Trump and Russia Pivot - October 2026

50,413 Views | 919 Replies | Last: 23 min ago by Teslag
CS78
How long do you want to ignore this user?
You really think Ukraine gives a flying flip what Trump thinks, at this point? He's already blown his wad and it fell flat. Unless Putin falls out a window, you're still going to be huffing and puffing a year from now.
nortex97
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Zelensky sure seems to spend a lot of time talking about Trump/Musk/America. So yes, I do think he cares quite a bit.

If Kiev gets more money by agreeing to the end of the conflict and so do the Russians, then I think it stops, simple as that. Neither side really gives a crap about their war dead or the donbas.

ETA: just as negotiations are underway, more chatter/whining about Americans asking him to negotiate an end to the war. So typical.

nortex97
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Blackrock has entered the chat. Always follow the money. (Czech source below).
Quote:

On November 3, the Democrats gained control of both chambers of the US Congress.

Just one day later, on November 4, BlackRock attended the talks in Brussels.

And on November 6, it emerged that the Democrats intend to make increased aid to Ukraine a priority for the new Congress.

Although these talks were clearly prepared in advanceand Trump still retains his presidential veto powerthe political signal sent to international financial capital is perfectly clear: the prospect of substantial US federal funding for Ukrainian projects is back.

This changes the economic calculus.

Investing your own capital in a war-ravaged country is one thing; participating in projects where risks are partly covered by government budgets and international institutions is quite another.

This raises a fundamental question: who will pay for "rebuilding Ukraine," who will set the financing terms, and who will secure the most lucrative contracts?
Meloni is well aware of this.

The Democrats' victory has given fresh impetus to the battle over funds earmarked for Ukraine.
At the same time, the emerging scandal reveals that, when it comes to dividing up potential profits, there is far less agreement among allies than their public statements of political solidarity might suggest.

Answer: American taxpayers will be the ones paying.
Rossticus
How long do you want to ignore this user?


" Russia appears to be using the Trump team's initiatives to win an important round in the negotiations. The discussion about how to stop its aggression is turning into a bargaining process over how Europe should defend itself. The Russian delegation explicitly describes the Ukraine issue as part of a broader agreement covering the entire continent. By agreeing to link these issues, Kushner is legitimising the Kremlin's demands.

Until now, Washington has mainly pressured Kyiv to make concessions for the sake of a quick deal. Kushner is now bringing the Europeans into this bargaining process too. He has not yet published a specific list of concessions, but he is already proposing negotiations with Russia over their security. Europeans are having to defend their own military capabilities in talks that should be aimed at making Moscow end its aggression. According to the FT, the broader American proposal was not agreed with European capitals in advance.

**Meanwhile, Moscow wants the war to continue.** On 10 November, Lavrov explicitly stated that Russia would not agree to an immediate ceasefire. He insists on the following sequence: first define the parameters of the future security system, then address a settlement of the war. He also rejected the deployment of European stabilisation forces after a ceasefire. Russia's demand is clear: the West must first accept new rules, and only then will Moscow consider ending hostilitieswith no certainty that it will agree to do so.

For the Kremlin, negotiations and continued warfare complement each other. Russian strikes are intended to convince Ukraine and its partners that rejecting Moscow's demands will become increasingly costly. Moscow demands concessions in exchange for the prospect of stopping those attacks. FT sources involved in back-channel contacts reported that Putin expects to weaken Ukraine through winter bombardments, while broadening the negotiations to encompass European security allows Moscow to drag out the process. According to those sources, he regards even Ukraine's withdrawal from the remaining parts of Donbas merely as a precondition for a ceasefire. Further demands may follow.

Russia's objectives have long extended beyond Ukraine. As early as 14 June 2024, Putin called for the gradual withdrawal of the military presence of "external powers" from Eurasia and described dependence on the US as Europe's main threat. Ryabkov now says that a future European security system can exist only as part of a Eurasian one, while Lavrov refers to a Russian position paper, mentioning the CSTO, CIS and SCO. Europe is being offered a place in an order in which Moscow will have a decisive say.

