Trump and Russia Pivot - October 2026

55,976 Views | 1016 Replies | Last: 1 hr ago by nortex97
1939
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Zelensky is an absolute fool. This war would have been over years ago and hundreds of of thousands of lives saved if he wasn't such a narcissist idiot.
GeorgiAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
1939 said:

Zelensky is an absolute fool. This war would have been over years ago and hundreds of of thousands of lives saved if he wasn't such a narcissist idiot.

Putin is an absolute fool. The war should have never been started, and millions of lives saved.
GeorgiAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
1939 said:

GeorgiAg said:

Imagine a world where Russia has a real democracy and gets along with its EU neighbors. Trump is thwarting that. What has EU/NATO ever done to Russia? Nothing? They cannot get rid of their cold-war era expansionist ideas.

American interests are that Putin and the Russian oligarchy be overthrown and replaced with a regime that can get along with the West.

The issue Trump has with Ukraine is that they sent gas/diesel prices higher and killed Russia's bot farms which infiltrate our social media to prop Trump up. That's why Trump is mad - purely personal reasons. He does not give a damn about US long-term interests, only himself.


You're delusional. What exactly is it that you want the US to do? Full scale ground war using US troops? Assassination of Putin?


Not throttle Starlink and Starshield.

Deliver weapons already purchased.

ETFan
How long do you want to ignore this user?
1939 said:

GeorgiAg said:

Imagine a world where Russia has a real democracy and gets along with its EU neighbors. Trump is thwarting that. What has EU/NATO ever done to Russia? Nothing? They cannot get rid of their cold-war era expansionist ideas.

American interests are that Putin and the Russian oligarchy be overthrown and replaced with a regime that can get along with the West.

The issue Trump has with Ukraine is that they sent gas/diesel prices higher and killed Russia's bot farms which infiltrate our social media to prop Trump up. That's why Trump is mad - purely personal reasons. He does not give a damn about US long-term interests, only himself.


You're delusional. What exactly is it that you want the US to do? Full scale ground war using US troops? Assassination of Putin?



Not explicitly helping Russia would be a start? Come on.
Featured Video Previews
nortex97
How long do you want to ignore this user?
A little too rosy for me, but it's another thought.
1939
How long do you want to ignore this user?
ETFan said:

1939 said:

GeorgiAg said:

Imagine a world where Russia has a real democracy and gets along with its EU neighbors. Trump is thwarting that. What has EU/NATO ever done to Russia? Nothing? They cannot get rid of their cold-war era expansionist ideas.

American interests are that Putin and the Russian oligarchy be overthrown and replaced with a regime that can get along with the West.

The issue Trump has with Ukraine is that they sent gas/diesel prices higher and killed Russia's bot farms which infiltrate our social media to prop Trump up. That's why Trump is mad - purely personal reasons. He does not give a damn about US long-term interests, only himself.


You're delusional. What exactly is it that you want the US to do? Full scale ground war using US troops? Assassination of Putin?



Not explicitly helping Russia would be a start? Come on.


Maybe "helping Russia" is the only way to get the dictator Zelenskyy to the negotiation table.

Based on you and Georgia's non answer, I suppose your strategy is to do the same thing as the last 4 years and spend mass amounts of money on an unwinnable war while Ukraine gets destroyed and hundreds of thousands of innocent people on both sides die and the world economy suffers.

There is no end game here as long as Zelenskyy is in charge. Yeah, Putin is a bad guy, but what is anyone realistically going to do about it and who actually gives a **** about the Donbas region? If anything, this war proves that Russia is not capable of a real war against major powers.

Let's get this thing settled. That is going to require concessions from Ukraine and their leader refuses to do so.
ABATTBQ11
How long do you want to ignore this user?
YouBet said:

Terrible optics but don't really care. If it brings Russia back into the world order and mitigates their aggression, then do it. We need Russia engaged with the western world and not be a pariah state. The way things are going we are likely going to have to replace Western Europe with someone new anyway. Will need a counter in Central and Eastern Europe to the coming Islamic States of Western Europe.


