BaseballReference.com oddities

52,079 Views | 339 Replies | Last: 5 days ago by AggieEP
McInnis
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I didn't know until recently that at one time runs scored were credited to the pitcher in the game at the time, not the pitcher that put the runners on base.

This came into play during a game played on this date in 1912. The Washington Senators and St. Louis Browns were playing in the second game of a doubleheader. Walter Johnson, who was sporting a winning streak of 16 games was brought in relief in the 7th inning. The Senators had a 3-2 lead but the Browns had two runners on with one out. Both runners scored to give the Browns a 4-3 win. And the Big Train took the loss.
agsalaska
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I did not know that either.
PDEMDHC
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
AgRyan04 said:

The first two Angels to win Rookie of the Year were Salmon and Trout


Seems kinda fishy to me
The Porkchop Express
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Carlo4 said:

AgRyan04 said:

The first two Angels to win Rookie of the Year were Salmon and Trout


Seems kinda fishy to me
If only they had drafted Kevin Bass.
agsalaska
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Carlo4 said:

AgRyan04 said:

The first two Angels to win Rookie of the Year were Salmon and Trout


Seems kinda fishy to me
My 12 yo son has two kids with the last name Fish at his school and a kid name Bass at the other middle school. The fish are somehow, even in this small town, apparently not related. I said to him the other day 'that's crazy son. to have two Fish at the same school that are not related.' He looked right at me and without missing a beat said 'If Bass ever transfers over here we will have three'

I laughed.
PDEMDHC
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
agsalaska said:

Carlo4 said:

AgRyan04 said:

The first two Angels to win Rookie of the Year were Salmon and Trout


Seems kinda fishy to me
My 12 yo son has two kids with the last name Fish at his school and a kid name Bass at the other middle school. The fish are somehow, even in this small town, apparently not related. I said to him the other day 'that's crazy son. to have two Fish at the same school that are not related.' He looked right at me and without missing a beat said 'If Bass ever transfers over here we will have three'

I laughed.


Now this is how you raise a kid. Bravo!
Corporal Punishment
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
On May 29, 1976, Joe Niekro hit the only big league home run of his career (973 lifetime at bats), and it came off his brother Phil.
Iowaggie
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
This may be elsewhere, but I'm sure quite a few remember this play




JT Snow should be his batboy
Johnsy3
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Corporal Punishment said:

On May 29, 1976, Joe Niekro hit the only big league home run of his career (973 lifetime at bats), and it came off his brother Phil.


Did Brother Phil Niekro punch a locker afterward?
The Porkchop Express
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Stan Musial was the rare star that didn't get drafted during the most intense fighting of World War II. At the time and throughout history many have thought the reason was because the Cardinals were able to somehow protect him, but the real reason was that he had just become a father before the war started for the US In 1941, and he was the sole provider of income for his parents.

Born in Donora, PA, he played on the same high school team as Ken Griffey Jr's grandfather Buddy Griffey. Remarkably, Junior and Musial have the same birthday.

Musial signed to play for a semi-pro team when he was 15 as a pitcher and struck out 13 grown men in 6 innings in his first game. The Cardinals signed him in 1938 as a pitcher, and in 1940 at age 19, he went 18-5 with a 2.62 ERA at Daytona Beach, while also batting .311.
His swing convinced the Cards to convert him to an OF, and after getting promoted twice in 1941, he played the final 12 games of the regular season with the big club, hitting an ungodly .426 (20 for 49) with a 1.024 OPS.

He eventually did go to the Navy in 1945, where the powers that be determined he should play baseball to entertain the troops. At one exhibition game, another sailor suggested he hit more homers and fewer singles and doubles. He complied by getting closer to the plate, and when he got back to the Majors, he ran it by his manager as a possible way to increase his run production.

In 1946, his career highs were 19 HR and 103 RBI. In 1948, he hit 39 HR and drove in 131 runs while also batting .376. He would hit 30+ HR 5 more times, drive in 100+ RBI 8 more times and finish with a .331 batting average, making a staggering 24 All-Star games.
McInnis
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Here's something that I just stumbled across that I found surprising. Sandy Koufax has a career WAR of 48.9. We've talked about a lot of players here who retired with WARs in the range of 50-60 and didn't make the HOF. Koufax is just barely edged out by Lou Brock as the Hall of Famer with the lowest career WAR, and we discussed the reason for that here a while back (his historically bad defense). But there's never been any controversy over Koufax being in.