Russia laid out its maximalist demands long ago. In December 2021, Moscow demanded that force and weapons deployments return to their May 1997 configuration, that NATO stop expanding, and that military activities in Ukraine and other countries in the region be restricted. Separate demands included returning American nuclear weapons to the US, dismantling the infrastructure used to deploy them abroad, and restricting military deployments, missiles, bomber flights and naval operations.

A new structure modelled on the NATORussia Council could become a permanent forum for such pressure. The old council did not give Moscow the right to block Alliance decisions: Russia's consent was required for joint activities, while NATO remained free to act independently. In any future arrangement, everything will depend on the new obligations. If strengthening defences requires every participant's approval, or if Russia can demand that such measures be suspended as a threat to its own security, consultations will become a means of obstruction. In its 2021 draft, Moscow already proposed allowing exceptional deployments beyond the established limits only with the consent of all parties. Such a rule would effectively give it the power to decide whether allies can reinforce their defences.

Washington has its own reasons to accept some of these demands. The 2026 US National Defense Strategy describes Russia as a persistent but manageable threat to NATO's eastern members and assumes that Moscow cannot establish dominance over Europe. Europeans are expected to take primary responsibility for conventional defence, while the US concentrates on defending its own territory and deterring China. This creates a temptation to strike a deal with Moscow to reduce American involvement.

Kushner has political backing to advance this approach. Trump himself announced a broad agreement concerning Europe, while Rubio supports the negotiating team and discussions about the post-war order. There is no confirmation that a specific package of concessions has been agreed within the administration. There is also bipartisan opposition in Congress to easing pressure on Russia. But presidential support is enough to conduct negotiations, propose options and gradually get allies used to the idea that their defence, too, is negotiable.

The most dangerous scenario is taking shape: weak guarantees for Ukraine are being negotiated alongside restrictions on European defence. Rubio is already saying that these guarantees must be acceptable to Russia; meanwhile, American officials are discussing shifting the financial burden onto Europe and gradually easing sanctions, with the option of reimposing them. In this arrangement, the West pays with concrete concessions in exchange for a promise to end the aggression, while Moscow strengthens its position and gains the ability to bargain over how its opponents defend themselves. The Trump administration's effort to save money on its military presence weakens alliancesone of the main sources of American power. Declining trust in the US pushes European governments towards separate deals and undermines a common policy towards Russia. The Russian threat remains, while Washington loses the ability to confront it together with its allies."
Featured Video Previews
Rossticus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
These should be interesting negotiations.




" The Russian delegation at talks with Ukraine and the US in Abu Dhabi included Dmitry Minaev, head of the FSB counterintelligence operations department.

Ukrainian officials had previously linked this structure to the attempted assassination of Kyrylo Budanov in 2019 and the bombings of cars belonging to Ukrainian special services.

In total, four new representatives were added to the Russian negotiating team. In addition to Minaev, these are the head of the FSB operational information service Alexei Komkov, Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov, and Director of the Foreign Ministry department Oleg Postnikov."



"russia brought an FSB general accused by Ukraine of organizing the assassinations of two Ukrainian intelligence officers to the negotiating table in Abu Dhabi.

Dmitry Minaev was accused of orchestrating the 2017 car bombings that killed HUR General Maksym Shapoval and SBU Colonel Oleksandr Kharaberiush. His department was also linked to an assassination attempt on Kyrylo Budanov.

Now Minaev sits at the negotiating table while Budanov represents Ukraine.

The people accused of organizing the murders of Ukrainians are now pretending to negotiate peace. This is russiaA"
Rossticus
How long do you want to ignore this user?


"Lavrov commented on the Abu Dhabi talks. He says all the EU and Ukraine want to talk about are an immediate ceasefire. He confirmed that Russia would not agree to this.