Russia was never really engaged with the Western world, and the only thing that will curb their aggression is a complete cleaning out of hardliners and former Soviet officials like Putin. They're all pining for the glory days and would will over Eastern and Central Europe without a second thought if they could. You don't give them anything unless it comes with the expectation they'll try to take more.
eric76
How long do you want to ignore this user?
aggie93 said:

Europe has always cared far more about Ukraine than we have as they should. It's just ridiculous to think that Europe was forced into a fight with Russia they didn't want because the US wanted war. You could argue the US was too ambivalent about Ukraine and Putin took advantage but in no world was the US wanting to fight with Russia over Ukraine and dragged Europe along.

Is "Blame America First" the new MAGA marching orders?
aginresearch
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I can't believe people actually think Russia can be brought into the world order! They've never been in it. They don't want to be in it. They want everyone to kneel to them. Current administration policy on Russia is based on fairies and unicorns.

Ronald Reagan would be rolling his eyes if he was still alive.
eric76
How long do you want to ignore this user?
1939 said:

Zelensky is an absolute fool. This war would have been over years ago and hundreds of of thousands of lives saved if he wasn't such a narcissist idiot.

That should have read: "Zelensky is an absolute fool. This war would have been over years ago and hundreds of thousands of lives in slavery if he wasn't such a narcissist idiot."
aginresearch
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I actually agree with most everything that aggie93 posts. In this one area of Russia and US policy towards Russia I strongly disagree on his take and analysis. He is not a pure MAGA person so I don't think that is a fair label of his positions. He seems to be a true conservative and has very pragmatic views on foreign policy.
flown-the-coop
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Lengthy but lots well said in there. Thanks for posting.
flown-the-coop
How long do you want to ignore this user?
aginresearch said:

I actually agree with most everything that aggie93 posts. In this one area of Russia and US policy towards Russia I strongly disagree on his take and analysis. He is not a pure MAGA person so I don't think that is a fair label of his positions. He seems to be a true conservative and has very pragmatic views on foreign policy.

There was nothing MAGA in his analysis as you point out. However, what is it you disagree with in their take and analysis?

There are some of their perspective I may not whole heartedly agree with but the position is rational enough where I would listen and consider, which is somewhat rare in these parts as many folks get their geopolitics from X posts which is pure ****e.

Just curious as to what your differences would be.
1939
How long do you want to ignore this user?
GeorgiAg said:

1939 said:

Zelensky is an absolute fool. This war would have been over years ago and hundreds of of thousands of lives saved if he wasn't such a narcissist idiot.

Putin is an absolute fool. The war should have never been started, and millions of lives saved.


And what do you want to do about it? What is the end solution? Based on your posts you want regime change in Russia. Do you have any idea what that would entail?

I bet you're at the same time whining and moaning about the Iran conflict and that is a drop I. The bucket to what you seemingly want to do with Russia.
YouBet
How long do you want to ignore this user?
ABATTBQ11 said:

YouBet said:

Terrible optics but don't really care. If it brings Russia back into the world order and mitigates their aggression, then do it. We need Russia engaged with the western world and not be a pariah state. The way things are going we are likely going to have to replace Western Europe with someone new anyway. Will need a counter in Central and Eastern Europe to the coming Islamic States of Western Europe.


Russia was never really engaged with the Western world, and the only thing that will curb their aggression is a complete cleaning out of hardliners and former Soviet officials like Putin. They're all pining for the glory days and would will over Eastern and Central Europe without a second thought if they could. You don't give them anything unless it comes with the expectation they'll try to take more.

Well, good luck with that. I guess Ukraine and Russia will continue to murder one another then and potentially take the rest of the continent down with them.

