A few excerpts from a Maldy Q&A I did on here a few weeks ago:
Texags: Deluxe, you were one of Maldy's biggest supporters last year. Why?
Deluxe: Every year is different. Last year, Maldy was our guy behind the plate and there was no doubt about it. He managed the best staff in baseball. His offensive numbers weren't even that bad from June on.
Castro and Lee didn't provide any real competition for his job. And Vazquez was brought in as insurance in case Maldy went down. It's also worth noting that Maldy outperformed Vazquez down the stretch last year (though one could fairly point out that it was at least partially due to Vazquez not getting consistent work).
Our offense was also better last year and it was easier to hide him in the 9 hole.
Texags: Why haven't you spoken out on Maldy's behalf much this year?
Deluxe: Again, every year is different. I was a big proponent of Diaz getting a lot of work early this season. We needed his bat. And given where the team was earlier this year, we had a good opportunity for him to audition for a bigger role on the team into the future. Not to mention playing Diaz more would keep more tread off Maldy's tires for when we need him down the stretch.
At this juncture, there's no question that Diaz outperforms Maldy in almost every measurable category. Significantly so in many categories. Whereas last year Maldy was unquestionably the guy, this year it's a little more complicated.
Texags: What value does Maldy add to the team?
Deluxe: Maldy is a scouting/matchup guru. Our starting rotation is top 5 this year with France, Bielak and Blanco pitching significant innings. I can't imagine he doesn't deserve any credit for that.
Texags: But pitchers have a better ERA this year when Diaz is catching.
Deluxe: Is Diaz devising that game plan on his own or is Maldy devising it behind the scenes and helping Diaz adjust throughout the game?
Texags: Not sure any of us can say for sure what goes on behind the scenes.
Deluxe: Agreed. I tend to think he's adding a lot more game-calling/matchup value behind the scenes than what most fans recognize. There's been plenty of accounts of this… from his teammates/coaches, to opposing managers and commentators who have given him credit for swinging multiple playoff series' in our favor. I also don't think one of the smartest organizations would continue to run out a player who's so bad statistically without a good reason.
Texags: Fair enough. But if Maldy's value is his brain, doesn't that mean Dusty should start Diaz and instruct Maldy to essentially be backup catcher/bench coach?
Deluxe: In a perfect world devoid of player egos, perhaps. But Maldy still sees himself as the starter. He LOVES the game and wants to play as much as possible. To say "hey Maldy, we need you to keep busting your ass for us and producing scouting reports, but Diaz is gonna play and you're gonna sit" probably isn't the best way to keep Maldy engaged.
Texags: If Maldy isn't going to be a team player and accept a backup/bench coach role at this point, we should just cut him.
Deluxe: He would get picked up by one of our rivals in two seconds.
Texags: Fine, let our rival have fun with his .160 batting average and lackluster play behind the plate.
Deluxe: Be careful what you wish for. Trust me, I get the frustration watching him trudge out there 3-4 times out of 5 games and look lost at the plate. Maldy's value clearly isn't in his 162 game production. But he's a guy you really really really want in your dugout when the playoffs roll around the game becomes exclusively about matchups.
Texags: Our clubhouse was able to withstand the losses of guys like Correa and Springer and keep rolling. We can withstand the loss of Maldy.
Deluxe: Maybe. But clubhouse culture isn't really the point. The point is the value he's adding to our game-calling processes.
Texags: Thanks Deluxe. You're right as usual.
Deluxe: I appreciate that but I don't consider myself "right" in this instance. Again, I share the frustrations this year watching him struggle while also watching Diaz mash. But I also think general fan disdain for Maldy has gone too far. I can't say with 100% certainty that he's adding enough game-calling/behind-the-scenes value to offset his lackluster production, but no one in the "disdain Maldy" camp can say with 100% certainty that he's not.
No one really knows and the truth is probably in the middle. The only thing I can say for sure is a fair analysis of Maldy's value add in the game-calling realm is much much more complicated than looking at pitcher ERA with either catcher behind the plate.
For now, I want to see Diaz play a little more. But I also think the job should be Maldy's when October rolls around.