Trump and Russia Pivot - October 2026

55,098 Views | 1009 Replies | Last: 10 min ago by Teslag
Teslag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Red Fishing Ag93 said:

Rossticus said:

Teslag said:

What are those same old conditions of a freeze at current lines? Can you share specifics?


Probably that they receive security guarantees and maintain a military capable of defending themselves. You know. Sane stuff for any nation interested in self preservation.

In other words, NATO.

Which is why we are where we are.


What alternative security guarantees do you propose to prevent Russia from invading again in the future?
Rossticus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Claude! said:

Ukraine better get those security guarantees written in stronger ink than they got after the Soviet Union fell.


It will have to be a formal security agreement with select European nations involved for Ukraine to accept it and for it to serve as a deterrent. Would need to be completely detached from NATO to prevent any non-signatories from being dragged in unwilling should Russia try to take another bite.

Ukraine learned their lesson this time. Neither our word nor Russia's word is worth the paper it's written on. Toilet paper otherwise.
nortex97
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Rossticus said:

Claude! said:

Ukraine better get those security guarantees written in stronger ink than they got after the Soviet Union fell.


It will have to be a formal security agreement with select European nations involved for Ukraine to accept it and for it to serve as a deterrent. Would need to be completely detached from NATO to prevent any non-signatories from being dragged in unwilling should Russia try to take another bite.

Ukraine learned their lesson this time. Neither our word nor Russia's word is worth the paper it's written on. Toilet paper otherwise.

Zelensky has demanded Europe AND the US provide security guarantees.

I would prefer he rely solely on European guarantees, as it is dangerous for America to be at risk to any provocations that don't involve our interests, though he also lamented a couple days ago that only the US can provide early launch warnings etc. vs. the Euros. I'd be fine with agreeing to commit to providing launch warnings for ballistic strikes etc.

Putin also talked about providing fertilizer to the US today with Witkoff (which he said he and Trump had discussed. Though I will say, calling him a 'humanitarian' in the meeting was...well, beyond the pale).

Charlie Kirk show excerpt on point:
Rossticus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I'm good with euros providing boots and we provide intel/infra/limited logistics along with agreeing to sell/license whatever they want to buy from us, manufacture (in some cases) or transfer.

OR, if Russia insists on Ukraine being fully neutral, zero limits on military capability/size. If you want peace through neutrality then there has to be strength to back it up in order for it to be practical.
nortex97
How long do you want to ignore this user?
We're not as far apart as usual then. Whatever gets American lives out of foreign entanglements and drops the price of energy/ends the war/carnage I basically would favor.
Rossticus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I think that you and I tend to be closer than it seems in our assessments of the ultimate goal, we just differ on the most effective path to reach it.

I will say that I still find the likelihood that Russia plays ball without a few additional twists and turns to extract more concessions slim. I think that there are too many Russians in position of power, to include Putin, who continue to see Ukraine as an illegitimate collective of self-loathing second class Russians who need to be put in their place and the territory as Russian birthright.



BlackGold
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Teslag said:

Red Fishing Ag93 said:

Rossticus said:

Teslag said:

What are those same old conditions of a freeze at current lines? Can you share specifics?


Probably that they receive security guarantees and maintain a military capable of defending themselves. You know. Sane stuff for any nation interested in self preservation.

In other words, NATO.

Which is why we are where we are.


What alternative security guarantees do you propose to prevent Russia from invading again in the future?


Whatever doesn't cost the American taxpayer a single dime.
samurai_science
How long do you want to ignore this user?
BlackGold said:

Teslag said:

Red Fishing Ag93 said:

Rossticus said:

Teslag said:

What are those same old conditions of a freeze at current lines? Can you share specifics?


Probably that they receive security guarantees and maintain a military capable of defending themselves. You know. Sane stuff for any nation interested in self preservation.

In other words, NATO.

Which is why we are where we are.


What alternative security guarantees do you propose to prevent Russia from invading again in the future?


Whatever doesn't cost the American taxpayer a single dime.
FWTXAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Teslag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
BlackGold said:

Teslag said:

Red Fishing Ag93 said:

Rossticus said:

Teslag said:

What are those same old conditions of a freeze at current lines? Can you share specifics?