Problem is Europe has no more money to give for Ukraine support. Germany and France are going to cut them off due to their deteriorating economies. I'm sure UK will try to keep spending because Burnham seems to think he has money trees that are about to bloom. Their reality is going to hit hard very soon.
aggie93
How long do you want to ignore this user?
GeorgiAg said:

Imagine a world where Russia has a real democracy and gets along with its EU neighbors. Trump is thwarting that. What has EU/NATO ever done to Russia? Nothing? They cannot get rid of their cold-war era expansionist ideas.

American interests are that Putin and the Russian oligarchy be overthrown and replaced with a regime that can get along with the West.

The issue Trump has with Ukraine is that they sent gas/diesel prices higher and killed Russia's bot farms which infiltrate our social media to prop Trump up. That's why Trump is mad - purely personal reasons. He does not give a damn about US long-term interests, only himself.

If you know anything about Russia it is a country that will never be a normal democracy. The geography, culture, and demographics make it almost impossible. It will always need a strong centralized leader or else it falls into chaos.
aggie93
How long do you want to ignore this user?
ABATTBQ11 said:

YouBet said:

Terrible optics but don't really care. If it brings Russia back into the world order and mitigates their aggression, then do it. We need Russia engaged with the western world and not be a pariah state. The way things are going we are likely going to have to replace Western Europe with someone new anyway. Will need a counter in Central and Eastern Europe to the coming Islamic States of Western Europe.


Russia was never really engaged with the Western world, and the only thing that will curb their aggression is a complete cleaning out of hardliners and former Soviet officials like Putin. They're all pining for the glory days and would will over Eastern and Central Europe without a second thought if they could. You don't give them anything unless it comes with the expectation they'll try to take more.

Let's say you "clean out Putin and the hardliners". You do understand that new ones will replace them or else the country will fall into chaos or civil war, right? Or do you think somehow they will all join hands and become a democracy in spite of 1000 years of history to the contrary?
flown-the-coop
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I support the female protest group taking over. Something... Riot was there name. Do'nt recall the first part of their name but it was catchy.
aggie93
How long do you want to ignore this user?
aginresearch said:

I actually agree with most everything that aggie93 posts. In this one area of Russia and US policy towards Russia I strongly disagree on his take and analysis. He is not a pure MAGA person so I don't think that is a fair label of his positions. He seems to be a true conservative and has very pragmatic views on foreign policy.

What part do you disagree with? My point is less about being pro Russia or pro Ukraine. I just have studied the history, geography, and politics of the region extensively. If you want to make Russia an enemy you need to be ready to go all the way otherwise you are just asking for nonstop pain. I don't think anyone truly wants to do what would be needed for lasting change in Russia because that would mean accomplishing what Hitler and Napoleon failed at and we don't have a fraction of their incentive to try. I'm for a pragmatic and realistic approach to foreign policy and prioritizing US interests above all.

It also seems to be lost that Zelenskyy and Ukraine are deeply corrupt and don't care about human life. That's how life is in that part of the world where strength and power are everything.
aggie93
How long do you want to ignore this user?
eric76 said:

aggie93 said:

Europe has always cared far more about Ukraine than we have as they should. It's just ridiculous to think that Europe was forced into a fight with Russia they didn't want because the US wanted war. You could argue the US was too ambivalent about Ukraine and Putin took advantage but in no world was the US wanting to fight with Russia over Ukraine and dragged Europe along.

Is "Blame America First" the new MAGA marching orders?

Lol, I have more than shown I call balls and strikes when it comes to Trump.
GeorgiAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
1939 said:

GeorgiAg said:

1939 said:

Zelensky is an absolute fool. This war would have been over years ago and hundreds of of thousands of lives saved if he wasn't such a narcissist idiot.

Putin is an absolute fool. The war should have never been started, and millions of lives saved.


And what do you want to do about it? What is the end solution? Based on your posts you want regime change in Russia. Do you have any idea what that would entail?

I bet you're at the same time whining and moaning about the Iran conflict and that is a drop I. The bucket to what you seemingly want to do with Russia.

It's a low cost war in relative terms for us. Russian is getting their arse kicked. Just let that continue.

