Vivek

23,253 Views | 441 Replies | Last: 2 days ago by fixer
No Spin Ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Teslag said:

FrioAg 00 said:

The same people that will die on the hill for WFH are the ones claiming companies shouldn't be able to import people willing to work hard for a certain price and instead we should just bid up the price for the Americans who aren't working hard now for current prices.

Some people just hate hard work and feel entitled to more money. Doesn't matter how they dress it up.


You can work hard from home just as easily as you can from an office
There are in fact two things, science and opinion; the former begets knowledge, the later ignorance. Hippocrates
Old McDonald
How long do you want to ignore this user?
vivek two days ago: americans are inferior workers because they send their kids to soccer and dance practice instead of kumon and we must replace them with cheap h1b workers for the shareholders' sake

vivek today: guys we can't let the leftists divide maga like this
richardag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Ag_of_08 said:

Look at how he runs spacex and to a lesser extent tesla...
I was asking for direct quotes, if you have any information backing up your contention regarding how he runs SpaceX's and/or Tesla's hiring practices could provide employment and compensation based on citizen or immigration status? TIA.
Among the latter, under pretence of governing they have divided their nations into two classes, wolves and sheep.”
Thomas Jefferson, Letter to Edward Carrington, January 16, 1787
richardag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Ag_of_08 said:

...what? We're talking about what a REPUBLICAN, who's supposed to be very conservative, said. Trying to deflect and blame democrats doesn't change who said what.

Good to see the whataboutism isn't going to wait for Jan 20th
What he said about the changing culture is absolutely true.
Not only is it true, it is a direct result of Democratic Party leadership and their absurd policy agenda.
Also in another post stated that if the immigration policy is corrupted it needs to be corrected.
I provided in a previous post the drop in education beginning in 1980 w/ President Carter' dept. of Education. Other examples are the DEI crap advocated by the Democratic Party leadership which has infected many major corporations. Even major banks are using DEI for acceptance of loan applications.
Colleges and Universities are offering courses in this crap. Take a look at the clowns running the bureaucracies appointed by President Biden.
This isn't whataboutism it is staight up facts.
Among the latter, under pretence of governing they have divided their nations into two classes, wolves and sheep.”
Thomas Jefferson, Letter to Edward Carrington, January 16, 1787
richardag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Im Gipper said:


Nothing wrong with American culture?
Then explain


If there is nothing wrong with American culture at all how in the hell were these incompetent people placed in positions of power.
This is what Vivek is pointing out and there needs to be vast changes. Including if the legal immigration system is being abused.
Among the latter, under pretence of governing they have divided their nations into two classes, wolves and sheep.”
Thomas Jefferson, Letter to Edward Carrington, January 16, 1787
Im Gipper
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Quote:

This is what Vivek is pointing out


You need to go back and read what he said.


You are talking about leftist culture. Vivek is against that too, but that's NOT what he was talking about!


Leftist culture does not celebrate prom queens and jocks.

I'm Gipper
FL_Ag1998
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
infinity ag said:

agdad4x said:

my two aggie sons have a construction company in the DFW metro area - most (if not all) of their field employees are foreign workers and I asked them why - their answer: American born workers do not want to do the work

They don't want to because you are paying them peanuts. Increase the pay and people will work.

The problem these days is American corps are so greedy, they are okay with hiring foreigners, lowering quality in order to make the CEO's obscene bonus numbers.


Not true, but you've already made your position very clear on other threads that you abhore "The Man" (i.e. corporations and any manager-level employee in a corporation), so your posts have to be viewed through that lens.

Here's reality....with the large company I work for I'm in a position where I have to interview and hire. Young workers (all native-born Americans) with very limited experience (2-3 years) and only bachelor degrees (not even any professional certs to their bame yet) expect management positions and extremely high salaries ($80-100k). But conversely its almost a given these days that you're lucky if they'll stay with your company for 2-3 years before jumping ship to the next company that's desperate enough to pay them $20k more than their really worth and give them a title with the word "manager" in it. There is a lot of entitlement in them due to unrealistic expectations (and I expect being given handouts from mommy and daddy their entire life). And there is zero loyalty from them no matter how well they're treated or compensated.

