad actor and most understand this.

All I'm arguing is that Western Europe is trending in all the wrong directions - overt communism in UK (you know what the USSR used to be) and ever more socialism up to the brink of communism in Spain and France. France is at least smart enough to recognize they can't continue with their cradle to grave welfare but the problem is that they've hooked their population into the Matrix so completely that the people refuse to let the government claw back any spending.

And then add in their open borders policies for low IQ Africans and Muslims who do not want to assimilate. We are watching cultural and economic suicide in real time. It's a death spiral.

So, if this trend continues, and no one is seeing any developments that it won't, those countries are going to fail and fall. If/when that happens, the EU will then fail. Central and Eastern European countries who have done much more to protect their borders and cultures will pull away, but they have little to no means to fight back the feral hordes that then come for them except for the Nordic countries and Germany who are re-arming as much as they can, right now.

You then have Russia who is still a regional power in the east who can serve as a lesser of evils bulwark against what Western Europe could devolve to. And what is happening in those three countries will spread. That is the nature of Islam and anarchy.

Thus, I'm looking beyond Putin, who is old by the way, and to larger geopolitical matters here.
Vepp
How long do you want to ignore this user?
If their is an overt EVIL actor in this world right now, it's Russia.

Partnering with evil makes us what, exactly?
Im Gipper
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I don't think you are cheerleading Putin at all. You seem to understand he's evil.

What I think you are naive on is his aspirations and intentions. He'd be back in Syria and all over if he thinks they can do it. He's just biding his time. He knows Russia that doesn't extend its tentacles worldwide is viewed as weak. Thats the last thing he wants.

I'm Gipper
flown-the-coop
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Vepp said:

If their is an overt EVIL actor in this world right now, it's Russia.

Partnering with evil makes us what, exactly?

Putin and Russia don't even crack the top 10.
aggie93
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Jeeper79 said:

YouBet said:

Jeeper79 said:

YouBet said:

Jeeper79 said:

YouBet said:

eric76 said:

YouBet said:

Terrible optics but don't really care. If it brings Russia back into the world order and mitigates their aggression, then do it. We need Russia engaged with the western world and not be a pariah state. The way things are going we are likely going to have to replace Western Europe with someone new anyway. Will need a counter in Central and Eastern Europe to the coming Islamic States of Western Europe.

Bring Russia back into the world order? That isn't going to happen.

Our helping Russia takes away any reason for them to join the world order.

And Russia doesn't want to join the world order -- they want the world under their control.


lol. No they don't. They want to ensure they can rule their immediate sphere of influence and protect their borders. This is known.

Took me 47 years on this planet before I learned Cuba and Venezuela are on the Russian border.

We get it. Trump likes Russia and it would agitate your type 2 TDS to go against him.


That was the communist USSR. Oligarchy Russia has no control or influence there.


https://thehill.com/policy/international/5889903-russia-cuba-support-us-embargo/

What strategic value could Cuba possibly provide to Russia on the other side of the world if its only interested in protecting its borders? They aren't exactly known for their humanitarian work.


Yes, I recall that from 5 months ago as well and It never materialized because Russia has no reach beyond their immediate sphere. That was leftover vain glory talk that meant nothing.

Russia has been run out of Syria and Africa in the last several years which were their other global outposts. They have no global reach anymore. It's a dying, sick country and is one of the main reasons they are desperate to take Ukraine back because it's adjacent for borders, historically Russian, and resource rich. They've lost everything else.

So you're saying its Russia's weakness that's preventing their sphere of influence from growing in the Americas. Gee… Maybe we shouldn't be helping them do that. You know… While they're providing support and weapons to the country we're actively fighting a war against. A country that's been our heated adversary for 80 years.

Iran is far more reliant on China than Russia. What have we done there? Found other issues of value to China and pushed them away from giving support to Iran. We are likely doing the same with Russia. Russia DGAF about Iran outside of how it benefits them. They are only aligned because they both are against the US. Iran under the Mullahs will always be a threat to us. Russia does not need to be and in reality shouldn't be.

Most of the Russia hate is "PUTIN!" which is fine and all but Xi makes Putin look like a softie, much less Kim, much less the Mulahs. Guess what? Zelensky is every bit as bad. He's a dictator who openly works against the US, is more than willing to suppress and kill his people, and he will do anything to hold on to power. If you can't see that it is because you simply choose not to but Ukrainians are at least as bad as Russians. They will and have turned on us the moment we aren't sending them massive amounts of money and supplies, they are only friends with us for that reason and have proven this over and over.