3 day war is on what day now?
aggie93
How long do you want to ignore this user?
aginresearch said:

I can't believe people actually think Russia can be brought into the world order! They've never been in it. They don't want to be in it. They want everyone to kneel to them. Current administration policy on Russia is based on fairies and unicorns.

Ronald Reagan would be rolling his eyes if he was still alive.

You lost me when you brought up Reagan. It shows you are looking at Russia of today as if it is the USSR of the '80s.

BTW, maybe you missed it but Reagan is the one who worked with Gorbachev on "Glasnost"
aggie93
How long do you want to ignore this user?
GeorgiAg said:

1939 said:

Zelensky is an absolute fool. This war would have been over years ago and hundreds of of thousands of lives saved if he wasn't such a narcissist idiot.

Putin is an absolute fool. The war should have never been started, and millions of lives saved.

The wild thing to me is both of you are right. Both Putin and Zelensky are fools. Well not really, both are bloodthirsty and corrupt narcissists that are more than willing to sacrifice human life for power without flinching. Trying to pick a side between them is like trying to choose sides in the Iran/Iraq war.
GeorgiAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
aggie93 said:

GeorgiAg said:

1939 said:

Zelensky is an absolute fool. This war would have been over years ago and hundreds of of thousands of lives saved if he wasn't such a narcissist idiot.

Putin is an absolute fool. The war should have never been started, and millions of lives saved.

The wild thing to me is both of you are right. Both Putin and Zelensky are fools. Well not really, both are bloodthirsty and corrupt narcissists that are more than willing to sacrifice human life for power without flinching. Trying to pick a side between them is like trying to choose sides in the Iran/Iraq war.

Iraq.
GeorgiAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
aggie93 said:

aginresearch said:

I can't believe people actually think Russia can be brought into the world order! They've never been in it. They don't want to be in it. They want everyone to kneel to them. Current administration policy on Russia is based on fairies and unicorns.

Ronald Reagan would be rolling his eyes if he was still alive.

You lost me when you brought up Reagan. It shows you are looking at Russia of today as if it is the USSR of the '80s.

BTW, maybe you missed it but Reagan is the one who worked with Gorbachev on "Glasnost"

Now we have what?

GASnost?




get it? GASnost? (Also, RIP Richard Riehle - died today)

aginresearch
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I disagree with you because I think for a modest investment of money we could push Russia over the edge to collapse or civil war. I am ok with that. I am under no illusion they will ever have a democracy. I don't care about a stable Russian government. I just want to bring them to heel so we can do what we want in Europe without them being a thorn in our side.

It's pretty clear their military is 3rd rate and even though we've strung Ukraine along they've held their own against Russia. If we had not strung them along I think we'd be well on the way to Russian collapse. That would make our engagement with Iran easier because that would be one less patron that would be funding Iran.

Why do you think I care one whit about if Ukraine is corrupt? All I care about is if Ukraine's munitions can hit their target and do maximum damage.
aggie93
How long do you want to ignore this user?
GeorgiAg said:

1939 said:

GeorgiAg said:

1939 said:

Zelensky is an absolute fool. This war would have been over years ago and hundreds of of thousands of lives saved if he wasn't such a narcissist idiot.

Putin is an absolute fool. The war should have never been started, and millions of lives saved.


And what do you want to do about it? What is the end solution? Based on your posts you want regime change in Russia. Do you have any idea what that would entail?

I bet you're at the same time whining and moaning about the Iran conflict and that is a drop I. The bucket to what you seemingly want to do with Russia.

It's a low cost war in relative terms for us. Russian is getting their arse kicked. Just let that continue.

3 day war is on what day now?

We have spent 3x as much on Ukraine as Iran.