Then, confirming that the USA want to discuss the European security architecture, Lavrov mocks the EU participation: "let them sit in the hotel there."
nortex97
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Euroswine waiting outside the discussions is the funniest part of this. Italy to withold Aster missiles as they need some for themselves.

Ukraine has apparently rejected territorial concessions and continues with fantasist demands. Not clear if it was a formal proposal in any case, but talks are done.

War continues...
nortex97
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Despite this lengthy post being based on @NYT propaganda, it's mostly true probably.

(Too long to paste the relevant text.)

ETA: LOL.
Teslag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Just as anyone could predict, everyone came to the table looking for a deal except for Russia
RedfishinAg93
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
" Ukraine has apparently rejected territorial concessions and continues with fantasist demands. Not clear if it was a formal proposal in any case, but talks are done."

No wai.
bobbranco
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Russia wants all of Ukraine. Same as Iran they are irrational and will sacrifice everything to get it.
nortex97
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Green goblin yet again taunting Trump, in English, before our chuckling 'allies' in Nato.

Again and again, from written remarks:

Rossticus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Red Fishing Ag93 said:

" Ukraine has apparently rejected territorial concessions and continues with fantasist demands. Not clear if it was a formal proposal in any case, but talks are done."

No wai.


Well, Russia rejected concessions/swaps as well. So until both sides are willing to compromise, nothing will progress.
nortex97
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG

The 'pivot' hasn't exactly bent the knee, clearly.
Teslag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Rossticus said:

Red Fishing Ag93 said:

" Ukraine has apparently rejected territorial concessions and continues with fantasist demands. Not clear if it was a formal proposal in any case, but talks are done."

No wai.


Well, Russia rejected concessions/swaps as well. So until both sides are willing to compromise, nothing will progress.


Not to mention Russia is still considering parts of Ukraine it doesn't control as "Russia". The absurdity of that thought process boggles the mind, but it's Russia so it tracks.
Rossticus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Funny you should mention that…

Rossticus
How long do you want to ignore this user?


"The talks in Abu Dhabi have ended. A few observations.

The fundamental obstacle to ending this war is that neither belligerent currently sees an available peace settlement that would secure its essential interests at a lower cost than continuing to fight. Negotiations can arrange prisoner exchanges and address other practical questions. But they cannot manufacture a political basis for peace where none yet exists.

For Putin, ending the war with a "victory" reduced to conquering the Donbas would create an enormous problem of historical judgment. Around 1.5 million Russian casualties, killed and wounded, to acquire another devastated stretch of Ukraine? Future generations of Russians might remember Putin as the opposite of a strategic genius: the ruler who squandered his country's people, resources and international position for gains grotesquely disproportionate to their cost.

This helps explain Moscow's determination to turn negotiations about its war against Ukraine into negotiations about a "new European security architecture." Russia needs a prize larger than the Donbas. Weakening NATO, pushing the Americans out of Europe and acquiring a veto over its neighbours' sovereign choices would provide one.

The historical precedent is clear. At the Berlin Conference in February 1954, Molotov proposed a European collective security system that would have displaced the Western alliances and relegated the United States to "observer" status. Today's vocabulary is different; the strategic ambition is familiar. If war against Ukraine could deliver the displacement of American power from Europe, the Kremlin could present it as a historic success and draw dangerous conclusions about what further wars might achieve.

For Ukraine, the calculation runs in the opposite direction. However appalling the costs of resistance, capitulation could still cost more. What is at stake is the survival of an independent state and the continued existence of Ukrainians as a distinct political nation.

Putin's account of Ukrainian history treats a separate Ukrainian identity as something cultivated by Russia's enemies, including Polish elites and Austrian authorities. The dangerous implication is that what was supposedly constructed can be dismantled. Deportation, killing and forced Russification become instruments for undoing a nation whose independent existence the aggressor refuses to accept. From Kyiv's perspective, surrender would therefore offer no reliable escape from violence. It could simply remove the means of resisting it.