Probably that they receive security guarantees and maintain a military capable of defending themselves. You know. Sane stuff for any nation interested in self preservation.

In other words, NATO.

Which is why we are where we are.


What alternative security guarantees do you propose to prevent Russia from invading again in the future?


Whatever doesn't cost the American taxpayer a single dime.


So basically the one Zelenskyy is supporting. Glad to see we are all on the same page now.

Let's hope Russia gets there too.
BlackGold
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Teslag said:

BlackGold said:

Teslag said:

Red Fishing Ag93 said:

Rossticus said:

Teslag said:

What are those same old conditions of a freeze at current lines? Can you share specifics?


Probably that they receive security guarantees and maintain a military capable of defending themselves. You know. Sane stuff for any nation interested in self preservation.

In other words, NATO.

Which is why we are where we are.


What alternative security guarantees do you propose to prevent Russia from invading again in the future?


Whatever doesn't cost the American taxpayer a single dime.


So basically the one Zelenskyy is supporting. Glad to see we are all on the same page now.

Let's hope Russia gets there too.


The one where we still provide him with intel and weapons systems? Sure seems like there's taxpayer dollars there.

Not a dime means $0. HTH.
GeorgiAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
BlackGold said:

Teslag said:

BlackGold said:

Teslag said:

Red Fishing Ag93 said:

Rossticus said:

Teslag said:

What are those same old conditions of a freeze at current lines? Can you share specifics?


Probably that they receive security guarantees and maintain a military capable of defending themselves. You know. Sane stuff for any nation interested in self preservation.

In other words, NATO.

Which is why we are where we are.


What alternative security guarantees do you propose to prevent Russia from invading again in the future?


Whatever doesn't cost the American taxpayer a single dime.


So basically the one Zelenskyy is supporting. Glad to see we are all on the same page now.

Let's hope Russia gets there too.


The one where we still provide him with intel and weapons systems? Sure seems like there's taxpayer dollars there.

Not a dime means $0. HTH.

Not having Russia roll all over Europe is in our National Security Interest.
Teslag
How long do you want to ignore this user?

Quote:

The one where we still provide him with intel and weapons systems?


The intel costs nothing as it's already being shared with our strategic partners and is being done by personnel already members of our intelligence community. Those costs are fixed regardless of weather we share the intel or not.

Our weapons provided to Ukraine now and in the future are purchased from us by Ukraine's European allies. Doesn't cost us a dollar. In fact, it actually contributes to our GDP and makes us wealthier.

So yes, you are in alignment with Zelenskyy. Do you think Russia agrees with you and Zelenskyy's proposal?
Old McDonald
How long do you want to ignore this user?
GeorgiAg said:

BlackGold said:

Teslag said:

BlackGold said:

Teslag said:

Red Fishing Ag93 said:

Rossticus said:

Teslag said:

What are those same old conditions of a freeze at current lines? Can you share specifics?


Probably that they receive security guarantees and maintain a military capable of defending themselves. You know. Sane stuff for any nation interested in self preservation.

In other words, NATO.

Which is why we are where we are.


What alternative security guarantees do you propose to prevent Russia from invading again in the future?


Whatever doesn't cost the American taxpayer a single dime.


So basically the one Zelenskyy is supporting. Glad to see we are all on the same page now.

Let's hope Russia gets there too.


The one where we still provide him with intel and weapons systems? Sure seems like there's taxpayer dollars there.

Not a dime means $0. HTH.

Not having Russia roll all over Europe is in our National Security Interest.

not according to the russian bots on my twitter timeline! they keep telling me russians are our based white Christian allies and europeans are our communist muslim enemies
Rossticus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
BlackGold said:

Teslag said:

BlackGold said:

Teslag said:

Red Fishing Ag93 said:

Rossticus said:

Teslag said:

What are those same old conditions of a freeze at current lines? Can you share specifics?


Probably that they receive security guarantees and maintain a military capable of defending themselves. You know. Sane stuff for any nation interested in self preservation.

In other words, NATO.

Which is why we are where we are.


