quote:I agree that that is all plausible / factual. The problem is they didn't do smooth job taking the viewer down that road of thought. Many people I have talked to (big fans and not), have been confused by that scene for the same reason.
1. Tried to kill fin not using force powers because he was a traitor.
2. Injured him severely. Went for Luke's saber.
3. Doesn't use force on Rey on purpose. Wants to somehow convince her to join dark side.
4. During the cliff convo, she finally believed she had the force. Her fighting went from scared/sloppy to confident.
5. He was wounded already. He was on defensive and scared. Scared like before when he knew she was better with the force with the mind block.
Could've done a better job, but hindsight is 20/20.