Zelensky knows the end of the war with Russia also means the end of his own power and he likely ends up in prison or killed, that's how things roll in that part of the world. Thus he will never agree to peace willingly and neither will Putin. Yet many simply support Zelensky blindly, especially older Americans that grew up thinking Russia and USSR are synonymous. I know I used to until I actually studied Russian history and culture and got to understand them. Putin is far more Peter the Great than Lenin or Stalin. He certainly is no true communist and only was one when he was younger because that was the only path to power in the USSR.

Russia has a smaller GDP than Texas. They don't have a military that is remotely capable of projecting global power anymore. They are of little threat to us. They are a threat to Ukraine and Eastern Europe AND they are a threat to China. Yet we push them closer and closer to China by alienating them. For Cold War acolytes, one of the key components we had was encouraging Russia and China to never trust each other and be truly allied yet many seem to have forgotten this lesson. You can't every truly trust either but we can certainly be on good enough terms with both that they focus their attention on areas and issues that don't effect us. That's essentially what Trump has been doing for years yet most can't see it or refuse to see it. China is a far greater threat to the US than Russia ever will be.
YouBet
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Vepp said:

If their is an overt EVIL actor in this world right now, it's Russia.

Partnering with evil makes us what, exactly?


They aren't close to China who we are highly integrated with from an economic standpoint. If we can be this tightly wound with China, then WGAS if we have a diesel deal with Russia.

And we are culturally closer to Russia than we are China.

I would prefer neither, but that isn't reality.
Jeeper79
How long do you want to ignore this user?
YouBet said:

Jeeper79 said:

YouBet said:

Jeeper79 said:

YouBet said:

Jeeper79 said:

YouBet said:

eric76 said:

YouBet said:

Terrible optics but don't really care. If it brings Russia back into the world order and mitigates their aggression, then do it. We need Russia engaged with the western world and not be a pariah state. The way things are going we are likely going to have to replace Western Europe with someone new anyway. Will need a counter in Central and Eastern Europe to the coming Islamic States of Western Europe.

Bring Russia back into the world order? That isn't going to happen.

Our helping Russia takes away any reason for them to join the world order.

And Russia doesn't want to join the world order -- they want the world under their control.


lol. No they don't. They want to ensure they can rule their immediate sphere of influence and protect their borders. This is known.
Took me 47 years on this planet before I learned Cuba and Venezuela are on the Russian border.

We get it. Trump likes Russia and it would agitate your type 2 TDS to go against him.


That was the communist USSR. Oligarchy Russia has no control or influence there.


https://thehill.com/policy/international/5889903-russia-cuba-support-us-embargo/

What strategic value could Cuba possibly provide to Russia on the other side of the world if its only interested in protecting its borders? They aren't exactly known for their humanitarian work.


Yes, I recall that from 5 months ago as well and It never materialized because Russia has no reach beyond their immediate sphere. That was leftover vain glory talk that meant nothing.

Russia has been run out of Syria and Africa in the last several years which were their other global outposts. They have no global reach anymore. It's a dying, sick country and is one of the main reasons they are desperate to take Ukraine back because it's adjacent for borders, historically Russian, and resource rich. They've lost everything else.
So you're saying its Russia's weakness that's preventing their sphere of influence from fluency from growing in the Americas. Gee… Maybe we shouldn't be helping them do that. You know… While they're providing support and weapons to the country we're actively fighting a war against. A country that's been our heated adversary for 80 years.


I realize I'm coming across as some sort of Russian supporter, but I'm not. Putin is a bad actor and most understand this.

All I'm arguing is that Western Europe is trending in all the wrong directions - overt communism in UK (you know what the USSR used to be) and ever more socialism up to the brink of communism in Spain and France. France is at least smart enough to recognize they can't continue with their cradle to grave welfare but the problem is that they've hooked their population into the Matrix so completely that the people refuse to let the government claw back any spending.

And then add in their open borders policies for low IQ Africans and Muslims who do not want to assimilate. We are watching cultural and economic suicide in real time. It's a death spiral.

So, if this trend continues, and no one is seeing any developments that it won't, those countries are going to fail and fall. If/when that happens, the EU will then fail. Central and Eastern European countries who have done much more to protect their borders and cultures will pull away, but they have little to no means to fight back the feral hordes that then come for them except for the Nordic countries and Germany who are re-arming as much as they can, right now.

You then have Russia who is still a regional power in the east who can serve as a lesser of evils bulwark against what Western Europe could devolve to. And what is happening in those three countries will spread. That is the nature of Islam and anarchy.

Thus, I'm looking beyond Putin, who is old by the way, and to larger geopolitical matters here.
Your analysis of the current state of things is reasonable, but I disagree with most of the rest.