Find me a noncomplaining hard worker from any country, US or foreign, and I'll go to bat for them when the time comes for raises and promotions.
Ag_of_08
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
You understand 80-100k is not extremely high anymore..... right? In many places, that's not even good.

You also understand that when there are no opportunities for advancement... they're going to leave to go elsewhere? And the ones willing to hire outside mgmt instead of promoting from within are what has created the lack of company loyalty and thebhopping culture? The dismantling of pensions, the outside mgmt hiring, the wage stagnation without job changes ... youve created the problem that people are griping about.

I don't know a single person who wouldn't like to work 30 years for the same company theyre confortable with and retire...but they can't.
jeremy
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Everyone who thinks "evil companies and businesses" are abusing laborers should run a business.

Is $60k salary peanuts? Maybe, but it costs the company at least $85k or more to employ you. Is $25 per hour crappy pay? Maybe, but that's what the owner can afford to pay for the best talent he/she can find. Any more pay than that and the company can't stay solvent. If I'm a business owner, busting my ass and paying my employees more means I don't turn a profit, eventually I close my doors.

Personal reference: have a friend who owns a mechanic shop. Fights like he'll to keep good employees and pays tons of money and gives them all kinds of random vacation to keep them happy and loyal. He went from making $200k+ a year to his salary as the owner is less than $120k. Dealerships have offered him to come take over for $160k. How long do you think he'll keep his doors open?

Everyone needs incentive and both parties would do well to "walk a mile in the other persons shoes."
richardag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Im Gipper said:

Quote:

This is what Vivek is pointing out
You need to go back and read what he said.

You are talking about leftist culture. Vivek is against that too, but that's NOT what he was talking about!

Leftist culture does not celebrate prom queens and jocks.
No I don't.
Previously I posted
  • Oh, and a perfect example of misplaced cultural priorities is paying an unnamed coach $75 million to fire him. Or being able to sell a majority interest in an NBA team for $3.5 billion.

    This is only possible because our Democratic Party leadership has warped our cultural priorities to the extent people are willing to spend ridiculous amounts of money on things that provide almost no benefit to our nation. Don't get me wrong, I don't blame Cuban or the unnamed coach accepting the money, I blame our culture and educational system.
  • I may be wrong, but seems people aren't blaming the jocks or the cheerleaders. They are blaming the culture that inordinately celebrate the jocks and cheerleaders.

    I used to like sports and watched/went to games until the values taught and instilled by playing was distorted and we ended up with billionaires like LeBron and Cuban who now represent the failures of a culture.
Among the latter, under pretence of governing they have divided their nations into two classes, wolves and sheep.”
Thomas Jefferson, Letter to Edward Carrington, January 16, 1787
Ag_of_08
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
The solution is not to continue importing labor that will work cheaper.... that's the point.

The solution is to get tax burdens down, regulatory burdens down, and fight inflation. Let the 25$ an hour salary become good pay again.

These people are arguing that we j7st need to import workers who will work cheaper.... that's a great way to make sure noone can afford to consume, and the whole house of cards collapses. Can't make ANY money when businesses can't exist.
Im Gipper
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I agree with you completely about democrats!

But Vivek is not talking about the freaks you posted. Thats not American culture.

I'm Gipper
FL_Ag1998
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Ag_of_08 said:

You understand 80-100k is not extremely high anymore..... right? In many places, that's not even good.

You also understand that when there are no opportunities for advancement... they're going to leave to go elsewhere? And the ones willing to hire outside mgmt instead of promoting from within are what has created the lack of company loyalty and thebhopping culture? The dismantling of pensions, the outside mgmt hiring, the wage stagnation without job changes ... youve created the problem that people are griping about.

I don't know a single person who wouldn't like to work 30 years for the same company theyre confortable with and retire...but they can't.


You're inserting a lot of assumptions that simply don't apply to the situation I described....someone either straight out of college or only 2-3 years removed applying for a new job simply because they think at 2 years of experience they should be in management and bringing in 6 figures.

Here in Florida for someone with just a bachelors degree in the environmental field and under 4 years experience $80-100k is a lot. That's a very good salary that someone can absolutely live off of, even start a family off of (especially when most of the time these days both partners in a marriage are working). This ain't the NE or West Coast.