Koufax pitched for only 12 years and everyone knows his career was cut short by recurring arm soreness. But what I didn't realize is that his first six years were the very definition of mediocre. In that time he had a record of 27-30 and an era of about 4.10. Then in 1961 he figured it out. He finished his career with:

Four no-hitters and a perfect game.
Three Cy Youngs, all of them by unanimous vote. And this was when only one Cy Young was awarded in the major leagues.
A career strikeout per nine inning ratio of 9.3, just under Nolan who had 9.5.
A career K to walk ratio of nearly 4.

Maybe most surprising to me is that in spite of his arm problems he went out at the top of his game. His last season was his best leading the NL with 27 wins and an era of 1.73.

Too bad he couldn't have lasted another two years and pitched in 1968, aka the year of the pitcher when Bob Gibson set a record that will probably stand forever by posting an era of 1.12. Wonder what Sandy could have done that season?

The Porkchop Express
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I was writing something about Billy Beane tonight and it mentioned he played minor league ball with both Dykstra and Strawberry. The Doc and Darryl stuff is pretty well documented, but I ended up looking at Strawberry on BR a little more closely.

In 1982 at age 20 in Double AA he had a 34 HR, 45 SB season
From 1983-1991 with the Dodgers and Mets he racked up 280 home runs and 201 steals. That was through his age 29 season. That seems like a pretty sure fire HOF track. Easily 400 HR and 300 steals.

From 1991-1999, he only played 303 more games (an average of 33 per season). He hit 55 more home runs and stole 20 more bases. That was it. And 24 of those 55 home runs came in his rebound 1998 season when was on their WS winner.

Dykstra, MLB's Danny Ainge, played 136 games of A ball at age 20 in 1983.
He had 132 runs scored, 188 hits, 14 triples, 105 stolen bases and hit .358.
AgRyan04
How long do you want to ignore this user?
1972

Billy Williams led the NL with a .333 batting average and finished second in HR and RBI by 3 each.....meaning he was 3 HR shy of the Triple Crown.

To this day, it still hasn't been done in the NL since 1937.

Has anyone been closer than that?

Ohtani this year is the only one I can think of that was comparably close.

Even in peak Bonds juicing years he was off in one catagory.
AgRyan04
How long do you want to ignore this user?
McInnis said:

Here's something that I just stumbled across that I found surprising. Sandy Koufax has a career WAR of 48.9. We've talked about a lot of players here who retired with WARs in the range of 50-60 and didn't make the HOF. Koufax is just barely edged out by Lou Brock as the Hall of Famer with the lowest career WAR, and we discussed the reason for that here a while back (his historically bad defense). But there's never been any controversy over Koufax being in.

Koufax pitched for only 12 years and everyone knows his career was cut short by recurring arm soreness. But what I didn't realize is that his first six years were the very definition of mediocre. In that time he had a record of 27-30 and an era of about 4.10. Then in 1961 he figured it out. He finished his career with:

Four no-hitters and a perfect game.
Three Cy Youngs, all of them by unanimous vote. And this was when only one Cy Young was awarded in the major leagues.
A career strikeout per nine inning ratio of 9.3, just under Nolan who had 9.5.
A career K to walk ratio of nearly 4.

Maybe most surprising to me is that in spite of his arm problems he went out at the top of his game. His last season was his best leading the NL with 27 wins and an era of 1.73.

Too bad he couldn't have lasted another two years and pitched in 1968, aka the year of the pitcher when Bob Gibson set a record that will probably stand forever by posting an era of 1.12. Wonder what Sandy could have done that season?


category.

Koufax, I think, is an interesting comparison to Trout. The years they were healthy they were gods....few fires burned brighter.....but just cut short by health
AgRyan04
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Another....

Doug Drabek won the Cy Young in 1990 with the Pirates and finished 8th in the MVP voting.....but not an all-star in '90 or '91
W
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
here's a baseball reference / WAR oddity from this season

according to B.R....Dansby Swanson had a 4.0 WAR season in 2024

however Cubs fans will say he had a bad year -- due to posting .701 OPS and OPS+ 98 for $26 MM

and the fans have a point -- because at the end of August, his OPS was a woeful .667

but then he had his best month of the season in September (after the Cubs were out of contention for the division) to clean up his stats

did he have a good year? WAR says yes...
AgRyan04
How long do you want to ignore this user?
As a Cubs fan, NO!
Fuzzy Dunlop
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
W said:

here's a baseball reference / WAR oddity from this season

according to B.R....Dansby Swanson had a 4.0 WAR season in 2024

however Cubs fans will say he had a bad year -- due to posting .701 OPS and OPS+ 98 for $26 MM

and the fans have a point -- because at the end of August, his OPS was a woeful .667

but then he had his best month of the season in September (after the Cubs were out of contention for the division) to clean up his stats

did he have a good year? WAR says yes...


