Harry Dunne said:
texasaggie2015 said:
fullback44 said:
When Brantley comes back I hope Yulks could play center.. let Myers and Chaz come into spell outfield starters needing a break ..
I'm not saying Julks can't play center, but it's worth pointing out that he played more games at third in the minor leagues than center field.
I'm sure he can play in a pinch but he's probably just not fast enough. I have tried hard to understand fielding metrics and the one thing they all agree on is that range is by far the most valuable quality in an OF, especially a CF.
Tucker is a great example. GG RF, great arm, great instincts, good wheels. Despite his skill and considerable range, he still didn't have enough range for the org to want to put him in CF...and like most players, his sprint speed has been slowing down a little bit every year since he was 22.
Meyers is in the top 5% in sprint speed in MLB and that's what is keeping him out there. I don't know how much difference it makes, but it must make an enormous one for them to keep his feeble bat out there.
On other hand you still have Aaron Judge out there for the Yankees and until last year Springer was still spending most of his time in CF, so I guess every organization has a different philosophy - seems like Tucker would be just as good as either of those guys.
Yea. Those are all good points. We have a number of guys who "can" play CF, but whether or not that's optimal is a different question.
From a defensive optimization standpoint, would we want Julks in CF? Probly not. But hypothetically, what if he's mashing OPS .850? .900? .950? There's probably a breakeven point where the offense/defense give-and-take makes it worth it.
But it's all relative too. Chas is the incumbent and plays a good CF. So Julks would have to significantly outperform him offensively to outweigh the defensive downgrade and be the everyday guy. That's a tall ask.
At this point, barring a mega offensive breakout where we can't keep Julks' bat out of the lineup, I think Chas/Dubon will see most CF reps post-Altuve's return. If Julks keeps it up, I could see him staying with the big club all year and getting a few starts per week as Brantley/Yordan/Abreu rest.
I'd love for Jake build on his mini-breakout yesterday. That'd be a nice problem to have. But even if he doesn't, he still might have a role with the team in the playoffs as a defensive replacement/pinch runner.