Tonight's episode was excellent. Along with last week's, amongst the better of the series. That said, here's how I felt about the season as a whole...
The show is a comedy by definition, but it doesn't fall in line with your typical TV comedies. The Office, 30 Rock, and the like, make hilarious comedy out of situations, and as such, are sitcoms. This show, however, is not funny enough to entertain us with it's comedy (evidenced by the fact that the funniest things about this season were the Matt Damon outtakes, as posted above in the youtube clip and at the end of tonight's episode, which weren't even included in the episodes, and real LOL moments are few and far between, minus Ari in the last 2 eps). As such, the series is defined by it's entertaining series plot lines laced with a fair amount of comedy and signature HBO sex and profanity.
So for me, a successful season needs decent story arcs to carry it. At the end of the day, the only character that really got a decent story arc over the season was Lloyd. Freaking Lloyd.
I'll start with Vince. Vince was ignored this season. In theory, I'm fine with this. Vince isn't the main character of the series. (Over the course of the series, it really is E and deserves to be Ari. That's why Connolly is considered a lead actor in the Emmy race each year, and Piven wins Best Supporting Actor year in and out- because he routinely steals the show from the alleged "lead" and makes it worth watching.) It's not like there weren't stories for Vince. Gatsby gets huge buzz, there was allegedly awards potential in the first 2 eps. Why not show us Vince going through the awards campaign, whether successful or a huge failure, to give him something interesting to do? He literally did nothing ALL season, other than look bored that everyone else had other things to do than hang out with him. As stated earlier, the reason I'm fine with Vince being ignored in theory is that he's not the main character and is the least interesting character on the show. It's fine for him to be ignored if the other characters have good storylines.
Which brings me to E. At the start of the season, the alleged "theme" of the season was that characters, particularly E, were growing up. Ultimately, that was a load of bull ****. E had some sort of romantic comedy/Fatal Attraction hybrid storyline where he ultimately realized that Sloane (extremely hot, and the heir to an Ari-purchased $75M+ fortune) was entirely too good for him and he should keep that if possible. Which every one knew about 4 seasons ago. He in no way "grew up". He got a new job at a management firm, ripe with story line possibilities. The only thing that happens is that he gets a secretary who is possibly hotter than any other female to appear in this series for more than one episode and is wasted, and a few funny scenes with Bob Saget. Every season of this series has had an arc, and this season's was allegedly growth of some characters. I expected a lot of people here to ***** about that. Turns out, it didn't happen. It was replaced by "no arc".
Turtle was the other character who was supposed to grow up. He was also thrown into something of a romantic comedy storyline which reeked of nothing but giving his washed-up real life gf a job. He went to a few classes and met a hot sorority girl. But again, a waste of screen time as Jamie Lynn was worthless and an unbelievable and unentertaining story.
Drama finally got to be Drama the last half of the season. The story with the NBC executive was blown- a lot of entertainment value of him doing terrible things to Drama was wasted. Classic Drama finally appeared in the last 2 episodes and it was great. Why couldn't we have gotten more of that the rest of the season? After Piven, Dillon is the best thing about this series, and he was completely underutilized until the end. The conclusion of the story was pretty stupid to. The CW (the "network" putting on the Melrose remake) offered him a talent holding-deal for a new series. No way. They don't have an actor under 30 on that network. It was a stupid conclusion, but the least of my complaints about this season.
WestTxAg06 has long lobbied for a MGA spinoff. While it will never happen since it isn't really commercially viable, as he and I and about 25% of this series' audience would entertained by agency antics alone in a series, it's about the only thing that would interest me at this point. Ari had little more to do than Vince this season (the last 2 episodes excepted). His storylines are generally driven by Vince stories. When Vince didn't have anything to do, Ari wasn't given anything to do. Complete underutilization, as we have seen Ari in some great non-Vince stories (particularly his break from Terrence). They somewhat redeemed in at the end. But what is the reason for not giving us more of this type stuff? Klein was briefly used, then brushed aside. We got nothing with Mrs. Ari until the end. He generally carries the show but wasn't given a chance to this season. Which makes no sense, because the storylines they chose to replace his screen time with were complete garbage.
I don't like to be an extreme complainer, this season just really fell flat for me as a whole, and the series really showed it's age. The last 2 episodes were a successful redemption attempt, but when a season is only 12 episodes and 6 hours long, there is no excuse for not drawing out a tightly-plotted story. Next season will be #7, and few shows of much higher quality have managed to make it farther than that. Since they are clearly running out of stories and aren't going to use MGA- the one place with ripe storylines- to carry the series, I'd say it's time to declare 7 the last season and go out with some sort of a bang.