A Russia that controls Central Europe is a much greater threat to us than a few allies moving further left. We have trade agreements, NATO, and centuries of positive relationships and integrated commerce with Europe. We have the opposite with Russia. I fully believe that any power given to Russia will only make it more authoritarian and imperialistic.
flown-the-coop
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Further isolating Russia is what makes it more authoritarian and imperialistic.

If your aim is the opposite, then you bring them back into the fold not force them further away.
Jeeper79
How long do you want to ignore this user?
flown-the-coop said:

Further isolating Russia is what makes it more authoritarian and imperialistic.

If your aim is the opposite, then you bring them back into the fold not force them further away.
We don't need to guess how they would react. History has already provided us with multiple examples.
YouBet
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Jeeper79 said:

YouBet said:

Jeeper79 said:

YouBet said:

Jeeper79 said:

YouBet said:

Jeeper79 said:

YouBet said:

eric76 said:

YouBet said:

Terrible optics but don't really care. If it brings Russia back into the world order and mitigates their aggression, then do it. We need Russia engaged with the western world and not be a pariah state. The way things are going we are likely going to have to replace Western Europe with someone new anyway. Will need a counter in Central and Eastern Europe to the coming Islamic States of Western Europe.

Bring Russia back into the world order? That isn't going to happen.

Our helping Russia takes away any reason for them to join the world order.

And Russia doesn't want to join the world order -- they want the world under their control.


lol. No they don't. They want to ensure they can rule their immediate sphere of influence and protect their borders. This is known.
Took me 47 years on this planet before I learned Cuba and Venezuela are on the Russian border.

We get it. Trump likes Russia and it would agitate your type 2 TDS to go against him.


That was the communist USSR. Oligarchy Russia has no control or influence there.


https://thehill.com/policy/international/5889903-russia-cuba-support-us-embargo/

What strategic value could Cuba possibly provide to Russia on the other side of the world if its only interested in protecting its borders? They aren't exactly known for their humanitarian work.


Yes, I recall that from 5 months ago as well and It never materialized because Russia has no reach beyond their immediate sphere. That was leftover vain glory talk that meant nothing.

Russia has been run out of Syria and Africa in the last several years which were their other global outposts. They have no global reach anymore. It's a dying, sick country and is one of the main reasons they are desperate to take Ukraine back because it's adjacent for borders, historically Russian, and resource rich. They've lost everything else.
So you're saying its Russia's weakness that's preventing their sphere of influence from fluency from growing in the Americas. Gee… Maybe we shouldn't be helping them do that. You know… While they're providing support and weapons to the country we're actively fighting a war against. A country that's been our heated adversary for 80 years.


I realize I'm coming across as some sort of Russian supporter, but I'm not. Putin is a bad actor and most understand this.

All I'm arguing is that Western Europe is trending in all the wrong directions - overt communism in UK (you know what the USSR used to be) and ever more socialism up to the brink of communism in Spain and France. France is at least smart enough to recognize they can't continue with their cradle to grave welfare but the problem is that they've hooked their population into the Matrix so completely that the people refuse to let the government claw back any spending.

And then add in their open borders policies for low IQ Africans and Muslims who do not want to assimilate. We are watching cultural and economic suicide in real time. It's a death spiral.

So, if this trend continues, and no one is seeing any developments that it won't, those countries are going to fail and fall. If/when that happens, the EU will then fail. Central and Eastern European countries who have done much more to protect their borders and cultures will pull away, but they have little to no means to fight back the feral hordes that then come for them except for the Nordic countries and Germany who are re-arming as much as they can, right now.

You then have Russia who is still a regional power in the east who can serve as a lesser of evils bulwark against what Western Europe could devolve to. And what is happening in those three countries will spread. That is the nature of Islam and anarchy.

Thus, I'm looking beyond Putin, who is old by the way, and to larger geopolitical matters here.
Your analysis of the current state of things is reasonable, but I disagree with most of the rest.

A Russia that controls Central Europe is a much greater threat to us than a few allies moving further left. We have trade agreements, NATO, and centuries of positive relationships and integrated commerce with Europe. We have the opposite with Russia. I fully believe that any power given to Russia will only make it more authoritarian and imperialistic.


I think you are underselling "a few allies moving left". They are moving left to the point that we have to question them as allies. That's my point. We can't be both allies to far left wing Islamo-Communist countries, but then hold our nose up at Russia just because they've been *******s since the Tsar was overthrown. And since 1991 the worst Russia has been is a spoiler country. That's 35 years now.