We are basically slowly choking out Iran and keeping casualties to a minimum because we have no intention of a ground invasion. Instead there are multiple rebellions under way in Iran and we are just letting them build. Iran can still take little stabs at us but they are a shell of a country at this point and now that we have taken out the mines in Hormuz and opened up commerce (thought it is more expensive and has some risk) they can't last much longer. It's fair to criticize the war but we are definitely winning and it is also foolish to ignore the potential benefits if we do finish Iran off and get regime change. It certainly would be more valuable than replacing Putin with the next dictator to replace him or for Russia to fall into civil war.
aggie93
How long do you want to ignore this user?
aginresearch said:

I disagree with you because I think for a modest investment of money we could push Russia over the edge to collapse or civil war. I am ok with that. I am under no illusion they will ever have a democracy. I don't care about a stable Russian government. I just want to bring them to heel so we can do what we want in Europe without them being a thorn in our side.

It's pretty clear their military is 3rd rate and even though we've strung Ukraine along they've held their own against Russia. If we had not strung them along I think we'd be well on the way to Russian collapse. That would make our engagement with Iran easier because that would be one less patron that would be funding Iran.

Why do you think I care one whit about if Ukraine is corrupt? All I care about is if Ukraine's munitions can hit their target and do maximum damage.

Fair enough. I just don't think you have thought through what it would take to "push Russia over the edge". Putin is very popular in Russia and has total control. He's killed any opposition long ago. So unless you assassinate him or do a full on land invasion it's not happening. Let's assume you somehow get him to cry uncle though. He will continue to do everything he can to retaliate against the US and Europe in that case. If you do remove him he will almost certainly be replaced with someone worse or more likely we get the civil war/chaos scenario. I don't think you realize just how dangerous some of the leaders of the outlying areas of Russia are and how you would basically be creating several nuclear armed countries with lunatics who aren't nearly as smart as Putin (and yes, Putin is highly intelligent even if he is ruthless) in charge. It's the dog chasing the car and finally biting the bumper and not realizing what they just got themselves in to.

Russia inevitably will be controlled by a strongman. Unless you invade Russia you don't get to pick who that strongman is. So best not to get involved because almost certainly it won't be someone we will like much less be able to trust. My argument is not to be "friendly" or "allies" with Russia but rather to not be their enemy and to find causes of mutual benefit while avoiding antagonizing them. We have much bigger problems than Russia.
YouBet
How long do you want to ignore this user?
aginresearch said:

I disagree with you because I think for a modest investment of money we could push Russia over the edge to collapse or civil war. I am ok with that. I am under no illusion they will ever have a democracy. I don't care about a stable Russian government. I just want to bring them to heel so we can do what we want in Europe without them being a thorn in our side.

It's pretty clear their military is 3rd rate and even though we've strung Ukraine along they've held their own against Russia. If we had not strung them along I think we'd be well on the way to Russian collapse. That would make our engagement with Iran easier because that would be one less patron that would be funding Iran.

Why do you think I care one whit about if Ukraine is corrupt? All I care about is if Ukraine's munitions can hit their target and do maximum damage.


What is modest? We've already committed $200B to Ukraine plus a separate $20B loan.

We can't afford to keep giving them money and resources when they have zero strategic relevancy to us.

And I think whatever Russia might be giving Iran is irrelevant. The only reason we haven't tipped that country over is because we refuse to take the gloves off. Nothing to do with Russia.
aggie93
How long do you want to ignore this user?
GeorgiAg said:

aggie93 said:

GeorgiAg said:

1939 said:

Zelensky is an absolute fool. This war would have been over years ago and hundreds of of thousands of lives saved if he wasn't such a narcissist idiot.

Putin is an absolute fool. The war should have never been started, and millions of lives saved.

The wild thing to me is both of you are right. Both Putin and Zelensky are fools. Well not really, both are bloodthirsty and corrupt narcissists that are more than willing to sacrifice human life for power without flinching. Trying to pick a side between them is like trying to choose sides in the Iran/Iraq war.

Iraq.

That's what we did, being Saddam's buddy was great. Still ended up getting ourselves in 2 wars with Iraq with very little to show for either in the end.

