This thread is going the way of The Last Jedi discussion...

Brian Earl Spilner said:

---

This thread is going the way of The Last Jedi discussion...

---

Not really.

The Last Jedi had genuine hate from people who saw it. I was one of them. There were detailed discussions of what people felt was wrong with that film. And it did get heated.

This movie? There are some who genuinely didn't like it, but the majority seems to be "good, not great." Very few people are expressing regret having watched it; just that they probably wouldn't watch it again. I'm still only one hour into it and am having trouble finding the desire to continue. I was hoping to read from others on this thread that it's worth going back to it. I'm not finding much encouragement, but I'm sure I will just so that I can form a complete opinion.

Many people were wanting to burn the negatives of The Last Jedi and have another writer/director re-do it from scratch.

aTmAg said:

---

Complete Idiot said:

---

aTmAg said:

---

ac04 said:

---

aTmAg said:

---

I've been avoiding this thread out of spoiler fear. But Google suggested an article titled something like "Admit it, there Irishman is terrible"

Should I avoid it?

---

maybe just watch it and form your own opinion?

---

I don't have time to watch every movie/show that I'm somewhat interested in to form my own opinion. I'd rather get a heads up before I waste my time on something mediocre.

---

Scorsese has been making movies for 40+ years, Pacino, Deniro, and Pesci acting for 40-50 years. There are probably 100 professional reviews on the internet and 6 pages of replies here before you asked if you should have avoid it. How much spoon feeding is required?

---

I wasn't aware of The Irishman until I saw the 10 second preview on Netflix as I was scrolling by. My wife is not into mob movies, so I was planning on watching it later when I had time, because I typically like Scorsese movies. Since it was already released, I avoided this thread out of spoiler fear.

But then I get a suggested Google story saying it's terrible. Since professional reviewers are pompous morons who have less than 1% of the talent of a guy like Scorsese, I came here to get the opinion of regular Joe's (who are likely Scorsese fans). But I still don't want to read the entire thread and get spoiled. I was just asking a simple question and am only reading replies to me.

---

I said this before, but if a Scorsese directed mob movie starring Pacina, Deniro, and Pesci doesn't already interest you enough to see it without being told you should see it then you probably won't like it.

He was also convinced we were going to beat either Georgia or LSU, if not both, so he's definitely no Nostradamus.

aTmAg said:

---

HoustonAg2106 said:

---

aTmAg said:

---

Complete Idiot said:

---

aTmAg said:

---

ac04 said:

---

aTmAg said:

---

I've been avoiding this thread out of spoiler fear. But Google suggested an article titled something like "Admit it, there Irishman is terrible"

Should I avoid it?

---

maybe just watch it and form your own opinion?

---

I don't have time to watch every movie/show that I'm somewhat interested in to form my own opinion. I'd rather get a heads up before I waste my time on something mediocre.

---

Scorsese has been making movies for 40+ years, Pacino, Deniro, and Pesci acting for 40-50 years. There are probably 100 professional reviews on the internet and 6 pages of replies here before you asked if you should have avoid it. How much spoon feeding is required?

---

I wasn't aware of The Irishman until I saw the 10 second preview on Netflix as I was scrolling by. My wife is not into mob movies, so I was planning on watching it later when I had time, because I typically like Scorsese movies. Since it was already released, I avoided this thread out of spoiler fear.

But then I get a suggested Google story saying it's terrible. Since professional reviewers are pompous morons who have less than 1% of the talent of a guy like Scorsese, I came here to get the opinion of regular Joe's (who are likely Scorsese fans). But I still don't want to read the entire thread and get spoiled. I was just asking a simple question and am only reading replies to me.

---

I said this before, but if a Scorsese directed mob movie starring Pacina, Deniro, and Pesci doesn't already interest you enough to see it without being told you should see it then you probably won't like it.

---

I don't like terrible movies no matter who is in it. That is the question at hand.

If it's on the bubble of "terribleness", then yeah, you are right. I'll skip.

---

I agree, it sounds like you should skip it.

aTmAg said:

---

HoustonAg2106 said:

---

aTmAg said:

---

Complete Idiot said:

---

aTmAg said:

---

ac04 said:

---

aTmAg said:

---

I've been avoiding this thread out of spoiler fear. But Google suggested an article titled something like "Admit it, there Irishman is terrible"

Should I avoid it?