Projects have to be profitable, or else clients leave and then none of us ends up having a job. Projects can't be profitable when we're paying the entry level person a hundred thousand dollars a year for them to write reports, get permits, manage a few simple tasks, etc.

I already stated in my earlier post that myself and my program manager stay engaged in our direct reports careers, making sure that they are on paths for career and financial advancement. Its absolutely crucial to our specific program to retain good talent rather than have constant turnover. And hell if there's not room for advancement in our group, we'll be the first people to try to find them someplace else in the company that they can move into, or be the first person to write them a recommendation letter if they seek work elsewhere.

There is a learning curve that young employees new to the career field absolutely have to go through before they're ready to be competent managers earning higher salaries. I've met a few young employees who acknowledge that and are willing to go through it, but most aren't. And many of the ones who aren't end up being the worst managers, all because previous bad hiring managers hired them into positions they weren't ready for.
richardag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Im Gipper said:

I agree with you completely about democrats!

But Vivek is not talking about the freaks you posted. Thats not American culture.
That meme represents an extreme extension of the deterioration of our culture as a nation.
I have explained my position that something is out of wack with our culture as a whole if the jimbo fishers of the world are valued at $75 million or in the case of LeBron whatever the hell he earns. Vivek wasn't describing athletes nor cheerleaders, he was describing a culture that idolizes them over placing emphasis on people who demonstrably contribute to the productivity of our nation. And I agree with him.
This nation was founded on Judeo/Christian beliefs and we are moving further and accelerating faster away from those beliefs as shown in the meme I posted(re: I am agnostic but value those beliefs and ethics).
I will add that I placed a post regarding immigration fraud
  • If true, seems true to me, that process should be ended immediately.
Among the latter, under pretence of governing they have divided their nations into two classes, wolves and sheep.”
Thomas Jefferson, Letter to Edward Carrington, January 16, 1787
agracer
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
He's FOS.
Bulldog73
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Is there nothing wrong with the current American culture?
A culture that celebrates the D1 schollie offer over the class valedictorian or travel club sports achievement over getting excellent grades?
A culture that celebrates participation over excellence?
A culture that celebrates the mindless good looking celebrity over the plain looking successful entrepreneur?
A culture that celebrates influencing and popularity over fundamental decency and common sense?
A culture that celebrates finding "your truth" over factual truth?
A culture that celebrates sexual pleasure over everything else?
A culture that celebrates getting high or wasted over sobriety?
A culture that embraces the 40 hour work week as the epitome of hard work (or maybe corporate oppression)?
A culture that celebrates diversity over unity?
A culture that celebrates equity of outcome over equality of opportunity?
A culture that opens its borders to let virtually anyone who wants to loot, steal, conspire and kill come in?
A society that endorses racism in the name of ending racism in the least racist major nation in the world?
A culture that gives serious credence to "defund the police" and Israel defending itself is genocide?
A culture that seeks to replace itself for globalism?
A culture that says little Johnny's feelings are more important than following the rules?
A culture that says serial monogamy is as valid as lifelong commitment?
A culture that says the lives of convicted murderers is more important than the lives of the innocent preborn?
Or a hundred other examples showing we live in a sick culture that is intent on committing societal suicide.

I'm noy saying everyone in America embraces these twisted sensibilities. I'm not saying you have embraced them. And I'm not saying I am 100% immune from some of these warped cultural values. But enough of our people/government have embraced them that they are very much a part of our national identity. And if we don't move away from them hard, I can easily see cultures that don't embrace and celebrate them passing us by or even our nation self destructing.

If Vivek wants to examine these issues and begin to address them, I'm not going to criticize him and say "what about".
kubiak03
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Vivek makes an important point but then flames out with tropes and crap.

Culture does need to change.

Many degrees are in fact worthless.
Nuclear family is important
Christian values are important
Our history is important
Extra curriculars are important
Hard work and letting failure happen is important
Cutting welfare is important

All this can be achieved with our own citizens and some key immigrants.
Tergdor
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
agdad4x said:

$25 / hour is peanuts ? I can remember working for a lot less than that not too long ago
It is now. Starbucks and Amazon workers are striking for $30+ an hour. McDonald's will start you at $20 at many places, and there's been push to get that raised again, too. $25 for manual construction labor is pennies in comparison.