Zelenskyy has made it clear he is not our friend and is only interested in what money and supplies we can give him. That's never going to change.
Tarponfly
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I can't believe there are people here that will contort themselves into believing that Trump supporting Putin through a deal that most of the Congress and the American people oppose is somehow MAGA. The entire notion is insulting and throwing Ukraine under the bust to help Russia is stupid. Trump needs to get over his love of foreign dictators. Zelenski has not sown for peace because Putin will not agree to end the war without Ukraine losing their sovereignty. Period. Trump cannot leave office fast enough for me after this debacle.
Red Fishing Ag93
How long do you want to ignore this user?
The Ukraine Russia war is not Ukraine vs Russia at all.

Read more.









And regime change in Russia ain't happening, especially for low cost. That's an MIC pipe dream.
aginresearch
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I don't buy we are on the brink of nuclear holocaust because Russia falls into civil war. I think they will all be fighting for their own power or survival. I don't want a land invasion that would be foolish. Just let Ukraine hollow them out. They've done a fabulous job of doing so with one hand tied behind their back and one of the legs knee capped. Stop doing that and just give them the funds to rain drones down on Moscow and St. Petersburg day and night, destroy their entire oil/gas infrastructure and slaughter their conscripts via drones on the front lines.

It'll be multiple generations before Russia is any real threat if they ever recover demographically. All I'm proposing is accelerating their demographic death. Who cares what they think? I don't. Next time start a war you can actually finish.
aginresearch
How long do you want to ignore this user?
200B? It's actually $127B in direct funds, but I don't care about the exact number. We spend $20B+ a day. That's 10 days of expenditures of the federal government over almost 5 years! It's a rounding error of the US FedGov budget. I'd probably have spent 4 times that amount over 4 years. So about $800B and I'd pay for production of drone weaponry for the US military. It would be worth every penny. So about 5 days of spending per year.

Also, yeah, the Iran war was mismanaged from the drop. You blockade the SoH day 0. You eliminate their port facilities. You destroy their railyards. You destroy their energy/water infrastructure. Russia ain't keeping Iran afloat singlehandedly but every little bit helps towards Iran's capitulation.

You also claim that we have no strategic interest but I outlined how I see our strategic interest in Ukraine. There is strategic interest if you believe that Europe has strategic interest to us. If you don't then good luck because they've been the cause of most of the world's instability over the past 120 years
Gordo14
How long do you want to ignore this user?
This is not a sudden flip. This has always been who Trump is and what Trump wants. It's been obvious for a long time his goal in getting peace is he and his family to make deals with Moscow at the expense of Europe. He's always admired and fantasized about Putin - Putin helps meet Trump's narcissistic supply needs. And losing the war in Iran means Ukraine has another purpose…. to blame for the situation he caused. Every step since day one has been against Ukraine and NATO and toward Russia. All that's happening is that it is accelerating.

It's depressing not only for how much this undermines America's interests for Donald Trump's interests…. But because Russia actively has helped Iran kill Americans, and Donald Trump actually doesn't care at all. Russia has been helping Iran with their ballistic missiles and providing updated satellite imagery of American military positions. Not only has Pete Hegseth stated this as fact to Congress, it's the only way that Iran could possibly have hit our AWACs in Saudi Arabia (as it was constantly being repositioned).

So my question is, how does this further America's interests? This will further Russia/Ukraine from peace (the closest path to peace is to make Russia realize it's against their interests to continue the war). Russia will be emboldened so why would they head to peace? This is the cost of personalized foreign policy from an "American interest" foreign policy. Trump now wants Ukraine to collapse as the fastest solution to "peace". Read between the lines. It's right in front of you, and accepting that truth is the first step to fixing this disaster. As the civilian population gets murdered by ballistic missiles, we are complicit.

The world is destabilizing at an accelerating rate and Donald Trump is the leading cause. The consequences are only going to continue to get worse. Destabilization will lead to less peace and deteriorating quality of life.
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.