Europe already has a security order worth defending. Its principles include sovereignty, territorial integrity and the freedom to choose alliances. Russia's violation of those principles is a reason to enforce them, not to replace them with arrangements requiring Russian permission.

Nor does the United States have a compelling national interest in surrendering its position in Europe to Russia. Its European presence sustains American influence, military reach and alliances. Whatever commercial opportunities Trump, Witkoff or Kushner may see in an accommodation with Moscow, those opportunities do not establish that such a retreat would benefit America. A deal attractive to individual negotiators is not necessarily a strategic bargain for their country.

That is the underlying impasse. Moscow wants a peace that converts aggression into a wider strategic victory. Ukraine needs a peace that preserves its ability to survive. Europe cannot accept Russian control over European security, and America has no sound strategic reason to facilitate it.

Until those calculations change, the war is likely to continue. Calling the process a negotiation does not make the interests compatible. Without that compatibility, we will keep getting diplomatic choreography and, around it, this ridiculous circus."
nortex97
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Yes Russians want a security structure, because they are being bombarded daily by munitions via Europe. And Ukraine/Z were boasting about invading Russia (Kursk) just a couple years ago.

The French (!) are even actively warning the Germans about long range weapons plans/developments triggering a wider response.

I will just agree to disagree as to which side desperately wants the bloodshed to continue at all costs, while publicly badmouthing Trump/America's support all along the way. European politics are an utter disaster on all fronts. The US should if anything, work to have as little to do with it as possible with Europe (get out of Nato this afternoon), and certainly not foot some sort of post-war bill to 'rebuild' what is left of Ukraine for them. The looming promises to do so only string along the warmongers further imho.
eric76
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
nortex97 said:

Yes Russians want a security structure, because they are being bombarded daily by munitions via Europe.

Gee. I wonder who is to blame for Russia being bombarded by European munitions.

Do you think it might be because Russia invaded the Ukraine in an attempt to enslave the people of that country?
GAC06
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Poor Russia is getting attacked by the warmongers
Teslag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG

Quote:

I will just agree to disagree as to which side desperately wants the bloodshed to continue at all costs


You literally just had a Russian member of the talks say they will take every inch of "Russian land" ie parts they don't control no matter what and you STILL think this war is being pushed by Europe or Ukraine?

It's just simply amazing at this point.
Rossticus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Will be interesting to see what the Russian proposal looks like. Of course, if we've asked for it to be drafted by tomorrow, we've already been working with them on a draft proposal behind the scenes.



"Axios reports that the US has asked Russia to draft a new European security agreement that includes concrete Russian steps to reduce tensions and reassure European states. Witkoff and Kushner will raise the proposal with Putin in Moscow on Thursday and push for European participation in future Ukraine peace talks. US officials say no agreement will be made without Ukraine and Europe's approval, and Russia will not receive a veto over European security decisions."
Rossticus
How long do you want to ignore this user?


"The Abu Dhabi meeting between UA, RU and Witkoff & Kushner is over. Apparently, apart from an agreement on a larger prisoner exchange, as expected, nothing particularly significant came out of it regarding a ceasefire or ending the war.

The UA and US delegations are now meeting with representatives from Europe, who are also on site but did not take part in the previous "negotiations," for a debriefing.

According to initial reports, Ukraine did not fundamentally reject the US proposals, but the Russians did.

As Zelenskyy already wrote yesterday, the RU delegation, including the GRU chief, did not even know the actual current front lines. The US military personnel present confirmed the Ukrainians' information on this based on their own intelligence findings, and also contradicted the Russians' claims."
Teslag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Quote:

According to initial reports, Ukraine did not fundamentally reject the US proposals, but the Russians did.


Completely expected. One side wants peace, the other wants surrender.
Rossticus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I don't expect any progress before this time next year, at the earliest.