And never mind we had a great opportunity to bring them into the fold back then but we chose to continue treating them as an arch enemy when we didn't have to. All kinds of fun history to debate on that.
AGHouston11
How long do you want to ignore this user?
It's funny when you remember all the things Trump said about Merkel and Germany making deals with Russia for energy.

Now full circle Trump takes away sanctions against Putin / Russia in the middle of a war he started with Iran and a war Putin started with Ukraine.
nortex97
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AGHouston11 said:

It's funny when you remember all the things Trump said about Merkel and Germany making deals with Russia for energy.

Now full circle Trump takes away sanctions against Putin / Russia in the middle of a war he started with Iran and a war Putin started with Ukraine.


Those weren't about some tankers for diesel, it was mortgaging Germany's industrial future on the flow Russian gas. Minor difference.
AGHouston11
How long do you want to ignore this user?
nortex97 said:

AGHouston11 said:

It's funny when you remember all the things Trump said about Merkel and Germany making deals with Russia for energy.

Now full circle Trump takes away sanctions against Putin / Russia in the middle of a war he started with Iran and a war Putin started with Ukraine.


Those weren't about some tankers for diesel, it was mortgaging Germany's industrial future on the flow Russian gas. Minor difference.


You can try to slice and dice it different ways but the whole point was Trump's complaints were that Germany was helping finance Russia.

Dropping sanctions by Trump for a drop of diesel is …..,,. helping finance Russia.

flown-the-coop
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AGHouston11 said:

It's funny when you remember all the things Trump said about Merkel and Germany making deals with Russia for energy.

Now full circle Trump takes away sanctions against Putin / Russia in the middle of a war he started with Iran and a war Putin started with Ukraine.

yea, ignore the complete difference between leveraging a short term deal with Russian on a particular area versus making the entirety of your country's energy supply dependent on Russia.
aggie93
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AGHouston11 said:

It's funny when you remember all the things Trump said about Merkel and Germany making deals with Russia for energy.

Now full circle Trump takes away sanctions against Putin / Russia in the middle of a war he started with Iran and a war Putin started with Ukraine.


Making some deals with Russia is not the same as making yourself completely energy dependent on Russia. I'm fine with deals with Russia that if they went away the worst case would be it might increase some prices a bit. Germany put itself completely dependent on Russia which was foolish. Russia will always do what is best for Russia and they trust no one, thus we shouldn't trust them. We also shouldn't ever trust China and honestly very few countries. The best course is to deal with countries in our best interests and assume they will work in theirs but never forget the second part of that equation as many do.
FIDO_Ags
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Quote:

Further isolating Russia is what makes it more authoritarian and imperialistic.

If your aim is the opposite, then you bring them back into the fold not force them further away.


On the surface, this is not a bad assumption and could be supported by policy. Unfortunately, that is the rub here.

You cannot treat with Russia, a historic antagonist, and at the same time alienate your closest allies, ones that you have developed relationships over the long term.

Since POTUS operates with no apparent policy and flies by the seat of his pants, both allies and Russia have no idea how to react, so everyone shakes hands while keeping their fingers crossed.

That instability is not good for any party and can certainly lead to further misunderstanding and unfortunate outcomes.
flown-the-coop
How long do you want to ignore this user?
The instability created by Trump has brought the US back from decades of being ever weakened by trying to appease everyone in the name of globalism… I mean "world peace".

People may not like the bumpy road but it's necessary to pull back from the superhighway off the cliff the Obamanites paved for Americas future.
aggie93
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AGHouston11 said:

nortex97 said:

AGHouston11 said:

It's funny when you remember all the things Trump said about Merkel and Germany making deals with Russia for energy.

Now full circle Trump takes away sanctions against Putin / Russia in the middle of a war he started with Iran and a war Putin started with Ukraine.


Those weren't about some tankers for diesel, it was mortgaging Germany's industrial future on the flow Russian gas. Minor difference.


You can try to slice and dice it different ways but the whole point was Trump's complaints were that Germany was helping finance Russia.

Dropping sanctions by Trump for a drop of diesel is …..,,. helping finance Russia.



No, it was about making Germany dependent on Russia. The financing was at best a secondary issue especially because that was prior to the Ukraine war.

BTW, it's naive to think you can stop Russia with sanctions. It has made them turn more internally and has actually built up their economy and it has also driven them into a much closer alliance with China which is a big loser for us. There is no controlling Russia, they are too big, too proud, and much more willing to sacrifice than Americans are. They are best dealt with carefully. Don't trust them but don't antagonize them. Russia has many enemies and issues to deal with, it's best to keep the US low on the list. Instead we antagonize them to placate Europe and to our own detriment.
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.