What alternative security guarantees do you propose to prevent Russia from invading again in the future?


Whatever doesn't cost the American taxpayer a single dime.


So basically the one Zelenskyy is supporting. Glad to see we are all on the same page now.

Let's hope Russia gets there too.


The one where we still provide him with intel and weapons systems? Sure seems like there's taxpayer dollars there.

Not a dime means $0. HTH.


Well, they're paying for the weapons systems they've been provided under Trump. And they're paying Elon. And we're going be collecting the intel whether we give it to them or not. So, your estimation is out of line with reality. Please recalibrate.

Edit: Oops. Missed Tesla's response.
Old McDonald
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Im Gipper
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Fill in the blanks!

If the Ukrainians laid down their arms, _____________

If the Russians laid down their arms, _____________

I'm Gipper
CascadiaAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
samurai_science
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Im Gipper said:

Fill in the blanks!

If the Ukrainians laid down their arms, _____________

If the Russians laid down their arms, _____________

I wouldn't care.

I wouldn't care.
Teslag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
samurai_science said:

Im Gipper said:

Fill in the blanks!

If the Ukrainians laid down their arms, _____________

If the Russians laid down their arms, _____________

I wouldn't care.

I wouldn't care.

But you do care or you wouldn't still be posting on these threads. You continue to say you don't care as long as we aren't funding it and we aren't. Currently we are even making money on it.
Gaw617
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Trump wants Russia to help with Iran. This is Putin's asking price.
Sq 17
How long do you want to ignore this user?
If Trump wants help with Iran he's talking to the wrong dictator

Putin has no leverage or resources and can't even win his current special military operation

Xi if he wanted to could likely get Iran and the Houthis to stop blowing up $*** but China is better positioned for this than any other country because if needed they can cease exports of refined products and their SPR is full of highly discounted sanctioned oil
Red Fishing Ag93
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Rossticus said:

Red Fishing Ag93 said:

Rossticus said:

Teslag said:

What are those same old conditions of a freeze at current lines? Can you share specifics?


Probably that they receive security guarantees and maintain a military capable of defending themselves. You know. Sane stuff for any nation interested in self preservation.

In other words, NATO.

Which is why we are where we are.


If you think that the only way for a country to have security guarantees is to join NATO then this entire matter may be just a tad out of your depth. That, or your criticism of Ukraine is that they won't agree to end the war without having any means of preventing another one. Which speaks either to a profound lack of logical thought or a foundational hypocrisy, because you and I both know that under similar circumstances you wouldn't serve your nation and its people up for consumption. But yet you expect the same from others. So suspect that your issue is the latter.
Lol, I understand perfectly, likely better than you.

We promised Putin no NATO expansion to tbe East, you know this.

Leading up to the war there were LOTS of talks and meetings of adding Ukraine, by NATO, EU, Biden, et al.

So your details of security guarantees like Article V and a defense military only (hilarious, btw) aren't going to mean squat to Russia and Putin, nor should they.

It will be viewed as essentially joining NATO. The trust if we had any, is gone.
Sq 17
How long do you want to ignore this user?
We could just give them
Back their nukes that they surrendered a few decades ago
5Amp
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Ukraine was the poorest country in Eastern Europe before the war, now it lays in ruins with a decimated population.

Teslag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Quote:

We promised Putin no NATO expansion to tbe East, you know this


We've never promised this to Putin.
Teslag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
5Amp said:

Ukraine was the poorest country in Eastern Europe before the war, now it lays in ruins with a decimated population.




And they'd choose that over being Russian.

And they also now have one of the strongest and most experienced armed forces in the world.
Red Fishing Ag93
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Teslag said:

Quote:

We promised Putin no NATO expansion to tbe East, you know this


We've never promised this to Putin.
Russia. Does it matter to you, Putin or Gorbechov?

It does not, wise guy.
Teslag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
We didn't promise Russia either.

We made assurances to the Soviet Union pertaining only the reunification of Germany and any NATO forces then remaining in said unified Germany. They (NATO) would not move east an "inch". It was important because the Soviet Union still had a presence in the soon to be former east Germany.