This is why I don't care for WAR as a metric. How many different sites have their own WAR statistic? It's not bad as a reference but I don't think it should be an end all, be all type stat or measure.
Double Talkin' Jive...
The Porkchop Express
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Fuzzy Dunlop said:

W said:

here's a baseball reference / WAR oddity from this season

according to B.R....Dansby Swanson had a 4.0 WAR season in 2024

however Cubs fans will say he had a bad year -- due to posting .701 OPS and OPS+ 98 for $26 MM

and the fans have a point -- because at the end of August, his OPS was a woeful .667

but then he had his best month of the season in September (after the Cubs were out of contention for the division) to clean up his stats

did he have a good year? WAR says yes...


This is why I don't care for WAR as a metric. How many different sites have their own WAR statistic? It's not bad as a reference but I don't think it should be an end all, be all type stat or measure.
WAR?
What is it good for?
Absolutely nothing.
Say it again.

The Porkchop Express
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
The greatest minor league player of the 20th century might have been Gary Redus of the Reds.A 15th-round draft pick, Redus started in Rookie bal in 1978 with Billings of the Pioneer league.

In 68 games, he scored 100 runs got 117 hits, 19 doubles, 6 triples, 17 HR, drove in 62, stole 42 bases, walked 62 times and had the unlikely slash of .463/.559/.787 for an OPS of 1.346. He had 199 total bases in 68 games.

A few of those numbers over 162 games equals: 238 runs scored, 279 hits, 45 doubles, 14 triples, 41 HR,
148 RBI, 100 steals, and 148 walks.

After a struggle year in 1979, he hits .301 with an .880 OPS in A ball Tampa in 1980 and .333 in Triple AA Indianapolis in 1982 with an OPS of 1.003 and a .604 slugging percentage, driving in 93 runs in 122 games

He finally made the big club as a starter at age 26 n 1983, but he could never find the magic. He stole 322 bases in the majors, but hit just .252 and never hit more than 17 HR. He didn't bat above .250 until he was a 32-year-old part time player for the Pirates in 1989. .

Ironically, he was fantastic in 15 post-season games for Pittsbugh, including hitting .438 with a 1.313 OPS in the 1992 NLCS vs. Atlanta.

agsalaska
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Wow that's crazy. I remember him.
The trouble with quotes on the internet is that you never know if they are genuine. -- Abraham Lincoln.



agsalaska
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I have quite the oddity here.

Don Mattingly had over 2,153 hits and 222 home runs. Of those 222 home runs six were grand slams. That by itself is not that unusual. What is unusual is that they were all hit in 1987. That is a major league record I think. And he hit all of zero across the rest of his career.
The trouble with quotes on the internet is that you never know if they are genuine. -- Abraham Lincoln.



The Porkchop Express
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
agsalaska said:

I have quite the oddity here.

Don Mattingly had over 2,153 hits and 222 home runs. Of those 222 home runs six were grand slams. That by itself is not that unusual. What is unusual is that they were all hit in 1987. That is a major league record I think. And he hit all of zero across the rest of his career.
Mattingly has to be on the "what might have been" all time list for guys who got hurt and couldn't get healthy again.

His span from 84-87 was like a Mantle or Dimaggio 4 years. He was automatic Top 5 MVP finish, All-Star Game, Gold Glove, Silver Slugger. In 1985, he had 145 RBI and the next guy on the list was Eddie Murray at 124.
He also had 370 total bases and second place was Brett at 322.

Even after the injuries he was still a very good contact hitter but he couldn't drive the ball anymore.

AggieEP
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Is that oWAR only l, or does it include his defensive WAR as well?

My guess without looking it up is that he was probably a 1.5 oWAR player buoyed in overall WAR by his defense.
W
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
and that's one of the issues with WAR -- too much emphasis on defense

the Cubs didn't sign Swanson to a 7-year contract for .700 OPS

they wanted the guy who averaged 25 HR's per year and .782 OPS in his last 3 seasons with the Braves

however...Swanson's 182 K's in his final Atlanta season...should have been cause for concern
Corporal Punishment
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Mattingly was THE best hitter in the majors during the mid 80s in an era of truly great hitters like Yount, Brett, Winfield, Boggs, and ****ton of other studs.
jja79
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Mike Schmidt says hello.
The Porkchop Express
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
jja79 said:

Mike Schmidt says hello.
Schmidt was the best power hitter, but only hit >.300 once and that was during the '81 strike year.
Strike probably cost him 15 HR and 50 RBI off his considerably lofty career totals.