" Russia's draft federal budget for 2027 allocates 17.1 trillion roubles, approximately $202.6 billion, to national defence. That is around 41% more than the amount allocated in the 2026 budget law. It is the highest defence allocation since the full-scale invasion began.

But the real story is what Russia is sacrificing to finance this war.

Federal spending on social policy is set to fall by 15.2% compared with the 2026 budget. Healthcare funding is down 4.6%, housing and utilities by 9.9%, and spending on the national economy by 4.6%. Meanwhile, defence and security together will consume around 44% of federal expenditure.

The financial pressure is already reaching ordinary Russians. Taxes are rising, borrowing is increasing, and regional authorities are cutting additional compensation for families of soldiers killed in Ukraine. In Bashkortostan, one regional payment fell from 2 million to 100,000 roubles.

The Kremlin is also expanding its control over private businesses. In August 2026, Putin signed a decree allowing temporary state management of critical infrastructure assets if companies are deemed to have failed to protect them against threats such as Ukrainian drone attacks. This is not formal nationalisation, but it gives the state extensive powers over private property.

What does all this tell us?

Moscow is preparing its economy and state institutions to sustain the war for longer. The old arrangement, in which the Kremlin tried to keep the costs of the war away from most ordinary Russians, is becoming increasingly difficult to maintain.

For Ukraine, this is a serious strategic challenge. We cannot mirror every measure available to the Russian state. We cannot simply seize private businesses, take citizens' bank deposits or abandon our obligations to military personnel and their families.

That makes an asymmetric response, continued pressure on Russia's military and economic infrastructure, and long-term support from our partners essential.

We should stop planning around the assumption that economic pressure alone will make Putin end the war. Russia is reorganising its resources to keep fighting. Ukraine and its partners must plan accordingly."
TRM
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Rossticus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
MaxPower
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Rossticus said:



"The talks in Abu Dhabi have ended. A few observations.

The fundamental obstacle to ending this war is that neither belligerent currently sees an available peace settlement that would secure its essential interests at a lower cost than continuing to fight. Negotiations can arrange prisoner exchanges and address other practical questions. But they cannot manufacture a political basis for peace where none yet exists.

For Putin, ending the war with a "victory" reduced to conquering the Donbas would create an enormous problem of historical judgment. Around 1.5 million Russian casualties, killed and wounded, to acquire another devastated stretch of Ukraine? Future generations of Russians might remember Putin as the opposite of a strategic genius: the ruler who squandered his country's people, resources and international position for gains grotesquely disproportionate to their cost.

This helps explain Moscow's determination to turn negotiations about its war against Ukraine into negotiations about a "new European security architecture." Russia needs a prize larger than the Donbas. Weakening NATO, pushing the Americans out of Europe and acquiring a veto over its neighbours' sovereign choices would provide one.

The historical precedent is clear. At the Berlin Conference in February 1954, Molotov proposed a European collective security system that would have displaced the Western alliances and relegated the United States to "observer" status. Today's vocabulary is different; the strategic ambition is familiar. If war against Ukraine could deliver the displacement of American power from Europe, the Kremlin could present it as a historic success and draw dangerous conclusions about what further wars might achieve.

For Ukraine, the calculation runs in the opposite direction. However appalling the costs of resistance, capitulation could still cost more. What is at stake is the survival of an independent state and the continued existence of Ukrainians as a distinct political nation.

Putin's account of Ukrainian history treats a separate Ukrainian identity as something cultivated by Russia's enemies, including Polish elites and Austrian authorities. The dangerous implication is that what was supposedly constructed can be dismantled. Deportation, killing and forced Russification become instruments for undoing a nation whose independent existence the aggressor refuses to accept. From Kyiv's perspective, surrender would therefore offer no reliable escape from violence. It could simply remove the means of resisting it.