A year later the Soviet Union dissolved and any verbal assurances were meaningless, as those Soviet forces had left Germany.

We have not ever promised the Russian Federation NATO would not "expand". Which is a ridiculous notion anyway. It's a defensive organization of volunteer membership. If Russia doesn't want people to join it then maybe they stop killing and invading their neighbors.
Rossticus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Red Fishing Ag93 said:

Rossticus said:

Red Fishing Ag93 said:

Rossticus said:

Teslag said:

What are those same old conditions of a freeze at current lines? Can you share specifics?


Probably that they receive security guarantees and maintain a military capable of defending themselves. You know. Sane stuff for any nation interested in self preservation.

In other words, NATO.

Which is why we are where we are.


If you think that the only way for a country to have security guarantees is to join NATO then this entire matter may be just a tad out of your depth. That, or your criticism of Ukraine is that they won't agree to end the war without having any means of preventing another one. Which speaks either to a profound lack of logical thought or a foundational hypocrisy, because you and I both know that under similar circumstances you wouldn't serve your nation and its people up for consumption. But yet you expect the same from others. So suspect that your issue is the latter.
Lol, I understand perfectly, likely better than you.

We promised Putin no NATO expansion to tbe East, you know this.

Leading up to the war there were LOTS of talks and meetings of adding Ukraine, by NATO, EU, Biden, et al.

So your details of security guarantees like Article V and a defense military only (hilarious, btw) aren't going to mean squat to Russia and Putin, nor should they.

It will be viewed as essentially joining NATO. The trust if we had any, is gone.


No. You don't. And frankly it's probably not even close in comparison to most other posters on this thread, regardless of which side of the issue they're on. Your grasp of both the facts and the logic you employ are… rudimentary, to put it nicely.

You're certainly more than entitled to your amusingly wish-cast based opinion that the only way to end this is forcing Ukraine to resume existence as either a Russian republic or vassal.

However, if you think that's any more realistic an option than that of the folks who think Ukraine can hold out until they win back all their land then I'm pretty sure your opinion on what I think isn't worth wasting any more time over.
YouBet
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I like this plan. This is good as it's going to get so hopefully they get it across the finish line.

Of course, if it happens we will have the inevitable confrontation when the moratorium on NATO runs out. Hopefully, we just keep re-upping that to keep Russia happy.

And Witkoff's humanitarian comment about Putin is absolutely absurd and embarrassing and never should happen but I'm also sure that was done totally for Russian media to help Putin save face.
Rossticus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Red Fishing Ag93 said:

Teslag said:

Quote:

We promised Putin no NATO expansion to tbe East, you know this


We've never promised this to Putin.
Russia. Does it matter to you, Putin or Gorbechov?

It does not, wise guy.


Actually, Gorbechov long ago clarified in an interview that this is a myth. Putin outwardly signaled that he had no problem with Ukraine joining NATO (here's an instance from 2002) because he owned the Ukrainian government through corruption and didn't anticipate a risk that they'd ever pursue an independent course. Once Russia no longer felt that they had firm control of Ukraine as a vassal state, THEN it suddenly became a red line.



Rossticus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Found this to be an interesting rundown of proposed deescalations in the past year and a half that went nowhere.

Rossticus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
YouBet said:

I like this plan. This is good as it's going to get so hopefully they get it across the finish line.

Of course, if it happens we will have the inevitable confrontation when the moratorium on NATO runs out. Hopefully, we just keep re-upping that to keep Russia happy.

And Witkoff's humanitarian comment about Putin is absolutely absurd and embarrassing and never should happen but I'm also sure that was done totally for Russian media to help Putin save face.


One can only hope.

Rossticus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
For all the "THE US AND NATO CAUSED THIS" noise, Russia has been bent on finding a justification to own Ukraine again since they managed to gain independence. LONG before there were any talks of NATO and when Ukraine was still officially neutral. Everything being thrown around publicly since 2013 has been Russian pretext. Interesting how the proposed timetable lays out.





Couldn't help but throw this in. It really is a fun account full of logic and Russians either saying the quiet part out loud or contradicting the current propaganda years before the modern op got underway.

 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.