jj9000 said:
Harkrider 93 said:
jj9000 said:
Interesting analysis.
clay711 pointed this out a few weeks ago.
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-04-01/a-66-billion-etf-haul-worries-bulls-looking-for-signs-of-bottom
I don't think looking at the 1st Qtr is a proper way to make a determination.
We hit a high midway through the qtr, and most of the time, people buy like crazy into the high and sell like crazy into the low. Best to look at weekly or even monthly flows.
I think the point is that people are still dumping money into ETFs which outpace the outflows.
Look at last week/month Inflows/Outflow for the big boys.
https://www.etf.com/etfanalytics/etf-fund-flows-tool
Premise is still the same.
There is a huge outflow of stock funds and a slight inflow of stock ETFs. The net is negative.
Below is a firm that researches both and they show negative outflows in Feb for stock ETFs. The above article is lumping bond and stock ETFs. Then, they are taking stock ETFs for a 3 mos time frame. It may be misleading, especially when taken with the research below.
https://www.yardeni.com/pub/icieqbnd.pdfOn the ETF website you showed, I looked at that when clay posted and again when you did. If you add up just the top 10 stock ETF inflow and same for outlow, the outflow was greater. The same for bonds, except inflows were greater. This coincides with the way it almost always is and with the article I attached.
Edit: on the ETF flow site, the inflow is actually greater than outflow (barely), but last week was a positive week for stocks, so you would expect that due to history. People buy when the market is up and sell when it is down. I would bet that even though we had a positive inflow for the week based on the top 10 ETFs (which do not include mutual funds), I bet the month was heavily outflow.