The problem will only get worse as professional fields continue to lag in their pay raises. I currently make $35 for my scientific job and my sister is a nurse in one of the most expensive cities to live and makes a little over $40. It's enough to live comfortably on, but people will stop going to school to pursue those fields when a dead-end service job gives a comparable wage without having to front debt. And then all of those people will be dead in the water when robots take over, and the government will have to pick up their tab.
zb008
How long do you want to ignore this user?
That's a fancy way of saying that immigrants are better labor slaves.
Muktheduck
How long do you want to ignore this user?
agdad4x said:

$25 / hour is peanuts ? I can remember working for a lot less than that not too long ago
Then you can also probably remember the ridiculous levels of inflation over the last few years.
No Spin Ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Bulldog73 said:

Is there nothing wrong with the current American culture?
A culture that celebrates the D1 schollie offer over the class valedictorian or travel club sports achievement over getting excellent grades?
A culture that celebrates participation over excellence?
A culture that celebrates the mindless good looking celebrity over the plain looking successful entrepreneur?
A culture that celebrates influencing and popularity over fundamental decency and common sense?
A culture that celebrates finding "your truth" over factual truth?
A culture that celebrates sexual pleasure over everything else?
A culture that celebrates getting high or wasted over sobriety?
A culture that embraces the 40 hour work week as the epitome of hard work (or maybe corporate oppression)?
A culture that celebrates diversity over unity?
A culture that celebrates equity of outcome over equality of opportunity?
A culture that opens its borders to let virtually anyone who wants to loot, steal, conspire and kill come in?
A society that endorses racism in the name of ending racism in the least racist major nation in the world?
A culture that gives serious credence to "defund the police" and Israel defending itself is genocide?
A culture that seeks to replace itself for globalism?
A culture that says little Johnny's feelings are more important than following the rules?
A culture that says serial monogamy is as valid as lifelong commitment?
A culture that says the lives of convicted murderers is more important than the lives of the innocent preborn?
Or a hundred other examples showing we live in a sick culture that is intent on committing societal suicide.

I'm noy saying everyone in America embraces these twisted sensibilities. I'm not saying you have embraced them. And I'm not saying I am 100% immune from some of these warped cultural values. But enough of our people/government have embraced them that they are very much a part of our national identity. And if we don't move away from them hard, I can easily see cultures that don't embrace and celebrate them passing us by or even our nation self destructing.

If Vivek wants to examine these issues and begin to address them, I'm not going to criticize him and say "what about".
There are in fact two things, science and opinion; the former begets knowledge, the later ignorance. Hippocrates
fixer
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Bulldog73 said:

Is there nothing wrong with the current American culture?
A culture that celebrates the D1 schollie offer over the class valedictorian or travel club sports achievement over getting excellent grades?
A culture that celebrates participation over excellence?
A culture that celebrates the mindless good looking celebrity over the plain looking successful entrepreneur?
A culture that celebrates influencing and popularity over fundamental decency and common sense?
A culture that celebrates finding "your truth" over factual truth?
A culture that celebrates sexual pleasure over everything else?
A culture that celebrates getting high or wasted over sobriety?
A culture that embraces the 40 hour work week as the epitome of hard work (or maybe corporate oppression)?
A culture that celebrates diversity over unity?
A culture that celebrates equity of outcome over equality of opportunity?
A culture that opens its borders to let virtually anyone who wants to loot, steal, conspire and kill come in?
A society that endorses racism in the name of ending racism in the least racist major nation in the world?
A culture that gives serious credence to "defund the police" and Israel defending itself is genocide?
A culture that seeks to replace itself for globalism?
A culture that says little Johnny's feelings are more important than following the rules?
A culture that says serial monogamy is as valid as lifelong commitment?
A culture that says the lives of convicted murderers is more important than the lives of the innocent preborn?
Or a hundred other examples showing we live in a sick culture that is intent on committing societal suicide.

I'm noy saying everyone in America embraces these twisted sensibilities. I'm not saying you have embraced them. And I'm not saying I am 100% immune from some of these warped cultural values. But enough of our people/government have embraced them that they are very much a part of our national identity. And if we don't move away from them hard, I can easily see cultures that don't embrace and celebrate them passing us by or even our nation self destructing.

If Vivek wants to examine these issues and begin to address them, I'm not going to criticize him and say "what about".
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.