---

maybe just watch it and form your own opinion?

---

I don't have time to watch every movie/show that I'm somewhat interested in to form my own opinion. I'd rather get a heads up before I waste my time on something mediocre.

---

Scorsese has been making movies for 40+ years, Pacino, Deniro, and Pesci acting for 40-50 years. There are probably 100 professional reviews on the internet and 6 pages of replies here before you asked if you should have avoid it. How much spoon feeding is required?

---

I wasn't aware of The Irishman until I saw the 10 second preview on Netflix as I was scrolling by. My wife is not into mob movies, so I was planning on watching it later when I had time, because I typically like Scorsese movies. Since it was already released, I avoided this thread out of spoiler fear.

But then I get a suggested Google story saying it's terrible. Since professional reviewers are pompous morons who have less than 1% of the talent of a guy like Scorsese, I came here to get the opinion of regular Joe's (who are likely Scorsese fans). But I still don't want to read the entire thread and get spoiled. I was just asking a simple question and am only reading replies to me.

---

I said this before, but if a Scorsese directed mob movie starring Pacina, Deniro, and Pesci doesn't already interest you enough to see it without being told you should see it then you probably won't like it.

---

I don't like terrible movies no matter who is in it. That is the question at hand.

If it's on the bubble of "terribleness", then yeah, you are right. I'll skip.

---

You do know that this is a Scorsese movie, right? It could star Rupaul, The Boz and Keanu Reeves and the chances of it being "terrible" are still about 0.00001%.

Quote:

---

It could star Rupaul, The Boz and Keanu Reeves and the chances of it being "terrible" are still about 0.00001%.

---

Um, there's no way that movie would be terrible, sign me up now for that.

HtownAg92 said:

---

aTmAg said:

---

HoustonAg2106 said:

---

aTmAg said:

---

Complete Idiot said:

---

aTmAg said:

---

ac04 said:

---

aTmAg said:

---

I've been avoiding this thread out of spoiler fear. But Google suggested an article titled something like "Admit it, there Irishman is terrible"

Should I avoid it?

---

maybe just watch it and form your own opinion?

---

I don't have time to watch every movie/show that I'm somewhat interested in to form my own opinion. I'd rather get a heads up before I waste my time on something mediocre.

---

Scorsese has been making movies for 40+ years, Pacino, Deniro, and Pesci acting for 40-50 years. There are probably 100 professional reviews on the internet and 6 pages of replies here before you asked if you should have avoid it. How much spoon feeding is required?

---

I wasn't aware of The Irishman until I saw the 10 second preview on Netflix as I was scrolling by. My wife is not into mob movies, so I was planning on watching it later when I had time, because I typically like Scorsese movies. Since it was already released, I avoided this thread out of spoiler fear.

But then I get a suggested Google story saying it's terrible. Since professional reviewers are pompous morons who have less than 1% of the talent of a guy like Scorsese, I came here to get the opinion of regular Joe's (who are likely Scorsese fans). But I still don't want to read the entire thread and get spoiled. I was just asking a simple question and am only reading replies to me.

---

I said this before, but if a Scorsese directed mob movie starring Pacina, Deniro, and Pesci doesn't already interest you enough to see it without being told you should see it then you probably won't like it.

---

I don't like terrible movies no matter who is in it. That is the question at hand.

If it's on the bubble of "terribleness", then yeah, you are right. I'll skip.

---

You do know that this is a Scorsese movie, right? It could star Rupaul, The Boz and Keanu Reeves and the chances of it being "terrible" are still about 0.00001%.

---

That's essentially what I was trying to say. You shouldn't need to do research on people's opinions and read articles from the new york suck my **** post to decide whether or not to watch a Scorsese movie starring a cast like this...

I get it this movie isn't for everyone, but I would watch those 3 actors and Scorsese sitting on a porch talking about literally nothing for 3 and a half hours and still feel like it wasn't a waste of my time.

I thought it was excellent. It wasn't as good as The Departed or casino or goodfellas but it was still very well made and worth the time. If you're not into film and prefer justice league or hobbits it's not for you.