Europe already has a security order worth defending. Its principles include sovereignty, territorial integrity and the freedom to choose alliances. Russia's violation of those principles is a reason to enforce them, not to replace them with arrangements requiring Russian permission.

Nor does the United States have a compelling national interest in surrendering its position in Europe to Russia. Its European presence sustains American influence, military reach and alliances. Whatever commercial opportunities Trump, Witkoff or Kushner may see in an accommodation with Moscow, those opportunities do not establish that such a retreat would benefit America. A deal attractive to individual negotiators is not necessarily a strategic bargain for their country.

That is the underlying impasse. Moscow wants a peace that converts aggression into a wider strategic victory. Ukraine needs a peace that preserves its ability to survive. Europe cannot accept Russian control over European security, and America has no sound strategic reason to facilitate it.

Until those calculations change, the war is likely to continue. Calling the process a negotiation does not make the interests compatible. Without that compatibility, we will keep getting diplomatic choreography and, around it, this ridiculous circus."
An eloquent way of saying we are at an impasse. I would say one of the biggest benefits of democracy is eliminating this sunk cost issue. You don't have the luxury of worrying about legacy when you're about to get kicked to the curb for an unpopular war. It's just sad this kind of thinking is going to lead to even more pain n and misery.
nortex97
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I guess the Israeli system and whining about America/Trump didn't work as well as hoped. 'Someone at the pentagon or spaceX...'. Middle range drone strikes.

Kushner and Witkoff are at the Kremlin today negotiating regarding the 'security plan' the Russians have indicated a peace deal requires.

Progress.
Quote:

Ukraine's chief negotiator Rustem Umerov said the discussions covered steps towards a broader peace agreement and the country's post-war reconstruction.

Quote:

Kushner acknowledged that significant differences remained, but suggested that the discussions had identified possible areas of compromise.

"Some areas we see places where we can find compromises, others we need to have more discussions, but I think this was a good first step," he told reporters.

Zelenskyy, who is in Dublin for meetings with European leaders, said he hoped the US envoys would return from Moscow with concrete proposals.

"What's important is that the Americans flew to Putin with specifics. I would very much like them to return to Dublin with specifics," he said, adding that while he remained skeptical, "there is hope".

The Americans don't report to Dublin, nor Zelensky. RIDICULE.
Teslag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
What about Russia? Do we report to Russia?
nortex97
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Teslag said:

What about Russia? Do we report to Russia?

It's pretty tough to negotiate a peace to the Russian-Ukraine war without involving Russia.

They did wind up flying back to Dublin from Moscow, fyi, will see if Zelensky cries more about what they say/Starshield/Spanish russian LNG purchases. His protracted absence from Kiev is drawing some scrutiny.

docb
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
If someone could rip a bullet through Putin's head these negotiations might be easier.
Teslag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG

Quote:

It's pretty tough to negotiate a peace to the Russian-Ukraine war without involving Russia.


Is it tough to do so without having your president suck up to them and bend to their every whim and desire while also being made a fool by them time and time again?
Rossticus
How long do you want to ignore this user?


"Clearly I do not agree with Alexander Dugin, but he articulates the 'real' Russian position concisely.

It's not, IMHO, entirely honest, so for example a neutral Ukraine would be the target of relentless Russian subversion, including thru violence and organised crime etc., so it would be an extremely unstable country. So the only reason Russia would tolerate a neutral Ukraine would be to collapse it and bring it back into the Russian fold.

But it goes to show the extent to which a deeply atavistic mindset, in part Soviet, in part a form of extreme Slavism, has gripped the Russian elite in the past 20 years.

To justify Putin's authoritarianism, the West as the enemy was recreated. For sure, NATO and EU didn't always help themselves, and they sometimes handled the relationship with Russia badly, but under the Putin regime, we can now see that the genuine independence of Ukraine was never going to be tolerated."
nortex97
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG

Comical at this point.

Largest POW exchange of the war pending.

 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.