Max Power said:
I don't understand the commentators on ESPN FC. I watched each of them to a person indicate they thought the red card was not the correct call, but also every one of them saying that FIFA should stand by the decision. Why do they think they stand by a decision if they believe it's incorrect? The red card against England last night was a textbook example of a true red card offense. What Messi did in Argentina's first game should have been a red card and didn't even draw a yellow. Why is the correcting of a bad call so offensive to these people?
Yep. If it's the wrong call, it should be corrected.
One of the problems with var, replay or any versions of it is how it's seemingly randomly used or has weird rules abouts it's use and enforcement.
Either use it or don't. Use it to fix everything or don't use it. Subjectively deciding when it might be proper or not to employ it creates an entirely different set of problems.
Again, red cards should already be automatically appealed post match to determine if the penalty was valid or overkill.