At the end, he and Dale Murphy suffered the same frustrating massive dropoff of skill level / injury.

In the juiced ball '87 season, Schmit was 37 and was 35 HR , 113 RBi, .293.

In 88 he hurt his rotator cuff and missed 54 games and only had 12 HR

In 89 he played only 42 games, hit 6 HR and batted .203
jja79
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
During the 1980s Schmidt had 13 fewer hits, 149 more HR and 212 more RBI. I just have a hard time saying anyone was better.
The Porkchop Express
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
jja79 said:

During the 1980s Schmidt had 13 fewer hits, 149 more HR and 212 more RBI. I just have a hard time saying anyone was better.
Mattingly didn't even start playing full time until 1984. He played 7 games in 1982 and 91 in 1983.

Schmidt played 1,330 games in the 1980s. Mattingly played 1,015.

It seems pretty staggering that Mattingly finished with more hits while playing in 315 fewer games.


jja79
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
He was very good without a doubt but he was no Mike Schmidt. Just shouting out to my all time favorite player.
The Porkchop Express
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
jja79 said:

He was very good without a doubt but he was no Mike Schmidt. Just shouting out to my all time favorite player.
For many years as a kid, I thought this was Mike Schmidt at the grocery store.

Smeghead4761
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Here's one of those "rest of the story" things that I stumbled across recently on FB: how Old Hoss Radbourn came to set the nigh unbreakable all time single season record for wins by a pitcher.


Quote:

On June 7, 1884, ace pitcher Charley Sweeney set a major league record that would stand for 102 years, when he struck out 19 batters in a single game. After this game, however, arm trouble put him on the bench, putting the bulk of the Providence Grays' innings on the back of Old Hoss Radbourn, who was the Gray's only other pitcher of note. Radbourn complained, and eventually Sweeney was forced to take the mound again. What followed is possibly the most old-timey baseball story in existence.
After a game in Woonsocket, Rhode Island, Sweeney got drunk and elected to stay in Woonsocket with a lady friend. Waking the next morning (still drunk) and realizing that he had to start in Providence, he rushed out the door. With an already-tight pitching staff, the Grays had no choice but to put the visibly hammered Sweeney on the mound.
They tried to pull him after five effective innings, but Sweeney was having none of it. This was a time where pitching anything less than a complete game brought your very manliness into question. He pitched another two against the wishes of his manager. When again they tried to pull him before the 8th, with the threat of a $50 fine, Sweeney told them to stuff their $50 fine and his whole contract. He walked off the field and watched the rest of the game with a woman in each arm, presumed to be prostitutes. This not only got him kicked off the team, but thrown out of the entire National League.
And that only sets up the final twist of the story. With the Grays being extremely understaffed, Old Hoss Radbourn offered to pitch the remaining games of the season for a small pay bump and an exemption from the reserve clause. He started 40 of the remaining 43 games in the season, and won 36 of them. His arm became sore enough that he couldn't raise it over his shoulders, and he had to warm up for hours before gametime just to get the ball to the plate. Just to add to his spectacular feat, Radbourn started and won every single game of the 1884 "World Series".
After an incredible 678.2 innings pitched, Radbourn amassed an official 59 wins for the season (sometimes reported as 60), an impossible record that will never be touched. And it's all because a man named Charlie Sweeney got laid on July 21, 1884.


https://www.facebook.com/share/p/1DEDTcufNp/
AgRyan04
How long do you want to ignore this user?
This morning's Immaculate Grid got me down a rabbit hole

Only one active player has a career average over .300 (Altuve .306).

No one has had a higher single season batting average since 2000 when Nomar and Helton BOTH hit exactly .3724 (Ichiro hit .3722 in 2004).

Man, the game has changed!
W
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Mike Schmidt was one of the few sluggers -- in the non-steroid era -- that was able to maintain his power numbers into his mid-30's

fun stat...he only hit into 156 career GiDP's in 8,300 career at-bats. Rather remarkable for a right-handed hitter who batter 3rd or 4th in the lineup

also fun...he was not immune to the cavernous Astrodome. 2nd lowest career slugging % (.440) and 3rd lowest career OPS in the dome.

strangely enough...his lowest career slugging % was at Three Rivers Stadium vs. the Pirates

of course he mashed at Wrigley Field. 50 career HR's in 138 games played in Chicago
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.